This book bills itself as a ‘survey of the burial and settlement evidence of late Iron Age Etruria’ that ‘offers a radically new interpretation of the so-called Orientalising material culture’ (dustjacket). Although an ambitious mandate, Corinna Riva's first monograph should be welcomed by Etruscologists (and classical archaeologists generally) for delivering on its promise: it is at once a meticulously researched archaeological synthesis and a theoretically sophisticated meditation that forces a rethinking of the traditional picture of the Orientalizing period in Etruria.
The book consists of seven chapters. Ch. 1 (‘The Ancient City and Etruria’) maps out the major issues, including recently proposed revisions to the chronology of the earliest phases of Etruscan urbanization, the deficit of Etruscan and the burden of Roman texts in writing history, and the importance of funerary architecture and grave goods as evidence for reconstructing socio-political relations. Ch. 2 (‘A Long Process and Rapid Change’) surveys the archaeological evidence for urbanization from the end of the Bronze Age to the seventh century by focusing on the settlements and cemeteries at several of the new large centres that emerge in this period (e.g. Tarquinia, Caere and Veii).
Ch. 3 (‘Orientalising: Accessibility and Transformation’) introduces a key theme — transformation — that runs throughout the next three chapters. R. argues against the traditional school of thought that holds that the rise in the late eighth and seven centuries of an ostentatious new Orientalizing lifestyle was ‘transmitted’ to Etruria and that it was fundamentally princely or monarchic in nature. As the author puts it, such a point-of-view is diffusionist and colonialist: the Etruscans’ adoption of certain aspects of the Near Eastern lifestyle does not predicate their adoption of the same monarchic system of political authority. R. instead grants agency to Etruscan élites, who used their access to trading partners and craftsmen to construct ‘their own idea of the East reflecting their own claims to sociopolitical status within the local community’ (47). For instance, élites used objects characterized by exclusive materials (bronze especially), impressive craftsmanship and exotic imagery to flaunt ‘their power over accessibility and the wider world’ (63) and thus buttress their socially exclusive position.
This analysis of the ‘material aesthetics of transformation’ is followed by a discussion of ‘the transformation of funerary ideology’ in ch. 4. Here R. argues that the ‘warrior ideology’ — ‘the vehicle for articulating status and political authority in Iron Age burial ritual’ (80) — was materially transformed by Orientalizing élite groups into an ideology of the ‘civilized warrior’ whereby social status, not gender, became the defining feature. This ideological shift thus finds its expression in a broad spread of Orientalizing artifacts, whose imagery (e.g. warriors, fantastic animals) and function (e.g. sceptres, incense burners, chariots) speak to their remarkable fusion of élite culture, warrior custom, and eastern influence.
Ch. 5 (‘The Transformation of Political Authority’) turns from the contents of tombs to their architecture. While it has long been recognized that multi-chamber tombs imitate domestic interiors in their structure and decoration, R. argues that their function as ritual spaces has been under-appreciated. In particular, the multi-depositional nature of these structures promoted the tomb as a communal space for the re-enactment of social rites (including banqueting and wine-drinking). She also holds that the construction of monumental tumuli created a ‘landscape of power’ (126) through which élites could stake their claim of land ownership while the rituals and ceremonies performed there provided eye-catching public spectacles. There is interesting discussion here, too, of ancestor cults and the way in which ritual was used to create fictive genealogies for the community, again to the élite's benefit (e.g. at the Tomb of the Five Chairs in Caere; however, see also now G. Camporeale, ‘The deified deceased in Etruscan culture,’ in S. Bell and H. Nagy (eds), New Perspectives on Etruria and Early Rome (2009), 220–50).
Ch. 6 (‘The Transformation of Grave-Goods’) continues the discussion of memory-making and élite political authority by focusing on rites of commensality and the materiality of the objects employed (inscribed bucchero pottery in particular). Even though few intact tombs are preserved, the material itself is highly suggestive, and it is probably for these reasons that she takes greater recourse to social anthropological theory in this chapter than in any other. Her interpretations, which pay their due respects to the gods of social theory (Foucault, Giddens and Strathern, among others), are pithy and wide-ranging, and so defy easy summary here. However, the central contention is that the practices of banqueting and drinking which élites introduced as the central ritual activities at the tomb mark a fundamental change in consumption habits, and that mediating that change in rites generated sociopolitical power and authority for them, especially since these were recursive practices.
Ch. 7 (‘Etruria and its Urban Mediterranean Network’) returns to the question that sits at the heart of her study: ‘how did Etruscan centres become cities of such a complex type and in such a swift fashion?’ (1). R. shifts focus from city and tomb to those factors that shaped the trajectory of urban development across not only Etruria but the wider Mediterranean.
In sum, this is not your traditional archaeological history of Etruria. The critical digest of sites and monuments should make it required reading for Etruscologists, while the broad implications of R.'s arguments and the interpretive sophistication of her method present an invigorating challenge to the orthodoxy that all classical archaeologists should weigh, if not welcome.
