Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-17T09:13:39.738Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Jazzing the Classics: Race, Modernism, and the Career of Arranger Chappie Willet

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 May 2012

JOHN WRIGGLE*
Affiliation:
jdwriggle@gmail.com
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

The American popular music tradition of “jazzing the classics” has long stood at the intersection of discourses on high and low culture, commercialism, and jazz authenticity. Dance band arrangers during the 1930s and 1940s frequently evoked, parodied, or straddled these cultural debates through their manipulations of European classical repertoire. This article examines Swing Era arranging strategies in the context of prevailing racial essentialisms, conceptions of modernism, and notions of technical virtuosity. The legacy of African American freelance arranger Chappie Willet, and his arrangement of Beethoven's Piano Sonata, op. 13 (“Pathétique”) for the black dance band of Jimmie Lunceford, suggests that an account of the biography and artistic voice of the arranger is critical to understanding the motivations behind these hybrid musical works.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © The Society for American Music 2012
Figure 0

Figure 1.Publicity photo sent to Louis Armstrong (“To King ‘Louie’ Best Regards ‘Chappie’ 1940”); the photo probably dates to December 1937. Willet accompanies client Carrie Belle Powell (vocalist with the orchestras of Willie Bryant and Claude Hopkins) in his midtown Manhattan office, located on West 44th Street off Broadway; Powell holds a copy of the 1936 published leadsheet for Willet's (instrumental) composition “Blue Rhythm Fantasy.” Courtesy of the Louis Armstrong House Museum.

Figure 1

Example 1.Sonatine Transatlantique: “Spiritual and Blues” mm. 21–23, by Alexandre Tansman (1930). Alphonse Leduc – Robert King, Inc. A subsidiary of Editions Alphonse Leduc (Paris). Used by Permission. Chord symbols have been added by the author.

Figure 2

Example 2.Whole-tone interlude voicings after “Stratosphere” mm. 77–83 (1:13), by Jimmie Lunceford (probably 1934, as per date of recording).

Figure 3

Example 3.“After You've Gone” mm. 129–33 (1:56), arr. by Willet for Louis Armstrong (probably 1937, as per air check date). Transcription by the author.

Figure 4

Example 4.“Prelude in C-sharp Minor” mm. 171–76 (2:54), arr. by Willet for Duke Ellington (1938). Chord symbols reflect the manuscript guitar part.

Figure 5

Example 5.Comparison of “Sonata Pathétique” mm. 123–30 (2:10), arr. by Willet for Jimmie Lunceford (1940), and Beethoven's original solo piano score.

Figure 6

Example 6.“Sonata Pathétique” mm. 176–80 (2:50), arr. by Willet for Jimmie Lunceford (1940).

Figure 7

Example 7.“Sonata Pathétique” mm. 134–42 (2:23), arr. by Willet for Jimmie Lunceford (1940). Chord symbols have been added by the author.

Figure 8

Example 8.“Prelude in C-sharp Minor” mm. 57–62 (0:54), arr. by Willet for Duke Ellington (1938). Chord symbols reflect the manuscript guitar part.

Figure 9

Example 9.“Rustle of Spring” mm. 47–51 (0:47), arr. by Willet for Lucky Millinder (circa 1942). Transcription by the author.

Figure 10

Example 10.Sonatine Transatlantique: “Spiritual and Blues” m. 80, by Alexandre Tansman (1930). Alphonse Leduc – Robert King, Inc. A subsidiary of Editions Alphonse Leduc (Paris). Used by Permission. Chord symbols have been added by the author.

Figure 11

Example 11.“Sonata Pathétique” excerpts from mm. 1–40, arr. by Willet for Jimmie Lunceford (1940).

Figure 12

Example 12.Comparison of “Sonata Pathétique” mm. 45–49 (1:19), arr. by Willet for Jimmie Lunceford (1940), and Beethoven's original solo piano score.