The Turkish experience with political Islam, particularly in recent years, has been closely observed in different parts of the Middle East because of its potential implications for the trajectory of political Islam regionwide. Since coming to power in 2002, the Justice and Development Party (JDP), also known as the AKP, appears to have lived up to expectations that it would pursue a moderate agenda. The unique platform of the party enabled it to initiate accession talks with the European Union (EU) toward full membership, pursue neoliberal economic policies, and maintain friendly relations with the Western world, all of which were once considered taboo for Islamists. In this volume edited by Ümit Cizre, contributors aim to understand and explain the JDP's transformation by asking the following question: “What is the key momentum for reshaping the nature and trajectories of the evolution of the JDP government?” (p. 3). This volume offers “identity” as an answer, implying that the JDP leadership sought to transform the identity of the party to make it compatible with the values of the “Republic” as well as those of “Western democracy.” Another goal of the volume is to identify causes of a slowdown since 2006 in the pace of reforms that the JDP has undertaken.
Most chapters in this volume take a strategic view of the JDP's creation and its relationship to other actors in Turkish politics. In essence, the JDP's transformation toward a more moderate and democratic platform is treated as an elite affair; according to this volume's contributors, the party specifically addresses the concerns of secularist actors with references to the “harsh learning curve” of political Islam in Turkey and its “coming to terms with Turkey's time-tested Westernization process” (p. 4). This seems to be very much in line with how politics in the Middle East is usually conceptualized in the literature. Part of the reason for this emphasis on elites and political parties might be that Islamist parties are conventionally conceived in isolation from their social bases, and the legitimacy of these actors rests on factors outside of societal preferences, such as religious doctrine.
The first part of the volume discusses the historical formation of the JDP. Menderes Çınar and Burhanettin Duran (Chapter 1) emphasize pragmatism, state involvement, and nationalism as “peculiar” elements of Turkish political Islam and argue that these factors explain the distinct trajectory of political Islam in Turkey as compared to Egypt and Indonesia. The authors make the case that the combination of a change of heart in “Islamic sectors” and the realization that their conceptualization of state and society was not suitable to the “modern nation–state” underscores the transformation of political Islam in the Turkish context (p. 32). Ahmet Yıldız (Chapter 2) puts a solemn effort into placing the transformation of the JDP into a political context, particularly by exploring how the party relates to the Islamist National Outlook Movement, from whose ranks it emerged. He analyzes the two in terms of their party cadres, program/discourse, and practice and interprets the JDP's emphasis on liberal values as an attempt to “free society from the clutches of the state” (p. 46). Yıldız also discusses several policy areas that have the potential to put the JDP on a collision course with the secular elite, such as education, women, alcohol consumption, and secularism. In one of the most original contributions, Kenan Çayır (Chapter 3) presents an introduction to the Islamic literature originating in Turkey and cleverly distinguishes between the “oppositional, essentialist, and collectivist” nature of political Islam until the 1990s and the “self-reflexive and self-critical” new Islamism of the 1990s and 2000s (pp. 68–70). By analyzing Islamic novels of the period, Çayır identifies how conservative democracy, a self-ascribed category for the JDP, interacts with the changes undergone in “Islamic circles.” In Chapter 4, Burhanettin Duran elaborates on how opportunities that international sources afforded the JDP, such as increased globalization and “integration with the EU,” enable the party to steer through the criticisms of “secular circles” in order to avoid a clash with them (pp. 80–81). Essentially, Duran makes the case that the JDP's new platform involves addressing the concerns of international audiences along with those of secularists in Turkey.
