Early in the Pro Milone, Cicero's defence of Titus Annius Milo on trial for the murder of Publius Clodius Pulcher,Footnote 1 the orator presents a list of exemplary figures from Roman history whose deeds offer parallels for Milo's alleged crime. Though these men murdered political enemies, they were nonetheless considered justified in their actions by their Roman peers.Footnote 2 In emphatic and memorable last place in this list is an example drawn not from Roman history but from Greek tragedy:
itaque hoc, iudices, non sine causa etiam fictis fabulis doctissimi homines memoriae prodiderunt, eum qui patris ulciscendi causa matrem necauisset uariatis hominum sententiis non solum diuina sed etiam sapientissimae deae sententia liberatum.Footnote 3
(Cic. Mil. 8)And so, members of the jury, it is not without reason that even in fictional tales the most learned men have passed down to tradition that the man who had killed his mother for the sake of avenging his father, even though mortal opinion was divided, was absolved of the crime not merely by a divine decision but by that of the wisest goddess.
Cicero here makes an obvious reference to Aeschylus' Oresteia. In this fifth-century Athenian trilogy, Orestes kills his mother Clytemnestra in vengeance for her slaughter of his father Agamemnon and, despite his open confession, he is ultimately acquitted of this crime in an Athenian courtroom presided over by Athena. Milo, too, Cicero insists, deserves a full pardon for his avowed crime.Footnote 4
Cicero introduces his allusion in such a way that the salient details likening Milo's case to Orestes'—just acquittal after confessed homicide—are transparent even for an audience that could not identify the Oresteia specifically. It is perhaps for this reason that I have not been able to find any modern scholarship that presses this reference for meaning beyond its immediate and obvious contextual relevance. I contend, however, that the choice of Orestes as an analogue for Milo allows the orator to exploit a rich series of parallels throughout the speech between the circumstances surrounding Milo's trial and the story told by Aeschylus in the Oresteia, parallels that support Cicero's rhetorical strategy for convincing his audience of Milo's guiltlessness. This early reference to Orestes, far from a mere throwaway mythological detail to gratify a well-read audience, allows Cicero to alter his audience's fundamental perception of Milo's crime by highlighting the similarities not only between the defendants, Milo and Orestes, but also between the victims, Clodius and Clytemnestra. By sustained comparison of the historical case and Aeschylus' mythological one, Cicero intimates to his reader that Milo's acquittal is the only reasonable outcome.
I say ‘reader’ because the Pro Milone we have is the version of the speech that was disseminated after the conclusion of the trial. Tasked with defending an essentially indefensible client,Footnote 5 Cicero had not been able to secure the acquittal of Milo, who was convicted and banished to Massilia in spite of his patron's efforts. The notional audience of the speech we have, therefore, is not jurors, but rather those reading the speech as it circulated ex post facto with knowledge of the outcome of the trial.Footnote 6 This reading audience included Milo himself, to whom Cicero sent the revised speech (D.C. 40.54), and probably, in the first instance, to Cicero's politically influential friends and acquaintances at Rome.Footnote 7 As I will show, Cicero could certainly have trusted such readers to know both Greek tragedy and its Roman adaptations well enough to appreciate fully the allusion he makes.
That the Pro Milone we have was read and not delivered strengthens the likelihood that its literary allusion influenced readers' interpretation of the speech. A reader could peruse parts of the speech more than once, rereading passages of interest as many times as he wanted to, and might even refer back to earlier sections. Even if Cicero's readers were not so diligent, at the very least, written rather than oral presentation would have allowed them to slow down or pause to reflect on elements of the speech when they wished rather than necessarily absorbing the speech at the pace of its delivery. Such an audience, presumably subject to fewer distractions than the jurors of the original courtroom, would have been especially receptive to literary references and more likely to pick up on them when they occurred, a fact of which Cicero must have been aware.Footnote 8
The written rather than performed nature of the Pro Milone also raises questions about Cicero's persuasive goals in the speech since its professed aim, the acquittal of Milo, was no longer possible. Through the circulation of the revised speech, Cicero may have been attempting to advocate for Milo's pardon and recall, influence the outcome of subsequent trials related to Milo's case, negotiate his own position in the fraught political climate of Rome in the late 50s BCE, supersede the unsuccessful original speech to rehabilitate his reputation as an advocate, or perhaps even get in a final venomous jab at Clodius to which Cicero's arch-enemy could not reply.Footnote 9 As interesting as such speculation is, however, my goal here will be confined to assessing the ways in which Cicero's appeal to Aeschylus' Oresteia contributes to the conclusion that Milo ought to have been acquitted in spite of what actually happened in the trial. Whatever other intentions Cicero may have had when he circulated the speech, these goals all embrace the exoneration of Milo.
