This book is a welcome delve into the history of social organisation (in this case, workers) in El Salvador, before and during the civil war of the 1980s. Newly available archive sources as well as interviews with survivors and exiles from that period have offered new detail and dimensions to this history. The Salvadorean labour movement of those decades was much overlooked at the time; authors (including myself) focused much more on peasant participation in the revolutionary movement. Peasants played a key role in that movement, but it was always in alliance with other social groups. The labour movement, not all of which was part of the revolutionary struggle, has never received the academic attention it deserves. And this book amply fills that void, with a careful and nuanced reconstruction of events over significant time periods that enable us to appreciate aspects of the country's labour history in relation to the struggles of other sectors of the population and the political projects that sought to mobilise their support.
In fact, Jeffrey Gould is less interested in the specificities of those projects, and rather in building the picture of labour in the port and shrimp industry of Puerto el Triunfo, from its own perspectives and actions, conflicts and achievements, ultimately undermined by the neoliberal turn and associated corruption, fostered by sectors of the Right in the 1980s and rampant by the 1990s. This is a refreshing and important lens. A light is shone on how the workers of this coastal area, living in conditions of extreme exploitation, began to organise and build union power in the 1970s. Particularly significant is the role women played in challenging the hardships of conditions in the shrimp factories, on top of often abusive relationships at home. The emergence of women activists, becoming in a few cases union leaders, captures aspects of history that would remain buried without Gould's scholarship. Their achievements of winning the right, for instance, to a cafeteria, in other words to have access to food in the working day, show how basic the rights they pursued were.
The detail of union leaders’ life histories gives depth to these labour struggles against the backcloth of tumultuous political events as civil war unfolded. The story of labour organising in Puerto del Triunfo weaves in and out of those events, always impacted by them, but having its own dynamics as well. The growth in self-confidence of individual union leaders as they gained negotiating skills in adverse and repressive conditions emerges strongly. The background political dynamics inform us of the contingent processes through which labour navigated its capacity to win rights and benefits and highlights the role of an increasingly socially and politically conscious leadership. However, while some leaders confronted their bosses and built a social base they were accountable to, others sought benefits for themselves and their followers through working with the bosses. The bosses benefitted from the resulting divisions. Other divisions between those working in the port factories, the temporary workers and the shrimp fishermen, some of whom could make extra money selling their catch on the side, convey the challenges of the workers’ struggle for decent working lives. Labour solidarity emerges as a significant thread as particular leaders embrace the rights of temporary workers, for instance, and become more political in relationship to the country's wider struggles. Nevertheless, unity in the struggle was never guaranteed, and solidarity itself was often contingent. Despite the very adverse conditions, and the increasing savagery and violence experienced particularly during 1980–1, workers made many advances, including in the mid-1980s at the height of the civil war.
There is much to learn from this book, which highlights the particularities of social struggle in this small Central American republic, in which the remarkable level of activism and popular, including union, organisation can be compared to much larger countries, such as Brazil. The substantive politics of this activism is addressed less in the book. The political movements which attempted to build and capture this militancy, and the real differences between them, are not discussed in such depth. The fact that the Communist Party had much more history of involvement in the country's labour struggles and was more inclined to continue strategic political action and build alliances with ‘progressive’ actors, rather than pursue armed struggle, is an important aspect of why labour was more divided around the political options than some other social sectors. The divisions between the Fuerzas Populares de Liberación (Popular Liberation Forces, FPL) and other armed groups that would eventually form the Frente Farabundo Martí para la Liberación Nacional (Farabundo Martí National Liberation Front, FMLN) guerrilla front are not just sectarian disputes. There was a substantive difference between those that believed in ‘prolonged popular war’ (such as the FPL) and building a social base with a real voice in the process, and those who aimed quite early on to organise an insurgency. These differences all mattered in terms of the nature of popular organising, such as the emergence of an organisation, the Bloque Popular Revolucionario (Popular Revolutionary Bloc, BPR), which did build an alliance of peasants, workers and students that took to the streets in massive demonstrations and effectively linked this to the FPL political project in the 1970s. The story which ensued is much more complex, as the armed struggle generated its own social and political dynamics, and the military logics of the revolution often took over from the political ones.
Ultimately, it was a massive banking fraud by members of the Far Right closely tied into the agro-financial sector that brought the fishing industry to an end. An interesting vignette brings Roberto D'Aubuisson, co-founder of the right-wing Alianza Republicana Nacionalista (National Republican Alliance, ARENA) party and also intellectual author of the assassination of Archbishop Romero, into the picture. Once ARENA won the 1989 election, the charges against the fraudsters came to nothing and the fishing business collapsed. The denouement of Gould's history is therefore a tragic one, and his interviews with those forced to flee to Los Angeles, or who migrated there, some of them key union leaders, capture memories of terror and the loss of their livelihoods, as well as some pride in what had been achieved. Through this book and the accompanying documentary he has made, Gould has ensured that the story will not be lost.
