The daily hearings of the Leveson Inquiry in 2011 and 2012 revealed the nature and extent of the complex interdependence between the media and politics in Britain. Never before was so much evidence made publicly available about the cosy deals between leading politicians and media owners, the complicitous bargaining between the two sets of actors for their mutual benefit and the sometimes conflictual nature of their exchanges when things turned sour. If politicians clearly sought to use the media for their own partisan political objectives, in return media tycoons appeared to exercise influence over decision making in the field of media policy, most notably with regard to ownership rules and content regulation. Do the media, however, exert political power across a broad range of policy-making sectors? This is clearly an important question for our understanding of the political process and, not surprisingly, is also an area of growing academic inquiry (Koch-Baumgarten and Voltmer, Reference Koch-Baumgarten and Voltmer2010).
Malcolm Dean's book is an important contribution to this debate. Dean was for many years the editor of the Society section of The Guardian, a weekly supplement specialising in social policy. He is, therefore, admirably qualified to write about the impact of the media on the formulation and implementation of social policy in Britain. Dean argues that the media have indeed influenced the content of social policy over the past four decades, albeit more in some areas than in others and that, in particular, certain right-wing tabloid newspapers used and abused their capacity to influence their readers as a means of exerting pressure on politicians.
The overall structure of the book is very clearly mapped out. In the first chapter, ‘The rise and fall of mainstream journalism’, Dean focuses on two aspects of political communication in Britain: the relationship between government and media since the election of Tony Blair as Prime Minister in 1997 and the commercial power of the Murdoch media group. Chapter 2 examines the social policy-making sector within the context of a changing welfare state since its inception at the end of the Second World War. There then follow seven case study chapters of variable length and depth that focus on specific fields of social policy: law and order; drugs; asylum; child poverty; vocational education; health and social care; and, finally, housing. The final chapter examines different ways in which the defects of the media can in the author's opinion ‘damage and erode the democratic process’ (p. 341). These ‘seven sins of the reptiles’ are: distortion; dumbing down; a greater interest in politics than in policy; hunting in packs; adversarialism; being too readily duped; and a concentration on the negative.
As one would expect from an ex-journalist of a quality newspaper, the book is well written in a very accessible style. In particular, there is none of the jargon that is a feature of so many academic books on the media and politics. In those policy areas such as law and order or asylum where Dean argues for a strong media influence on policy making, the case is put forcefully and with considerable supportive evidence. The argument is also put forward with some subtlety, for instance when Dean points to the way in which on the question of the possible reclassification of the usage of certain drugs the media did not behave in as critical, knee-jerk fashion as anticipated by politicians. The book is as much a critique of politicians, for instance the way in which they often prefer to brief general rather than specialist correspondents so as to avoid expert critical coverage, as it is of the media.
From an academic perspective, the book does suffer from certain weaknesses. It is certainly not a systematic, far less scientific, analysis of the media's impact on social policy making, as Dean freely admits. Moreover, quite a lot of the material is less about the impact of the media on policy making and more a general account of how the media report on social policy formulation – not quite the same thing. Finally, a policy-making analyst might argue that Dean does not disentangle the precise nature and level of media influence as an analytic variable. For example, on an issue like asylum one can analyse media coverage on the one hand and chart political pronouncements and policy proposals on the other, but establishing that the former is driving the latter is by no means methodologically straightforward. Governments, after all, frequently resist well-orchestrated media campaigns.
Where, however, the book is extremely strong is in its critique of the media's deformation of its information role. At the end of one chapter, Dean writes: ‘The most serious charge against the media . . . is denying the public a rational debate. Democracies are strengthened by serious well-informed debate and subverted by being denied one’ (p. 206). In highlighting some of the defects of media performance in their coverage of important areas of social policy, Dean reminds us of the constant need for citizens to be aware of the malign consequences of government spin, political misinformation, unsubstantiated media framing, half-truths, hyperbole and sheer journalistic prejudice. While the recommendations of the Leveson Inquiry may help in addressing some of the chummy excesses of the relationship between politicians and the media in Britain, there will still remain a need for citizens in their media usage to subject news content to their own critical scrutiny.
