One of the most common strategies for delegitimizing new directions within an academic discipline is to deem them beyond the clearly defined disciplinary boundaries. An increasingly prevalent counterstrategy has been to reconsider key assumptions within disciplinary history by revisiting a discipline's moment of formation and unearthing forgotten lineages in the writings of the founding figures. This serves simultaneously to legitimize the new directions and interpretations and to undermine the existing barriers considered to be too constraining. This work by Chris Renwick is one example of such a tack; his primary aim is to provide a historical account of the discipline's emergence, but he uses that as a platform to challenge what he sees as the constraints that currently limit both sociology and the history of science.
In the case of sociology, Renwick aims to legitimize sociological research that addresses matters which are seemingly rooted in biology, such as that done by Steve Fuller, who also wrote the book's Foreword. In the case of the history of science, he states that over the past two decades, historians have focused on what he calls ‘science-as-practice’, having actively decided to ‘move on’ from ‘philosophical or history of ideas orientated histories’ (p. 180). As a consequence, ‘historians of science have grown accustomed to deriding intellectual history as something that consists of “elite” ideas that have little bearing on how science is actually done’ (p. 181). He advises historians of science to break this habit and to ‘spend as much time examining the ideas that motivated [contemporary scientists] as we do the artefacts they left behind’ (p. 181). Renwick's main thesis is that sociology was constructed from the rubble of political economy's intellectual collapse during the 1870s and was built with the aim of establishing a true science of society. Its earliest incarnation was as Section F of the British Association for the Advancement of Science; its status, however, was controversial from the beginning. Of all the sections of the BAAS, Section F attracted the most attention (and thereby the most money) for the association, yet its members also regarded it as the least scientific. Squaring this circle required securing sociology's scientific credentials, something that was achieved by treating it as a branch of biology. The emphasis was on the apparent promise of eugenics as pioneered by Francis Galton, although a considerable faction – chief of whom was the Scottish biologist, town planner and later professor of sociology and civics at Bombay University Patrick Geddes – argued that sophisticated organisms like humans prospered more by cooperation than by competition. Interestingly, Renwick argues that Herbert Spencer is widely misunderstood, and was more influential amongst the Geddes group than were the eugenicists.
By the early twentieth century, the movement towards establishing a Sociological Society had gathered pace, but a third strain of thought emerged, one that disputed the primacy of biological thinking within sociology. Just before the establishment of the first chair of sociology (at the LSE in 1904), therefore, the field was engaged in an acute theoretical debate over the delineations of the field's methodology, epistemology and ontology. It was as much by luck as by design that the chair was received by the anti-biological L.T. Hobhouse, who then set the boundaries of the discipline and thereby created a canon that wrote out the field's biological roots.
Overall, Renwick makes four major calls for reassessment: first, to say that Herbert Spencer was not a ‘red in tooth and claw’ social Darwinist, as has often been assumed; second, that, within Britain, the discipline of sociology has neglected its biological roots; third, that the theoretical debates surrounding its inception were highly sophisticated and are worthy of retrieval; and fourth, that historians of science are currently prone to ignoring intellectual contexts, aims and assumptions for the practice of science.
Renwick is most convincing on the first two of these claims. His case for the third claim is less persuasive. Whilst lively and thoughtful, the calibre of the sociological debates does not seem comparable to their contemporary Continental counterparts, and in that sense it seems unlikely that their participants will be recovered and reclaimed as lost prophets. His final claim is the one most likely to raise the interest (if not the sceptical eyebrows) of historians of science. Readers will probably have their own views on Renwick's claim that they deride intellectual history because they believe that ideas and social contexts ‘have little bearing on how science is actually done’ (p. 181). Suffice it to say that this reviewer, at least, considered the charge to be more ‘courageous’ than convincing.
If there is a notable absence in this work, it is the question why British sociology took a biological path at a time when German sociology did not – particularly as social Darwinism was at this time more politically influential and popular in Germany than in Britain. Also, although Renwick outlines how political economy disintegrated because a key assertion – that increasing wages would damage the economy – was effectively disproven, it does not ask why this (essentially ‘pro-worker’) acknowledgement in particular was so devastating that it caused the disintegration of an entire discipline. Somewhat ironically given the charge he levels at historians of science, the political context of the scientific concepts – and the acceptance of some of these over others in the case of sociology – is largely left unexamined.
Nevertheless, despite this absence and the questionable validity of his assessment of history of science, this work is both well written and well researched. Anyone with an interest in the origins of sociology in Britain, the application of biology as a social science during the late nineteenth and the early twentieth centuries, or the broader question of the relationships between scientific thought and theories of social management, will benefit significantly from reading it.
