For an historian who for so long has drawn primarily on written sources, reviewing this book is a challenge as well as a stimulus. Written sources, it is true, are inflected at origin by feeling, by prejudice, by purpose. And subsequently they are open to interpretation, since what they convey — by precision or imprecision, by inclusion or omission — may mean different things at different times to different people: they can be read along the grain or against it. Juxtaposition with other sources may help; so, too, may experience. Even so, the reader may come by habit to share too much of the rhetoric or even the modes of thought of the sources or, perhaps less likely, to reject them too firmly.
Some sources are, of course, written to persuade: they look to the future. Others are more completely a matter of record, perhaps of ex post facto justification. Those may rely, in part at least, on memory, on recollection. That feature they have in common with oral sources, but the subsequent processes differ. What has been set down in a written source will be given meaning or, more likely, meanings, by subsequent readers. What is held in the mind will mutate. Human memory is both a wonderful thing and a fallible one. What it retains is selective, though the criteria for selection are various, seeming to include trauma and chance, experience and rote-learning. Memories are sometimes seen as ‘refreshed’, but they may be changed in the process. They have a loose connection with chronology, often a greater one with place, circumstance, even scent. And setting such memories down makes them written sources, subject to some of their drawbacks and advantages. It is often done by interlocutors, if not with their own agendas, their own capacities and sympathies. Their questions may be met with enthusiasm or with evasion.
I recall — if I dare attempt such a risky thing — an interview with the late Lord Milverton at the House of Lords. Much earlier in his career he had been A.F. Richards, Governor of North Borneo, and I was trying to interpret a document of his I had found in the records of the British North Borneo Company at the Public Record Office in London. What he remembered some forty years on seemed to be rather what he wanted his letter to achieve rather than what it seemed to me to state. Interviewing the elite is by no means uncommon, though perhaps it is better done without the written source in hand.
Oral history is, however, more often associated with attempts to give voice to those whose records would not normally be found among the despatches in the national archives. That has been done, of course, by recourse to other archives, most copiously, perhaps, by James Warren. It has also been associated with the genre of ‘subaltern studies’ and with the work, for example, of Gyanendra Pandey and his concept of ‘fragments’. It is the latter that particularly inflects the essays in this book, which began as a collection of papers presented at a conference held in Singapore in 2010, ‘Historical fragments in Southeast Asia: At the interfaces of oral history, memory and heritage’. Pandey conceptualised the ‘fragment’ as ‘a trace of a lost history and a fracture within the dominant narrative’ (p. 3).
It was an attractive, if somewhat adventurous, topic in Southeast Asia, where nationalism is strong, and governments promote its grand narratives, and the resultant book adds a new piquancy to the distinguished Palgrave series Studies in Oral History, belatedly bringing the region into its purview. It was all the more attractive and adventurous in Singapore. There the state is insistent on a particular ‘grand narrative’, finding fragments rather jagged and fractures rather dangerous, a kind of historiographical fracking, but has also, since 1979, supported the practice of oral history, at the same time as, like other Southeast Asian governments, maintaining a reluctance to open up its written archives to the public. About half the present book deals with Singapore.
The work is divided into three parts, each comprising three chapters. The first part deals with the relationship of oral history and official history. All three chapters are Singaporean in focus. On the basis of student exercises Kevin Blackburn argues that family narratives at times endorse the ‘Singapore Story’, at times dissent from it, but that they are more accessible by ‘insider’ interviewing than by the ‘outsider’ interviewing of oral historians. Kah Seng Loh argues that the official narrative of the impact of the British withdrawal after 1967 is ‘fragmented’ by oral testimony. Framed as a severe crisis in the People's Action Party's official history, it caused hardship for some, but not for others, and most have come to terms with the past, making do, at times with an admixture of nostalgia. A third essay is Ernest Koh's on the Chinese diaspora and their wars. Memories of the Second World War were heterogeneous, but in the 1990s the Government sought to make it the first act in Singapore's national history. Some veterans — flying for the RAF or for the Republic of China — fall outside the narrative.
The second section of the book is entitled ‘Memories of violence’. Rommel A. Curaming and Syed Muhd Khairudin Aljunied discuss the Jabidah massacre of 1968 through the personal memories of a survivor, Jibin Arula. It shows how his story was made part of Nur Misuari's propaganda and how he himself came to lament the violence that ensued. Jularat Damrongviteethan gives an account of the appalling ‘Red Barrel incident’, in which suspected Communists in Lamsin were incinerated in petrol barrels as part of the Thai state's efforts to suppress the Communist Party of Thailand (CPT). A memorial is the focus each year of a ceremony of remembrance. Not all the villagers agree: some in their families were victims of the CPT. A third essay, by Leong Kar Yen, deals with a different kind of violence, the alleged massacre by Scots Guards of some 24 villagers at Batang Kali in December 1948. It serves, the author says, ‘as a reminder through its oral history that while Malaysia has a grand narrative, it can only be made whole if it acknowledges the many other fragments of its history’ (p. 133).
The third part of the book, ‘Oral history and heritage’, begins with Emilie Wellfelt's ‘The anthropologist as heroine’, an account of Cora Du Bois's work in prewar Alor and the people's postwar recollections of her. Those have changed, as those who knew her have died, and a new generation has taken over the corpus of Du Bois stories. Chou Wen Loong and Ho Sok Fong deal with the Sungai Buloh Leprosy Settlement, founded in 1930 some fifty years before leprosy became curable. Some 280 residents are left. A final chapter returns us to Singapore. The lightermen who worked on the River were driven out as it was cleaned up and made a tourist attraction and containerisation rendered them superfluous at Pasir Panjang. They tell their story in their own way, not quite the Government's.
Not wishing to write a nationalist ‘grand narrative’, a historian of Southeast Asia has to wonder how this material should be included, rather than merely passed by with a sigh or a tear. Can these be more than fragments? — or, to change metaphors, more than rocks that the historiographical tides both expose and cover up?
