Hideo Kimura, a 46-year-old Japanese male patient in a Boston hospital, needs to undergo surgery to remove part of his lower intestine but resists signing the consent form and has little understanding of English. Discussing this with an interpreter, Hideo is puzzled, because he has already authorized his wife Sachiko to decide on his behalf. The interpreter points out to him that he has a right, a moral right, to give his informed consent to the surgery and that Hideo is quite competent to decide for himself. Nonetheless, Hideo cannot grasp the meanings of “informed consent” and “moral right.” Hideo agrees to sign the consent form only after he is told that this is official hospital policy.
Though not as gripping as other dramas (a Sudanese couple insisting upon a clitoridectomy for their baby girl), this is one of many that continue to be played out in U.S. hospitals. Consider the discomfort of Muslim women when they are asked to wear “immodest” hospital garments. At Maine Medical Center in Portland, because of having to wear these “johnnies” (as called in New England), nearly 30% of female Muslim patients from African countries refused to show up for hospital appointments. For these women, wearing “johnnies” violated Qur'anic teachings on modesty and privacy.1
In July 2004, the medical center designed a new full-length hospital garment that met with approval, not only from the Muslim community, but from other patients.
Cultural beliefs and values exert a powerful influence in healthcare. Unless our healthcare institutions and professionals become more culturally aware and responsive, patients from diverse cultures risk substandard healthcare service due to misinterpretation, lack of understanding, and stereotyping.2
It is easy as well as naïve to simply reduce the problematic with the “unfamiliar” to matters of culture. We need to be careful and not attribute to culture more than warranted.
Culture and Healthcare
The link between culture and healthcare is unmistakable in Western biomedicine, our own dominant health culture, though in reality “one ethnomedicine among many others,” and one having certain patent features.3
Hahn RA. Sickness and Healing: An Anthropological Perspective. New Haven: Yale University Press; 1995:132.
The Alfred I. DuPont Hospital for Children in Wilmington, Delaware, and Boston Children's Hospital exemplify general pediatric holistic programs.
See note 3, Hahn 1995:142ff. With respect to crisis orientation, biomedicine is distinct from public health; public health has a major prevention focus.
At its heart, in its efforts to restore health and save and extend life, healthcare is about alleviating pain and suffering. In response, Western biomedicine offers a physicalist causal ontology. In pointing out that biomedicine is only one of a number of “causal ontologies” to explain suffering, cultural anthropologist Richard Shweder describes others that are moral, sociopolitical, interpersonal, and psychological:
a biomedical ontology of organ pathology/physiological impairment/hormone imbalance, or a moral ontology of transgression/sin/karma, or a sociopolitical ontology of oppression/injustice/loss, or an interpersonal ontology of envy/hatred/sorcery, or a psychological ontology of anger/desire/intrapsychic conflict and defense. (p. 315)6
Richard A. Shweder, Thinking through Cultures: Expeditions in Cultural Psychology. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press; 1991. Shweder cites the 1986 work of Arthur Kleinman, Social Origins of Distress and Disease, as a brilliant study in how different cultures view suffering.
Awareness of the force of our own dominant culture of Western biomedicine as well as the values of the market-oriented framework within which it operates is a first and essential step toward cultural competence.
What Is Cultural Competence and Why Is It Necessary?
Cultural competence goes beyond mere cultural awareness. In view of meanings of “culture” and “competence,” it is commonly rendered as
a set of congruent behaviors, attitudes and policies that come together as a system, agency or among professionals and enable that system, agency or those professionals to work effectively in cross-cultural situations. The word “culture” is used because it implies the integrated pattern of human thoughts, communications, actions, customs, beliefs, values and institutions of a racial, ethnic, religious or social group. The word “competence” is used because it implies having a capacity to function effectively. (p. 13)7
Cross TL, Bazron BJ, Dennis KW, Isaacs MR. Towards a Culturally Competent System of Care: Vol. 1. Washington, DC: National Technical Assistance Center for Children's Mental Health, Georgetown University Child Development Center; 1989.
In principle, this appears neat enough. Yet compare this with Centers for Disease Control and Prevention epidemiologist Robert Hahn's description of cultures and subcultures:
(1) a domain of knowledge or belief, that is, a definition of what this cultural system or subsystem is about, (2) a system of values and ideals of behavior, (3) an organized means for teaching this domain and its cultural values to recruits and other participants, and (4) a setting of norms of behavior and practice in which these beliefs, values, and teachings are enacted. (p. 132; italics in the original)8
See note 3, Hahn 1995:132.
