Christopher Degelmann's monograph is the slightly revised version of his 2016 Ph.D. thesis at the Max Weber Center for Advanced Cultural and Social Studies (University of Erfurt). As D. illustrates in his introduction (11–30), squalor refers to the practice of members of the Roman elite appearing in public with untrimmed hair and in mourning dress — dark, worn clothes — in an effort to win the support of judges, the Roman Senate or the Roman people in a difficult situation. Squalor might also encompass displaying grief, imploring the audience and sometimes even tearing one's clothes apart. A prominent example is Cicero, who employed squalor in 58 b.c. in an ultimately unsuccessful attempt to prevent his exile as a consequence of a law promulgated by his arch-enemy Clodius. Many of the features of squalor were firmly rooted in Roman funerary rites. Therefore, D. suggests, squalor should be understood as a form of symbolic mourning. His monograph builds on earlier works by Karl-Joachim Hölkeskamp on Roman political culture and those of Egon Flaig on rituals and public gestures in Roman politics. Cases of squalor in different political and legal arenas are taken into consideration, as well as both the successes and failures of symbolic mourning.
In his first chapter (31–43), D. argues that individuals utilised specific symbols closely tied to funerary rites in different performative settings to achieve their political aims. However, in order to employ symbols successfully in such a flexible way, the intended target audience must be able to recognise them easily within their new context. Ch. 2 (44–70) turns to the origins and historical background of symbolic mourning in Rome. In the following chapter (71–93), D. discusses testimonies of squalor in works of Cicero, Livy, Appian and Cassius Dio to identify narrative patterns associated with symbolic mourning. Ch. 4 (94–111) illustrates the inherent tension between the formation of literary tradition and the question of whether scenes of squalor in ancient sources may be considered authentic. D. devotes chs 5, 6 and 7 (115–35, 136–55, 156–75) to an analysis of key elements that were used to signify symbolic mourning. D. focuses on the role of clothes, the act of tearing one's clothes apart, the gesture of beating one's chest (planctus) and the imitation of a funeral procession (pompa funebris) in such scenes. Ch. 8 (176–92) investigates how gestures belonging to the sphere of the patron-client relationship could be utilised in squalor. Ch. 9 (193–211) turns to expressions of grief and gestures of supplication. In ch. 10 (212–20), D. briefly summarises the results achieved so far, before turning to squalor and the arousal of emotions (ch. 11, 221–33). The following chapter (234–48) analyses clementia, fides and pietas as fundamental Roman values which formed the common basis of understanding between protagonist and audience in scenes of symbolic mourning. Ch. 13 (249–64) discusses different options available to members of the Roman elite when a political opponent employed squalor. While ch. 14 (265–76) investigates specific situations in which symbolic mourning could have resolved a political conflict, but was not performed, ch. 15 (277–89) is devoted to the question of why squalor was marginalised during the early Empire. In his final chapter (290–302), D. concludes that symbolic mourning was an integral part of Roman political culture from the Punic Wars onwards and was employed to express personal or collective crisis in order to promote conflict resolution. However, with the advent of the Principate and the emperor as a single authority for resolving conflicts within the Roman elite, the relevance of squalor declined. An extensive bibliography and useful indices complete D.'s book (303–61).
D.'s monograph is a valuable contribution to the field of Roman political culture. D. discusses both successful and unsuccessful examples of squalor and describes squalor as a set of practices and gestures drawn from funerary rites and the patron-client relationship. He suggests understanding squalor as a form of symbolic mourning. Persons expressed squalor by utilising elements of funerary rites, even though no one had actually died (12 and 291). D. focuses on squalor as a means for evoking emotions such as sympathy or compassion in the audience (ch. 11), but neglects the role of emotions on the part of the protagonists of squalor. Yet, when one looks at Cicero's squalor in 58 b.c., the possibility cannot be ruled out that Cicero was actually moved by strong emotions arising from the grave personal losses that he feared as a consequence of his impending exile. This raises the question of whether the term symbolic mourning is fully appropriate in such cases, even when taking an author's tendency towards self-fashioning into account. The adjective symbolic implies — at least to some extent — that mourning was simply pretended, and that it is not necessary to consider a wider range of emotions on the part of persons or groups employing squalor. In summary, D.'s monograph is an interesting read, provides useful insight into the many facets of squalor and will undoubtedly open up new avenues of research in this important field.
