Amanda Rees has written a wonderfully cohesive and in-depth history of a scientific controversy that has been alive in primatology since the 1970s: is infanticide caused by unusual social or environmental conditions and thus rarely seen in primate societies or is infanticide in fact an all too common behavior explained by sociobiology? Although many may assume an adaptive framework unequivocally explains infanticide among primates, serious questions have been raised concerning the validity of the data upon which this belief is based.
Rees argues that the problematic status of observation in fieldwork and primatology's multidisciplinary roots have sustained the infanticide controversy. At the centre of Rees's argument is a concept she calls the ‘fieldworker's regress’. This term is used to capture the flexibility involved in interpreting data collected in unique field settings and represents a new application of Harry Collins's experimenter's regress. The introduction clearly lays out how Rees will use the fieldworker's regress to demonstrate ‘how the context of the field both aids and hampers the conduct of controversy’ (p. 10), and indeed the term is central to each of the subsequent chapters. For example, Rees's understanding of the field as a place limited by the dynamic nature of the environment and the variability of the study subjects smoothly connects Part 1, which gives an overview of the history of primatology, with Parts 2 and 3, which demonstrate how this history of field science contextualizes the intense controversy surrounding primate infanticide.
Contradictions between theories and contentious relationships among personalities are often what make histories of controversies so enjoyable and The Infanticide Controversy is no exception. Rees paints a vivid picture of fieldwork through detailed accounts of the publications and conferences around which the infanticide controversy pivots. With concise and lively writing, Rees guides the reader through complex scientific arguments by providing detail while also highlighting the key points that differentiate them from the opposition. For example, Rees provides an in-depth analysis of key articles, such as Sarah Hrdy's 1974 paper that strongly argued that infanticide was an adaptive strategy, and the critical responses these publications provoked. Rees also focuses on specific conferences, such as the 1982 Wenner-Gren Conference held at Cornell University, which brought scientists from both sides of the controversy together for in-person debates that were later captured in edited volumes.
Interviews with a number of primatologists and anthropologists enrich Rees's comprehensive knowledge of the published literature. Several of the individuals interviewed played central roles in the infanticide debate, including Sarah Hrdy, Anne Pusey and Bob Sussman. Quotes from these interviews are interwoven within each of the chapters dedicated to the infanticide controversy and particularly in Chapter 5. In addition to adding further complexity to Rees's analysis, these interviews reflect the positive relationships she has developed with the primatological community. Indeed, Hrdy shares her praise for The Infanticide Controversy on its back cover.
Rees's application of sociological methods in combination with approaches and scholarship from the history and philosophy of science ensures a robust analysis of a significant scientific controversy that intersects with several questions within the history of science. This characteristic of The Infanticide Controversy ensures the book will have an impact far beyond the small group of scholars who, like myself, specialize in the history of primatology and animal behaviour studies. Seamlessly, Rees integrates a detailed analysis of debates within primatology regarding the cause of infanticide with broader questions concerning observation, the connection between practice and theory, and the relationship between scientific disciplines and the humanities. The fact that this is accomplished by combining historical, philosophical and sociological approaches makes this book an ideal choice for the HPS classroom as well as the HPS scholar.
