Akhil Gupta has written a thought-provoking text that broadly reconceives how to analyze a “disaggregated” state shaped by international, transnational, and “translocal” forces. This disaggregated power, Gupta argues, is deployed on behalf of the poor, and yet at the same time perpetuates systematic violence toward the poor. His contribution to development literature and state theory is to consistently theorize state power outside of nation-state-centered analyses. Gupta shows how a postcolonial state like India is different from states like the United States or France, which may have always experienced foreign influences but not to the same degree and not as hegemonic forces. He demonstrates how various power dynamics—from the colonial to the neocolonial to foreign direct investment and Bretton Woods institutions—can make up translocal bureaucratic powers that defy not merely the logic of the nation-state but also presuppositions about the terms “local” and “rural.” In this way, he challenges simplistic assumptions about development, including presumptions about the political astuteness of illiterate peasants or the degree to which these areas are alienated from foreign and even national influence. Indeed, on Gupta’s account, even class position is fixed only in the ideas of power elites, who conceive of the poor as an undifferentiated, naive mass in need of enlightenment, effectively lumping together scheduled castes, poor peasants, abandoned women, and undernourished children and conceiving of their needs as purely biological.
In effect, Gupta’s work suggests how transnational and translocal development and neoliberal influences attempt simultaneously to create static subjectivities and to explode fixed identities and subject positions through development programs that are destabilizing and uprooting. By studying development programs aimed at the poor, we learn more about state power (at elite and local levels) than about the poor themselves, whose very different experiences are often reduced by state elites to biopolitical needs.
In developing these themes, Gupta draws on the work of Michel Foucault and Giorgio Agamben, both of whom have focused on the ways political power regulates and disciplines bodies and identities. His ambivalence about Foucault tests the boundaries of Foucault’s theories while reaffirming their importance by interpreting bio-power through an analytics of governmentality. Among other things, this amounts not merely to questioning Euro- and Anglo-centric scholarly analyses of countries like India but also to challenging researchers who rely on a theory of nested hierarchies, studying national- or elite-level power structures and extrapolating from these findings to understand the local. To Gupta, the local has its own specificity that is not only irreducible to notions of backwardness, provincialism, or unqualified illiteracy but which also challenges views of the local as a microcosm of broader national policies or a carbon copy of other localities. In this way, he employs the most challenging elements of Foucault’s analytics of power to more thoroughly conceive of power as always shifting and contested.
Gupta also contends that development programs do not merely treat the rural poor as biopolitical subjects but are killing them through structural violence. Drawing on Agamben, whose work is less interestingly theorized, Gupta suggests that the suffering of the poor is due to more than bureaucratic ineptitude: “Caring” development policies lead to suffering and death. Agamben’s work is useful in conceiving how violence and killing occur impersonally and through ostensibly democratic strategies; the subject population targeted for death are not criminals but sacrificed on behalf of a biopolitical logic that fails to “let live” more than truly killing. That is, the very population seemingly targeted for life-affirming biopolitical strategies are the ones who continue to be immiserated.
Gupta offers a conventional reading of Agamben’s work as presupposing a Nazi-like state disengaging with and abandoning a subject that is absolutely stripped of legal status. He adds to the more conventional analysis by explaining how it is perhaps unintentionally Eurocentric, nation-state centered, and reliant on a central authority. I take Agamben’s work to be more dynamic, conceiving of bare life as based on an “inclusive exclusion” and the camp as the geo-spatial representation of this tension; both terms are on a spectrum of possibilities and are meant to suggest productive tensions that allow democracies to successfully deploy biopower. In my reading, Agamben’s work explains the Indian state’s simultaneous enfranchisement of the functionally literate poor at formal levels, while also subjecting them to ineffective biopolitical programs that do not merely disenfranchise them de facto but lead to mass suffering and early death. Gupta does not read Agamben this way, leading to a more black-and-white view of how bare life is constituted.
