On a hot, late-June day in 1884, Red Cloud rode out from his home on Pine Ridge Reservation, with an entourage of fifty to eighty people, to meet Dr. Thomas A. Bland, the soon-to-be founder of the National Indian Defense Association (NIDA). Bland and Red Cloud had become friends during the latter's many visits to Washington, DC, in the 1870s, and he now appealed to his ally for help in removing the federal agent at Pine Ridge, Valentine McGillycuddy. Bland, a protégé of former peace commissioner Alfred Meacham, was a populist agitator and critic of forced assimilation and Indigenous dispossession. Herbert Welsh, founder of the Indian Rights Association (IRA), supported Agent McGillycuddy, once calling him “a man of remarkable ability.” The agent employed all possible techniques in his efforts to confine and limit the Oglala Lakota and to undermine Red Cloud and other customary leaders, including reducing treaty stipulated rations; pitting community leaders against one another; and pressuring them to abandon Lakota social, cultural, and political practices such as the Sun Dance.
After Red Cloud welcomed Bland and stopped for lunch, Indian police officers sent by McGillycuddy arrested the doctor. At the agency office, the two men screamed at one another and—on the verge of a fistfight—had to be separated physically. McGillycuddy threatened to remove him from the reservation, and Bland shouted, “I'm a citizen of the United States with a letter from the Secretary of the Interior giving me permission to come here.” McGillycuddy yelled back that they were not in the United States; they were, he said, “on an Indian reservation” where he was in “supreme command.” The agent disregarded Bland's letter of permission, instead issuing ammunition to the Indian police officers. He ordered them to escort Bland away from the reservation, adding that they could use force if necessary. They reportedly dragged him from the office as he screamed, “My wife said I was a fool for visiting your agency.” It's no small wonder then that Bland concluded Pine Ridge had become “the little monarchy over which McGillycuddy reigns.” This conflict, far from being an obscure and exceptional event, illustrated the intensity with which opposing Indian policy reformers brought to their debates in the Gilded Age.Footnote 2
A common refrain in policy studies of the late nineteenth century is “to be pro-Indian … was to be pro-allotment and pro-assimilation.”Footnote 3 Scholars of the era have primarily focused on the shared social, religious, and economic backgrounds of the predominant reform organizations. These groups—collectively the “Friends of the Indian”—included the IRA, the Women's National Indian Association, the Boston Indian Citizenship Committee, and the other attendees at the annual Lake Mohonk Conference in upstate New York.Footnote 4 Focusing instead on the debates and conflicts between these groups, however, this essay argues that they situated their arguments about policy reform within a framework that tied developments in Indian affairs to larger concerns about the role and nature of the state, as well as the relationship between the federal government and its citizens and wards. This case study suggests that Indian policy reformers were not confined by a narrow set of ideas but rather understood their campaigns as part of larger, national conversations. An analysis such as this one also encourages a reevaluation of the centrality of Native history in the late nineteenth-century United States.
The NIDA's stance on Indian policy reflected its founder's midwestern upbringing and devotion to working-class and agrarian causes. Though Bland did not support that kind of antigovernment rhetoric that had become the rallying cry of former Confederates and far-western radicals, he certainly found himself at odds with elite eastern philanthropists and western politicians. The NIDA rejected forced assimilation and focused instead upon using the federal government to provide resources and opportunities for Indigenous nations while simultaneously protecting the integrity of communally held land. The NIDA was both an important and numerically significant organization whose members sought to provide viable alternative policy reforms, yet they have not received equal attention in the literature. As historian Benjamin Johnson concluded, many scholars “either misunderstood or ignored Bland and the NIDA because they also assume that a monolithically capitalist white America wielded irresistible power in its quest to destroy Indian landholding.”Footnote 5
Historians Heather Cox Richardson and Elliot West have argued persuasively that while questions about the federal government's role and its relationship to its citizens were by no means new in the late nineteenth century, they took on new meaning in that time period and in the West because Congress imposed national taxes during the Civil War. How those taxes were to be used and who had a voice in this decision motivated reformers and legislators. In addition, the Thirteenth, Fourteenth, and Fifteenth Amendments were the first to expand, rather than limit, the power of the federal government.Footnote 6 Questions about inclusion and exclusion, as well as the rights and responsibilities of citizenship, were layered atop the debates surrounding land allotment (the parceling of communally held reservation lands into individual family plots, ultimately codified in the General Allotment Act of 1887) and forced assimilation (through boarding schools and other OIA programs). Allotment and assimilation were to serve as the means, with citizenship and all that status entailed (including the cessation of tribal sovereignty) as the end. Thus, in the late nineteenth century, Indian policy reform debates connected to the Office of Indian Affairs (OIA), and especially the contestation between the NIDA and the IRA, became a critical site where reformers and activists developed ideas about the evolution of the state that would ultimately find application in many different areas of social policy.