In making an argument about a sustained tragic analogy in the Pro Milone, I do not intend to suggest that the dramatic elements of Cicero's speech constitute the only or even necessarily a primary rhetorical strategy. Rather, I suggest only that we cannot ignore the broader implications of Cicero's early reference to the Oresteia when assessing the ways in which the published Pro Milone attempts to persuade its reading audience that Milo should have been acquitted. Cicero's speech, in its content and, to some extent, in its style, repeatedly calls attention to the similarities between the substance of Milo's trial and the tragic story of Orestes and Clytemnestra. Drawing on the myth as it was presented in both Greek tragedy and its Roman Republican adaptations, Cicero manages his audience's perception of both Milo as defendant and Clodius as victim and so justifies the murder retrospectively.
1. Cicero and the theatre
Cicero's deep familiarity with both Greek and Roman theatre is well known and supports my arguments about a sustained analogy between the Oresteia and Milo's story. A bilingual, that is, Greek and Latin, education that included exposure to the classics of Greek literature was de rigueur for the upper classes of Republican Rome, including Cicero.Footnote 10 He was working and writing in a cultural context that used examples lifted from Greek epic and tragedy as a kind of intellectual shorthand in political and philosophical discussion.Footnote 11 Dozens of references to Greek tragedy in the Ciceronian corpus leave no doubt as to Cicero's familiarity with the plays of the three Attic masters: Aeschylus, Sophocles and Euripides.Footnote 12 Cicero studied these plays in the original Greek as a student, producing both faithful translations from the Greek and looser adaptations of the agones using rhetorical language appropriate to a Roman context.Footnote 13 While there is no evidence one way or the other as to whether Cicero ever produced a translation of any part of the Oresteia, the fact that he did translate large sections of Aeschylus' Prometheus Unbound for the Tusculan Disputations makes it likely that Aeschylus' much more famous chef d'oeuvre was also familiar to Cicero in the original Greek.Footnote 14
Of course Cicero was also deeply familiar with the Roman theatre of his own time both as circulated scripts and as live performance. While his correspondence attests to the fact that he regularly attended the theatre,Footnote 15 his philosophical and theoretical texts in particular are replete with quotations and examples drawn from Republican tragedies based on Greek models.Footnote 16 Cicero's own wide exposure to Republican theatre leads him to assume a similar familiarity among his readers. For example, in the Tusculan Disputations, Cicero expects his reader to be able to fill in missing lines from Ennius' Andromache without mentioning the author or title: scitis quae sequantur (‘you know what follows', Tusc. 3.44).Footnote 17
One indication of Cicero's wide acquaintance with the theatre and his conviction that his audience shared this familiarity is his use of theatrical tropes in his oratory. Most notably, Cicero's rhetorical use of comic themes has often been observed, particularly in the Pro Caelio, where the features and disposition of comic stock figures are ascribed to the major players in the trial for the purpose of characterisation.Footnote 18 Scholars have been more hesitant to identify tragic tropes in Cicero's oratory, possibly because the fragmentary state of Republican tragedy makes it more difficult to identify what constitutes a ‘typical’ tragedy or tragic figure.Footnote 19 In the case of Cicero's use of the Oresteia, however, the fact that the allusion Cicero employs can be securely traced back to an original and complete Aeschylean text obviates the need to identify standard tropes and character types in Republican tragedy.
In addition, there is ample evidence that Cicero believed that oratory could be improved not only by the use of theatrical content, but also by the use of theatrical style. While it is true that, in some instances, Cicero shares the widespread Roman disdain for the low social status of the actor, his oratorical theory insists repeatedly that good orators and good actors make use of the same performative and rhetorical techniques to affect and persuade their audiences.Footnote 20 In sum, there is strong evidence to suggest that Cicero was both capable of and inclined to incorporate the tragic content and theatrical style that I have identified in the Pro Milone.
