The publisher describes this book as “compelling and thought-provoking” as well as “essential reading for archaeologists, international lawyers and all those involved in cultural resource management.” Publishers often employ hyperbole, but here I agree with the assessment: It is a thought-provoking, provocative, and substantial contribution to the most contentious museum issue of the last 100 years.
The book's title belies the scope of its contents. The author traverses a wide range of interrelated and (in the author's argument) indivisible issues concerning the legacy of colonial rule, particularly the return of cultural objects (excluding human remains) to their country, state, or peoples of origin following decolonization. She presents three “rationales for restitution” (p. 2), from which she develops a cogent argument for returns, coupled with examination of how international laws and other instruments have addressed the issue from 1815 to the present. Her starting point is the Congress of Vienna, which returned the artworks and other cultural items plundered during the Napoleonic wars. This date coincides with Lord Elgin's offer of the Parthenon marbles to the British Parliament; but the author eschews recitation of specific case histories in favor of analyses of international instruments relating to colonial and postcolonial situations, and to acts of war and genocide, particularly in Europe during World Wars I and II.
This approach leads the author to draw a relationship between policies of physical genocide and the cultural genocide of colonial occupation, including settler states. Colonial administrations instigated or permitted practices that destroyed cultural practices and eliminated the identities of many colonized populations. One such practice was to allow museums, particularly the national museums of the occupying states, to acquire and remove cultural items under circumstances of unequal relations with the occupied people. In some cases these items were comparable with what Lord Castlereagh in 1815 described as “the title deeds of the countries” plundered by Napoleon (p. 19). In the colonial situation possession of such items “was central to the collective imaginings of the occupier and the occupied,” acting on the one hand as symbols of empire and domination over others, and on the other as symbols of “dispossession of lands, autonomy and identity” (p. 299).
Vrdoljak argues that only through the restitution (her preferred term, contra the book's title) of these items can we correct the discriminatory and genocidal practices of the past and complete the process of decolonization. She extends this argument to encompass indigenous minorities in settler states, drawing attention to how they have been ill served over many decades, not least because international instruments focus almost exclusively on the state rather than its constituent people. Unconditional restitution can contribute to self-determination and assertion of identity and allow all parties to move forward to reconciliation on an equal basis. Even here, however, there are problems of potential conflict between the “national imaginings” of the new states and the “imaginings” of their minority groups, whose inclusion reflects the arbitrary nature of territorial boundaries defined by the colonizing powers. For some minority groups, decolonization gave them no option for self-determination, but merely changed one controlling authority for another.
After nearly 200 years of conflict, argument, and debate, and a proliferation of international instruments (pp. xx–xxvi), we are still a long way from resolving even fundamental issues. The author describes how the increasing number of newly independent states has affected the content of these instruments; but market states and former colonial states continue to promote self-interest through the protection of their universal survey museums, the rights of their individual citizens, and that strange creature known as free trade. This does not mean that progress is not being made, but I question whether pursuing yet more international instruments is the only or most useful way to proceed. Changing minds by moral persuasion can be a drawn out affair during which patience can be sorely tested, whereas coercion brings reluctant and often limited compliance. This is particularly so where implementation of compliance requires domestic legislation and the government of the day faces that most powerful political motivating force to retain the status quo: its own electoral survival. Around the world we have also seen that a change of national government can negate progress, or worse still turn back the clock. In this context, readers should note that the Australian government that “repeatedly sacrificed the rights of indigenous peoples” (p. 286) was not returned to office in November 2007.
During my time at the Australian Museum (1971–2000), we usually dealt with returns of cultural items on a case-by-case basis through face-to-face discussions, relying on a statement of principle that was shorter than the titles of many international instruments addressing this issue. We did not work from a detailed policy to set out the conditions and procedures to which a requesting party should conform, and we avoided where possible the involvement of governments. This approach permitted flexibility. Here the author and I diverge: She appears to prefer a more prescriptive approach, arguing for action in a manifesto that allows little or no deviation from its premises and underlying logic (pp. 299–304). I am uneasy about this, because it runs the danger of becoming reductionist and exclusionary, ignoring the complexity of relations between people throughout history and into the present, and reducing returns and related issues to a rigid, binary opposition of being for or against. Conversely, the frustration of many formerly colonized states and indigenous peoples, particularly in settler states, is justified, because they have waited far too long for constructive action. But the solution is not wholly or even largely within the capability of museums, which have neither the resources nor the authority to affect the changes required to achieve the objectives set out on this book. Their task is made more difficult by the governments of market and settler states that perpetuate “a cult of forgetfulness” about past iniquities (p. 195), and for which self-determination of groups within their territorial boundaries is anathema. Here museums have a significant, ongoing role in jogging memories at all levels.
The act of returning cultural items is as much about a shift in power relations as it is about cultural revival, reassertion of identity, and self-determination. When museums in Australia embarked on returning cultural items in the 1970s, they confronted two main psychological barriers: the perception that they would lose control over their collections and fear that one return would lead to a flood of claims, leaving empty storerooms and exhibition halls throughout the nation. These are powerful emotions, as the author points out, in relation to the removal of “artistic, literary and scientific objects” from Parisian institutions after the Congress of Venice, when “the reaction of the citizenry to this process naturally overshadowed the volume of objects that remained in France” (p. 29). Over the last 30 years, returns of cultural items to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities as well as to Pacific Island nations, Canada, and India have not resulted in empty museums. On the contrary, the act of giving back has often benefited both parties in various ways, but we are still far from perfection, as chapter 8 illustrates. The documents adopted by the peak bodies of Australian museums and galleries in 1993 and 2004 (pp. 282–86) marked significant progress in bringing the disparate entities together on common ground. The fact that neither document was perfect reflects the reality of what could be achieved at the time. They are now effectively national standard setting instruments for museums participating in the Return of Indigenous Cultural Property Program (RICPP) (p. 285). In contrast to the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA) project in the United States, this program did not require the imposition of legislated proscriptions on museums. It was established by consensus between the Commonwealth of Australia and its states and territories, with the broad support of indigenous Australians and the national museum profession.
