Cool Britannia? is a revealing anthology whose contributors read various British plays against the background of sociopolitical shifts in 1990s Britain. The essays chart the psychological, social, physical, and economic changes that occurred from the Conservative rule of Margaret Thatcher and John Major in the 1980s and 1990s to Tony Blair's “New Labour” of the late 1990s. Blair arrived on the heels of the creation of “Cool Britannia,” a branding campaign, as Graham Saunders sees it, in which New Labour “could shed its reputation for being stuck with postwar socialist dogma and be seen instead as a youthful and forward-thinking alternative to a beleaguered, fractious and increasingly weary-looking Conservative Party” (11). Behind the hip and progressive veneer, however, New Labour's implementation of economic and social policies (including privatization and entrepreneurial models in artistic sectors) more closely resembled the neoliberal policies established by their predecessors than a radical break with the past.
In addition to this complex sociopolitical terrain, the anthology takes as its impetus Aleks Sierz's book In-Yer-Face Theatre (2001), and a 2002 conference that aimed to interrogate this label's relevance to British playwriting more broadly in the 1990s. To that end, the book is divided into three parts: “In-Yer-Face Theatre: A Reconsideration,” “Thatcherism and (post)Feminism,” and “Nation, Devolution and Globalization.” Each section contains an introduction, followed by three or five essays from theatre scholars that hone in on specific playwrights and playtexts to illustrate the legacies of British policy-making on theatre. I have chosen to focus on two essays from each part.
In the first part, Aleks Sierz's essay walks a hazy line between acknowledging some of the alleged shortcomings of his 2001 book (including the mostly male, white, London-centric coterie of writers he examines) and defending his study's subjective approach to assessing British drama. Although he justifies more than he queries, Sierz does point to the significant problem of branding particular artists and their work. Ken Urban picks up on the politics of storytelling with an emphasis on cruelty, which he sees operating in the plays of Sarah Kane and Mark Ravenhill as both a reflection of and challenge to the “despair of contemporary urban life” (39). He contrasts the coolness of the Cool Britannia motif with the neoliberal, individualist emphasis that eroded artistic funding structures and community ties within Britain. Urban then suggests the possibility of reading the “ethical possibilities of an active nihilism” (as articulated by Artaud and Bataille) in these works (39).
The anthology's second part considers women's writing beyond the work of Sarah Kane. Essays by Lynette Goddard and Elaine Aston address, respectively, the prevalence of mental health issues in black women's writing and popular theatre structures that offer women “A Good Night Out” while they confront important social issues. “Black women's plays of the 1990s,” argues Goddard, “demonstrate how ideas of individualistic attainment are problematic because education, career choices and overall self-esteem affect one's potential to actualize notions of freedom and choice in an institutionally racist society” (98). Her readings of Zindika and Bonnie Greer provide compelling accounts of plays that wrestle with split psyches and social fragmentation brought on by a violent colonialist past. Aston's essay identifies shifting definitions of feminism in Eve Ensler's The Vagina Monologues, the stand-up of Jenny Eclair, and Catherine Johnson's Shang-a-Lang and Mama Mia! Aston reads an ambivalent politics within the “curious mix of the pleasurable and the painful” in Monologues. Although the play has become part of college campus “Take Back the Night” events aimed at educating coeds about violence, Aston interprets Ensler's success, predominantly in these privileged institutional sites, as ultimately capitalizing on women's pain. In contrast, the work of Eclair and Johnson, on the one hand, creates a confrontational aesthetic that deconstructs a femininity proffered by commercial cultures, and on the other hand, makes visible British culture's failure to offer women alternative models for constructing their sexuality and family structures.
Issues of political and social displacement link the essays in the final part. Roger Owen considers pre-Devolution work by Welsh playwrights Mark Jenkins and Ed Thomas. Owen uses Manuel Castells's consideration of a network society to identify how certain plays present a convergence of national and individual identity whereas other plays suggest a separation between self and society. While Owen sees Welsh identity in the work of Jenkins as “largely removed from the integral self” (165), in Thomas's plays he observes how “the Net necessarily invades and subverts the self” (171). The book's final essay, by playwright David Greig, compares theatre making at London's Royal Court with work in two unstable transnational locales: Beit Jala (near Bethlehem) and Lisbon. Greig draws a distinction between the rough theatre created at these sites (i.e., unfinished work in crumbling buildings that contained histories of violence and oppression) with the rough-looking theatre programmed by the Royal Court. He questions the “politics of creating self-conscious theatre amongst real bullet holes and the creation of self-consciously political theatre amidst a ‘bullet-hole’ look” (211).
Together, these essays, in addition to ones by Mary Luckhurst, Rebecca D'Monté, David Pattie, Nadine Holdsworth and Wallace McDowell, and Dan Rebellato, create several critical routes through, and an important historiogrphic account of, 1990s British drama. They bring to the surface provocative writers (among them, women, racial minorities, and those geographically-distanced from London) that other scholars have overlooked. The collection suggests important overlaps among racial, gender, and class inequalities amid sociopolitical developments in the British Isles, and provokes complex questions about what a British identity means at the turn of the twenty-first century. The essays also provide well-articulated, succinct synopses of the plays, and the most engaging ones weave together textual analyses and theorizations with cultural or literary history, contemplating how these dramatic works attend to, resist, or challenge such histories. Because of the breadth of material in the collection, however, one may argue that the anthology may have benefited by extending some of the essays or providing different interpretations of one set of plays or of a single playwright. Nevertheless, Cool Britannia? makes a noteworthy contribution to studies on British drama and contemporary performance by shaking free the embedded branding of “in-yer-face” drama and questioning brutal actions taken in the name of a Cool Britannia.