2. Cicero's readers and the theatre
My argument relies not only on Cicero's theatrical expertise but also on that of the notional reading audience of the published Pro Milone. Such Roman readers would have been widely exposed to the theatre. In the approximately two centuries between the introduction of Roman theatre and the publication of the Pro Milone, the number of days in the calendar for performance had increased significantly and scripts began to circulate broadly.Footnote 21 These Roman plays were, in some sense, imported from Greece and, even if they were not translated word-for-word, they at least followed closely the myths, plots, characters and often even dramatic conventions that had been established by the poets of fifth-century Athens.Footnote 22 One piece of evidence that such Greek precedents were well known in Rome is that Plautus expects at least some portion of his theatre audience for the Rudens to find a reference to Euripides' Alcmene meaningful.Footnote 23 More specific to Cicero's social circle, a growing number of aristocrats in the late Republic were translating, adapting and even composing tragedies of their own based on Greek models, including, in Cicero's social circle, his own brother Quintus.Footnote 24 There is every reason to believe that Cicero would have expected those to whom he entrusted the revised Pro Milone, including Milo himself, to be well acquainted with Greek tragedy.
It is also important to understand that readers of Cicero's Pro Milone, beyond mere exposure to the shared theatre tradition of Greece and Rome, lived in a society in which public life and theatrical spectacle were inextricably linked. Religion, politics, warfare and law all found theatrical expression in elaborate funerals, electoral campaigning, triumphal processions and, indeed, in histrionic courtroom speeches.Footnote 25 The relationship between theatre and public life was bi-directional, in that Romans not only incorporated elements of theatre into their public activities, but also regularly saw the public and political world reflected in dramatic productions, connecting tragic events and characters with the events and characters of contemporary Rome.Footnote 26 This is a phenomenon of which Cicero was certainly well aware; indeed, much of our evidence for it relies on Cicero's testimony.Footnote 27 If we take Cicero as our guide, it seems that the Roman citizens of the Late Republic were not merely capable of seeing the political in theatrical productions but, in fact, were disposed to do so as a matter of course.
In Republican Rome, a symbiotic relationship existed between the non-fictional world of politics and the fictional world of the stage; these spheres were often entangled in the realm of public discourse and were mutually influential.Footnote 28 The Ciceronian corpus reflects an awareness of the ability of these analogous performative spheres to inform and enrich each other and this principle, I argue, underlies the reference to Aeschylus at the beginning of the Pro Milone. Even if some of Cicero's apparent confidence in the shrewd perceptiveness of the Roman people as a whole is rhetorical bluster, it seems quite reasonable to conclude that some of Cicero's more extravagant claims apply, if not to all Romans, at least to the much smaller circle of politically savvy and well-educated friends to whom he entrusted the revised text of the Pro Milone.
3. The dramatic style of the Pro Milone
While all oratory is to some extent theatrical because it is a performed genre, the Pro Milone seems to be composed with particular emphasis on dramatic qualities that support Cicero's early reference to the Oresteia. While some of these features of the speech could perhaps be explained away as mere overlap between the kinds of rhetorical effects that make both oratory and drama animated, engaging and striking, the cumulative effect of such features in the Pro Milone plays an important role in supporting Cicero's insistence that his readers must view the story of Milo and Clodius through the lens of that of Orestes and Clytemnestra.Footnote 29
Cicero's early focus on vision in the Pro Milone sets up Milo's trial as a spectacle in its own right and prepares his readership for the theatrical reference that follows. Consider, for example, just the opening sections of Cicero's oration:
…tamen haec noui iudici noua forma terret oculos qui, quocumque inciderunt, ueterem consuetudinem fori et pristinum morem iudiciorum requirunt…non illa praesidia quae pro templis omnibus cernitis…nec eorum quisquam, quos undique intuentis, unde aliqua fori pars aspici potest, et huius exitum iudici exspectantis uidetis…
(Mil. 1-3, excerpts)…nevertheless, the new form of this new trial frightens my eyes, which, wherever they fall, seek out the conventions of the forum and the ancient custom of trials…these troops whom you see in front of all the temples…not one of those whom you see watching from every side, from where any part of the forum can be seen, and whom you see looking forward to the outcome of this trial…
This brief segment contains more visual cues than is typical in the openings of other Ciceronian speeches.Footnote 30 This emphasis on vision and spectacle is maintained throughout the speech by Cicero's use of visual metaphors, asking the jurors to allow the light of truth to shine forth (Mil. 6, 61), for example, and by abundant use of verbs formed on the stem spect- (Mil. 3, 11, 15, 16, 24, 49, 52, 53, 70, 74, 85, 90, 95, 101, 103). As Dupont suggests, ‘Savoir convaincre à Rome, c'est savoir faire voir’,Footnote 31 and Cicero certainly seems to espouse this principle. Reinforcing these visual cues are imperatives that demand the reader's attention: attendite (Mil. 23, 79) and adeste (Mil. 4, 77). These imperatives, characteristically used to direct the attention of the theatre audiences of Republican comedy, accentuate Cicero's dramatic style in this speech.Footnote 32 These attention-drawing features, introduced early in the Pro Milone and sustained throughout, support the Aeschylean reference in section 8 by invoking the atmosphere and sense of spectacle found in the theatre.
