Cinema, Slavery, and Brazilian Nationalism explores how films about slavery produced in Brazil between 1976 and 2005 reaffirm and adjust a sense of national identity among their audience. Gordon lays out his premise in the introduction: ‘Filmic depictions of slavery evoke for audiences part of the genesis of social inequality in Brazil as well as the development of its racial, ethnic and cultural diversity. If historical films in general lend themselves to provoking reconsiderations of national identity, cinema about slavery intensifies this tendency.’ The result is a highly detailed, student-friendly analysis of five films, including two films by the Cinema Novo exponent Carlos Diegues Xica da Silva (1976) and Quilombo (1984), and the first book-length study of the representation of slavery on the big screen in Brazil.
At the heart of the book's argument is the proposition that the treatment of slavery in each of the five films ‘resonates’ with Abdias Nascimento's take on the ‘culturally syncretic nature’ of the Brazilian population in his 1980 book O quilombismo: documentos de uma militância pan-africanista. Gordon explains how Nascimento proposes a modification of the then hegemonic discourse on cultural syncretism and racial miscegenation in Brazil, enshrined in Gilberto Freyre's Casa grande e senzala. In this book, first published in 1933, Freyre famously challenges the conviction, based on the discourse of biological determinism, that miscegenation leads inevitably to degeneration. Instead he emphasises the positive dimensions of the African influence in Brazil. Despite this, Freyre has subsequently been criticised for being Eurocentric and paternalistic, assigning Portuguese Christians a privileged role in this Brazilian mixture. While Nascimento agrees with Freyre's emphasis on cultural hybridity in Brazil, ‘he inverts Freyre's Eurocentrism and advances a fundamentally Afrocentric view of the nation’. O quilombismo is part of a wider effort among activists and academics to ‘underscore the inequality and social exclusion’, which are disavowed by Freyre's celebratory ‘happy hybridity’ take on Brazilian culture.
Each of the book's five chapters examines how the films participate in this process of emphasising the African and Afrodescendent role in Brazilian national identity. The chapter on Aleijadinho: paixão, glória e suplício (2000), directed by Geraldo Santos Pereira, focuses on how the film uses slavery to ‘urge national cohesion by alluding to a sense of ongoing, shared oppression’. The film is set in eighteenth-century Minas Gerais and narrates the life of Antônio Francisco Lisboa, popularly known as Aleijadinho (which means ‘the little cripple’), who became one of Brazil's most celebrated baroque sculptors and struggled with a severe degenerative disease for most of his adult life. Aleijadinho has often been appropriated as a national hero, most famously by one of the architects of Brazilian modernismo Mário de Andrade in his essay ‘A arte religiosa no Brasil’ in which he describes the sculptor as ‘um gênio virgem […] puro e inocente’ and the founder of a genuinely Brazilian art. Aleijadinho carries out another appropriation of the sculptor by treating colonial-era Brazil of the eighteenth century as an allegory of Brazil at the turn of the twenty-first century. Gordon draws on research from the field of social psychology (mainly through Patrick Colm Hogan's Understanding Nationalism) to analyse the modes of audience identification or ‘techniques of nationalisation’ encouraged by the film. He concludes that Aleijadinho emphasises the national category of identity and encourages a sense of cohesion ‘by depicting a social context – colonisation – in which a population that would become Brazil is collectively oppression’.
In an illuminating footnote to the introduction, Gordon lays out his approach to film analysis. On the one hand, he uses terminology drawn from social psychology to construct an ‘audience-centred’ perspective that aims to draw out likely audience reactions to the film by focusing on the nationalisation techniques such as ‘opposability’ (defining a national identity by constructing its collective outside or Other) and ‘affectivity’ (encouraging viewer empathy with a character or group that embodies a certain notion of national identity). Although, since he admits he can only ‘propose likely responses among diverse members of Brazilian audiences’, Gordon's analysis is mainly ‘text-centred’, consisting of a highly detailed, sometimes blow-by-blow analysis of plot, character construction, and the use of extra-diegetic and often (especially in the case of Gilberto Gil's score for Quilombo) anachronistic soundtracks. This approach is both the book's strength and its weakness: strength because students (the book's clear main target readership) will find the plot recapitulations and detailed analysis very useful; weakness because this almost exclusive reliance on social psychology (via Hogan) leads to a somewhat one-dimensional analysis. It often feels as if the somewhat clunky framing devices used in the films (in which characters ‘look back’ at an earlier period of history and in the process encourage viewers to make connections between that period of history and their own) do not merit Gordon's almost frame-by-frame analytical scrutiny. Some of the most illuminating moments of the book derive from a loosening of its text-centricity, such as when the treatment of slavery in Chico Rei (1985) is placed in the context of the final years of the dictatorship.
Furthermore, it seems a shame that the first monograph study of representations of slavery in Brazil should focus exclusively on the national context. Although Cinema, Slavery, and Brazilian Nationalism argues very persuasively for the nation as the main frame for identity in the films, one cannot help but feel that this simplifies the picture somewhat by sidestepping the evident transnationalising tendencies that traverse the films. There is no attempt, for instance, to view the films in relation to wider diasporic discourses on the legacy of slavery, either through a comparative angle (an approach favoured by Robert Stam in his 1997 study Tropical Multiculturalism: A Comparative History of Race in Brazilian Cinema and Culture, Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 1997) or by engaging with the transnational scope of diaspora (in fact the theme of diaspora and its many theorists get scarcely a mention). Such a broadening of focus would have increased the significance and gained a wider readership for this valuable discussion of slavery on film in Brazil.
