Studies of violence in the Middle East have been notoriously fraught with troublesome cultural, religious, and racial stereotypes. Women in Conflict in the Middle East joins a rapidly expanding field of literature that pushes back on previous problematic approaches to the subject, exploring Palestinian women's subjectivity in the face of diverse incarnations of violence. The book presents, at best, a mixed bag to those familiar with Palestinian women's experiences in Lebanon and the West Bank. In some ways, Holt provides a general update to canonical works published by scholars such as Rosemary Sayigh and Julie Peteet. In contrast to much of the scholarship on Lebanon, she also makes an effort to capture the experiences of those who live outside of Beirut. Yet, by relying on a broad and underspecified interpretation of what constitutes “violence,” Holt unfortunately risks pathologizing her interlocutors rather than realizing her goal of emphasizing Palestinian women's resilience, creativity, and agency.
Holt's claim that examining categories such as “home” and “memory” provides fruitful space to explore the ways that Palestinian women negotiate and renegotiate identity in the face of nested violent contexts will resonate with scholars of Palestine and the region in general. However, given previous—and productive—scholarly attention to intimate partner and sexual violence, refugee identities, and the effects of war on women in the Middle East (specifically Palestine), it seems that much of the ground covered in Women in Conflict in the Middle East has already been more effectively and clearly trodden. Holt's amalgamation of direct, structural, and cultural violence prevents her from parsing relationships and interactions between these categories, rather than opening new space for analysis. Moreover, she frequently glosses over the way in which intersecting identities—factional affiliation, socioeconomic status (not all Palestinian women live in poverty or in refugee camps), access to citizenship (some Palestinian women in Lebanon are Lebanese citizens but still identify primarily as Palestinian), religion (not all Palestinians are Sunni Muslim)—operate among Palestinian women, again foreclosing opportunities to explore multiple subjectivities and tensions among and between her interlocutors. While many of these issues stem from the author's sincere desire to spotlight those who endure deeply unjust conditions, the work suffers from a pronounced lack of theoretical clarity and depth as a consequence.
These problems are potentially caused and certainly compounded by the author's methodology. The book relies almost exclusively on interviews and (English-language) secondary literature to make its arguments. Holt repeatedly takes interviewees’ words at face value rather than probing and interpreting them. She presents block quotes from her interlocutors with little analysis, leaving the casual reader lost and the expert frustrated. There was ample room in the text—often used for extended, repetitive historical prose rather than for original interpretation—for Holt to expand, develop, and further problematize her interlocutors’ responses. Given the author's long-term engagement with Palestinian communities, it was also surprising that she did not use more evidence from participant observation, Arabic-language sources, archives, or “human artifacts” (trinkets, clothing, etc.). The book's discussion of rumor, for example, could have been augmented by a discussion of the strategies that women and girls use in order to evade camp gossips (such as teens meeting on proximate rooftops to chat or the increasing use of online messaging applications to mask communications). Discussions of women's roles in historical preservation might have gained more texture and dimension had the author, for example, delved into Palestinian social associations’ events centering on Palestinian food, weddings, poetry, and music. To those intimately familiar with life in the refugee camps, the picture that Holt presents seems limited.
Several glaring empirical errors or omissions also overshadow the contribution of Women in Conflict in the Middle East. Holt erases the Syrian occupation of Lebanon—and its fragmenting impact on Palestinian and Lebanese communities—from her analysis. As a result, the book ignores the profound yet paradoxical effects of the Syrian presence on Palestinian women. For example, when remembering the period between 1989 and 2005, many unaffiliated women and those linked to Syrian-allied political factions report that the camps became physically safer in contrast to the preceding years. For those affiliated with Fatah, by contrast, this period often represents a time when they or their family members were subjected to surveillance, intimidation, imprisonment, and/or death at the hands of the Syrian regime and its allies. Highlighting these types of processes could have productively underscored the diversity of experiences in the community. It also would have allowed Holt to examine how political affiliation, in addition to empowering Palestinian women, has divided them and exposed them to violence.
Discussion of the historical role of nongovernmental organizations and social associations in Palestinian communities is also completely omitted from Women in Conflict in the Middle East, with several groups’ perceived political affiliations, their relationships with Lebanese communities, and their struggles to maintain funding streams in the face of changing donor priorities generally left aside. For example, the author does not address Fatah's much-critiqued dominance of the General Union of Palestinian Women, the convergence of foreign nongovernmental organizations in Lebanon during the civil war, or the risks involved with operating an association in the camps without a political “umbrella.” In other words, in a book about women and violence, Holt decontextualizes and underanalyzes one of the primary organizational sites of women's activism in response to violence. As a consequence, the book disregards the roles that these organizations, and the debates surrounding them, play in constructing women's subjectivity and in (re)producing structures of domination.
Women in Conflict in the Middle East clearly reflects the author's sincere respect for her interlocutors and her desire to make their voices heard. If nothing else, it holds value because it keeps an easy-to-forget, complex set of issues on the table. However, Holt simply does not demonstrate the same engagement or precision that is evident in previous scholarship on this general topic. Given other recent works focusing on memory, civil society, and violence in Palestinian communities (such as Rochelle Davis's Palestinian Village Histories [Palo Alto, Calif.: Stanford University Press, 2010], which is missing from Holt's bibliography), it seems justified to expect a new book on Palestinian women's responses to violence to push beyond superficially “feminist” analyses and to more creatively explore intersections of gender, citizenship, activism, and violence.