Such theatrical framing underpins dramatic vignettes that unfold within the larger structure of the speech. In great visual detail and with a keen eye for characterisation and tableau-painting, Cicero describes, for example, Clodius hiding under a staircase in fear of Milo (Mil. 40), and Milo dramatically tearing off his toga in a Senate meeting to prove that he is not carrying a concealed weapon (Mil. 66). The most vividly described scene in the speech, however, referenced on multiple occasions and with the strongest thematic links to Aeschylus, is Cicero's account of the meeting between Clodius and Milo on the Via Appia on the night Clodius was killed. The most extensive and detailed description of this night occurs, unsurprisingly, in the narratio (Mil. 28-29). Cicero here purports to offer his readers an unobstructed view of Clodius' ambush.
The narratio is replete with detailed imagery used to characterise both Milo and Clodius and heighten the sense of dramatic spectacle.Footnote 33 Cicero offers a description of Milo and Clodius before the attack, which tendentiously portrays Milo as the harmless traveller and Clodius as the scheming highwayman. In her analysis of this scene, Berger notes that style artfully reinforces content. Clodius' unencumbered mobility is emphasised through asyndetic, anaphoric statements. However, while each aspect of Milo's travelling provisions corresponds to one of Clodius', the congestion of adjectives and adverbial phrases in the description of Milo on the road emphasises the slow, encumbered train of followers accompanying him.Footnote 34 This vivid description, as Cicero later tells his reader, is intended to reinforce Milo's innocence and Clodius' guilt, specifically because it allows the audience to visualise the action so clearly:
si haec non gesta audiretis, sed picta uideretis, tamen appareret uter esset insidiator, uter nihil mali cogitaret, cum alter ueheretur in raeda paenulatus, una sederet uxor.
(Mil. 54)If you were not listening to the things that happened, but you could see them painted for you, then it would still be clear which of them was the plotter and which had no thought of evil, since one of them was carried in a wagon and wrapped in a travelling cloak with his wife sitting beside him.
In addition, the intrusion of the present tense in Cicero's otherwise past tense narratio, implying that the author is visualising the scene in his own mind's eye as he describes it, encourages his reader to do the same, reinforcing the impression of a scene played out in front of an audience.Footnote 35
One detail of this visual description is especially emphasised by Cicero and deserves further scrutiny. Cicero goes to unusual lengths to call attention to Milo's travelling cloak, his paenula. In the narratio he takes the time to mention that Milo, before setting out, calceos et uestimenta mutauit (‘changed his clothes and shoes', Mil. 28), much as an actor dons a costume before arriving onstage. He also specifies twice in the following description that Milo is wearing a paenula (he is paenulatus, Mil. 28, and jumps from the wagon reiecta paenula, ‘with his cloak thrown back’, Mil. 29). In the recapitulation of this scene, Cicero again emphasises Milo's cloak, that he is paenulatus and cum paenula inretitus (‘wearing a travelling cloak’ and ‘entangled by a travelling cloak’, Mil. 54). However much this cloak would have impeded Milo in the event of an ambush, it is no more cumbersome than a large train of performing slaves or the presence of Milo's wife, aspects of Milo's description that are emphasised much less than the cloak. The care that Cicero takes each time he recounts this scene to remind his reader that Milo was paenulatus, therefore, appears to be motivated by more than a desire to strengthen his argument from eikos.Footnote 36 Instead, I suggest that Cicero may be playing with the vocabulary of theatrical genre in order to heighten the theatricality of his vivid description of the ambush on the Via Appia and so reinforce his imperative to the reader to consider the encounter between Milo and Clodius as a scene in a tragedy.
