Ed: Catherine Parsons Smith, an active and longtime member of the Society for American Music and a fervent advocate of its aims and principles, passed away on 1 September 2009. In the few weeks before her death, Smith rushed to complete some unfinished projects, among them this short review, which may, in fact, constitute her last writing on American music.
The depth of Daniel Chennevière's lifelong commitment to Orientalist mysticism is shown in his adoption, in his early twenties, of “Rudhyar,” a name derived from “Rudra,” a Sanskrit word for the Hindu god Shiva. Rudhyar may not have been the only composer to cultivate his own ego while seeking simultaneously to merge it into that of all humankind, but few other creative artists have chosen to assume the name of a deity as part of their search.
Born in Paris in 1895, the future Dane Rudhyar suffered bouts of illness in his youth serious enough to exempt him from military service in World War I. He developed a profound interest in the work of Bergson, Nietzsche, and Scriabin. He also studied composition with Debussy; at age eighteen, he produced a biography of his teacher. He came to the United States in 1916, becoming a U.S. citizen a decade later. Some of his contemporaries may have perceived a certain arrogance in his philosophical approach, his self-presentation, or his music. Elliott Carter wrote to Ives of Rudhyar's Paeans after it appeared in a New Music Edition (vol. I, no. 2, Jan. 1928): “Paeans are good but they seem a little too majestic, too much of his own greatness taken for granted.”Footnote 1 Rudhyar, an eloquent advocate for his own vision of modernism, joined Varèse and Salzedo in breaking away from Copland and the League of Composers to form the International Composers Guild in 1923. He also carried on a fierce debate with Charles Seeger in the pages of the Aeolian Review during the 1920s. (The unflappable Henry Cowell refused to be drawn into these disputes and presently published several more of Rudhyar's scores in his New Music Edition.) His early confrontational style, involving flamboyant behavior at a concert in Montreal, is documented elsewhere.Footnote 2
In 1919 and 1920 Rudhyar published three articles in the Musical Quarterly under the name Rudhyar D. Chennevière. In these three essays he set out his views about the increasing spiritual emptiness, brokenness, and general decay of Western music, using the music of Stravinsky and Schoenberg as Exhibit A. He saw the Western scale and Western musical instruments, particularly the piano, as hopelessly limiting obstructions to accessing true “tonality.” (Later he used “Tone” for this mystical concept.) “All there is in Nature expresses itself in music,” he proclaimed as an ideal in the first of the essays, published in April 1919.Footnote 3 Two issues later, he dismissed Erik Satie as “as little a musician as it is possible to be . . ., the representative in music of an intellectualism and individualism beyond measure . . ., complex, sterile, as opposed to the profound and essential worth of true Art, whose values are synthetic and mystic, ‘synanthropic’ values . . . based on the communion of humanity.”Footnote 4 A year after that, he lamented that the practitioner of music had been reduced in the course of Western history (that is, from the time of Pythagoras) from a religious celebrant to a mere artisan: “Soon he will be a proletarian!” He concluded that “the music of today is built on nothingness, on mortuary fragments. . . . The composer can no longer exist without prostituting his art.”Footnote 5 (Elsewhere, he found similarly dismissive language for Nadia Boulanger's students and for neoclassicism in general.) However, he saw glimmers of hope in the work of Debussy and particularly Scriabin. Much later he resumed writing on music.
Rudhyar first went to Los Angeles in 1919. There he composed music for the Pilgrimage Play, an account of the life of Christ, premiered in an outdoor amphitheatre near the Hollywood Bowl, in 1920. Christine Wetherill Stevenson, whom he later described in a letter to me as “a fine theosophist,” was the moving spirit behind the production; it was she who commissioned the music from him.Footnote 6 After 1930 he composed less and wrote numerous books on what he called “humanistic astrology.” He returned to composition in the mid-1970s, when there was a revival of interest in his music.
Rudhyar steadfastly refused to offer reasoned explanations of his compositional practice, drawing his aesthetic from his broader mystical position. The few works that are available, most of them for piano, abound in rich and dissonant gestures and sonorities. His books on astrology, on the other hand, are well organized, with clear and colorful expositions. (These provided his livelihood for most of his life.) New Mansions for New Men (New York: Lucis Publishing Company, 1938), for instance, is divided into three parts. The first describes twelve “Mansions of the Self” (“To Breathe,” “To Own,” “To Know,” etc.); the second sets forth “Music of the Spheres” in thirteen discrete sections (“Prelude,” “The Song of Light,” etc., including a section on the meaning of each of eight planets); and the third, reminiscent of the four Aristotelian humours, sets forth “Meditations at the Gates of Light,” one at each point of the compass, with a concluding fifth “City of Light.”
One of Ertan's stated goals for this biography of Rudhyar implies a caveat for JSAM readers: “This book is by no means a comprehensive survey of Rudhyar's creative work; the musical and nonmusical works addressed are intended as a means of engaging with his overall vision,” as a means of illustrating “the relationship between idea and realization” (xiii). Ertan has had access to the very extensive, privately held Dane Rudhyar Estate Archive of Rudhyar's writings, containing much unpublished material. From her heavy reliance on this source, I infer that the archive is dominated by Rudhyar's writings on theosophy and astrology, as transmitted by Rudhyar's widow, Leyla Rael Rudhyar Hill, who maintains the archive. Unfortunately, she, too, is frequently quoted, reinforcing a sectarian patina that makes the book more obscurantist than it needs to be. Following the practice of Rudhyar's time but not our own, Ertan is unapologetic about the use of “Orient,” with its post–Edward Said implications of colonialism. She aspires quite uncritically to “clarify, realign, and situate Rudhyar through three geocultural domains—Europe, the Orient, and America” (xi). The book is divided into three sections, each with three chapters: “Autumnal Decay: Seed Ideas,” “Wholeness: The Scope of the Orient,” and “Rawness and Vigor, Innocence and Experience; An American Experience.” There is a lengthy chronology at the front, especially important because the author generally does not periodicize Rudhyar's life or treat it with any chronological consistency.
Rudhyar's music is little known and scarcely recorded. Four musical examples are discussed; I was able to find recordings of two of them on the Web site that draws on the resources of the Rudhyar Archive: www.beyondsunsigns.com/rudhyaraudioastrology.html. The book includes a group of Rudhyar's rather arresting paintings, full of symbolism and possibly of more interest than the music. Little of Rudhyar's poetry is quoted.
Various kinds of spirituality and myth provided American audiences with an inviting way into the new departures in harmony, rhythm, and tone color that became commonplace in the early 1920s. In southern California this open attitude changed as the connection of dissonance with spirituality dissipated in the mid-1920s, exiling musical modernism until the advent of Evenings on the Roof and the arrival of the famous émigrés from Hitler late in the 1930s.Footnote 7 (Even then the audience for modernism was far smaller than it had been early on.) The importance of theosophy and spirituality to the musical modernism of the early 1920s—specifically the importance of Rudhyar's contribution—is established, among other places, in Judith Tick's work on Ruth Crawford Seeger and in Carol Oja's Making Music Modern: New York in the 1920s.Footnote 8 Indeed, Oja's chapter, “Dane Rudhyar's Vision of Dissonance,” which actually contains a coherent music example, remains the best introduction to this topic.
Rudhyar was a man of many talents whose work seems always dominated by his astrological and theosophical mysticism. Music played an important but, in this telling, an ultimately secondary role. We may have a long wait for a more objective account of this intriguing figure in American musical modernism.