The IRA occupies a significant place in studies of late nineteenth-century policy reform, yet there has been little effort to contextualize the organization and its founder within wider currents of the era. For example, Herbert Welsh, the founder of the IRA who served as its president and secretary for over three decades, connected his interests in Indian policy with a broader devotion to civil service reform. “This Indian question,” he once wrote, “like the national evil of slavery in the past or the corruption of the Civil Service in the present, was a great national question.”Footnote 7 Other IRA leaders highlighted their belief in the connection between the state and the economy. Together, they asserted that through civil service reform and the professionalization of the Indian Service, corruption would cease, and furthermore, that it was the responsibility of the state to foster economic development by opening land, resources, and markets for American entrepreneurs.
In the 1880s, partly motivated by the patronage politics of the Cleveland administration and bolstered by the passage in 1883 of the Pendleton Act, Welsh became a devoted proponent of civil service reform and its extension to the Indian Service.Footnote 8 He solicited information from and built friendships with several important leaders of the movement, including Dorman B. Eaton, the man who drafted the Pendleton Act; Richard H. Dana, the editor of the Civil Service Record; and George W. Curtis, the editor of Harper's Weekly and president of the National Civil Service Reform League (NCSRL).Footnote 9 Curtis and Welsh coordinated strategies; consulted other civil service reform leaders, including Theodore Roosevelt and Secretary of the Interior, Charles Schurz; and looked for opportunities to publicize their cause.
Early victories for Welsh and the IRA in this campaign came when the NCSRL passed a resolution in 1886 to advocate the application of civil service rules to clerks in the Indian Service and when the “Friends” passed a similar resolution at Lake Mohonk that year.Footnote 10 In his speech at Lake Mohonk, which IRA published in the form of a pamphlet, Welsh told the stories of Morris A. Thomas and Dr. J.J.S. Doherty to illustrate the need for civil service reform in the Indian Office. These two men, he said, had been accused of fraud, yet were subsequently appointed to important positions in the Indian Bureau—Indian Inspector and Government Physician.
Welsh advanced this argument further by recounting the story of General R. H. Milroy, former Indian agent from the Yakima Agency. According to Welsh, once political enemies forced Milroy to resign, conditions at the reservations within his agency quickly deteriorated. Welsh concluded that to protect against such actions, “the reform civil service spirit, and, in some shape, the civil service rules should be extended to the system which controls the appointment and removal of inspectors, agents, chief clerks, farmers, and other subordinates in the Indian service.”Footnote 11
Milroy's personal letters to Welsh, which he wrote to solicit help in appealing his removal, were filled with vitriolic statements on the fitness of his replacement. Among his complaints, Milroy argued that the new agent was a Catholic and smoked tobacco, thus making him spiritually and morally unsuitable for the position. In addition, perhaps appealing to their shared political philosophies in the Republican Party, he waved the bloody shirt and referred to the Secretary of the Interior Lamar, a Democrat, as a “darn Reb.”Footnote 12 While Milroy's comments appear to be an emotional reaction to what he perceived as unjust termination, his comments were intended to win the political favor of the letter's recipient—Welsh, a staunch Republican who, at times, demonstrated an anti-Catholic bias, particularly in Indian education.Footnote 13
While reading about the history of civil service reform in the United States and Great Britain, Welsh fixated upon the idea of competitive examinations. In England, one of the most significant features of the new system, Welsh observed, was “that it substituted an open competitive examination, as a means of testing the qualifications of those seeking place in the Civil Service of the Government, for the former methods of influence and pressure.”Footnote 14 Through civil service reform, he perhaps believed that it was possible to shape the policy agenda and administration of the Indian Bureau by controlling who became administrators.Footnote 15 Welsh might have considered the idea that these examinations could serve as a gateway through which only properly educated and ideologically homogenous individuals would pass.
