Despite a robust and growing body of literature in the emerging field of ludomusicology—the study of video game music—video game sound has remained something of a paradox in the game industry: an integral afterthought. Music and effects are often vital to the gaming experience, creating a powerful connection with the player. However, the industry tends to privilege visual and gameplay elements over sound, rushing development and implementation of audio, or allocating fewer resources in terms of storage space, budget, and personnel. To compound this issue, game audio is at its most effective when it is seamless, unnoticed. As Tracy Bush says in his interview in the Beep book, “It's a lot of work to be invisible. It's a lot of work to be a ninja.”
Throughout her career, Karen Collins has sought to uncover the hidden work of these audio ninjas, publishing some of the most influential texts on the history of game audio.Footnote 1 In August 2014, she launched a Kickstarter campaign to fund a documentary project cataloguing interviews with dozens of game audio industry professionals. Over one thousand backers helped the team exceed its initial funding goals, and the Kickstarter page remains open, suggesting that the team will continue to update materials in the future with additional financial backing. The result is Beep, a paired set of a video documentary (Beep: Documenting the History of Game Sound) and a companion book of interviews (Beep: A Documentary History of Game Sound).
Both the book and the documentary exist in physical and digital versions, and readers can purchase the two separately or together from the Beep website (http://www.beepmovie.com). The film is also available for rent or purchase on Vimeo, which requires members to sign up for a free account before they can access the material. All versions are relatively inexpensive, particularly the digital copy, which allows for unlimited streaming and downloading. The book is available for Kindle via Amazon—the print version of the book was only available to the project's Kickstarter backers, so the eBook is the primary format for the interview transcripts. It's just as well—the book lacks an index, so the digital copy allows for keyword searches that make it easier to parse the over 410,000 words of text for particular topics of interest.
The film contains two main sections. The first follows a largely linear path, beginning with arcade sound and tracing its history chronologically through the 1990s. After discussing the switch from FM synthesis to the CD-ROM era, however, the film makes a stylistic break, focusing on several topics within game sound (voice-over, sound design, implementation, etc.) rather than providing a strict historical narrative. This shift may frustrate some viewers; the opening half contains a wealth of technical detail and anecdotes about the process of composing and translating sounds to various platforms. Those seeking a more in-depth history—particularly of the technological advancements in game sound—may find it useful to supplement the documentary with Collins's earlier books. The second half, however, is perhaps more accessible to non-specialists, and covers topics ranging from designing sound for mobile and indie games to chiptune culture.Footnote 2 The Blu-ray menu helpfully breaks up the material into chapters, but the digital version lacks this same delineation of content. That lamentable absence could have been remedied by incorporating live links on the streaming page that could jump to specific moments in the film (as one might find if the content were uploaded to a platform such as YouTube). The film currently offers subtitles in Spanish, French, and German, and the team plans to add additional language support as future stretch goals for the Kickstarter campaign.
The book, which contains the full text of all of Collins's interviews, is organized alphabetically by the interviewee name. A list of ninety-six names may be a bit daunting for the researcher or pedagogue searching for game-audio experts from specific eras or genres of gaming. Perusing the introduction to each interview one by one gives a sense of what each person has worked on, but it is a time-consuming method. An index might have made this resource easier to incorporate in the classroom, as well as a bit more useful for research, but electronic keyword searches remain a viable option for locating specific information more efficiently.Footnote 3
Despite any limitations in the formatting or presentation of material, the content remains an unparalleled achievement, preserving firsthand accounts from several decades’ worth of game audio history. Beep is a rich, detailed primary source with a number of pedagogical and scholarly applications. Assigning students snippets or entire interviews allows teachers of game music to present questions of authorship and intention; most games (even indie titles) represent collective creative efforts, and this fact can serve to decentralize individual artists in favor of a focus on reception or the game as text. Pairing these interviews with gameplay or audio could help students to isolate and examine game music in relation to broader issues in music criticism and scholarship, and begin to think about these musical objects as a series of relationships between creators and players instead of belonging solely to the game and a particular audiovisual context. The interviews are often only a few pages each, which makes them easy to assign—a course with non-major undergraduates might read a couple of interviews for a group discussion, for instance, whereas an undergraduate seminar or a graduate course might take a more in-depth look at a broader swath of the material.
Scholars might not find the content of the interviews revolutionary, but the resource remains valuable as the only existing collection of primary source material on game sound. Any scholar looking at games is likely to come up empty-handed when trying to find interviews about a particular game, especially for those from the era before marketing showcases and game industry conferences raised public awareness of game design and development.Footnote 4 The Beep interviews provide a useful entry point—a name to follow up with, a confirmation of who worked on which games, and descriptions of compositional philosophies and working methods.Footnote 5
Game music is often most interesting outside of the actual game, and so these resources represent an opportunity to consider the social, cultural, technological, or political moments this music inhabits. Using the Beep film and book allows scholars and students of game music access to a rich repository of sources to challenge and enrich their understanding of composition, programming, implementation, fandom, and reception. By blowing the ninjas’ cover, Collins has done a great service in documenting this often-neglected area of game history.