The meaning of “culture” is arguable.9
Given the plurality of cultures and subcultures in our “American Mosaic” (Carnevale AP, Stone SC. The American Mosaic. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1995), it makes good sense to apply a wide enough brush to “culture” that it covers not just race, ethnicity, and geographic origin, but also “subcultures” related to religion, age, gender, socioeconomic status, sexual orientation, and physical capacity. This broad band incorporates numerous other marginalized groups like the homeless, the poor, gays and lesbians, and the disabled. The American Medical Association reaffirms this in a circular definition of culture as “any groups of people who share experiences, language, and values that permit them to communicate knowledge not shared by those outside the culture.” See AMA Cultural Competence Compendium at http://www.amaassn.org/ama/pub/category/4848.html; retrieved Oct 2004.
Quoted from John Stone of the Tuskegee Institute.
Why be culturally competent? First and foremost, cultural competence is a critical road map to trust, the most important factor in the caregiver—patient relationship. Patients who trust their caregivers will be more forthcoming, open, and honest. In addition, culturally competent institutions and professionals help to remedy and prevent healthcare treatment and outcome inequities due to cultural myopia, insensitivity, discrimination, misunderstanding, stereotypes, and ignorance. Along with this explicit moral rationale, there are more pragmatic reasons:
- Demography. The U.S. Census reports that our nation comprises at least 66 racial and ethnic groupings. The Bureau also predicts that, within the next 50 years, non-Caucasian cultures will constitute close to 50% of the population.11
Day JC. Population Projections of the United States by Age, Sex, Race, and Hispanic Origin: 1995 to 2050. U.S. Bureau of the Census, Current Population Reports. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office; 1996.
- Regulations. These include Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act; the Joint Commission on the Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO); the National Committee for Quality Assurance (NCQA); the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME), mandating curriculum material on cultural competency in medical schools; the Surgeon General's August 2001 Report on Mental Health: Culture, Race, Ethnicity; and the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) Office of Minority Health report, Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services (CLAS).12
For a copy of CLAS and commentary, see http://www.omhrc.gov/clas/cultural1a.htm; retrieved Nov 2004.
- Good business. Health consumer satisfaction works in tandem with health outcomes, so that effectively serving a diverse patient market via culturally responsible policies and procedures will no doubt produce a favorable impact. Connect the dots: Communication gaps and cultural divides lead to less effective services; less effective services aggravate patients' problems, resulting in the need for increased levels of care; this, in turn, incurs higher costs, costs that are borne by the healthcare organization, patients, and taxpayers. Organizations with a clear mission to promote cultural competence and who actively engage in efforts consistent with that mission gain a competitive edge in a market-driven health system.13
Achieving customer satisfaction along these lines validates allocating the needed financial resources for cultural competency programs. This business edge for healthcare organizations in adopting cultural competency is described in Brach C, Fraser I. Reducing disparities through culturally competent health care: An analysis of the business case. Quality Management Health Care 2002;10:15–28.
- Medical liability. Policies that promote culturally competent care are likely to help reduce claims alleging the absence of informed consent and the violation of standards of care.
Planning for Institutional Cultural Competence
Despite the strong case for organizational cultural competence, operationalizing that commitment generates challenges. Institutional mechanisms only have teeth through a systemwide collaborative and integrative effort that extends from executives to top-level management, medical and nursing staff, office staff in human resources, finance, housekeeping, and all other departments.
Such efforts will encounter resistance: Where is the funding? Why cater to the interests of “other” groups when basic services should be top priority? Aren't training programs in cultural competency impractical and burdensome? Don't we already offer fair access and treat all equally? This resistance requires competency efforts to be backed with strong top-down support and encouragement from senior officers. Furthermore, expectations need to be realistic. Cultivating cultural competency is an ongoing process. It is not a matter of being culturally competent, but of becoming more culturally aware, sensitive, knowledgeable, and responsible. Along with top-down support and reasonable expectations, here are further components in initial planning.