Such a notion would not have been foreign to him, Herbert's uncle William Welsh and the Board of Indian Commissioners (BIC) tried to control who had access to political power within the OIA in the 1870s, most notably in 1871, when they charged Ely S. Parker, the Tonawanda Seneca Commissioner of the OIA, with mismanagement and corruption in his duties. A subsequent House of Representatives investigation and hearing exonerated Parker, but the stress and disappointment of the whole affair was discouraging and he resigned his position. Herbert Welsh often praised the early BIC, once calling them “an important link between the educated Christian people of the country and the Executive” (it is worth noting that Welsh's language here also revealed his elitist vision that the “educated Christian” members of the polity were best suited to direct policy). He also stated that while “the board proved of great value,” he believed that it had not been able to go far enough in its efforts to control who had access to the mechanisms of policy creation. He concluded, perhaps referencing the 1871 Parker investigation, that the BIC “failed to accomplish the full measure of the purpose which General Grant had in view … owing to the firm grip with which political corruption held the Indian service, and because of the President's own fatal unwillingness to ‘desert his friends under fire.’”Footnote 16 Welsh recognized the utility of shaping the personnel make-up of the Indian Office and through civil service reform, attempted to manipulate Indian policy debates through the methods by which the OIA made appointments.
In the late-1880s and 1890s, civil service reform began to occupy more and more of Welsh's time, and he shifted the direction of the IRA's Indian policy reform agenda to incorporate these ideas. In the Lake Mohonk conferences of the late 1880s, Welsh and IRA devoted significant attention to their concerns about the connections between patronage, corruption, and mismanagement in the Indian Service. In 1890, IRA published a pamphlet outlining these arguments entitled A Hideous System. In 1891, following the Wounded Knee Massacre and the assassination of Sitting Bull, Welsh penned an article in Scribner's Magazine in which he acknowledged that the horrible tragedies there had unfolded because hunger, poverty, and desperation that had followed dispossession and the reduction of reservation land. His prescription, though, was not an end to allotment, dispossession, and confinement; instead he argued that a remedy would be found if the Indian Service was “conducted in absolute harmony with the principles of Civil Service Reform—the principle of merit, not of spoils.”Footnote 17
IRA also argued for a significant expansion of governmental intervention into the economy. In his presentation to the “Friends of the Indian” assembled at the seventh annual Lake Mohonk Conference, C. C. Painter argued that in order for the allotment program to be successful, the government should help create contracts between the Indian allottees and landless white men. The white men would help break and cultivate the land for a period of years, while the Indians would work as paid laborers on their own acreage. At the end of the period, the white men would move on and the Indians would keep the ready-made farms.Footnote 18 Two years earlier Painter had written a pamphlet entitled “The Dawes Land in Severalty Bill and Indian Emancipation,” and asserted that by breaking apart tribal relations, creating individual farms for commercial agriculture, and disposing of “surplus” lands to white settlers, the government would not only hasten the assimilation process, but stimulate an economic windfall for the federal coffers.Footnote 19
It appears that the question of the viability of farming on the reservations never significantly entered into the IRA leaders thinking, but after the passage of the Allotment Act, many Indian agricultural developments failed, for a variety of reasons, and the Indian people leased their lands to non-Native farmers, homesteaders, and mineral extraction companies.Footnote 20 Nonetheless, when they made these arguments, IRA leaders envisioned a greatly expanded federal bureaucracy with economic regulatory powers previously unseen. Creating contracts between landholders and laborers or lessees would expand state power into the economic structures of various regions, a move many believed to be wrong headed. By considering an expanded federal bureaucracy, however, the IRA's ideology was very typical of the larger social and political reform movements of the era.
