Has there been a more important time to study violence, business and government in the last 100 years? In Latin America, as the citizen experience with violence in Latin America has gone, so has the study. Much work is attentive to those in the midst of violence; the poor, the marginal, the politically distant. Dominant debates have been shaped by those who kill and those directly victimised, their networks and the lived condition of violence in a democratic moment. Far too absent has been a consideration of what looms, quietly, behind those portraits – those with political capital and the ability to shape policy, and their relationship with formal political institutions.
Enter a very important piece of work: Cities, Business and the Politics of Urban Violence in Latin America, by Eduardo Moncada. This book is thorough, precise and diligent in picking through the mire to find an important needle in the haystack – a tentative answer to the question ‘How do we get enduring and participatory public security policy?’ The response, after much careful presentation, discussion of evidence and comparison is that such a possibility depends on an underappreciated empirical fact: business leaders and political actors don't often get along. And how they might succeed when they do get along depends on who else has control over the parts of cities where violence is a problem. So when do they succeed, how does it come to pass? And why don't we see similar outcomes in other places with similar policies? For Moncada, succinctly, ‘the interaction between urban political economies and patterns of armed territorial control influence the nature and trajectory of the political projects that cities launch in response to violence’ (p. 156).
From Colombia, Moncada shows how there are divergent patterns, historical contingencies and questions of scale that matter. The book approaches the problem of violence in a novel and well-justified way, by considering how it has become an urban question. Processes of decentralisation and post-Cold War devolution of authority mean that the violence occurring in cities is not well understood from a national frame. It is driven by local ‘sub-national’ patterns of engagement or political disinterest. Moreover, cities are of course full of ‘complex cross currents of political power’ (p. 3), overlapping jurisdictions and competing interests that move from the local to the national and beyond. Urban political economies are a peculiar (but patterned) species. The book is entirely on the mark in this regard: what is necessary is a more thorough understanding of the comparative divergences – why did a similar policy fail in one city and not another, given many symmetries?
The book advances through a comparison of political projects confronting urban violence in three cities, Medellín, Bogotá and Cali. Moncada advances an analytic framework to identify and isolate the patterns that matter across these locations, as they hinge on two key variables, urban political economy and armed territorial control. Most of Chapter 1 follows a deliberate and succinct description of the various considerations and assumptions of the framework, as they relate to the nature of politics, business and territorial control. This does not demand restatement here, except to say that this treatment of the variables and considerations is as transparent as I can imagine. The rest of Chapter 1 considers some contextual necessities of urban governance and describes the methodology – 211 qualitative interviews and a thorough review of archival, news and a range of other secondary sources. Chapter 2 provides historical context, especially as it relates to the historical politics of exclusion in Colombia, the rise of the drug trade and the fracturing of politics further into armed conflict and violent actors in a moment of decentralisation. Chapters 3–5 present and discuss each of the cases in great nuance and detail, providing a thorough account of each within the analytic framework. Chapter 6 reflects on the findings, before moving to an excellent contribution: Moncada extracts some of the key initial lessons learned and seeks to test them in an external case, Ciudad Juárez (Mexico), where he similarly carried out exploratory fieldwork.
The book gives us some vital takeaways in its analysis of these participatory security policies of the 1990s. First, Bogotá was reasonably successful in advancing an enduring policy with sustained effects. Medellín and Cali were not. But for different reasons. Bogotá’s business community was cohesive, its mayor advanced a truly inclusionary vision and the territories where violence existed were controlled by highly atomized actors. Medellín's business community was similarly cohesive, but its mayor was exclusionary, and the city's armed actors were organised but fragmented. By contrast, in Cali, the business community was segmented and in near-conflict with the political realm. In addition, armed actors had fragmented territorial control over space. And while the mayor was participatory, advancing inclusionary policies, the project failed roundly.
It does not surprise me that when Moncada took these findings and examined their relevance in Ciudad Juárez he found many symmetries. Making a tentative comparison with a 2012 policy, ‘Todos Somos Juárez’ (‘We are all Juárez’, TSJ), Moncada finds that three patterns hold especially true. First, that the private sector is a crucial component in a policy's failure – or success. In Juárez, business leaders linked to the maquiladoras sought to privilege their own cause, protecting their supply routes to the border. Second, clientelism shapes political preferences. In the absence of a transcendent mayor, clientelism remains a powerful and disruptive force that makes money disappear, drives wedges between civil society and business and limits collective claims on the state for better security policy. And, lastly, that territorial control indeed matters for policy outcomes. Juárez was in the midst of an explosive territorial war between the Sinaloa and Juárez cartels, which had both co-opted local gangs. But when the homicide rate fell almost overnight in 2012 it was not because of the TSJ policy. Rather, it was because the Sinaloa cartel had prevailed with a monopoly (at least for the most part), more or less in spite of TSJ.
This book is a consummate piece of deliberate and nuanced social science scholarship. It is carefully crafted, rich with analytic importance and built upon a research design that should be much more thoroughly used in political science today. The comparative method, which recognises cities (rightly) as sites of power and agency, is a substantial contribution to ongoing debates to the discipline and the study of Latin America. In addition, I find Moncada's work to be a very welcome qualitative and locally situated contribution in a field that increasingly side-steps larger questions of context in favour of method. Moncada's contribution is, then, substantial in two ways. He offers us important new knowledge about the role of elites as a lever for effective policy, and a diligent and situated method for answering pressing comparative urban questions that rightly does not take ‘the State’ as a normative departure point. I eagerly recommend this book to colleagues and students in Latin American studies and beyond.