Menderes Çınar (Chapter 5) analyzes how and why the JDP transformed its political discourse in the post-28 February process, a “postmodern” form of military intervention in Turkish politics. He argues that the JDP leadership “realized that attaining and maintaining power required toning down the political polarization” in order to conduct “politics” and to safeguard the rights and liberties of the “conservative constituency” (p. 111). Duran makes use of the concept of “negative political discrimination” to distinguish between policies and their makers; this distinction serves to denote a shift in the Kemalist establishment's political discourse toward opposing the JDP and the JDP's response to it. In this regard, EU membership is seen as a policy choice to enhance the credibility of the party in the eyes of the secular establishment (p. 120). Ümit Cizre's (Chapter 6) detailed analysis of the JDP–military relationship since 2002 reinforces Çınar and Duran's strategic approach to the JDP insofar as the JDP is seen as eschewing conflict with the “military guardians” of the Turkish state. Cizre highlights the impact of the EU membership process on this relationship, particularly since October 2005, arguing that following the beginning of the accession talks between Turkey and the EU at that time, the JDP converged with the preferences of the military on key issues, such as the Kurdish question and Northern Iraq. This convergence was a way to make up for the decreasing euphoria of the EU membership process and the JDP's inability to keep the “‘military question’ within its remit.” It was also in stark contrast to the period between 2002 and 2005, when the party had the thrust of extensive EU reforms to initiate the membership process and keep the military at bay (p. 133).
Ali Resul Usul (Chapter 7) traces the JDP's attitude toward the EU since 2001 and argues that in contrast to political Islam's historical opposition to EU membership, the JDP supported EU membership because it was an opportunity to “win over secularly-oriented and influential civil society organizations, such as the TUSIAD” (p. 180). In the final chapter, İbrahim Dalmış and Ertan Aydın (Chapter 8) use multiple survey data to elaborate on the social bases of the JDP. In the only quantitative analysis of the volume, the authors analyze data on party members from provincial organizations, party supporters, and JDP parliamentarians. They are able to identify several characteristics setting the party's social base apart from that of other parties. Among these features are levels of religiosity, conservatism, and support for democracy and political Islam (pp. 213, 219).
In terms of methodology, vague formulation of research questions permeates the volume. Only three chapters introduce their research question to the reader in a clear manner and provide a brief explanation of how they will seek an answer. Most chapters therefore bear a resemblance to descriptive accounts. As a corollary of this problem, in several chapters empirical evidence appears to be casual at best. A significant portion of the evidence presented in the volume is based on events in Turkish politics in the last decade or so. Yet the authors, without recourse to primary sources or interviews with relevant individuals, draw conclusions about key actors’ motivations. In other words, the use of a “sketch of evidence” approach leaves little room for causal analysis grounded in empirical evidence. The narratives do not go beyond conjecture and opinion. In the absence of alternative explanations and a thorough literature review, we are left to wonder whether the explanation, in fact, supports the argument.
Another problematic feature of this volume is the authors’ inconsistent use of terminology, especially in their discussions of the JDP. Terms used to describe the party include: Islam-friendly (p. 2), Islam-sympathetic (p. 3), conservative democrat (p. 44), Islamist (p. 17), post-Islamist (p. 21), moderately Islamist (p. 41), and new Islamist (p. 42). Language concerning social cleavages and groups is similarly confusing: secularist establishment (p. 35), Kemalist establishment (p. 112), secularist circles (p. 80), Islamic circles (p. 76), Islamic actors (p. 64), Muslim vote (p. 43), and Islam-sympathizing constituency (p. 10). Interchangeable use of the terms “Islamic” and “Islamist movements” (pp. 25, 34) presents another difficulty because these terms are conceptually quite different from each other. In most cases, we are left unguided in terms of the meanings of these distinct terms and their substantive implications. The fact that the JDP and similar parties were recently established alleviates the problem somewhat. Even so, the sheer number and casual use of differing terms implies discord among contributors to the volume as to what the party stands for; the reader is left with the task of constantly redefining terminology across the chapters.
This volume is an important contribution to understanding various aspects of the JDP as a political party, but the generalizable implications of this critical actor are left unexplored. Single case studies are important in social-scientific inquiry for many reasons, including their extensive focus on a single case; however, what makes single case studies most valuable is their explicit or implicit comparative inference, presenting implications that can be generalized for similar cases. The only attempt at comparison by the contributors is the introduction of Egypt and Indonesia in the first chapter, but even then, those two cases remain casual references rather than part of a structured comparative analysis.
Despite the issues discussed previously, the volume appears to be a valuable addition to the ever-expanding literature on the JDP. Its breadth of information and depth of analysis provide readers from both academia and the general public with a worthwhile read.