The IRA agenda also fit nicely with Welsh's other reform interests. Among other causes, Welsh participated in the Philadelphia and National Municipal Leagues, working to combat corruption in city governments. He also helped to found a Pennsylvania forestry association; served as a vice president for a national Forestry Congress; worked in the Law and Order Society of Philadelphia; sat on the Board of Managers for the City Parks Association; and played a key role in the Culture Extension League, an organization created to improve recreational facilities for the poor. He participated in the local Board of Education and in the Universal Peace Union.Footnote 21 One key factor that characterized all of the reform organizations in which Welsh participated was that they all engaged in creating a physical and human environment that elite, educated, white, Christian philanthropists felt was most appropriate for United States society. In Indian policy this ideology manifested itself in an approach characterized by dispossession and the spatial, social, political, and economic confinement of Indian people.
In their fight against the IRA and allotment legislation, the NIDA first attempted to frame their arguments within the context of legal philosophy. Bland and NIDA leaders suggested that the question of allotment presented a legal contradiction and in a fundamental way would destabilize or at least reshape congressional power, the authority of the states, and the ability of municipalities and private corporations to operate with minimal federal regulation. In the October 1885 issue of the Council Fire, Bland published the transcript of a minority report filed in the House of Representatives by Russell Errett of Pennsylvania, Charles Hooker of Mississippi, and T. M. Gunter of Arkansas, which drew attention to one of the primary contradictions of the severalty bill. The report argued that Indian people would hold a paradoxical position before the law. Errett and the other representatives stated that the first part of the program treated the Indian “as a man in giving him land and exacting from him the duty of maintaining himself upon and off of it.” They continued, however, “as soon as we do this, we proceed to treat him as a child, an infant, a ward in chancery, who is unable to take care of himself and therefore needs the protecting care of the government.”Footnote 22 NIDA leaders believed, like the representatives who filed the report, that this program would set a poor and contradictory precedent. In its rhetoric it would place Native people on an equal legal footing with other members of the polity, but it would simultaneously disadvantage them by withholding the franchise and Native people's ability to elect leaders to represent them. In addition, the allotment program took a similarly contradictory approach in relation to economic development on the reservations by pressuring Indian farmers to participate in commercial agriculture, while holding their profits in trust accounts for which they were not given complete access.
The more significant NIDA argument, however, came in the form of an extended discussion of the role and power of Congress and the impact that enacting allotment legislation might have. Judge A. J. Willard, in an 1887 Council Fire article, stated that the land rights of Native people “are vested in the tribe as a corporate body.” And furthermore, that the tribes held political authority over these lands in the same ways that private corporations and municipalities held their property. This was significant, Willard wrote, because, if Congress could arbitrarily “distribute the tribal property among the members of the tribe,” through the allotment program, then it could just as easily divide the lands held by municipal corporate charters or private companies “among the individuals constituting such corporate bodies.” With this precedent, Congress could dispossess city governments and private landholders alike. Willard asked rhetorically if the people of the United States were willing to extend such extraordinary powers to Congress. He concluded most directly that the issue was no longer simply a question “of robbing the Indian, but … a question whether Congress shall enter upon a career of legislation that embodies the worst principles … upon the stability of social institutions.”Footnote 23
NIDA continued to connect Indian policy to broader political issues in the United States even after the allotment act was passed. In an 1889 Council Fire article, Willard warned of the dangers inherit in the allotment legislation, both for Indian people and non-Natives alike. NIDA asserted that it was Congress's responsibility to compensate for dispossession and the history of colonization by providing opportunities for Indian communities, and continuing to distribute treaty appropriations. Allotment, however, threatened the balance of political power and authority between the federal and state levels. The allotment program removed Indian affairs from congressional jurisdiction, because the Constitution, which established congressional authority, assumed the existence of tribes, and once tribal land was allotted, the individual landholders would no longer maintain tribal status.
