Adam Mestyan's book Arab Patriotism: The Ideology and Culture of Power in Late Ottoman Egypt is an excellent addition to nineteenth-century Egyptian historiography. By probing the intersection of theater, official khedival culture, and politics, Mestyan succeeds in examining this oft-studied period of Egyptian history in a new light. In a well-researched book, Mestyan brings to light many of the elite musical, theatrical, and cultural dynamics of late-nineteenth-century Egypt, especially as they relate to Khedival circles. Mestyan makes a compelling case for the importance of this transformation of elite Khedival culture from Ottoman Turkish to European and later on Arabic performances. Throughout the book, Mestyan details state sponsorship of elite high culture from Italian operas to fusha adaptations of European plays and, in the process, brings to life dozens of previously unexamined Arabic songs, poems, and panegyrics, all used to legitimize the Egyptian ruling family.
Mestyan excels at explaining the many palace intrigues surrounding a host of European, Syrian, and Egyptian playwrights, artists, cultural brokers, and government officials working to carry favor with the Khedival court. The book utilizes a slew of previously underutilized primary sources and provides rich and minutely detailed accounts of dozens of significant interactions between important, though previously understudied, cultural actors in late-nineteenth-century Egypt. Mestyan effectively uses government records, letters, and petitions from Dar al-Watha'iq and the rarely used Dar al-Mahfuzat to complement his selection of late-nineteenth-century Egyptian periodicals to give a comprehensive view of the inner-workings of the European and the elite Egypto-Syrian theater scene. Mestyan describes the lives of writers and journalists, such as Abdallah Abu al-Su‘ud and his son Muhammad Unsi, as well as many other previously overlooked personalities, revealing a complex, interconnected web of state influence, if not an altogether state-directed cultural agenda. Paul Draneht, who is described as the man “who made the system of khedivial theaters work” (99), comes to life in Mestyan's book, revealing a behind-the-scenes look at the programing and decision-making process of early state theater in Egypt.
However, the examination of these cultural productions through the lens of what Mestyan labels “Arab Patriotism” seems forced and somewhat detracts from the many strengths of the book. I was not convinced of the existence of a tangible widespread conception of “patriotism” in nineteenth-century Egypt, be it Ottoman, Egyptian, or especially “Arab.” Also, the use of “Arab” as indicating group identity was radically different in nineteenth-century Egypt as compared to the second half of the twentieth century. The very use of the term to describe nineteenth-century non-Bedouin natives of Egypt is problematic and needs quite a bit more unpacking. For example, it was difficult to reconcile Mestyan's labeling of Abbas Hilmi II as an “Arab Prince” and Mustafa Kamil as an “Arab patriot,” given the contradiction with how they self-identified and with the plethora of documents they left behind. In his autobiography, which he chose to pen in French, Abbas Hilmi clearly identifies himself as ethnically Turkish. Kamil on the other hand, who was obsessed with flagging his national pride to all those who would listen, left thousands of pages of his letters, speeches, and articles. Not once did he self-identify as an Arab or an “Arab patriot.”
Although I was not convinced that “Arabness,” as a modern collective identity, had an earlier non-colonial Ottoman role in nineteenth-century Egypt, Mestyan makes a convincing argument for the importance of an Egyptian state-sponsored Arabic-language musical theater, which aimed to enhance the legitimacy of Khedival authority among the Egyptian elite. What Mestyan amply demonstrates throughout his book is not “Arab Patriotism,” but a sort of Khedival dynastic loyalty that was often sponsored or subsidized by the Egyptian court. In many ways, the subtitle of the book (The Ideology and Culture of Power in Late Ottoman Egypt) is more accurate in describing the major contribution of this study.
These minor reservations notwithstanding, Arab Patriotism is an innovative re-examination of late-nineteenth-century Egyptian history. I found the concept of “khedival culture” as coined by the author to have great explanatory potential. Indeed, its application could be expanded beyond the theater to all forms of Khedival-sponsored cultural production during the nineteenth century. By probing the evolving parameters of sponsored Egyptian state culture, Mestyan not only reveals a vital building block of khedival legitimacy, but also demonstrates the importance of studying the evolution of these cultural institutions. This work is a welcome addition to the field and will be of great interest to scholars and students of the late Ottoman Empire and modern Egypt.