Bound up in these questions is the author’s notion of citizenship, which despite his rather complex, disaggregated notion of power, seems rather dichotomous—citizenship and popular sovereignty are evident in the enfranchisement of the poorest of the poor and official recognition of their electoral power. But this is not enough to demonstrate a tension between full citizenship and complete exclusion. Gupta suggests as much in his claim that local sites of power are not adequately captured by the law-enforcement binary that many theorists employ; rather, local sites of disenfranchisement in rural areas have their own political logic, with tenuous links to more national and transnational processes. In this way, he offers a new way to conceive of second-class citizenship as having its own uniqueness and specificity—again, challenging nested hierarchies—despite the binary framework that structures his notion of citizenship and which effectively dismisses Agamben’s notion of bare life. Despite my disagreements, I find these questions incredibly important for understanding development and neoliberal capital.
To Gupta, the Indian state—granted that it is fragmented, transnational, shifting and nonuniform in scale—is killing the poor and employing discourses and practices of thanatopolitics, despite the benefits of economic liberalization. He chooses these terms, particularly violence and killing, despite acknowledging that there is no particular agent doing the killing and no clear intent to wield violence (p. 20). Under the guise of care and development, thanatopolitics involves a systematic abandonment of the rural poor (including scheduled castes and tribes), not through ignoring them per se (granted that concerns about the poor have disappeared from media debates [p. 4]) but through simultaneously making them the object of the developmental state and recognizing their electoral importance, but inefficiently and corruptly implementing programs so that the poor continue to suffer and die from malnutrition, disease, occupational and environmental hazards, and other forms of vulnerability. As he states, “extreme poverty should be theorized as a direct and culpable form of killing made possible by state policies and practices rather than as an inevitable situation in which the poor are merely ‘allowed to die’ or exposed to death’” (pp. 5–6)
Violence to Gupta is “structural” and systematic. It is not defined by spectacular, explicitly violent episodes (p. 20) “and far from disrupting actors’ understandings of their social worlds, it provides them with a particular kind of situated knowledge with its own epistemic certainties” (p. 20). In this way, the illiterate poor both suffer but are also politically savvy, exploding many of the Enlightenment-based notions of development agencies. Gupta uses the term “structural violence” because “it keeps one’s attention on its impact on mortality” (p. 20). But it could be argued that terms like “violence” and “killing” lose their meaning in the absence of intent or agency. Violence may not be episodic or signal a temporal rupture, but the systematic instances of corruption and ineptitude that he explores do not clearly indicate thanatopolitics. Gupta’s use of the latter terms—in the end—highlights the significance of the situation but perhaps at the expense of more precise terminology. Regardless, the broader critique is valuable in considering how biopolitical development programs are life affirming yet perpetuate suffering.
It is interesting to note that Gupta synthesizes the broad range of disaggregated political forces, which include vestiges of colonial ties and the influence of foreign nongovernmental organizations, Bretton Woods institutions, and foreign capital. While others have pursued a similar analytic framework (the “disaggregated state”), his exploration of the daily practices and manifestations of this fragmentation, particularly in a developmental state like India, provides fresh insights regarding this theory. In contrast to briefer examinations of this approach, Gupta’s contribution is a more sustained, comprehensive, and up-to-date exploration of these ideas. He provides further insight into this disjointed and shifting set of power structures as he explores the uneven workings of neoliberalism in conjunction with transnational and translocal powers, which are manifested in different power arrangements at different scales of power hierarchies. His book challenges recent work on “convergence” and “harmonization” in the literature on globalization and in World Bank documents. Where authors like Thomas Friedman or Dani Rodrik conceive of a smooth world of economic harmonization (the first advocating it and the second warning against it), Gupta presents a bumpy, imperfect, and tension-filled web of shifting power. While it may not be particularly surprising to learn that neoliberalism has been implemented imperfectly and contradictorily in India, Gupta offers a powerful account of how and why this is the case.
The author’s fieldwork in India highlights everyday instances of local particularity and the relative inefficacy of neoliberal programs in rural areas. In particular, Gupta investigates and compares two programs aimed at helping the poor: ICDS (Integrated Child Development Services) and Mahila Samakhya. His narratives of these programs are not particularly dramatic or forceful (in comparison to Arundhati Roy’s work, e.g.) but do amount to a practical and in-depth examination of state power at the local level. Importantly, agents who constitute and represent the state at this level are often marginalized, sometimes illiterate officials who can act arbitrarily toward the poor but are also often treated dismissively and arbitrarily themselves.