Good planning requires clear goals, realistic timelines, long-range vision, incremental strides, and good leadership. Planning should be assigned to a taskforce comprising select healthcare organization leaders, institutional ethics committee members, and representatives of diverse groups within the community. This taskforce could constitute a new Office of Cultural Competency (or a similar title), and its aim would be to construct clear, achievable goals and specific action plans within a reasonable time frame for development and implementation. The taskforce can conduct its initial planning in four typical phases:
- Phase One requires thorough and comprehensive research into existing literature and consulting with experts and community members from diverse groups.
- Phase Two assesses community healthcare disparities and needs on the basis of sound research utilizing demographic and socioeconomic data. This community study may include various focus groups and will be an ongoing process with updated data.
- In Phase Three, the taskforce evaluates the healthcare institution's capacity to serve the health needs of its diverse community members. As above, this appraisal should undergo regular review.14
See the Minnesota Department of Human Services. Guidelines for Culturally Competent Organizations; 2004, which offers in appendix H a solid tool for self-assessment. Another good instrument is available from the National Center for Cultural Competence, Georgetown University Child Development Center, at http://www.georgetown.edu/research/gucdc/nccc/ncccorgselfassess.pdf; retrieved Nov. 2004.
- In Phase Four, the taskforce designs a cohesive cultural competency implementation plan to address community health needs in view of the healthcare institution's strengths and deficiencies.
Strategies for Realizing a Culturally Competent Institution
To avoid the fate of guideline documents that collect dust on some shelf, a healthcare institution's cultural competency plans must have tangible strategies for implementation. These strategies should include having cultural representatives from the community on its board; ensuring suitable interpretation assistance; offering ongoing staff training in cultural competency; having cultural competency skills as part of performance evaluations; seeing to it that the institution's physical environment is culturally diverse, for example, through artwork, posters, and magazines; ensuring that clinics be geographically accessible; encouraging work schedules that accommodate special holidays for employees; and conducting regular, systematic review of these procedures. There should also be a reasonable channel for settling cross-cultural disputes, perhaps the task of a group from the institutional ethics committee or the Office of Cultural Competency. Even though employees can be trained to recognize signs of potential conflict, conflicts are expected. As noted above, all of this requires top-down support. A genuine commitment from the governing board and leading administrators will help to prevent cultural competency efforts from becoming marginalized.15
See Betancourt JR, Green AR, Carrillo JE. In: Cultural Competence in Health Care: Emerging Frameworks and Practical Approaches. New York: The Commonwealth Fund; 2002; Mott Jr WJ. Developing a culturally competent workforce: A diversity program in progress. Journal of Healthcare Management 2003;48:337–42; Shaw-Taylor Y, Benesch B. Workforce diversity and cultural competence in healthcare. Journal of Cultural Diversity 1998;5:138–46; also see note 14, Minnesota Department of Human Services 2004.
Self-audit
A clear and present danger lies in thinking of cultural competency as an exclusively outward-directed venture to understand others in cultures different from our own. Cultural competency is not just about Others; it is also about understanding Ourselves. An institutional self-audit is of vital importance, for it enables an institution to become more aware of its own organizational culture.
What kinds of issues would this self-audit address? Dennis Andrulis and others, in their Conducting a Cultural Competence Self-Assessment, pose questions like
- When you hear the term “cultural competence,” what comes to mind?
- What are the major organizational obstacles (policies, organizational characteristics) inhibiting ethnic and cultural understanding among staff, patients, and providers? What are the major organizational characteristics that enhance the multi-ethnic and cultural nature of the healthcare organization?
- What mechanisms, if any, are in place that promote communication among different levels and departments of the healthcare organization in regard to issues of cultural competence?
- In what ways have you addressed the ethnic and cultural needs of patients as they receive care throughout the continuum (home health, social services)?
- In what ways are providers trained and helped to deal with ethnic and cultural issues (e.g., trained to recognize diseases common in certain populations, mechanisms and protocols by which providers can request assistance in dealing with ethnic/cultural patient issues and needs)?16
Andrulis D, Delbianco T, Avakian L, Shaw-Taylor Y. Conducting a Cultural Competence Self-Assessment, p. 5. Available from: http://www.consumerstar.org/pubs/Culturalcompselfassess.pdf; retrieved Oct 2004. Also see Lumetra. The Cultural Competence Self-Assessment Protocol for Managed Care Organizations; Developing a Self-Assessment Tool for Culturally and Linguistically Appropriate Services in Local Public Health Agencies: Final Report. Rockville: Md: U.S. DHHS; 2003.