By the late Republic the generic terms for different kinds of theatre that had originated in the third century were widely used.Footnote 37 These were the fabula palliata (comedy in Greek dress), fabula togata (comedy in Roman dress), fabula crepidata (mythical tragedy in the Greek style), and fabula praetexta (plays dramatising events from Rome's legendary-historical past). In light of the fact that all of these genres were named for articles of clothing, Cicero's emphasis on Milo's paenula—a piece of costumery that had not yet been claimed explicitly by the Republican theatre—may suggest, with a wink to the reader, that the events on the Via Appia might be understood as a new kind of theatre introduced by Cicero to his public. Asking his reader to view the events of history (usually presented in a praetexta) through the lens of a mythological comparison (usually presented in a crepidata), Cicero implicitly creates a new theatrical genre for the ‘drama’ he presents in this speech: the fabula paenulata. The two occurrences of paenulatus in the Pro Milone represent the first attested use of this adjective, which otherwise is used only a handful of times by later authors (TLL 10.1.70.74-10.1.71.12). It is at least possible, then, that Cicero coined an adjectival form of paenula to suit his specific argumentative goals in a speech in which his carefully constructed account blurs the lines between mythological and historical storytelling.
Even small details in the speech reflect Cicero's blending of genres. Take, for example, the emphasis that Cicero places on the location of the ambush, the Via Appia, which is mentioned no fewer than six times in the speech (Mil. 14, 15, 18, 37, 57 and 91). Although it has little obvious bearing on Milo's actions, Cicero goes to great lengths to inform his readers that Clodius' illustrious ancestor, Appius Claudius Caecus, built the roadway almost as if, Cicero remarks, he intended to provide a place for his descendants to commit their brigandry (Mil. 17). In fact, Cicero continues, Clodius has already fulfilled that expectation, murdering M. Papirius on the Via Appia (Mil. 18), while his vicious attack against Milo is a continuation of the pattern. The noble Appius Caecus' unwitting instigation of his descendant's murderous actions obviously offers a much tamer example of family causality than the unstoppable vengeance that drives the Pelopidae.Footnote 38 However, in the context of a speech that makes explicit reference to the House of Atreus, Cicero's emphasis on family continuity might nonetheless have prompted some readers to discern a suggestion that Clodius was at the beginning of a cycle of crime that had the potential, had Milo not stopped it, to rival the crimes of Atreus and his kin.Footnote 39 In fact, Cicero signals the correspondence between history and myth explicitly: nunc eiusdem Appiae nomen quantas tragoedias excitat! (‘now what tragedies that same name Appia evokes!’, Mil. 18). Cicero's ‘fabula paenulata’ encourages the reader to interpret Clodius' historical crimes through the lens of mythological inevitability. Cicero's dramatic blend of myth and history implies that Milo, like Orestes, was not merely justified in killing the person he killed but somehow predestined to do so.
Later sections of the Pro Milone, like the narratio, also convey Milo's story in a way that evokes the stage, though they achieve their character not through vivid description, as we find in the sections describing the events on the Via Appia, but rather through prosopopoeia and tragic lament.Footnote 40 In the second half of the speech, Cicero takes on the role of Milo himself and is thereby able to allow his defendant to appeal to the audience directly even though the actual Milo would have been silent during the delivery of the speech and, more importantly, living in exile in Massilia by the time Cicero's readers had access to a published copy. Cicero, by adopting the other man's persona, is able to play the part of Milo just like an actor on the stage. As Milo, Cicero laments Milo's misfortunes (Mil. 69), condemns a long list of Clodius' crimes (Mil. 72-75), celebrates Milo's role as saviour of Rome (Mil. 77), imagines his imminent unjust exile (Mil. 93-94), contemplates the future glory of his name (Mil. 98) and magnanimously accepts his undeserved banishment (Mil. 104). These instances of prosopopoeia heighten the impact of Milo's words, making them stand out as markedly theatrical and performed in a text whose performed quality readers might otherwise begin to forget. The same effect is achieved in section 99 where Cicero stages a dialogue between Milo and himself: haec tu mecum saepe his absentibus, sed isdem audientibus haec ego tecum, Milo (‘these were often your words to me when these jurors were not here, but here are mine for you, Milo, as the same men listen’, Mil. 99). Rather than simply speaking as Milo's advocate, Cicero constructs a performance within a performance, intensifying the impact of his written words by the unusual rhetorical trick of assuming the role of ‘Cicero’.Footnote 41
The words that Cicero speaks as Milo make abundant use of the figures of speech common to Republican tragedy, insofar as these can be reconstructed on the basis of the existing fragments, particularly from Ennius onward. These include alliteration and assonance, homoeoteleuton, polyptoton, repetition, parallelism, anaphora, antithesis, metaphor and, more generally, high emotional tone complemented by strong, concrete imagery.Footnote 42 Unsurprisingly these are the same rhetorical techniques commonly found in oratory at the moments of greatest excitement, tension and emotion. Examples of these devices can be found throughout the moments of prosopopoeia in the latter half of the Pro Milone. Take, for example, the first time that ‘Milo’ speaks in the speech:
uides quam sit uaria uitae commutabilisque ratio, quam uaga uolubilisque fortuna, quantae infidelitates in amicitiis, quam ad tempus aptae simulationes, quantae in periculis fugae proximorum, quantae timiditates. erit, erit illud profecto tempus…cum…et amicissimi beneuolentiam et grauissimi hominis fidem et unius post homines natos fortissimi uiri magnitudinem animi desideres.
