Ports capture the imagination. For ancient Rome, ports signal the diverse, dynamic, mobile and cosmopolitan societies from which an empire was assembled, as well as the practical infrastructure and logistics through which it was maintained. Recent investigations into Roman ports more often have centred on the latter theme, especially their commercial development, human–environment interactions and underpinning technologies like hydraulic concrete. This is for good reason, since Roman engineering changed the maritime landscape by enabling the construction of harbours along any coast, wherever one was necessary or simply desirable. The communities that laboured and dwelled in these ports are no less important as objects of study, and they receive new treatment through the lens of epigraphy in this first volume of the Roman Mediterranean Ports project, co-directed by the book's two editors until Keay's unfortunate passing in 2021. This multidisciplinary project explores the topographical layout and technologies of Roman ports, their commercial organisation and the hierarchies and connections that marked their interactions.
Two initial chapters lay out the project's context and goals and the present volume's structure (Keay, ch. 1), as well as the varied potential, challenges and complexities of using epigraphy to understand port societies (Arnaud and Keay, ch. 2). The contributions that follow take up the associations for which the epigraphic evidence is well known and particularly rich in social implications, allowing examination of the varied professions and their internal organisation, dynamics and hierarchies. Merchants feature prominently, as one would expect, with studies examining how cultural diasporas of traders from Tyre and Berytus (Steuernagel, ch. 3) and Roman agents far beyond Mediterranean shores (Terpstra, ch. 8) may have sustained commercial connections through institutional features like stationes and even the imperial cult. In the varied social statuses of professions that form a recurrent theme, such merchants often emerge near the top of the hierarchy, even occasionally passing into elite circles. Whether one sees these associations as more open or more restrictive, it is clear that their social, economic and religious networks were often the path towards a wage, and perhaps also advancing one's place in society, according to Tran's view (ch. 4) of collegia of boat operators in the Roman west. The limited integration of Narbo's commercial networks does not seem to have kept a rising economic tide from metaphorically lifting at least some boats, whose navicularii joined the elite ranks (Christol, ch. 11). These opportunities and social dynamics of port contexts may, in fact, have afforded greater chances for more — and more rapid — upward mobility, as Mayer reads into the inscriptions from Narona near Dalmatia's Adriatic shore (ch. 12).
Yet from the absence or rarity of many port-based professions in the record at even epigraphically rich places like Ephesos, Rohde (ch. 5) cautions against over-positivist assessments of the roles of these associations, a point echoed by Verboven (ch. 14) through case studies that demonstrate the highly variable nature of different mercantile associations in the shaping of Roman trade. To this, Arnaud (ch. 15) and Aubert (ch. 9) add the challenges of disentangling the varied persons, roles, responsibilities and legal institutions within the world of shipping that lie beneath such opaque titles as navicularii, naukleroi, etc. Even among the epigraphically identifiable, Rougier's analysis (ch. 6) suggests how different the social hierarchies may have been from one port to another, embedded in contrasting local contexts like Panzram's Iberian case studies (ch. 10). The evidentiary imbalance may also be a by-product of the variable complexity of ports, with larger and busier harbours giving rise to more long-distance trade and correspondingly more specialisations that came to assert a public identity epigraphically: for example, Ostia-Portus offers extreme distance and scale of exchange along with a dedicated group of ballast handlers for those ships (Rougier, ch. 6).
Casting the net widely over different port societies therefore becomes an imperative but difficult undertaking. Across the volume's sixteen chapters, Puteoli appears in several; Narbo, Hispalis, Arles, Tarraco and a few others provide important comparative case studies. Inevitably, Ostia-Portus looms large as the prime example or touchstone. This creates a certain tension throughout, as contributors necessarily rely on sources from the metropolitan port while continually acknowledging its unique, even artificial, status. Notwithstanding the rewarding examinations of Ephesos that throw some variation into sharp relief (Rohde, ch. 5; Arnaud, ch. 13), the corpus and comparative framework remain strongly skewed toward Ostia-Portus, and toward Italy and the west more generally. As a result, it is difficult to evaluate the extent to which these rich observations on social dynamics reflect broader realities of Mediterranean ports.
Another area where epigraphy may stand at odds with dockside reality is at the lower end of the socio-economic scale. Traces of enslaved and other unheralded labourers actually working the ports are generally rare in the epigraphic record, but Virlouvet's horrea (ch. 7) provide tantalising clues to a world bustling with humble guards, measuring assistants and hunched-over porters. Some glimpses come from sources like the Sulpicii archives, but most are non-epigraphical: background figures in iconography, excavated clues to spatial experience and osteological testimony of bodies subjected to harsh labour. In confronting the invisibility of guards, Virlouvet captures a theme implicit throughout many discussions: ‘It is their low status — they seem to have been mostly slaves — which doubtless explains the dearth of epigraphic evidence which we have for them’ (165). Lower-status individuals and marginalised occupations occasionally peek through: for example, a remarkable inscription attesting to the pooling of resources by Ephesos’ fishermen to build a customs house lists individual contributions of as little as 5 denarii (Arnaud, ch. 13). Yet in general, if the lower social classes and large sectors of diverse port societies — not to mention those facets of life simply not memorialised as such — are left out of the epigraphic record, how complete and representative a picture of a port society can inscriptions provide? Purcell weaves this fundamental question throughout the concluding discussion (ch. 16), which situates the particular epigraphic habit at ports within the broader social context — and spatial and temporal extent — of Rome's Mediterranean world.
The editors’ assertion that ‘inscriptions are the main class of evidence for any attempt at reconstructing social life and interaction, especially where ports are concerned’ (36) underscores the strengths and limitations of this source, especially considering the choice to discount ‘non-monumental epigraphy’ (i.e. stoppers/sealings, tituli picti). The humble evidence from such inscribed objects also calls attention to the unrealised potential of a social archaeology of ancient port life. The richer stories of Roman port societies include non-elite voices recovered through archaeological finds and contexts, as well as the identities and experiences of coastal dwellers beyond the major urban centres that have dominated discussions to date. Just as Rome brought port infrastructure not only to the largest hubs but to many new shores and smaller settlements, so too were the social dynamics of these vibrant little maritime communities integral to Rome's Mediterranean. Arnaud and Keay have provided a welcome epigraphic compendium for understanding Roman port societies, and a simultaneous call to take seriously — and prioritise archaeologically — the many diverse port dwellers up and down the social ladder and all along the shore. The fieldwork of the Roman Mediterranean Ports project appears poised to tackle these questions.