The new law, Willard asserted, “destroys the tribal condition and assumes to place the Indian on the same footing within the States as their white citizens.” This development would unsettle the balance of federal and state power, an issue that, less than a generation before, during the Civil War, almost tore the nation asunder. Willard also asserted that the history of Indian-white contact demonstrated that when Native communities fell under the jurisdiction of a state or territory, there was often little interest by local politicians or settlers to protect them and their lands. He concluded that the allotment program broke the “solemn trust” between Congress and Indian people, and more importantly for his larger argument, undermined the power of Congress and the federal government more generally.Footnote 24
In much the same way that Welsh's individual interests shaped the IRA agenda in late nineteenth-century policy debates, so too did Bland's shape the NIDA. Bland's work demonstrated an intense distaste for concentrated economic power. As Benjamin Johnson noted, his writing and policy advocacy was animated by the “deeply anticapitalist strains of American politics.”Footnote 25 The books Bland wrote protested railroad monopolies, the establishment of a national bank, and advocated for populist causes, the greenback party, and medical as well as religious reform. While he may not yet have articulated it as such in the late 1870s, Bland's emerging interest in Indian policy reform and especially his efforts to protect communally held Indian lands, connected quite clearly with his arguments in support of democratic self-determination and an active federal government that performed a protective role in some form or another.
Bland's books reflected these interests, as did his membership in a number of political parties and organizations that espoused these values. In the 1870s he published Farming as a Profession (1870), How to Grow Rich (1879), and The Life of Benjamin Butler (1879).Footnote 26 The first was a novel about a young man named Charley who chose to farm, despite a successful Harvard education and against the prodding of his elitist friend and fellow Harvard graduate, Fred. When the two men met later in life, Fred (then a Boston attorney) was unmarried, unhappy, and barely getting by; Charley was living happily and profitably with his wife. In the end, Fred chose to farm as well. The message was clear: honest labor, community ties, family, and personal happiness were all tied together. In How to Grow Rich, he attacked monopoly, and argued that it was easy to accumulate wealth, if one was willing to go about it ruthlessly. Bland's biography of Benjamin Butler applauded the subject's support for labor regulation, his support for women's rights, and his attacks on corporate and government corruption. It also focused intently on the “greenback” issue and celebrated Butler's promotion of the use of fiat currency (Butler would run for president as the candidate of the Greenback and Anti-Monopoly parties in 1884).
Bland believed that the federal government should issue paper money, and he vehemently opposed bankers. “Banks are foes to justice and equality always,” he argued.Footnote 27 In a capitalist society, honest farmers and the working classes would always operate at a disadvantage. It was the role of the state, Bland suggested, to compensate for the shortcomings of a capitalist economy and level the economic playing field. As a greenbacker, Bland supported labor against capital, the eight-hour workday, the establishment of an income tax, and even women's suffrage.Footnote 28 He also took issue with railroad monopolies; this in fact, dovetailed nicely with his efforts at Indian reform, and was the subject of his fourth book entitled The Reign of Monopoly (1881).Footnote 29
In 1892 he turned back to his interest in challenging bankers and published Esau: or the Bankers Victim, in which he railed against hard currency and the dangers of unrestrained capitalism. In this, as well as several of his previous works, Bland juxtaposed small-town, local, community mindedness with ruthless corporate development and the inequities of economic growth. He also published, in 1892, People's Party Shot and Shell, which addressed the reform agenda of the upstart populist party.Footnote 30 His interest in populism not only reflected his notions of state responsibility and fears of uncontrolled capitalism, but also his support for agrarian radicalism.Footnote 31
When we consider the broader reform currents in which these opposing Indian policy advocates operated in the late nineteenth century, we are able to envision their work as they would have understood it themselves. They saw their debates as part of a larger, national conversation about state development. Situating these men and women within the national dialogue also pushes us to consider the centrality of the Indian experience in the nineteenth-century United States. While narratives of state development have often surrendered the Gilded Age as a period of unimpeded corporate power, governmental passivity, corruption, and unrestrained inequality, focusing instead on the hybrid, public and private policy innovations of the Reconstruction Era and the urban, social, and political reforms of the Progressive Era, suggests otherwise.Footnote 32 Policy debates between leading organizations such as the NIDA and IRA demonstrate how the OIA served as a crucial meeting ground for ideologies of governmental authority, and these contests for control not only demonstrated the lengths to which some actors in the federal government were willing to experiment in this period—as policy makers allowed the state to take on increasingly interventionist functions—but also shows the evolution of social policy making.Footnote 33 By focusing on some of the broader themes of the Gilded Age, scholars of Indigenous studies might deepen their own analyses of settler colonialism by contextualizing Native experiences within the framework of state development and social policy.
