Till Dűppe’s The Making of the Economy is, to my knowledge, the only attempt to seriously apply Edmund Husserl’s interwar phenomenological thinking to economics and its history. The book is highly original, thought-provoking, and rich in its survey of the entire history of economics. Husserl’s complaint against modern science (1970) is that it ‘forgets’ our immediate, pre-given ‘life-world’ (Lebenswelt-vergessenheit), and creates an abstract, false world of objects and facts it investigates in an abstract (indeed, alienatedFootnote 1) way. ‘Scientification’ is an ‘objectification’; ‘nature’ is constructed; science is a history of accumulating facts (Tatsachengeschicte) whose justification is a hollow, scientific, realist progressivism. Husserl and phenomenology are Continental philosophy’s answer to logical positivism and the whole twentieth-century philosophy of science tradition derived from that starting point—which, it is worth noting, has also long been the way that the history of economic methodology has been seen, or at least until the disjuncture caused by the rise of the sociology of scientific knowledge and social constructivist thinking, as influenced by people such as Steven Shapin. Thus, one definite service Dűppe provides is to encourage us to take an unfamiliar and, in many respects, deeper philosophical look at how we understand the evolution of the history of economics.
His title gives us economics’ particular form of scientific objectification: the economy itself is something made. “The economy—one may quote me on thisFootnote 2—has never shown itself, even if the government were on holiday” (p. 119). In this, he shares with Margaret Schabas (Reference Schabas2006) the view that ‘scientification’ in economics is associated with a denaturalization of economic life. The lived ‘natural’ world, the Lebenswelt, is a matter of human concern prior to seventeenth-century British mercantilist economics, but after this time—here, Dűppe especially follows William Letwin (Reference Letwin1963)—the emergence of trade and the disturbing manifestation of private interest drove a new liberal political economy discourse, ultimately the science of wealth (J. S. Mill), whose crowning achievement was to successfully dispel, at least temporarily, a ‘culture of suspicion’ surrounding the new science over whether the world of the economy commonly worked to one’s disadvantage.
Indeed, suspicion, the shadow of the suppressed and forgotten Lebenswelt, the vague sense that economics misrepresents the world, is the principal theme in Dűppe’s argument. This is the meaning of the painting on the book’s cover—Ein Notar (1542) by Marinus van Reymerswaele—which shows a seemingly inconspicuous clerk in the center of the picture recording an unhappy transaction between a money lender and a poor debtor. The clerk’s persona is the one sought by the future economist, who seeks the virtue of ‘blind sight’ (Daston and Galison Reference Daston and Galison2007) associated with the anonymity of a scientist concerned only with how ‘objective’ forces operate in the ‘economy.’ Yet, suspicion persists, and so, for Dűppe, the evolving history of economics is built around constructing an increasingly abstract structure lying beyond human interests and removed from the world we experientially occupy. Here, then, it is Michel Foucault who matters for Dűppe, because Foucault sees the development of science as inseparable from the development of authority. Economics, then, does more than simply objectify; it governs and rules our perception of the Lebenswelt.
A few words about Dűppe’s periodization of the history of economics: the ‘first wave of scientification of economic writings,’ liberal political economy, lasts until the 1840s, when J. S. Mill and Karl Marx confront industrialization. The second wave, ‘high modernism,’ lasts from then until 1945. These two waves are described with much historical knowledge and insight, but it is the third wave, the ‘formalist revolution’ (with its seed in the socialist calculation debate), and the symbolic figure of Gerhard Debreu, that is of special interest for current debates over the nature of economics (also cf. Dűppe Reference Dűppe2012). What future might economics then expect, having reached a pinnacle of abstraction? Here, Dűppe’s verdict is not unremittingly pessimistic, but he also gives little reason for optimism. Might economics thus be at the end of its alienated ‘life-cycle’? I won’t tell you how the story ends (indeed, it cannot), but simply note that, for Dűppe, economics can only press the forgetting of the Lebenswelt, never eliminate it as its basis.
A couple of issues: first, one criticism might be made of Dűppe’s phenomenological argument. The central claim of the book is that economics has redirected and controlled our perception and thereby suppressed the Lebenswelt, the lived natural world of which we are part. But one could ask: why isn’t the objectified world our real Lebenswelt? And why shouldn’t our own Lebenswelt be different from that which we imagine occupied the pre-modern world? Second, why not include phenomenologist Maurice Merleau-Ponty in this account?
However, whatever one’s view is of Dűppe’s overall arguments, he is surely to be commended for his impressive knowledge of the history of economics, which exceeds that of not a few more senior scholars. And his writing a whole history also prompts us to ask: where are the ambitious histories of economics among the publications of historians of economics today? Indeed, who any longer debates the major interpretations of the history of economics in our contemporary small-scale culture of journal publication? Do historians today even recognize that historiographic form that once made an issue of how the history of economics is to be interpreted, such as occupied such great historians as Edwin Cannan, Erich Roll, Henry William Spiegel, Warren Samuels, and so many others of two generations past?
