No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 June 2004
There is an extensive literature (to which I have contributed), affirming and denying the idea that the Wizard of Oz by L. Frank Baum reflects the major political and economic controversies at the turn of the twentieth century. In this book, Ranjit S. Dighe has done a superb job of summarizing and extending this literature. Apparently, Dighe left no stone unturned as he searched Baum's writings, the secondary literature on Baum, and the history of the period for relevant material. The resulting book has a Talmudic structure. At its heart is the original text of the Wizard of Oz. Then in detailed footnotes Dighe presents the allegorical interpretations previously suggested, his shrewd comments on these interpretations, and a number of new interpretations. Dighe also provides brief essays on the monetary history of the period, on Populism, and on the quantity theory of money—everything in fact that a teacher will need for a successful lecture.
For readers who use the Wizard in their teaching, the most important question will be whether Dighe has uncovered some new stories to add to their repertoire. Here the book does not disappoint. One episode, to which Dighe draws attention in an appendix, appears in the Marvelous Land of Oz, the sequel to the Wizard of Oz. The Scarecrow faces an untimely end because he has lost his straw. He is saved when his friends stuff him with paper money—a clever illustration of the idea that money has the power to revive the ailing farmer. Another example is Dighe's extended footnote on Coxey's Army. Others have suggested this famous 1894 “jobs march” as a possible inspiration for the Wizard of Oz. Dighe, however, goes on to point to one of the strangest characters involved as a possible source for the Wizard. This gentleman referred to himself while on the march as the “Great Unknown.” He was later identified as a patent medicine salesman from Chicago known as “A. P. B Bozarro” and as the “Wizardo Supreme.” Dighe also refers the reader to secondary sources that are likely to be unfamiliar to economic historians. Michael Riley's persuasive comparison of the Emerald City with the “White City,” the site of the Chicago World's Fair, (“The Great City of Oz: L. Frank Baum at the 1893 World's Fair,” The Baum Bugle, winter 1998, 32–38) is a good example.
One of the interesting findings of recent research on Baum is that he was more conservative than had been believed. It had been assumed, based on his son's biography, that Baum was a Democrat who had supported William Jennings Bryan. New evidence shows that Baum was probably closer to being a Progressive Republican. He was certainly highly skeptical of politicians including Populist politicians. Some critics have fastened on Baum's Republican leanings to conclude that an historical reading of the Wizard of Oz is mistaken. In my view, and I believe that Dighe's book support this, the historical reading works better when it is freed from the assumption that Baum was a staunch Bryan supporter. Criticism of Populist politicians, of course, did not exclude sympathy for the people who became Populists or, at times, sympathy for their causes. In any case, Baum has proved difficult to pin down. For example, as an editor of a newspaper in South Dakota Baum wrote some extremely harsh words about Native Americans, and he has been rightly castigated for this. However, the wonderful fictional character that Baum created for his newspaper, “Our Landlady,” joins the Populists and expresses a more sympathetic attitude toward Native Americans.
How does Dighe treat the debate over Baum's intentions? Dighe stresses the lack of direct evidence for an allegorical intent, and the need to warn students about this. Dighe then maintains that the story “works” as an allegory and goes on to develop the analogies in detail. This is sufficient to justify using the historical reading as a teaching device. However, if we are going to use the literature from a period to explore economic history, we will need to consider the likelihood that writers of fiction can be influenced by the political, social, and economic context of the times in which they write, even when they are not trying to convey a carefully worked out interpretation of their period.
Ranjit S. Dighe has written a fine book that will serve both the practical purpose of helping teachers use the Wizard of Oz in the classroom and the scholarly purpose of helping economic historians use the historical reading of the Wizard of Oz.