On 11 April 1981, a soccer game between two teams representing Palestinian towns in Israel, Kafr Yasif and Julis, ended in a violent clash that resulted in the death of two fans, one from each town. Three days later, an armed mob from Julis stormed the streets of Kafr Yasif in a well-planned revenge campaign, killing two persons, injuring ten, and causing significant property damage.
The event left bitter memories and anger toward the police and the state among the residents of Kafr Yasif. The residents of Julis are Druze, a religious community that maintains an alliance with the state and whose male members even serve in the Israeli security services; the attackers from Julis were armed with IDF-issued weapons. In contrast, Kafr Yasif, a mixed Christian–Muslim village with a tiny Druze minority, has a history of political nonviolent resistance to the state's oppressive policies; they did not have similar arms to protect themselves. The police were criticized for not intervening in the attack, which lasted almost two hours. According to the police official line, the assault of Kafr Yasif caught them unprepared because they could not have predicted it.
The violence took place only twelve miles away from my home on a kibbutz in the Western Galilee. Kafr Yasif was familiar to me since it is located on a main road, and I regularly passed through it on my way southward. Although I was only twelve, I remember well the shocking reports in the media about the event. Magid Shihade was even closer to these events. He is a native of Kafr Yasif who attended the infamous soccer game and later heard the gunshots from his school classroom. Decades later, this event triggered the research presented in this book, in which Shihade tries to explain the eruption of violence.
The book contextualizes the events within the broader history of the colonial divide and rule strategy employed by the State of Israel toward its Arab–Palestinian citizens. Its importance lies in reminding us that analyzing violence between citizens of any state should begin by considering their status in the state and the policies of the state toward them. This is especially important when violence occurs in non-Western societies, since in these contexts the Western media tends to attribute violence primarily to cultural factors.
The text is most convincing when the author explains the state's contribution to internal divisions between its Arab citizens. However, problems begin when he tries to trace the specific historical details of the Kafr Yasif-Julis confrontation of 1981, deriving from this history some overarching insights about the direct responsibility of the police and the state, and even seriously considering conspiracy theories. This caveat lies not in the reasonability of the argument, as in the mismatch between the research question and the sources used to investigate it. The book's argument about the police's responsibility centers on the motivation and the practice of the state, whereas most of the empirical material is based on interviews held between 2003 and 2005 with Kafr Yasif residents, with some analysis of media coverage in Arabic and Hebrew.
Although relevant documents of the security services about the event might not be available to the public yet, interviews with retired policemen, twenty-two years after the event, could have been useful in understanding the dynamics of the confrontation and would not have necessarily echoed the official line. Even if we take into consideration the elusive nature of memory, the actors themselves are important sources for understanding what occurred. Similarly, not a single resident of Julis was interviewed, and there is no explanation in the text for this absence. What we know about the actions and motivations of the people of Julis is always inferred from the words of Kafr Yasif interviewees. For example, the mayor of Kafr Yasif at the time of the events said that after the deadly soccer game, government officials forced the mayor of Julis to reject an invitation to meet with him. What does the mayor of Julis or anyone else who was involved have to say? Is it possible that even after more than two decades the issue is still too sensitive to allow an open conversation between a scholar from Kafr Yasif and the residents of Julis? At any rate, the absent voice from Julis is the large “elephant in the room” throughout the book.
If the scholar's interest is only in the subjective memories of Kafr Yasif residents, his sources are sufficient. As stated, however, his aspiration is also to understand “what really happened,” especially the state's role in the event. Methodologically, there is another problem that should have been discussed: there is not a single reference in the book to the possible effect of the passage of time from 1981 until the interviews and of intervening events on the memory of his subjects. The interviews took place soon after Israeli police killed thirteen Palestinian demonstrators inside Israel in October 2000, and it is more than likely that this recent event influenced the way interviewees saw the police.
Furthermore, the book not only argues that internal divisions between Palestinians serve the state's interest but also that not interfering in internal violence among Arabs is “a policy by design” (p. 143) and that violence among Palestinian Arabs is rewarded (p. 144) or even planned by the state (p. 43). Although the first argument is sound (as illustrated by Ian Lustick, Arabs in the Jewish State [Austin, Tex.: University of Texas Press, 1980], Hillel Cohen, Good Arabs: The Israeli Security Agencies and the Israeli Arabs, 1948–1967 [Berkeley, Calif.: University of California Press, 2010], and others), the book fails to convince at least this reader that the state had an interest in this internal violence and actively encouraged it. In other words, I was not convinced that the state had a motivation to undermine its sovereignty by privatizing violence. Regarding the specific case of Kafr Yasif, the Israeli government even contributed most of the money for the reconciliation agreement. The author mentions this fact briefly, without considering its significance.
Shihade uses some other instances of interreligious clashes between Palestinian citizens of Israel in order to argue that there is a pattern of state nonintervention. He cites as an example the 2005 Druze–Christian clashes in al-Maghaar and asserts repeatedly that the police did not intervene. Media reports, however, mention that three policemen were injured while intervening. The author also quotes unidentified eyewitnesses who alleged that some policemen took part in the anti-Christian attacks. This vague testimony later becomes an undeniable fact when the author analyzes the event. Beyond such methodological lacunae, the text is frequently repetitive and could have benefited from significant editing work, including correcting inaccuracies in regard to the dates of some major events.
Using the violent events of 1981 as a starting point for discussing Israel's policy toward its Arab citizens is an intriguing approach, but in order to validate the proposed explanations of the specific case study a more rigorous and careful investigation is needed. At the same time, it is noteworthy that at the macro level, Shihade's arguments are correct: divide and rule has been a consistent policy of the Zionist movement and later of the State of Israel, and the social distance between Kafr Yasif and Julis is partly a result of this policy. The Israeli police are less likely to intervene in internal conflicts between Arab citizens, while media coverage of intra-Arab clashes tends to prefer an Orientalist “cultural” explanation over questioning state policy. This book's major contribution is to highlight these tendencies.