(Mil. 69)You see how changeable and unstable is the course of life, how wandering and wavering is fortune, how many acts of betrayal there are in friendships and how suited are these pretences for our time, how many desertions there are of those closest to us in times of danger, and how many acts of cowardice. There will soon be a time, there will…when…you may long for the kindness of the greatest friend, the loyalty of the sincerest man, and the magnanimity of the bravest man unique among men.
Milo's speech begins with much alliteration of ‘u’ sounds. This is followed by a triple anaphora of the word quantae, a tricolon in decrescendo to sharpen the impact of the last item in the list, timiditates. Immediately next comes the repetition of erit, an emotional hiccough in the delivery of this line. Finally, the passage ends with homoeoteleuton of the masculine genitive singular, strengthened by the fact that all three adjectives are superlatives.
The same literary and sound effects are also found in Cicero's own lament for Milo, delivered in high tragic style in the final sections of the speech (Mil. 92-105). Here, too, Cicero makes use of alliterationFootnote 43 and homoeoteleutonFootnote 44 as he raises the emotional temperature in the peroratio. He also uses both exclamationFootnote 45 and the rhetorical questionFootnote 46 to suggest his own heightened emotion. While these are all features that can be found in both rhetoric and theatre, and while none of these features is strictly necessary for Cicero's analogy between Milo and Orestes to work, the concentrated presence of these histrionic elements does help to reinforce and sustain the early reference to Aeschylus' Oresteia by encouraging the reader the see Milo's story as a kind of tragedy.
4. The Pro Milone and the Oresteia
All of these dramatic qualities sustain Cicero's early reference to the Oresteia throughout the speech, supporting my claim that the orator is not offering a casual literary ornament but rather a programmatic introduction of a set of themes and especially characters that will bolster his defence of Milo. This rhetorical strategy, as I have said, is by no means the only one present in the speech. However, I will show that the rhetorical implications of Cicero's Aeschylean reference are much more extensive than has been noticed before, suggesting that this should be taken into account when scholars assess the rhetorical virtues of the Pro Milone.
Of course, the first and most obvious parallel established by the reference to Aeschylus is that between Milo and Orestes. Even before Cicero refers to the Oresteia, he takes care to establish that Milo's trial is something new and precedent-setting. In his first sentence, he introduces his speech as part of a noui iudici noua forma (‘a new shape of a new kind of trial’, Mil. 1), and soon thereafter emphasises the importance of the outcome of Milo's trial not just for Milo but for Rome and all its citizens, now and in the future (Mil. 3). While some of this patriotism is the familiar ubiquitous Ciceronian bluster, and while Milo was indeed prosecuted in a novel way under the new lex Pompeia de ui,Footnote 47 Cicero's emphasis on the idea of a new kind of trial with lasting civic consequences also specifically evokes the courtroom described in the third play of Aeschylus' trilogy, the Eumenides, when Athena gives instructions to the jury before their vote:
People of Attica, you who are judging the first trial for spilt blood, hear now my decree. This council of judges will always belong to the people of Aegeus in the future.
Because Cicero insists on the importance of Milo's trial by reference to the circumstances that surround Orestes', his readers are primed to receive the reference to the Oresteia before it occurs and this, perhaps, would have strengthened the force of the allusion.
