Almost as much as themes of landscape, space, and place, the concept of reconciliation—of synthesis—has characterized criticism of John Luther Adams's music. Calculated and lush, abstract and immediate, personal and post-human, Adams's music obviates the old debates surrounding the relative value of the beautiful and the sublime in art. The one-movement orchestral piece Become Ocean resonates with both of Immanuel Kant's senses of sublimity: the mathematical sublime, with its nigh-infinite expanses and complex patterns, and the dynamical, which sees the human subject dwarfed and overwhelmed by indifferent nature. But Adams's obvious gift for the transcendent has never prevented him from crafting gorgeous utterances, works that shimmer even as they pull audiences into their undertow. Become Ocean, a forty-minute musical palindrome, sounds less like a math problem than a sonic rendering of a dream— or, as Alex Ross puts it, like “the loveliest apocalypse in musical history.”Footnote 1 Seldom since the death of Alban Berg have rigorous compositional processes yielded music so utterly immersive, powerful, and rich. In his ability to achieve both “formal rigor and visceral impact,” as he puts it, Adams has few living peers beyond Kaija Saariaho, his near-exact contemporary.Footnote 2
Certain facts about Become Ocean have become commonplaces of critical coverage. Its title, drawn from a poem by John Cage, alludes to the potential submersion of humanity as sea levels rise. Its composer long lived and worked at the cultural and geographic margins of the United States, in Alaska; however, Adams won the 2014 Pulitzer Prize for Music Composition with Become Ocean and moved to Harlem mere months later.Footnote 3 Since then, he has been the first composer featured on Nadia Sirota's WQXR interview podcast Meet the Composer, written for Slate and The New Yorker, created the piece Soundwalk 9:09 for the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and contributed an essay to a collection based on the work and thought of Jonathan Kramer.Footnote 4 Become Ocean also won the 2015 Grammy Award for Best Classical Contemporary Composition; enchanted by the Seattle Symphony's recording of the piece, Taylor Swift donated $50,000 to the ensemble. Adams's music and writings have found a wide and welcoming audience. To extend praise to Adams or Become Ocean in 2017 feels almost redundant.
Yet for all the attention devoted to Become Ocean since the Pulitzer Board's announcement, the Seattle Symphony's recording under music director Ludovic Morlot has attracted few long-form assessments. A product of Bang On a Can's Cantaloupe label, the record comes to listeners in two physical forms: the CD, which plays the stereo version, and a DVD that contains a six-channel surround mix, as well as a repetitive but inoffensive slideshow of seascapes. A sobering epigraph, excerpted from Adams's program note for the piece, greets the listener as the package is unfolded:
Life on this earth emerged from the sea.
Today, as the polar ice melts and sea level rises,
we humans face the prospect that we may once again,
quite literally, become ocean.
The envelope's three inner panels form a single panoramic photograph of melting ice at the edge of a dark sea; art director Jim Fox delivers an emotional one-two punch before the listener can even fish out the disc. The simple, stylish booklet consists solely of acknowledgements, including a much-appreciated list of every symphony member and added musician involved in the recording.Footnote 5
D. Edward Davis has commented on the recording's refusal to sound like either an overheard live event or a glossy product of studio magic.Footnote 6 Indeed, whether listening to the stereo or the surround version, the auditor feels less like an audience member than a silent participant, seated in some perfect place among the orchestra's three individual choirs. Adjectives such as “immersive” apply to this recording not only because of the piece's obvious aquatic associations, but because its particular musical qualities and intended meaning align so well with its aesthetics. The piece's wide registral distributions translate as physical immensity and weight. Near-imperceptible shifts between harmonic and textural states confound any attempts to discern teleology and instead impart a sense of eternal fluidity. With its available surround sound and remarkably wide dynamic range—the soft moments are hushed but crystal clear, the loud moments apocalyptic—the recording floods a speaker system or set of headphones with vibrations both subtle and terrifying. Pushing one step further than Davis, I would argue that the experience of hearing this recording feels more like stepping into a piece of installation art than listening to a record per se. Given the fact that Adams's catalogue includes actual installation pieces, along with a number of compositions intended for outdoor performance, the inclusion of the DVD surround recording should come as no surprise.Footnote 7
The Seattle Symphony distinguishes itself as a first-rate ensemble on this disc, recorded in Adams's recommended stage configuration.Footnote 8 From its opening rumble of rolling percussion to the breathtaking brass swell at its midpoint, and from that dynamic peak through the quiet conclusion, the orchestra never sacrifices a chance to give even the humblest whole-note of Become Ocean a sense of direction and vitality. Morlot coaxes warm, balanced textures from every instrumental section and all three of the orchestra's choirs. Special congratulations must go to the harpists, who churn their way through the recurring arpeggiated figures with grace and coordination; pianist Kimberly Russ and the percussionists, all of whom must maintain a single repeated motion throughout; and the entire brass section, whose phrasing, range of tone-colors, and flawless tuning astound. Of course, the piece would lack its characteristic density and power without a string section as united in purpose as this one, and the woodwinds merit praise for their ability to sneak into and out of larger textures with uncanny subtlety. In this piece and recording, no one musician gets to play a true starring role. In addition to portraying the Earth's waters as a sort of annihilating originator, Adams's piece offers an image of humanity in which all are created—and destroyed—equal.
A draft of Adams's sequel piece, Become Desert, already exists; the Seattle Symphony will give the work's premiere in March 2018. In the interim, Become Ocean will remain one of the most significant orchestral pieces of the early twenty-first century. A year after honoring Adams's piece, the Pulitzer Prize Board announced that Julia Wolfe's Anthracite Fields would receive the 2015 Award. Similarities abound between Wolfe's and Adams's works, two meditations on humanity's relationship with nature made audible to the listening public in recordings by Cantaloupe. But where Become Ocean leaves the cries of the implicated humans unvoiced, Anthracite Fields places its emphasis squarely on the stories of men and women who imperiled themselves and their environment for the sake of survival. For an observer in 2017, the selection of these two pieces in consecutive years may seem prophetic. Human voices wake us, and we drown.
