No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 August 2004
The subject of this book is the recent political and economic history of the Central Asian republics as well as the state of Azerbaijan in the Caucasus since the end of the Soviet era and their subsequent independence. In addition, the author examines the present-day conditions of these republics up to the year 2000.
The subject of this book is the recent political and economic history of the Central Asian republics as well as the state of Azerbaijan in the Caucasus since the end of the Soviet era and their subsequent independence. In addition, the author examines the present-day conditions of these republics up to the year 2000.
In the Foreword, written by John E. Wood, we are promised a fresh look at the vicissitudes of the republics. There it is asserted that scholarship on these nationalities has always been conditioned by their long-standing positions in the Soviet Union and their relations with Russia that preceded that. That seems a perfectly natural thing. However, the historical, linguistic, religious, and cultural ties of these states with their other neighbors, far and near, are said to be more important. In this book, Alaolmolki sets out to examine the newly independent republics' recent problems by relying entirely on products of the Western media, especially American and British ones. He tries to do exactly what is promised in the Foreword and informs those with raised eyebrows that the U.S. administration and especially American business now have their eyes on the natural resources of these nations and seek both economic and political influence in the region.
In his Introduction, the author informs the reader of political instability in the northern Caucasus; inter-ethnic and religious conflict in Central Asia, and the threat of the then extremist Muslims of Afghanistan, the Taliban, to Central Asian peace and security. While throughout a semblance of scholarly objectivity can be traced, when it comes to explaining U.S. policy in the region, the objectives are merely quoted. Taken at face value, U.S. policy until recently consisted of four main points: formation of democratic political institutions; promotion of market economic reform; integration of the Central Asian states and Azerbaijan into the “international communities”; and arms control, “anti-terrorism,” and measures against drug trafficking (?). This time, eyebrows do not have to be raised for long, as the reader soon finds out that it is all good for business—or, at least, most of it. And in that direction, the United States has long encountered these states in the manner of an arrogant imperialist.
The first chapter contains a short history of the republics, mainly during Russian and Soviet rules, in which the author describes what is generally thought of as the oppression of the nationalities—nationalities with a virtually total lack of national consciousness and a religious doctrine that still allows for the burning of women. Perhaps Alaolmolki dreams of a khanate of Bukhara, for instance, entirely populated by mullahs and the amir's little male toy boys that would in turn be friendly with America. The British interventionists in the Russian civil war envisaged something similar, but in this day and age the U.S. State Department ought to be more careful. Alaolmolki calls the end of state capitalism in the Soviet Union “Russia's freedom,” although he repeatedly admits and agrees that since then, political rule in the Central Asian republics, as well as in Azerbaijan, has been more arbitrary, and the condition of their economies can only be described as devastated. He nevertheless attempts to play havoc with the sentiments of freedom-loving readers: “[t]he former Soviet republics suffered extraordinarily under Russian and Soviet rule. Forced russification in the late nineteenth century and the exploitation of the former Soviet republics' natural resources by Tsarist Russia for its own use only harmed the people in the former Soviet republics” (p. 22). History is not Alaolmolki's strong point.
In the chapter on economic conditions of Azerbaijan and the Central Asian states, where the author describes U.S. (and others') efforts to fully exploit these nations' natural resources, he comes up with his main criticism of U.S. government policy. Although a number of routes are available for oil and gas pipelines to go through, a route through Iran is more desirable because it is cheaper and more secure. That is what American business wants, and that is why it is at odds with the administration. This argument is pursued further in the book.
Another criticism of U.S. policy is (or, rather, was) its support for the CIA creatures Osama bin Laden and the Taliban in Afghanistan. Alaolmolki argues that a pipeline route through Afghanistan and Pakistan would also have been desirable had there not been so much political turmoil. When the book was being written, a stable Afghanistan must have seemed like a far-fetched imperial dream—but, of course, it is all virtually a reality now.
Throughout the book there appears to be something inherently bad about the republics' relations with Russia and something intrinsically good about the growing American influence in the region. In the last chapter, Alaolmolki prophesizes on the bleak future of dependence of these states, both economic and political, on the Russian Federation. On this point, political reality has proved him wrong. After the imperialist invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq (and especially the former) we have witnessed an increasing U.S. military presence in the region, and if economic domination has not come in full force yet, it will.
This is a book that by its nature goes out of date rather quickly. The next updated edition would benefit from more careful editing, as a number of sentences are incomprehensible, and there are paragraphs that are hard to understand. Some parts also ought to be rearranged to make comprehension of the story easier. The Tajik civil war could be explained more clearly and all in one place. Discussions of Russian and Chinese efforts to gain influence could be included in Chapter 9 (“Neighbouring Influences”), and in the same place the author ought to discuss Indian and Pakistani competition in Central Asia, too.