Book reviews for The Journal of Pension Economics and Finance reflect reviewers' own views and in no way represent the views of the institution(s) with which they are affiliated.
The problem addressed by this book can be stated rather simply: given a pay-as-you-go social security system and an aging population, how can a country provide adequate social security benefits to the old without imposing unduly burdensome taxes on the young? Of course, coming up with an economically and politically viable solution to this problem is anything but simple. The book demonstrates that, in fact, several countries have made good progress on the problem.
Based on a 2006 Urban Institute conference, the book is primarily written for people who influence, study, and formulate Social Security policy in the United States. At the time of the conference, it was clear that the Social Security reform proposals made by President George W. Bush were unlikely to yield positive results. In particular, they were unlikely to produce movement toward solving Social Security's long-run financing problem. And that long-run problem is, indeed, serious. Due in part to increasing longevity and to an aging baby boom generation, the U.S. Social Security program is projected to begin making benefit payments that exceed tax collections in 2017, and to exhaust its reserves in 2041. It is true that the long-run fiscal problem is much worse in the Medicare program, but the Bush administration decided to focus first on reforming Social Security.
The fact that the administration's reform proposals did not lead to progress on the long-run financing problem is a source of concern. The problem will have to be solved sometime. Given the demise of the administration's proposals, what should we do next? This book helps address that question by looking at other developed countries with a similar long-run financing problem. It examines what they have done, and how they have done it. The book consists of six chapters focused on six countries: Canada, Sweden, Japan, Germany, the United Kingdom, and Italy. Each of these countries has an aging population and a pay-as-you-go public pension program. And each has sought to reform its public pension so as to address a long-run financing problem. The chapters begin with an essay that first describes the particular country's public and private retirement system and then traces recent reforms. This essay is followed by two commentaries that not only discuss the essay, but also consider the extent to which the country's experience is relevant to the U.S. Social Security debate. The essays are written by one or more experts from the country, while the authors of the commentaries are intimately familiar with the features, economics, and politics of the U.S. Social Security program.
This thoughtful design is one of the book's many positive features, and Penner should be commended for it. Too often, edited volumes are like a cocktail party: while the invited guests are in the same place at the same time, they engage in several distinct conversations. This is not the case here: the chapters share a common structure and a common topic, the conversations are similar, and there is a nice coherence to the book.
The first chapter on Canada by Réal Bouchard is especially clear and well-written. It has the markings of a good undergraduate reading. Moreover, the commentaries by Stuart Butler and James Capretta do a fine job of examining the extent to which Canada's experience carries lessons for the U.S. An interesting feature of the Canadian reforms is an independent investment board which invests public funds in private companies. Butler argues (and Capretta agrees) that this is one area where Canada can do things that may not be possible in the U.S.; the political cultures are just too different. The paper by Agneta Kruse and Edward Palmer discusses Sweden, which is the odds-on winner of any public pension beauty contest. The authors argue that Sweden's new set of retirement programs incorporates automatic mechanisms that make it more financially stable (more robust to economic and demographic changes) than the old. The superb commentaries by Estelle James and Lawrence Thompson take a skeptical view of that claim and its applicability to the U.S. Indeed, for those who are enamored with Sweden's retirement system, both commentaries, but especially that by Estelle James, are excellent antidotes.
A fine essay by Tetsuo Kabe caps the third chapter's examination of Japan's retirement system. After describing that system, Kabe details the country's demographic and financial challenges and then traces the repeated reforms undertaken to address those challenges. Excellent commentaries by Jagadeesh Gokhal and Richard Jackson put these reforms into perspective. Gokhal evaluates Japan's efforts at establishing automatic benefit adjustment mechanisms that take into account demographic changes and reduce the need for repeated reforms. Jackson notes these same reforms, but emphasizes that Japan has still not solved its problem. The demographic challenges are daunting; Japan's retirement system would greatly benefit from more babies.
The chapter by Michael Mersmann focuses on Germany, and it provides a concise description of Germany's recent pension reforms. It could have said more about how and why Germany made progress on reform: how serious was the looming financial crisis? How did Germany assemble a political coalition in favor of reform? The commentaries by Maya MacGuiness and Neil Howe do a good job of examining to what extent the German experience is applicable to the U.S. Particularly interesting is the discussion of Germany's Reister pensions, which are a form of state subsidized individual defined contribution pension. Despite the subsidies, Reister pensions suffer from low take-up rates. Interestingly, both commentators argue that choice is a problem here, and that the pensions should be mandatory.
Alex Beer provides a masterful description of the United Kingdom's retirement programs. Here we learn that, in part due to reforms introduced in the 1980s and 1990s, the UK's programs are something of an outlier. That is, the problem for the UK is less one of financial sustainability, and more one of benefit adequacy. The commentary by Sanford Ross hones in on this, essentially arguing that in its effort to keep down costs, the UK has sacrificed social protection. John Turner's excellent commentary focuses on the UK as an innovator in retirement income policy (e.g., voluntary carve-out individual accounts), and nicely points out the problems that accompanied some of these innovations.
The chapter by Alicia Puente Cackley, Tom Moscovitch, and Benjamin Pfeiffer, examines Italy. After describing the country's retirement system, the essay traces the sequence of major reforms to that system. We learn that, in the face of a demographic challenge greater than that confronting the U.S., Italy has rather dramatically reduced out-year benefits in its pay as you go pension. In an strong commentary, Paul Van de Water states that the Italians “seem to have stabilized the long-run cost of their social security system, and in the process have cut current workers' pension wealth by about 40 percent.” The companion commentary by Dalmer Hoskins tempers any undue enthusiasm for this accomplishment. Italy is on a path that is likely to lead to declining replacement rates and increased poverty among the elderly. It remains to be seen whether Italy's political system will actually walk the talk.
In summary, this is a fine book. It does an excellent job of using other countries' experiences to examine possible routes by which the United States could reform its Social Security program. Moreover, woven into the fabric of the six chapters are arguments about the advantages and disadvantages of different kinds of reforms. I only wish this were more explicit. For example, it would be useful to pull together arguments for and against automatic mechanisms for insuring financial stability, using country specific cases to illustrate the points. The same applies to notional defined contribution pensions, individual accounts, and policies that increase the age of benefit eligibility. Although Penner's preface, which is both interesting and thought provoking, does some of that, it could have gone further. The reader is left with the task of pulling together the related threads from the book's similar conversations. While that may be a good exercise for the reader, it is likely that Penner could do it better given his knowledge and skills.
Finally, there is meat here for a broader study of why some countries embrace public pension reform while others do not. I went into the book thinking that some countries -- in particular parliamentary democracies – might be more foresighted and proactive than others. I came away surprised at the role of crises. Many countries that introduced innovative reforms were confronted with severe and immediate problems attributable to public pension solvency. Perhaps the early movers cannot be said to have been more rational; perhaps instead, they were simply blessed with an earlier crisis.
