Though he draws from theorists like Gadamer, Ricoeur, Lindbeck, Tracy and others, and he does not want to be identified with a particular school of hermeneutics, in The Hermeneutics of Doctrine, Anthony Thiselton has clearly accomplished for doctrinal hermeneutics what Hans-Georg Gadamer did for philosophical hermeneutics in Truth and Method. That is, Thiselton has written a book which will shape and inform the future trajectory of the hermeneutics of doctrine for generations of scholars in the same way that Gadamer expanded the discussion of philosophical hermeneutics beyond Heidegger. It is all too seldom that scholars use actual practice to provide insights into a particular hermeneutical theory. Thiselton's substantive sampling of biblical texts and doctrinal themes, engaged through the discipline of hermeneutical consideration, is a remarkable contribution and will gently guide committed readers through a ‘fresh eye’ approach to the discipline.
Thiselton introduces his study with a quick but important primer on hermeneutics, where the attuned reader will discern a subtle but critical situating away from the individual-centred rationalism of Descartes and Kant to a communal, practice-centred engagement best exemplified by Gadamer. He is interested in understanding if the interaction between hermeneutics and doctrine can play a part in ‘rescuing doctrine from its marginalized function and abstraction from life, and deliver it from its supposed status of mere theory’ (p. xvi). In contrast to rationalist objectivism, Thiselton wants to engage doctrine in such a way that it is not divorced from the situation that gave it birth (p. 5). The hermeneutical experience is formative, even transformative, and not simply informative. Through the rigorous experience of communal engagement (i.e. practice and/or worship), doctrine becomes more than the acquisition of knowledge; new horizons of understanding are engaged through the dialectic of question and answer, resulting in what he refers to as an active participation rather than a distanced observation which is, itself, transformative (p. 84).
The Hermeneutics of Doctrine is comprised of three different parts with a total of twenty-two chapters. In part I, Thiselton provides the reader with an impressive collection of applicable hermeneutical theory with contributions from Wittgenstein to Dilthey, Gadamer and Ricoeur, to Betti. Like many European scholars, Thiselton displays an extensive knowledge of each theorist's unique contribution to the discipline of hermeneutics but, importantly, it is a knowledge which clearly has emerged through an intensive engagement with each primary text. Chapter 5, ‘Formation, Education, and Training in Gadamer, Ricoeur, and Betti’, is particularly rich and provides an approachable point of entry for those who are newer to the discipline. Part II is Thiselton's attempt to respond to potential objections; a kind of theoretical pre-emptive aimed at those who might argue that a hermeneutical consciousness is not located on a rigorous epistemological foundation. This theme is nicely addressed in the essay entitled ‘Does Communal, Contingent, Hermeneutical Approach Exclude Epistemology?’ where, again, the legacy of Descartes is engaged and Rorty's postmodern ‘strategy of coping’ with ‘no claims to truth’ is juxtaposed to Gadamer's notion of ‘“judgment” as a form of knowledge that can differentiate between the appropriate and inappropriate . . . in more than merely pragmatic terms’ (pp. 131–2). The result of this analysis sets up an argument that ‘truth’, for matters of doctrine, might best be understood as ‘coherence’; an argument which is elaborated in ‘Can Doctrine as “Science” Remain Hermeneutical and Promote Formation?’. Here Thiselton acknowledges T. F. Torrance's ‘profoundly hermeneutical conception of both theological and natural sciences’ (p. 146) and explodes any notion that ‘truth’ is the result of ‘method’. Rather, ‘[g]enuine critical questions as to the possibility of knowledge [read: truth] cannot be raised in abstracto, but only in concreto, not a priori but only a posteriori’ (p. 146). For Thiselton, Torrance's Theological Science more accurately represents what, in practice, happens in the give and take, to and fro of hermeneutical engagement which in turn can facilitate ‘transformative effects’ (p. 150).
Unlike Truth and Method, where Gadamer is disappointingly thin in book III, his hermeneutical application, ‘Part III of The Hermeneutics of Doctrine [thoroughly] expounds the content of specific Christian doctrines, but always from the specific standpoint of hermeneutical starting points, hermeneutical resources and hermeneutical currencies’ (p. xx). Throughout these chapters, Thiselton links the first hermeneutical horizon, i.e. pre-understanding with the second hermeneutical horizon i.e., a Torrance-informed, disciplined hermeneutical reflection (e.g. ‘hermeneutic of truth’). The result of this hermeneutical inquiry is a profound work of rigorous scholarship that may, indeed, be transformative.
The Hermeneutics of Doctrine is clearly not an easy read. Pastors who are looking for a quick ‘how to’ book in the discipline of hermeneutical inquiry will most certainly be chagrined. Those readers who are willing to invest the time and intellectual energy it takes to absorb this contribution to scholarship, however, will be intellectually and spiritually nurtured and prepared to engage both rationalists and postmodernists alike in an intellectually engaged conversation of faith.