Even without this setup, however, those with even a glancing familiarity with the Oresteia, particularly its final play, would immediately note a few obvious parallels when Cicero introduced his allusion. Both Milo and Orestes, for example, confess freely and openly to the crimes for which they are on trial. On Milo's behalf, Cicero emphasises again and again that Milo, so far from denying that he slew Clodius, candidly accepts responsibility for the crime (Mil. 7, 15, 23, 29, 30, 57, 81). On trial at Athens, Orestes, too, humbly and without guile confesses to Athena, ἔκτεινα τὴν τεκοῦσαν, οὐκ ἀρνήσομαι (‘I killed my mother, I will not deny it’, Eu. 463). So many moments of bald confession in the Pro Milone might seem out of place in a defence speech but for the fact that Cicero makes this position a key part of his rhetorical stance. Like Orestes, Milo can openly confess to the murder because it was fully justified. Orestes' exoneration in Aeschylus supports Cicero's policy of (ostensible) honesty and implies that the outcome of Milo's trial ought to be the same.
Another more subtle comparison between Milo and Orestes concerns the fact that both men are presented as having committed murder with divine sanction. In the case of Orestes, the divine instruction is very explicit. Apollo, in the opening scenes of the Eumenides, says to Orestes, καὶ γὰρ κτανεῖν σ’ ἔπεισα μητρῷον δέμας (‘I persuaded you to slay your mother’, Eu. 84) and confirms this not only by later repeating his assertion to the Furies (Eu. 203) but also by acting as Orestes' defence counsel in the trial at Athens. Milo, of course, can claim nothing so specific as oracular instruction let alone a divine advocate. However, Cicero is careful to suggest that Milo's part in the death of Clodius was aligned with the will of the gods, even that Milo was acting as an instrument of the gods.Footnote 49 Just as Orestes undertook to slay his mother because of an oracle from Apollo, Milo saved the Republic because the gods cast a maddened Clodius in his path with the intent that Milo should put a stop to Clodius' impieties (Mil. 89). It is perhaps in order to suggest some divine involvement in the murder of Clodius that Cicero emphasises repeatedly that Milo was travelling the Via Appia on that night because he was en route to install a priest at Lanuvium (Mil. 27, 45-46). Milo's pious activity, by implication, aligns his deeds against Clodius with the will of the gods. Of course, this alone is not enough to suggest a comparison with Orestes; however, in the context of the rest of the speech with its numerous and more overt comparisons, the divinely inspired aspect of Milo's actions serves to reinforce the larger picture.
Beyond the obvious parallels between these men, there is good reason to believe that Cicero felt confident that his readers would know the details of the Orestes myth necessary to understand the full implications of the reference. Orestes seems to have been a favourite example of Cicero's, used to illustrate many different concepts: madness, especially guilt-inspired madness (Pis. 46-47, Tusc. 3.11), justifiable homicide (Inv. 1.18-19, [Cic.] Rh. Her. 1.17, 25-26), the wickedness of parricide (S. Rosc. 66-67) and friendship, focusing on Orestes' relationship with Pylades (Fin. 1.65, 2.79, 5.63; Amic. 24). In texts written for courtroom audiences as well as texts distributed to smaller private audiences, including the published Pro Milone, Cicero often refers to Orestes without any compunction to explain the context or the details of his story. In De Inuentione Cicero is explicit about this, introducing Orestes as peruulgato (‘very well-known’, 1.18) and so in need of no introduction.
Cicero's apparent confidence in his readers' familiarity with the details of the Orestes myth seems, on balance, to be justified. Of course, the most obvious and most likely place that such readers would have encountered Orestes was in the theatre and we will return to the question of Republican drama below. However, complementing the world of theatre was the well-known mytho-religious tradition at Rome that had Orestes travel to Rome via Magna Graecia after his escape from Tauris with Iphigenia.Footnote 50 Orestes is firmly linked with the cult site of Diana at Aricia, very close to Rome, and was assimilated as the founder of the rites of the rex nemorensis in the sacred grove at Nemi.Footnote 51 His bones and possibly ashes, once located in this sanctuary, were, according to tradition, later moved from the temple of Diana and buried outside the temple of Saturn in the city of Rome itself, right beside the forum in which Cicero defended Milo.Footnote 52 While it is unlikely that the bones had been moved as early as 52 BCE—Green posits a date of 31 BCEFootnote 53—their location in the nearby sanctuary at Aricia with its close ties to Rome would certainly have bolstered the prominence of the figure of Orestes at Rome, supporting Cicero's case.