This self examination can enable an institution to embody cultural competency through seeking to eliminate discrimination due to race, origin, culture, religion, sexual orientation, gender, age, and socioeconomic status. A self-audit process should lead an institution to become culturally competent not only in its treatment of patients but in its treatment of personnel and staff at all levels. This constitutes a moral imperative in any genuine effort at cultural competency. Otherwise, efforts at cultural competency are merely token measures and signify institutional deceit.
Because cultural competency affirms the dignity of all persons in all cultures, a culturally competent organization should help to cultivate an ethical organizational climate. Cultural competency is an antidote to both cultural imperialism (alleging superiority of some cultures over others) and moral relativism (asserting no universal moral standard). However, cultural competency efforts do not guarantee a moral climate, particularly in the face of systemic inequities and other roadblocks. An institutional self-audit is thereby crucial. It examines whether individual and institutional behaviors are congruent with the organizational values expressed in the institution's mission statement—in the case of a healthcare organization, to serve the healthcare needs of its community in the best way possible. Through measuring transparency, accountability, and commitment to the institution's mission, a self-audit is therefore an ethics audit.
This is no easy task. Workplace discrimination is more institutionalized than overt, woven into the fabric of organizational culture where perspectives, attitudes, and practices are tainted by stereotyping, favoritism, biased performance evaluations, sexual harassment, hidden agendas, micromanagement, and inequitable distributions of authority and power. As part of its self-audit, therefore, a healthcare organization needs to ask: Is there a persistent workplace climate of personal and professional respect and collegiality? Are there fair hiring, promotion, and termination procedures? Even if there is no favoritism, how are hiring, promotion, and termination perceived by staff? Perception matters and indelibly affects workplace morale. Philip Boyle and other ethics scholars affirm this explicitly when it comes to perceived conflicts of interest:
Moreover, the mere appearance of a conflict of interest can be harmful…. The culture of an institution is powerfully shaped by how employees perceive the actions of fellow staff and administrators. If they come to believe (justifiably or not) that an administrator is putting his or her own interest above that of the organization, this belief can corrupt the culture, breeding suspicion and possibly encouraging others to put aside the organization's interests in favor of their own personal interests. (p. 148; italics mine)17
Boyle PJ, DuBose ER, Ellington SJ, Guinn DE, McCurdy DB. Organizational Ethics in Health Care: Principles, Cases, and Practical Solutions. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass; 2001.
Language Assistance
Free translation services must be accessible to all those with “limited English proficiency” (LEP), including patients with low literacy levels and those who are hearing impaired. These services include notices about the availability of language assistance; written translations of consent forms, job applications, and service information; and information regarding the right to appeal. Yet it is breathtakingly naïve to think of linguistic competency as the cure-all for intercultural conflict. Correct translation does not necessarily equate with proper interpretation.18
See Purnell LD, Paulanka BJ. Transcultural Health Care: A Culturally Competent Approach. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Company; 2003:15.
Recruitment
The institution must seek to recruit and retain staff that reflects the cultural diversity of the community it serves. Successful recruitment of multilingual, multicultural staff relies on job descriptions that emphasize cultural sensitivity and skills. In so doing, the institution manifests the principle of equal respect for other cultures; this means more than meeting equal opportunity requirements. A diverse staff can help in generating new ways of thinking about illness, enhancing the mission of the healthcare organization to serve all members of its community, enriching levels of care for its patients, and improving communication among various patient populations. A diverse staff is a testament to the community it serves.
Community Links
The importance of maintaining active links between the institution and its community cannot be overstated. As noted above, the healthcare institution's governing boards should include representatives from relevant cultures in the community. Knowing communities' needs and tapping into their resources empowers the community and underscores the principle of reciprocity in that there is mutual social and economic gain for both the healthcare organization that engages community members and the community at large that offers its services for that institution.19
Mason J. Cultural Competence Self-Assessment Questionnaire. Portland, OR: JLM & Associates; 1996.
National Center for Cultural Competence. Policy Brief 4: 4. Available from: http://www3.georgetown.edu/research/gucchd/nccc; retrieved Oct 2004.