For example, Gupta points out that most bureaucratic complaints are not initiated by villagers against local officials but, rather, filed by bureaucrats against each other. He notes that when rural programs fail, these lower-level bureaucrats’ lack of educational attainment is automatically used as the reason, disregarding the broader context of massive, unchanging poverty, and that these same officials are often blamed for a corruption that in fact pervades the government at every level. These complaints, in turn, indicate the importance of writing and literacy, but not in ways that are conventionally understood in development programs. As Gupta argues, “literacy” and “illiteracy” are not absolute terms. A more precise and flexible concept is “restricted literacy” (pp. 197, 205). Challenging one of the main tenets of development programs, both national and transnational, literacy does not indicate political sophistication to Gupta but does represent cultural capital, allowing for more active political participation and influence. Those who are viewed as uneducated and illiterate are not formally disenfranchised, but they are de facto excluded from important debates, and this exclusion amounts to structural violence. In elucidating these tensions, Gupta effectively challenges the simplicity and naïveté of developmental slogans based on reducing literacy or using the $1/day poverty line (e.g.) as an absolute measure of poverty reduction.
The author also disputes the idea that if the rural poor are protesting their conditions, it is because they are not receiving the full benefit of development programs. At the end of the book, Gupta explores the Naxalites, a Maoist resistance group that has been deemed by many official voices to be one of the greatest threats to peace and security in India. The Indian state cynically perpetuates its developmental mission through this campaign, effectively displacing the poor in its militarized skirmishes with this relatively minor group. Like James Scott’s focus on the social costs of uprootedness, Gupta argues that development projects are displacing these groups who have no claim to the land that they inhabit or formal recognition of their status as a group. Ironically, indigenous Maoist resistance to the state aids the government in displacing tribes and the rural poor as they flee the violence, effectively evicting themselves from the land and becoming doubly or triply displaced. In this way, the $1/day poverty line that determines whether the poor are surviving or not is a cruelly reductive and ultimately biopolitical measure of well-being that effaces more complex political dynamics of marginalization. Unresolved issues regarding tribal status and rights, peasants’ claims to the land, and the fate of scheduled castes cannot be equated with the goal of merely sustaining lives.
Gupta views corruption as a productive force in constituting and imagining the state and mediating a popular understanding of politics. While he claims that there is little attention paid to the subject, particularly corruption as state building (and not state destroying, e.g.), it is more accurate to say that the term is often used uncritically, untheoretically, and to reference a destructive rather than a productive force. He explores varying perspectives on corruption and gives some striking instances on three levels: first, as evidence of intrabureaucratic conflict; second, as part of the popular imaginary (including humorous treatment of the subject); and third, as a key contributor to structural violence against the poor. Nevertheless, he never really defines what corruption means despite his lengthy investigation of its importance in everyday understandings of the state. He cites James Scott’s 1973 essay on the subject but does not engage it in this chapter, despite the fact that Scott poses a number of interesting challenges to the subject, including a rigorous review of the definitions of corruption and their deficiencies; his own suggestion of corruption as influence; and his examination of the connection between the various systematic abuses of power in the West/North and how they have influenced modern constitutional systems in postcolonial areas, constraining the possibility of corruption because they have more constitutional provisions and safeguards than Western countries when they were new, but also opening up new opportunities for corruption (e.g., selling votes in the Philippines). Scott recognizes that corruption can be harmful, but in this essay views it as filling in the gaps when newly independent states adopt modern Western constitutions, most often allowing the truly marginalized to have influence where they would not otherwise.
Gupta interprets corruption negatively: as embezzlement, bribes, and exacting a cost for what were supposed to be free provisions for the poor. Corruption provides an education for the poor, giving them a sort of situated knowledge, but also producing lethal results. Both authors indicate that corruption should be viewed as a productive force, creating new subjectivities and power relations, rather than simply entailing losses. If Gupta disagrees with Scott’s more positive analysis of corruption, it would have been interesting to read why this is the case. To Gupta, all of this amounts to structural violence that does not exactly undermine state programs but produces tensions by which care for the poor often amounts to killing them.
Red Tape is really worth reading for the provocative and insightful questions that Gupta asks and the way in which he pushes state and development theory in new directions. His sustained analyses of these complex issues not only provide insight into the workings of Indian development programs but also serve as a reminder to those of us who study the link between a “disaggregated” state and poverty to truly explore this disaggregation in all of its manifestations.
