This is a study of the sophisticated ‘men about town’ (nāgarakas), ‘connoisseurs’ (rasika), and ‘heroes’ (nāyaka) who populated early medieval Indian courts and imaginations, based upon provocatively original analysis of the literature composed by, for and about them. Ali argues that largely unstudied and/or trivialised dimensions of courtly life, including etiquette, ornamentation, eloquence, play and especially erotic dalliance, were in actuality central and consequential concerns of courtiers – not only kings but also their various ‘circles’ of allies and rivals; friends, courtesans, ministers, scholars and artists; wives and other female relatives; palace functionaries – which suffused the whole of medieval Indian political life with a particular “aesthetic sensibility” that constitutes the main topic of this book.
The book's first section details Indian political life and the culture of Indian courts from the time of the Guptas (fourth to sixth century, CE) until about 1200 CE. Chapter One, ‘The people of the court’, explicates uniquely Indian understandings of lordship in relation to palace architecture and personnel, and discusses the court's proximity to larger urban(e) environments sharply differentiated from the rustic countryside, delineating the contexts in which courtly affairs took place inside the palace (e.g., assembly-hall, harem, garden) and also outside it (Ali is especially interested in the salon or goshṭī wherein ‘men of taste’ gathered for conversation and entertainment). Chapter Two, ‘The culture of the court’, provides an overview of the śāstric goals of rectitude (dharma), acquisition (artha) and pleasure (kāma) as they were played out in court literature, shaped educational purposes and practices and underlay the court's operative value systems. Chapter Three, ‘The protocol of the court’, examines the dynamics of day-to-day interaction there: expectations revolving around service, loyalty and favour which were articulated in elaborate codes of exchange and courtesy and fulfilled in proper deployment of gesture, speech and bearing.
The book's middle section deals with the cultivation of aesthetic sensibility. Chapter Four treats “Beauty and refinement', as ‘something like a worldview, an idea through which people conceptualised relationships with both themselves and others” (p. 143). Detailing courtly attention to beautifying the body, bearing, speech and the palace itself, Ali suggests that ‘ornamentation’ (alaṃkāra), in particular, worked as a foundational ‘cultural figuration’ of the court: the king was ‘ornamented’ not only with his jewellry and crown, royal robes and perfumes, but also with his ministers, harem, offspring, intelligence, discernment, generosity, and so forth; underlords ornamented themselves with lesser versions befitting their ranks and statuses. Chapter Five, ‘The education of disposition’, moves toward a “theory of courtly subjectivity” based upon the “savouring” (rasa) of emotions. Śāstric taxonomies and literary stylisation of emotions, and especially of the second-order experience of them, are shown to reflect courtly preoccupation both with discernment of the emotions of others and the strategic deployment of one's own (p. 204). This supremely important ‘ornament’, like the various related virtues which men of the court strove to cultivate, was not considered innate, but rather was a specific skill in which princes and other aspiring ‘men of taste’ had to be trained; the theatre, wherein emotions, their interrelationships, and the mannerisms expressive of them were displayed, functioned both to train and further refine aesthetes.
The book's final section of the book zeroes in on the ‘hypertrophied ideological life’ (pp. 23–24) of erotic love among courtiers. Chapter Six, ‘Courtship and the royal household’, catalogues the types of liaisons, both licit and illicit, which were available to courtiers, and which provided contexts for voluminous śāstric advice, poetic allusion and theatrical scenes. Erotic love is the primary theme of all but one of the court dramas surviving from the early medieval period (p. 209) is analysed at length in the śāstras (especially, of course, kāmaśāstra), which provides a dominant metaphor of realpolitik in inscriptions (and it is well known that marriage alliance was a major political strategy); “sex . . . was a highly mannered and tutored experience, an ‘art’, which like other aspects of the courtier's life, was to be refined and perfected” (p. 213). Indeed, erotic love was considered by many thinkers to be the most ‘lordly’ of all the emotions, even the foundation of the very self. (p. 209) Theatrical portrayals of royal courtship were especially significant in this regard, not for revealing royal sex per se (which was usually public) but rather for revealing the inner emotions of the ‘hero’ and the skill with which he deploys them in conquering his lover. Chapter Seven, ‘Anxiety and romance in court society,’ argues that the martial imagery associated with love was not merely to make it a metaphor of power, but rather was appropriate because “[t]he contexts of courtship . . . were the contexts of the court, and as such were governed by the same principles and strategies” (p. 259). Erotic love was “a sort of ‘enactment’ of the affiliative dynamics which obtained between men at court” (p. 260), complete with ambivalences (Ali stresses the considerable fluidity of favour, rank and status) and anxieties (especially surrounding attachment and separation); the sexual training of princes (like their training in all the subsidiary emotions and manners) was in fact training in statecraft; the sexual practices of sophisticates involved on-going refinement of courtly skills; “[t]he king as the most powerful man at court had to constantly represent himself as the most perfectly skilled player in the contest of love” (p. 260).