Education and Training
Culture-specific education and training are vital. During meetings with Japanese healthcare professionals at Tokyo University Hospital, I modified my communication style after my colleague Akira Akabayashi cautioned me to avoid direct eye contact, particularly with female nurses, as this could be construed as impolite and sexually aggressive. What we know no doubt affects how we communicate. At the same time, acquiring a cultural knowledge base does not guarantee good dispositions and attitudes. Education and training must therefore include not only culture-specific knowledge but, more importantly, skills in intercultural communication, especially those skills needed for the medical interview and for communicating overall with patients. This also enables healthcare professionals to recognize their own cultural ignorance and biases. For example, assumptions about physical contact during a routine exam can conflict with Muslim patients' views regarding the exposure and touching of genitalia by health professionals of the opposite sex.
Ongoing education and training need to be offered, not only for healthcare professionals, but for all staff, especially for those who work at the front desk, make patient appointments, answer hot lines, and work in billing. The public's healthcare experiences, impressions, and beliefs are influenced by relationships with all whom they encounter in the system. As for health professionals, there is certainly enough on their plate, particularly within tightening institutional constraints, without demanding an unrealistic degree of knowledge about specific cultures. Although culture-specific knowledge is valuable, it is more helpful to know and understand a particular patient's expectations, views of his or her illness, and its meaning for that patient.21
A phenomenological orientation is valuable in learning more about the patient's world. See Brannigan M. Re-assessing the ordinary/extraordinary distinction in withholding/withdrawing nutrition and hydration. Contemporary Philosophy 1990;13(6):16–20; Brannigan M. Medical feeding: Applying Husserl and Merleau-Ponty. In: Toombs SK, ed. Handbook of Phenomenology and Medicine. Dordrecht: Kluwer; 2001:441–54. This is also referred to as the patient's “explanatory model” in Carrillo JE, Green AR, Betancourt JR. Cross-cultural primary care: A patient-based approach. Annals of Internal Medicine 1999;130:829–34.
As with most skills, it comes down to refining the basics. The key lies less in acquiring in-depth knowledge of various cultures and more in honing fundamental communication skills. For instance, in the medical interview during which health professionals should avoid technical jargon, slang, and colloquialisms, they can explore with their patients how these patients explain and interpret their illnesses. Add to this the equally critical nonverbal interview in which caregivers “listen” to cues in bodily and facial gestures, eye contact, and personal space. The heart of the caregiver–patient relationship lies in knowing and working interactively with the patient, not the patient's culture.22
A good summary of leading questions in the medical interview is offered by Carrillo et al.; see note 21, Carrillo et al. 1999:830.
See note 21, Carrillo et al. 1999:833.
Organizational Ethics
Given the above, institutional cultural competence showcases four basic features of organizational ethics. First, just as the aim in organizational ethics is to develop and promote an ethical environment throughout all levels of the organization, efforts to cultivate a culturally competent healthcare institution will, it is hoped, reach beyond its treatment of patients to transform the institution as a whole. Second, just as organizational ethics reminds us that clinical conflicts often need to be understood and resolved within the context of the specific institution and the wider health system, strategies for cultural competence present the same challenge. There is no “one size fits all” template for cultural competence. Cultural competency efforts need to adapt to each healthcare organization's own constituency and set of needs. Third, as in organizational ethics, an institution's efforts to cultivate knowledge, skills, attitudes, and behaviors conducive to cultural awareness and responsibility also require revisiting the mission of healthcare. As we said above, one critical aim in the self-audit is to measure an institution's actions in light of its mission statement. Fourth, just as organizational ethics seeks to prevent ethical conflict from occurring in the first place, a healthcare organization's cultural competency work must be proactive in ways that seek to short-circuit moral problems related to cultural differences before they arise.
Conceptual Caveats
By themselves, these institutional strategies for cultural competency remain inadequate. They need to be implemented with the following caveats. Without addressing these conceptual hurdles, any institutional action plan will fall thoroughly short of its goal. To help clarify these pitfalls, we will allude to our Japanese opener.
Self-referentialism
Our conceptions of others are filtered naturally through our own personal lens. However, when we presume that our viewpoints are the only valid points of reference, we commit the error of self-referentialism. In holding that autonomy can only make sense in terms of private, individualized self-determination, we may infer from Kimura's case that Japanese plainly lack any sense of autonomy. By the same token, it is wrongheaded to postulate that Japanese have no conception whatsoever of the individual. Japanese do possess a sense of individual existence, though the term for “individual,” kobutsu, was coined only after the Meiji Restoration. Nonetheless, the individual per se is not viewed principally as an independent entity of the type emphasized throughout much of Western philosophy.