Chapter 7 covers the 1970 UNESCO Convention concerning the illicit export or change of ownership of cultural items, together with how the United States, United Kingdom, and Australia have complied with it, and the UNESCO Intergovernmental Committee (IGC) to promote the return of cultural items. The IGC resulted from two meetings of experts in 1976 and 1978 and a study by International Council of Monuments (ICOM). I attended the 1978 meeting in Dakar, which was charged with preparing draft statutes of the committee for submission to the director general and the general assembly of UNESCO (p. 212). In reality, the meeting did not draft the statutes but reviewed and slightly modified a set derived from the 1976 and ICOM deliberations and from the secretariat of UNESCO. Given the ideological gulf between participants of opposed political persuasions, it would have been impossible for the meeting to develop draft statutes from scratch in the time available. The prepared version considered at the meeting reflected a strongly European-centered view that found little support among some participants, and it was remarkable that the meeting completed its work. The final form of the statutes; the deficiencies of the IGC's operations; and its use of “State,” “nation,” and “peoples” as if they are interchangeable (pp. 213–17, 234–241) reflect, to my mind at least, the extreme difficulty of operating effectively in an environment where strongly opposed views and values must be accommodated by compromise.
The 1970 UNESCO Convention stimulated a program to inventory the Pacific Islands' cultural items held in museums in the United Kingdom and Ireland, United States and Canada, and Australia and New Zealand (with a parallel program for indigenous collections within Australia) (pp. 237–39). As the author notes, the resulting inventories proved of limited value to claimant States for a range of reasons. Those of us who participated in the project over several years readily acknowledge these failings, but the author misses the most enduring contribution of the inventories: They signalled a willingness to communicate openly with the states and peoples of the Pacific Islands, thus breaking down psychological barriers on both sides. This may seem trivial today, but 25 years ago it was an important step. With today's technologies, such a project would be vastly different and, hopefully, more effective.
A point of clarification is required in relation to the MacGregor collection of Papuan cultural items (p. 225). At the end of the nineteenth century the colonial governor, William MacGregor, assembled more than 14,000 items for a colony museum. Lacking local facilities, he placed the collection in the Queensland Museum, Brisbane, on the condition that it should be returned once suitable facilities became available. In the 1980s the National Museum and Art Gallery of Papua New Guinea exercised this right of return but donated a substantial number of items to the Queensland Museum in recognition of its assistance. This was not the collection referred to on page 225, which confuses MacGregor's collection with the later Papuan Official Collection (POC) made in the same territory and for the same purpose by Hubert Murray, lieutenant governor of Papua from 1906 to 1940. Murray faced the same accommodation problem as MacGregor and sought the assistance of the Australian Museum in Sydney as temporary custodian of the POC from 1915 until 1934, when Murray authorized its transfer to the Australian capital in Canberra. This collection remains in Canberra despite efforts to have it returned to Papua New Guinea.
Some readers with only a general knowledge of the operations of the United Nations and its associated agencies such as UNESCO may have difficulty in comprehending the various kinds of instruments mentioned in the book. The listing (pp. xx–xxxviii) of conventions, declarations, protocols, recommendations, resolutions, and so forth is useful but would be improved by brief explanations clarifying the distinctions between them and how they affect the international community (e.g., which are binding, with or without domestic enabling legislation, and which are advisory, etc). I also found difficulty with the lack of clarity regarding what constitutes a “people” or “peoples,” and how these differ from nations, communities, groups, and minorities.
The author notes in the introduction and final chapter that the book focuses on Anglo-American colonialism and its effect, but “this colonial project has been neither uniform nor is it exclusive” (p. 303). She adds the need to consider “rival contemporaneous colonial projects” under Civil Law traditions and the potential for this to “enrich our understanding of the development of the pertinent areas of international law and museum practices.” These statements suggest a degree of incompleteness in the preceding 300 pages, but I am sure that was not the author's intention. Discussion of this issue, however, might have been better at the beginning of the book, because it is important for contextualizing the three “rationales for restitution” and the analyses of international instruments. The concepts employed in these instruments and their analysis are culturally constructed and mostly derived from the Western intellectual tradition. They do not have automatic universality, until and unless member states of the various international bodies agree on what they mean and how they should be used. Such an agreement is clearly some distance away, even without considering indigenous minorities in settler states.
The author provides a well-written presentation of the issues refracted through her analyses; but, despite her advocacy in the final chapter, I see no simple, ready-made answers. The book's subject matter and its structure demand close reading, particularly passages that at first sight seem to repeat previous text but often contain subtle but important differences. Those unfamiliar with the literature on international law and the publications of UNESCO and related agencies may find the plethora of instruments and their various versions a challenge, but that is the reality of the situation. What, then, is my overall assessment? I reiterate my thoughts from the first paragraph: It is a thought-provoking, provocative, and substantial contribution. It should be read by a wide audience, including museum directors and trustees and politicians of all shades of the spectrum. Let the debates begin.
