This book joins a growing body of scholarship that explores how memory shapes knowledge and how the techniques for identifying, collecting, recording and storing this knowledge shape what is remembered as well as what is forgotten. Geoffrey Bowker draws on an unusually eclectic range of academic literatures, from literary studies to science studies to more traditional kinds of sociological and historical studies of memory-making and forgetting. What makes Bowker's book fairly novel is that it appropriates some of the insights gleaned from these areas to understand specifically the making of scientific knowledge.
The thirty-four page introduction surveys the intellectual territory and lays out the rationale for Bowker's approach. Two questions drive the project: first, how do scientists figure their own past both as creatures on Earth and in terms of their disciplinary heritage? Second, how do scientists figure the past of the entities they study, whether organisms, climate, extinction events or whatever? To explore these and other related concerns, Bowker examines a range of memory practices (which he classes as technical, formal and social) and how they shape scientific knowledge. He chooses three historical moments, or ‘memory epochs’, which he views as especially rich in demonstrating how the social and practical infrastructure of identifying, recording and categorizing knowledge shapes that knowledge. The first is in the nineteenth century, in the period of industrialization which, in Britain, saw the establishment of the science of geology; the second is the ‘cybernetic movement’ of the 1960s; and the third is the recent attempt to create a biodiversity index. According to Bowker, the first two epochs have much in common because both geology and cybernetics attempted through their indexical schemes and devices to package time itself into a single unit, while the last and current memory epoch in biodiversity science attempts to ‘database’ the world in what appears to be an inclusive scheme but which in fact simultaneously excludes part of what can count as ‘the world’. Comparing these three epochs, Bowker points out that what memory practices in these areas do is to project the present into the past or our own practices, habits and beliefs into the natural world.
His closing insights are not entirely surprising to anyone versed in the history of classification, the subject of Bowker's previous work. But the process of getting to this ‘big picture’, so to speak, makes Memory Practices in the Sciences worth reading. The treatment of the final memory epoch is especially welcome because it draws on some recent history of botany generally unfamiliar to scholars in science studies or in history of science. Bowker notes how practices from the choice of names to the inscription of index cards to the diagrammatic and representational practices used to record the Earth's diverse organisms fundamentally shape what is being counted as being part of the diversity of life. It is an interesting section of the book and anyone concerned with the histories of ecology, botany and biodiversity studies will find some new sources being used.
On the whole, this is a worthy book. Its real drawback is that it is annoyingly brief in all of the areas covered. In the rush to demonstrate how memory practices have operated – and operate – in all three epochs, Bowker breezes through considerable stretches of time, disciplinary area and scientific practice. A number of small erroneous statements or misunderstandings (biodiversity is not a ‘science’ per se) along with typographical and spelling errors and the absence of full engagement with relevant historiographies will disappoint some readers, especially historians of science. More disappointing to this reader is the author's lack of involvement with issues and literatures pertaining to commemorations, rituals and monuments, and how they function within a disciplinary matrix to invent and maintain scientific memory. So, too, even some of the theoretical literature Bowker does consider in this vein appears to be superficially engaged. My overall sense is that this is an interesting and eclectic book but one that could have been more carefully and substantively developed.
