The review by Kurt Weyland correctly points out that my book depicts and measures the factors that lead to the democratization of countries, and whether the traditional notion holds that a country’s development is the most detrimental to the development of democracy. The reviewer also correctly noticed that when the interplay between the factors of development and diffusion is considered, diffusion factors have a stronger influence on a country’s threshold for adopting democracy. In addition, the reviewer recognized that the book enhances our understanding of a country’s decisions to adopt democracy and a country’s potential to achieve a certain level of democracy. Nonetheless, the reviewer put forward several concerns about the analyses found in the book.
These concerns mainly stem from a) the reviewer’s interpretation of the concepts of diffusion and development, which is different from the interpretation presented in my book, and b) a misunderstanding or misinterpretation of the methodology of multilevel longitudinal models used to conduct my analyses of the growth of democracy within each country, region, and across the world since the 1800s.
Specifically, a misinterpretation of my concepts of diffusion and development led the reviewer to mistakenly believe that my analyses focus on the sharp distinction between external and internal factors leading to processes of democratization, and that external influences account for diffusion and a country’s internal characteristics account for development. As explained in the first chapter, the categories of diffusion and development are rooted in the theories of diffusion and development and do not follow an external/internal dichotomy. For instance, in my analyses, even though an indicator of the level of development of a region where a country is located (i.e., regional development depicted as regional nonagricultural labor) is an external factor, it is an indicator of development. At the same time, the indicator of societal access to media is an indicator of diffusion (media factor) but could also indicate development if defined as a form of media. By treating media conceptually as societal exposure to media information that varies over time, as opposed to the concept proposed by the reviewer, one can see how media facilitates a path of diffusing democratic/or antidemocratic ideology—a classic approach of diffusion. This conceptualization of media allowed me to demonstrate that the effect of media could be a “roadblock” on the path to democracy. Indeed, figures can be found in my book for the present countries of the Middle East, where levels of democracy have declined as a result of an increase in the average societal exposure to media information.
Weyland’s different interpretation of diffusion also led him to overlook my study’s treatment of “diffusion of democracy as an outcome” variable that depicts processes of the spreading of democracy with a certain temporal rate and velocity. The application of multilevel longitudinal models allows me to assess temporal heterogeneity of the growth of democracy—its increase and decline across time within countries, across countries, and within the world’s regions. Thus, contrary to Weyland, the methodology used clearly accounts for the temporal variability of all indicators of the growth of democracy and shows their historical direction via graphs and the results of statistical analyses presented in tables included in Diffusion of Democracy.
Weyland’s book and my own share similar topics but apply different methodological and conceptual approaches, and by considering both together, we can hopefully enrich scholarship about democratic processes.
