From the time of the revelation of the Qurʾan to today's experiments in graphic art, the written word has reigned supreme in Islamic traditions. It is this large and complex field of artistic production that forms the central focus of Sheila Blair's Islamic Calligraphy. This handbook—the first broad survey of its kind in the field of Islamic art history—discusses thirteen centuries of Islam's written heritage from the Iberian Peninsula to the Chinese coast, and materials include Qurʾans, Persian poetical works, Ottoman calligraphic exercises, and modern installation works.
Blair's study is structured primarily by the chronological framework laid out in Marshall Hodgson's Venture of Islam. The five periods—identified as early (7th–10th centuries), early middle (10th–13th centuries), later middle (13th–16th centuries), age of empires (16th–19th centuries), and modern (20th century)—are further subdivided into themes and regions that allow for a certain latitude in organizing and discussing disparate materials. The volume's preliminary chapters describe Arabic language, writing tools and implements, and the appearance of Arabic script in various media during the 7th century before its appearance in the earliest extant Qurʾans written in Kufic script or the “angular style” (p. 104) during the 9th to 11th centuries.
In Chapter 4, Blair analyzes Kufic Qurʾans, their internal structures, and the functional and liturgical roles of diacritical marks. With an eye toward dating and localizing these early Qurʾans, Blair advocates art-historical techniques in combination with textual and paleographic evidence (p. 110). This integrated methodology appears most promising and owes much to Estelle Whelan's unpublished article, “The Phantom of Hijazi Script” (which should be published posthumously so that it is available to scholars in the field). Although these methodologies are critical for establishing stylistic and regional developments, the nonspecialist reader would have benefited from a more contextualized discussion of the orthographic variants and unusual verse orderings—that is, the rather unsteady and perduring processes of textual recension—displayed in these Qurʾans, issues that forcefully entered the public domain because of Toby Lester's notorious article “What is the Koran?” (The Atlantic Monthly, January 1999).
In Chapters 5 and 6, Blair demonstrates that the emergence and proliferation of round scripts as well as codification of the vocalization system around 1000 transformed Arabic from a rather inconsistent scriptio defectiva to a fully legible scriptio plena (p. 162). Scholars have sought to explain the triumph of cursive scripts: reasons include new writing technologies, the rise of the secretarial class, and religious sectarianism. Blair convincingly forwards the argument that this gradual change was effected by the influence of a growing class of copyists and the professionalization of the book trade during the early middle Islamic period (p. 177). For a generalist audience, however, a brief sociohistorical discussion of the deployment of a large administrative apparatus and the increasing presence of nonnative Arabic speakers during the Abbasid period would have framed more broadly the question of why rather illegible angular scripts finally gave way to legible cursive scripts.
Chapters 7, 8, and 9 tackle the theme of regional calligraphic developments in Iran, Syria and Egypt, Anatolia, Central Asia, India, and the Maghrib, circa 1250–1500. Blair describes the rise and subsequent dominance of the hanging scripts taʿlīq and nastaʿlīq in Persian lands. Due to its kinetic modulations and melodic undullations, nastaʿlīq is described as best suited to Persian poetry (p. 276). Particularly valuable is Blair's detailed analysis of Mamluk calligraphy not only through the materials themselves but also through the writings of several Mamluk scholars, especially the chancery secretary al-Qalqashandi (d. 1418), who divided calligraphy into rectilinear and curvilinear scripts.
Moving forward to the age of empires, Chapters 10, 11, and 12 analyze calligraphic traditions in Safavid and Qajar Persia, Ottoman lands, Mughal India, the Maghrib, and sub-Saharan Africa. Blair's discussion of the great Persian calligraphers such as Mir ʿAli Haravi (d. 1544)—who allowed his students to sign his name in his stead (p. 430), thus creating a kind of “trademark” that recalls the collaborative nature of contemporary artists' studios in Europe—is masterly and will stimulate future research questions about calligraphy during this period, among them, why Ahmad Nayrizi and his followers revived the cursive naskh script at the turn of the 18th century to transcribe Qurʾanic and other religious texts (p. 425). Was this a kind of Persian antiquarian revival or a reactionary response to modernity? Also, what were the influences of new print technologies on traditional calligraphic practices and forms during the 18th and 19th centuries in both Persian (p. 447) and Ottoman (p. 483) lands? Finally, how have female practitioners contributed to the history of Islamic calligraphy (p. 427), and how can one approach the question of gender within this male-dominated field of artistic production?
Blair in no way claims her survey to be exhaustive (p. xxxiii). Although the book is impressively thorough, many themes indeed remain to be explored. The two most promising fields of inquiry are Qajar and sub-Saharan Islamic calligraphy. In 2006, two new studies by Maryam Ekhtiar dealing with Qajar calligraphers and calligraphic practice sheets appeared in print, and more surely will follow. Likewise, our knowledge of sub-Saharan Islamic calligraphic traditions will expand exponentially over the coming years as the Timbuktu Libraries Project unfolds. Thousands of newly uncovered materials from Mali will help determine to what extent sub-Saharan scripts are derived from the northern Maghribi styles, what percentage of Islamic manuscripts from the 16th to 18th centuries were loose leafed and contained in leather satchels, and what elements gave form to the distinctive ornamental panels found in sub-Saharan Qurʾans (pp. 575–76).
In sum, Sheila Blair's Islamic Calligraphy is exciting on two levels: it will remain the major reference tool on Islamic calligraphy for years to come and, without a doubt, will prompt new questions about the art of “beautiful writing” in Islamic cultures from its inception to the present.