Ali's work illuminates in utterly new ways well-known facts about medieval Indian courts, and primary sources. He writes in the wake of a formidable scholarship on the “grotesque” ornamentation of Sanskrit poetry (kāvya) and the effete and ineffective if not titillating niceties of the “oriental” court, and draws upon such Indological staples as the śāstras (especially Nāṭyaśāstra, Kāmasūtra, Arthaśāstra and Manavadharmaśāstra); the story of Nala and Damayantī, Pañcatantra, subhāṣita texts, and court drama starting with Bāņa's Kādambarī; published stone inscriptions. But he teaches us to see that, and how, the rhetorical flourishes, aphoristic admonitions and elaborate metaphors abounding in these sources, which historians all too easily skim past as merely decorative displays of linguistic bravado, were instead all-important markers of and actions within a ubiquitous, trans-regional ‘world’ (p. 212) of shared discourses and practices based upon this courtly aesthetic, wherein the scores of actual courts that Ali mentions rose and fell, and all this literature was produced; a ‘world’ which in addition to spanning the whole subcontinent, and most of pre-Islamic South Asian history, also has important implications for our understanding of (its transformation within) the Delhi Sultanate, the British Empire, and ultimately Indian modernity ‘a future discussion to which this is intended as a modest first contribution, as Ali suggests in his ‘Postscript’ (pp. 265–271)’.
The newness of Ali's reading is nourished in part by contemporary historiography of medieval European court life, and by Foucauldian concern with technologies of self, power and sexuality (pp. 9–11, 179). But while these may have provided him some ‘inspiration’, Ali's argument diverges from earlier Indological scholarship primarily for ‘taking seriously’ the specific content and context of the primary sources (p. 11). This involves a two-fold methodological strategy, empirical and analytical (p. 18). On one hand, the literature is taken as empirical evidence of just what this aesthetic and ethical ‘world’ entailed. Ali shows that śāstra, kāvya and inscriptional rhetoric (and also art and architecture; the book includes numerous useful plates and diagrams) overlap on many specific points and general perspectives to suggest that this aesthetic sensibility is what really mattered to the men of the court; only scholars, somewhat inexplicably, have ignored or dismissed it. On the other hand, as will already be clear, Ali treats these documents as relics of the history that he wants to reconstruct, analysing how particular texts and genres would have ‘worked’ as “‘modes through which individuals were ‘educated’ and ‘interpolated’ into the structure of courtly life in a highly reflexive manner” (p. 18). Śāstric concerns like how to read gestures and facial expressions or the much dissected and classified role of biting and scratching in lovemaking – all of them repeatedly played out as the tropes of poetry and the stage – are taken seriously as aspects of the refined self which princes and other aspiring men of the court were trained to become, and according to which successful agency in the highly sophisticated and subtly textured ‘world’ of the court was measured and deployed. It is thus that the seemingly empty boasts of royal inscriptions, so long and so completely ignored by historians – conceits about the king's beauty and grace; the attachment others feel for him, and he for them; his virility; his poetic flair – turn out to be highly technical claims to forms of self-mastery that his peer groups of kings and courtiers also strove to attain, and that was exercised, at whatever level possible, as mastery over others; the real ‘stuff’ of political authority and power. Subsequent analysis will doubtless widen even further the horizons Ali has opened up – my own work with Sinhala documents, for example, suggests that Buddhists constructed royal ‘attachment’ and pleasure rather differently – but learning to see this ‘world’ at work will surely enrich every study of medieval Indian materials, most of which survives from these same royal courts.
