In his introduction, Daniel Carey provides a clear and nuanced view of political economy after the age of mercantilism. He notes that early modern thinkers did not place themselves into neat groupings. (“Mercantilism” is a catch-all term for a variety of viewpoints, and some early thinkers were not even mercantilist.) An individual who could be considered ‘conservative’ politically might be progressive in economic matters, or vice versa. Carey makes the important point that it is difficult to categorize which economic ideas were progressive and which were backward looking. In addition, what suited the domestic economy might not be useful for supporting international trading links. Therefore, it mattered whether a writer was interested in the domestic or the international political sphere. Carey disagrees with Steve Pincus’s method of splitting thinkers into groupings largely along party lines. Carey argues that Pincus’s categorization is too extreme and that some individual thinkers were representative only of themselves. Carey also discusses the Great Recoinage of 1696 and the debate between John Locke and William Lowndes in detail. This leads to a consideration of what money itself is or could be, according to contemporary thinkers.
Johann P. Somerville’s chapter concerns Sir Robert Filmer’s tract on usury, which has hitherto received little scholarly attention. Somerville argues that Filmer has been unfairly dismissed as a traditionalist who merely wished to preserve an existing social order, believing it to be “natural and divinely established” (p. 31). Locke castigated Filmer for his supposed views. Somerville convincingly argues that Filmer’s work on usury was far-sighted and did not rely on religious arguments or favor the traditional social order. He also contends that Filmer has been misrepresented for holding opinions that do not actually appear in his writings.
Daniel Carey contributes a chapter about Locke’s views on money. He returns to Locke’s arguments regarding the Recoinage and sets them within the context of Locke’s wider philosophy concerning money, language, and politics. Locke’s insistence that the coinage should not be devalued had implications for debtors as well as creditors, although he does not seem to have considered this. Anyone who had made a bargain in the era of clipped coinage might be required to pay in full-weight coin. Locke believed that devaluation would have unintended consequences in an open economy, including generating arbitrage opportunities.
Charles Larkin’s chapter also concerns the Recoinage. Larkin discusses the views of Charles Davenant on the subject. Davenant opposed Locke, partly because Davenant understood the role of credit in the economy. Locke was focused on commodity money and insisted that silver coins had an ‘intrinsic’ value, which could not be tampered with. Davenant took a pragmatic view and argued that a recoinage could wait at least until peacetime. He privileged the role of money as a medium of exchange rather than merely being a store of wealth. Larkin argues that Davenant was willing to use money and credit as tools of policy making, rather than viewing money as merely an object of policy. This was a radical departure from existing approaches. Larkin clearly explains aspects of monetary theory, both modern and early modern, in a detailed way for a non-specialist audience. Davenant understood the importance of paper money, but his views were too radical for many contemporaries to grasp. Larkin argues that the Great Recoinage prompted developments in monetary theory itself.
Justin Champion discusses the political economy of Commonwealth England. He revisits the contributions made by John G. A. Pocock and the more recent work of Steve Pincus. Pocock argued that post-regicidal republicanism, following from the ideas of James Harrington, was concerned with the creation of communal virtue. Pincus argued that Harringtonians were obsessed with an agrarian society while they were actually living in a newly emerging commercial one. Champion challenges that view by following the careers of various neo-Harringtonians. John Toland discussed an alternative scheme for a Bank of England. Toland’s bank would offer commercial banking services and therefore shore up the Commonwealth rather than destroy it. Champion also challenges received opinion about Toland’s Secret History of the South Sea Bubble, and also about Cato’s Letters. He argues that Toland and the republican polemicists of Cato’s Letters did not object to “credit per se, but to the corruption of credit” (p. 134). Champion also draws attention to Toland’s involvement in South Sea shares (with another famous critic of the South Sea, Robert Molesworth). Molesworth’s own economic viewpoint is also discussed and Champion finds him to be more adaptable to changing economic circumstances than is usually thought.
Patrick Kelly’s chapter focuses on George Berkeley’s proposal for a national bank of Ireland. Berkeley recognized that national wealth was not measured by a quantity of specie but by how much individuals could satisfy their needs and wants. This was particularly pertinent in the Irish case. Many Irish people were living at subsistence level while basic necessities were being exported. Berkeley discussed private banks, with and without the addition of national banks. He believed that banks such as the Bank of England were not truly ‘national’ as they were answerable to their shareholders rather than to the nation.
Ryan Patrick Hanley and Maria Pia Paganelli contribute a chapter on Adam Smith’s view of money. They discuss the various strategies of the state such as debasement and paper credit money, which they term “proto-monetary” policies (p. 190). They note that the word “policy” is perhaps too strong a description of state actions, which were often ad hoc. Smith’s approach to money is part of his wider belief in the market’s superiority over a planned economy. Hanley and Paganelli discuss Smith’s characterization of the various unintended consequences of monetary experiments. The final chapter, by Thomas Hopkins, explains how Smith’s theories about human nature were received and critiqued by French thinkers. Carey’s earlier co-edited volume (with Christopher J. Finlay), The Empire of Credit, also covered the Financial Revolution period. Readers who enjoyed that volume will find that this one is of the same high standard.
