Aptly titled, Sunshine Was Never Enough details the struggles and plight of industrial workers in Los Angeles and its surrounding environments from 1880 to 2010. John H.M. Laslett has written an engaging work of not only labor history but also one that portends where today's America's multi-layered work forces may be headed.
Well-written and comprehensive in scope, Laslett takes his readers back to Los Angeles’ early stages of business development and follows it and its workers through the emergence of today's modern Southern California. Among Laslett's strengths is that he knows the lay of the land, which is not easy considering that Los Angeles County today is home to more than ten million residents who reside in 88 separate cities, amid a physical space of more than 4,000 square miles. Despite this challenge, Laslett narrates a captivating story of visionary leaders (and the workers they employed) who moved the frontier-facing pueblo out of colonial dependence on east coast manufacturing to become a world leader in such diverse industries as oil extraction, aircraft construction, movie production, and fashion design.
Among the early leadership profiled in this study are Harrison Gray Otis, publisher and editor of the powerful Los Angeles Times, whose vehemence towards the closed shop earned him the label of “the most anti-union man in the country.” Echoing his sentiments was fellow regional developer, Henry E. Huntington, whose Pacific Electric Railway served as the backbone of Southern California's public transportation network and from which the region's suburbs would sprout. Aiding their anti-labor efforts was the well organized Merchants and Manufacturers Association whose tight alignment with the city's judicial system and police force (L.A.P.D.), succeeded in preventing unions from gaining a firm hold in Los Angeles for nearly 40 years (extending from the early 1890s to the onset of the New Deal).
It was during the Great Depression that organized labor in Los Angeles began make substantial gains. Central to the change was Franklin Roosevelt's pro-labor National Industrial Recovery Act of 1933. This New Deal program allowed workers to successfully challenge the prevailing practice of open shop that had dominated the region's industries. Laslett, however, points out, that the gains were often small and that the labor movement itself was internally torn by race and gender issues. Laslett's examination of these conflicts make for some of the book's most provocative reading. Disputes between nationalities, men and women, whites and blacks, give insights as to how labor acted to solve these disputes within its own confines giving the appearance of a united front amongst all workers. Adding to the book's strength is the inclusion of interesting vignettes that personalize these difficulties workers faced on and off the job in Los Angeles. They included low wages, long hours, unaffordable housing, and especially for those living in racially segregated communities often away from factories—long commutes. Among the narratives are those of female war workers, striking Hollywood studio employees, and a range of unskilled laborers extending from the region's packing houses to its docks.
The onset of World War II also proved a positive change for organized workers in Southern California. Eager for well-paying federal defense contracts, many Los Angeles based employers turned from open shop policies to ones that required them, by federal mandate, to allow for collective bargaining. Unrest and actual strikes still occurred despite the necessities of all-out war production. Union leaders at war production plants often found themselves shadowed and carefully monitored. Included in union concerns was the lack of adequate transportation for minority workers who often lived in distant and racially segregated neighborhoods. At the war's conclusion and as a now economically booming Southern California grew, these same labor activists sometimes fell prey to the Red Scare finding themselves and their supporters labeled as Socialists or Communists.
Although the labor movement in Los Angeles made substantial gains during the decades of the 1940s, 1950s, and 1960s, Laslett's demonstrates that advances for workers would prove elusive in the decades that followed. Steel and auto plant closings became common as the southland's smokestack factories gave way to high tech production particularly in the historically non-union electronic and computer industries. Adding to organized labor's regional woes was the onset of globalization where just across the relatively nearby border with Mexico, maquiladoras (factories) were quickly built employing a workforce at the fraction of the cost it would be in the United States. Additionally, the continued arrival of both migrants and immigrants into Los Angeles kept low wages stationary for unskilled workers. Service industries, in particular, saw little need to improve wages and benefits for its easily replaced workers.
Laslett concludes his study with a very insightful look into the future of labor in Southern California—both workers and those who employ them. Although he does not openly state it, apparent is a breaking point on the horizon, too, for those burdened by long work hours, traffic congested commutes, and continually rising rents at their often below standard domiciles. It was shortly after the book's release that a well-publicized fight by Los Angeles hotel and fast food workers demanding a “living wage” began.
Sunshine Was Never Enough is a major contribution to our understanding of the development of Southern California and the workers who helped to build it into the economic behemoth is today. Although broad in scope, Laslett's work is remarkable for its ability to successfully synthesize a wide range of labor issues and struggles over a 130-year period within the vast spaces that comprise modern Los Angeles today.
