In this intriguing book William Gruber discusses the aesthetics of absence, and interrogates the narrative strategies used by playwrights to help audience members conjure the unseen within their imaginations. Taking Plato's distinction between mimesis and diegesis as his point of departure, Gruber explores the wide variety of ways in which playwrights deploy these modes, and how subtle differences in their uses can have a huge impact on how “offstage space” is conceived by an audience. Gruber's is a wide-ranging volume that considers works from artists as disparate as Euripides, Edward Gordon Craig, Susan Glaspell, Brian Friel, Edward Albee, Suzan-Lori Parks, and Marguerite Duras.
In his introduction, Gruber notes that he is interested in exploring why a playwright might choose narrative over scenic enactment in a play. He then explains his intention of presenting a wide survey of plays that demonstrate various uses of narrative. Gruber notes that he does not aim to present a comprehensive overview, but rather to present “examples sufficiently numerous and varied to be illustrative” (13). He succeeds admirably in this aim, for the examples that follow present an extensive view of the ways in which playwrights have used telling versus showing to create the world of a play.
In Chapter 1, “Showing vs. Telling,” Gruber launches into a discussion of that staple of classical tragedy, the messenger speech. He offers a brief survey of the criticism devoted to messenger speeches, and rightly points out that even though there is a long tradition of playwrights using this dramaturgical device, there is relatively little critical theory devoted to the subject. Gruber takes a close look at the function and format of these speeches, noting that they are more than just a vehicle for keeping unseemly scenes off the stage. He points out that the description provided in these moments can stimulate a more complex contemplation of described events than might an actual enactment. Through an examination of the rhetorical features of the messenger speech in Euripides' Medea, which describes the agonizing death of the princess of Corinth from a poisoned robe and crown, Gruber shows how the mixing of past and present tenses creates a sense of immediacy that connects with a feeling of powerlessness and horror for an audience who cannot change “what they know has already come to pass” (35). The end of the chapter moves into a discussion of the erotic, and of the role concealment plays in creating desire. Here, Gruber discusses David Hare's sexually charged play The Blue Room, and the “allure of the unseen,” demonstrating how, by denying sight of the object, playwrights “may actually cause audiences to see it” (75).
Chapter 2, “Against Mimesis,” explores the “self-conscious uses of diegesis” (77) in the works of Bertolt Brecht, Suzan-Lori Parks, and William Butler Yeats, among others. Gruber discusses teichoscopy in particular, a technique in which a character relates events that he or she is witnessing as they “occur” offstage, just beyond the playing space (91). Gruber notes that when playwrights use this technique, not only can they still have offstage events happen in “real time,” but they can also give the audience a chance to use their imaginations to create a mental image of the extrascenic space. The intermediary character who witnesses events for the audience can also provide an extra layer of commentary depending on how they choose to relate the details and on their own reactions to the events.
No book about the aesthetics of absence would be complete without a discussion of Waiting for Godot, and Gruber provides this in his third chapter, “Theatres of Absence.” Here he discusses plays that contain a thematically central character who is not materially represented in the text. In his explication of Godot, Gruber notes that the titular character is imbued with theatrical power because of his deliberate concealment. Gruber also shows how Godot gains potency through absence because he is weighed against the comparative powerlessness of the onstage characters. Gruber then moves on to discussions of several other plays featuring “absent” characters, including Susan Glaspell's Trifles, Federico García Lorca's The House of Bernarda Alba, and Marguerite Duras's “India Cycle” of plays and films.
Although this book is primarily focused on the rhetorical aspects of dramatic texts, it can be a useful catalyst for the consideration of directorial choices for staged productions. As directors, we are always deciding what to show and what not to show; this book provides new ways to think about these dramaturgical choices of inclusion and exclusion. Gruber has given careful consideration to the texts around which we build our productions, and has crafted an interesting and useful look at some elements of dramaturgy that often go overlooked.
