Lisa Balabanlilar's detailed and rigorous approach to the history of the Mughal Empire offers a dexterous investigation of the contested and sometimes contradictory origins of imperial identity. The work addresses the era from the Timurid period to the end of Aurangzeb's reign, or roughly from the 15th through the 18th centuries. Balabanlilar relies on Chaghatai Turkish and Persian sources, squarely and purposefully demonstrating the Mughal Empire's Turco-Mongol lineages and inheritances. In many ways, this is the central contribution of her work, as much prior Mughal historiography has overlooked, downplayed, or marginalized the ties Mughals had to Timurid and Central Asian norms, mores, and cultures.
Balabanlilar's linguistic training allows her to forge a historiography in which the nomadic legacies of the Turco-Mongol lineages are shown to deeply influence the noted rootedness of the South Asian empire. This is an important contribution to the historiography of South Asia; indeed, by neatly linking the Turco-Mongol to the Mughal, Balabanlilar ably demonstrates the multiple identities of the Mughal royal families. These identities center both on regional and cultural practices as well as distinctive events that came to shape a new, distinctive Mughal character. The regional and cultural norms are easily listed: Central Asian ruling cultures, Turco-Mongol linguistic patterns, and, among others, Perso-Islamic mores (be they religious, political or otherwise). The significance of the lineages and interpretations of the cultural linkages that formed Mughal identity are Balabanlilar's pivotal evidences as well as her distinct contributions. Balabanlilar argues that Mughals used common cultural practices as well as a shared (though often imagined) history in such a way that they became distinguishing identity-markers and, indeed, identity-shapers. These include a Mughal self-understanding as refugees, as peripatetic rulers, as charismatic leaders, and as religious beacons. It is the marriage of these historiographical claims to identity—the broader, sociocultural, and historical patterns as well as the unique voices that articulate specific ideas of a Mughal collective self—that marks Balabanlilar's work as a formidable contribution to South Asian historiography.
The book's sections are divided according to topic. Balabanlilar begins by explaining the Timurid style of rule in the prologue. Here, she highlights the ideological frameworks at play in Central Asia, focusing on the tenets that will become important later for Mughals, including the importance of charismatic leadership, military victories, Islam as a useful tool, Persian literary culture, and pleasure gardens. The first chapters delve more readily into the matter at hand—Mughal identity—beginning with Babur, the earliest Mughal emperor. Balabanlilar articulates a Mughal identity that is at once Turco-Mongol and Perso-Islamic, and rooted within a narrative of displacement, migration, and loyalty to the Timurid line. She also structures her discussion around the concept of memory, which helps to demonstrate her overarching premise that the Mughals were a purposefully hybrid empire whose dominant discourse was characterized by collective remembrance. Balabanlilar is careful to insist that memory is not static, and she explains how the experiences of migration and displacement described in the first chapter shaped the ways in which Mughal lineages were manipulated to suit different historical needs, such as the formations of a community, a common culture, and a political regime. Focusing on memory is theoretically timely as many recent studies have adopted this analytical approach, but it is also inordinately valuable to her work; by stressing the manipulation of memory and its effects on self-conceptualization, action, and public articulation, Balabanlilar successfully avoids merely listing historical events or data that support her claim of Mughal hybridity, and instead demonstrates the empire's unique positionality.
The later chapters deal with themes familiar to scholars of Central and South Asia—gardens and issues of lineage—and relate them to the formation of Mughal identities. These chapters stress the role of both Timurid and Perso-Islamic influences upon the Mughal Empire. Gardens are, as many scholars have pointed out, a defining characteristic of both Timurid and Perso-Islamic cultures. Balabanlilar discusses the importance of such features to individual kings as expressions of their individual political might; she argues that gardens were less religious than imperial affirmations of dominance over new territory, and, as such, were crucial to the expansionist efforts of the nomadic empire. Toward the end of the work, Balabanlilar addresses issues of succession and legitimacy. While this later chapter centers on the ways in which princes were trained to rule and how they actually came to rule, the author pays special attention here to the role of women, as well; by stressing the importance of clan in Timurid systems, she highlights the ways in which mothers and wives served to legitimate fathers, sons, kings, and princes.
Balabanlilar ultimately concludes by stating that the Mughals were truly Timurid kings of India, having maintained a remembered lineage of generations past while simultaneously forging new, distinct characteristics and norms for their empire. Throughout the book, Balabanlilar nimbly weaves together divergent sources that span the entirety of the period; furthermore, she utilizes a variety of theoretical lenses (memory, identity, migration, imagination) to great effect. The particular contributions of this work lay in her close readings of a collection of Central and South Asian texts that deal not only with political events but also with religion, lineage, and Mughal self-fashioning, and will no doubt serve as useful resources for scholars of those regions. The broader contribution of the work, however, may simply lay in her premise: the Mughal Empire drew upon its Timurid genealogy in a way that, with few exceptions, has been overlooked or downplayed. By making this relationship primary, Balabanlilar successfully articulates an innovative way through which to view not only the Mughal Empire but also the Turco-Mongol lineage from which it stems as well as the relationship of the Mughals to other Perso-Islamic empires of this period. Similar work that would take up any number of the subjects that she addresses—Islam, nomadism, and gender, among others—and engage with the sources she uses would only add to our collective understanding of this massive empire and its lineages and legacies.