An institution's education and training in cultural competency need to be alert to this fallacy of self-referentialism. For instance, it can point out that many Asian cultures, particularly those under the light of Confucianism, view personal identity as more contingent upon the relational web within which individuals interact, whether family, workplace, or some other social setting. At the same time, as in the next caveat, this is no absolute rule.
Homogenization
The first commandment in intercultural studies: Thou shall not cast monolithic nets over cultures. It is all too easy to neatly package the “unfamiliar” and trim down complexity. Doing so ignores meaningful internal discrepancies as well as external similarities with other cultures. For example, Latinos in America rightfully claim distinctions among first-generation immigrants and fourth generation Mexican-Americans. Actually, it may often be the case that there are more intracultural distinctions and variations than there are intercultural ones. Though it may be fashionable to think of cultures such as Japan as plainly unique (as in the Japanese literary genre of Nihonjinron), an institution's cultural competency efforts need to point out that generalizations can often lead to pernicious patterns of simplification and inaccurate cross-cultural analyses.
Reification
Terms and phrases are reified when their abstract quality is objectified in such a way that they become “thinglike,” negating their essentially dynamic trait. For instance, we often reify “rights” as well as “moral rights.” Prior to the Meiji Restoration, there was no Japanese term for what we refer to as a “right,” whether moral or legal. The closest equivalent to “right” appeared in 1868 with the new term kenri, which combined ken (“power”) and ri (“principle” and “interest”). Kenri thus meant the “principle or interest of power” associated with persons, not necessarily what many of us may attribute to the meaning of “right.” This helps explain Kimura's puzzlement over the idea of his alleged “moral right” to give his consent to surgery.
This has noteworthy implications for cultural competency work. In acquiring a knowledge base of specific cultures, we need to be careful about drawing inferences on the grounds of either presence or absence of specific terms. The lack of a term for “right” in Japanese thought does not necessarily mean the absence of any idea regarding “right” as we conceive of it. Terms need to be contextualized within their specific cultural and historical framework. This is one reason why, when it comes to linguistic assistance, fluency demands more than the bare-bones transliteral knowledge of another language.
Tolerance Is Not Identical to Uncritical Acceptance
Cultural sensitivity and respect go beyond mere tolerance, and tolerance itself assumes various meanings.24
See Ricoeur P, ed. Tolerance between Intolerance and the Intolerable. Providence, RI: Berghahn Books; 1996.
If we wrongfully identify tolerance with uncritical acceptance leading to accommodation, we risk moral relativism. Consider Japanese ethics' emphasis upon a relational framework in which collective interests take precedence over individual concerns, highlighting a system of duties and obligations to the group. Relationality assumes a complex context: the dynamics involved in human interactions, the intrinsic significance given to special groups such as family, and particular virtues prominent in powerful traditions like Confucianism and Buddhism. Because moral principles are situated within an intricate human drama, relationality thus presumes a flexibility in ethical assessment, a sort of moral contingency. This moral contingency avoids demarcating without exception what is wrong from what is right. Yet this moral contingency does not entail the rejection of moral standards.
How is all this relevant to issues of tolerance and cultural competence? Efforts at cultural competency need to avoid the facile equation of cultural understanding and sensitivity with tolerating all of any culture's practices. Cultural respect does not require that we embrace practices with which we disagree. We can learn to understand why, for instance, Sudanese parents may insist upon clitoridectomy for their infant daughter, but this is a far cry from accepting it. As the noted ethics scholar Ruth Macklin incisively reminds us, explaining a certain practice is not the same as morally justifying it.25
Macklin R. Against Relativism: Cultural Diversity and the Search for Ethical Universals in Medicine. New York: Oxford University Press; 1999.
Conclusion
Although healthcare professionals need to foster cultural awareness, sensitivity, and responsibility in order to deliver good healthcare, these professionals are also part of an institutional fabric. Their individual moral imperative is an organizational one. Cultural competency is a test case for organizational ethics, in which the aim is to cultivate an ethical culture within all sectors of the healthcare organization. Yet, even the most comprehensive institutional plan is not enough to accomplish the task. The plan needs to be implemented with keen awareness of the major conceptual hurdles to cross-cultural understanding. The action plan needs to be realized within a framework that gives equal, if not more, weight and consideration to these caveats and that embodies a steady stream of respect, compassion, and empathy for the Other.