Indeed, so popular and well-known was Orestes that many scholars believe he was embraced as a mythical analogue for Octavian and the vengeance he took on the assassins of his adopted father, Caesar. Some interpret this as a deliberate strategy of self-promotion on Octavian's part, while others see it as a mythical paradigm applied to Octavian by enemies wishing to highlight his impiety.Footnote 54 For my purposes, the implications of the comparison are less important than the confirmation this anecdotal evidence provides that, a mere two or three decades after Milo's trial, the Romans appear to have been entirely comfortable assimilating a public figure to the mythical persona of Orestes. This was, perhaps, an extension of the practice of Roman aristocrats of the late Republic, presumably including those to whom Cicero would have given the published Pro Milone, of tracing their ancestry back to Greek gods and heroes like Orestes.Footnote 55 There is every reason to believe that Cicero's reading audience would have been quite comfortable with Cicero's invitation to view Milo's situation in light of the myth of Orestes.
Cicero's reference to the Oresteia has been widely recognised as establishing a parallel between Milo and Orestes. However, I would now like to explore a possibility that, to my knowledge, has not yet been recognised, namely that the logical extension of Cicero's comparison of Milo and Orestes is the corresponding comparison of Clodius and Clytemnestra. As with Orestes, Cicero does not name Clytemnestra explicitly; however, the figure of Clytemnestra is clearly evoked in Cicero's reference to Aeschylus.Footnote 56 This early allusion to Clytemnestra allows Cicero to exploit thematic similarities between Orestes' victim and Milo's arch-enemy throughout the Pro Milone in order to strengthen his arguments justifying Milo's actions. Three characteristics of Clytemnestra associated particularly with her presentation in the Oresteia are emphasised in Cicero's descriptions of Clodius. By drawing attention to the fact that both Clodius and Clytemnestra exhibit bestial qualities, both transgress gender norms and both threaten the living as reanimated ghosts, Cicero invites his audience to arrive at the same conclusion about Milo's murder of Clodius as Athena does in the matter of Orestes' murder of Clytemnestra.
In his famous trilogy, Aeschylus makes Clytemnestra's animal qualities a prominent feature of her characterisation. His vocabulary for her includes μισητῆς κύνος (‘hateful bitch’, A. 1228), ἀμφίσβαιναν ἢ Σκύλλαν (‘two-headed snake or Scylla’, A. 1233), and λέαινα συγκοιμωμένη / λύκῳ (‘lioness who sleeps with a wolf’, A. 1258f.), a clear reference to her illicit affair with Aegisthus. Agamemnon is described as dying ἐν πλεκταῖσι καὶ σπειράμασιν / δεινῆς ἐχίδνης (‘in the twisted coils of a terrible viper’, Ch. 248f.), while Electra asserts that she and Orestes have inherited from their mother a mind like a λύκος…ὠμόφρων ἄσαντος (‘a savage and ungentle wolf’, Ch. 421). The Agamemnon and Choephori in particular also play with the verb λάσκω, with its secondary meaning of ‘howling’,Footnote 57 to reinforce Clytemnestra's bestial nature (A. 614, 1427, Ch. 35, 39).
With this Aeschylean model in the background, what might otherwise appear to be offhand invective in fact strengthens the persuasive power of the tragic comparison at work throughout the Pro Milone. Cicero three times refers to Clodius as a belua (‘beast’, Mil. 32, 40, 85)Footnote 58 and Clark comments that Cicero may be suggesting animalistic savagery by his choice of the verb pauit to depict Clodius' insatiable rage.Footnote 59 In addition to reinforcing the larger suggestion that the trial over Clodius' death ought to yield the same result as the trial over Clytemnestra's death, namely the acquittal of the accused, Cicero's description of Clodius as an animal downplays Milo's transgression in committing murder. Like Orestes' victim, Milo's is in some sense subhuman and guilty of animalistic violence, rendering the crime less serious.
The suggestion that Clodius' murder ought to be viewed in light of the mythical murder of Clytemnestra also raises the issue of gender. This is not merely because a male victim is assimilated to a female one, though this is certainly part of the effect that Cicero's comparison achieves. Cicero capitalises on this aspect of his comparison of Clodius to Clytemnestra when he attributes Clodius' failure to kill Milo to a lack of manliness: cur igitur uictus est?…quia, quamquam paratus in imparatos Clodius, ipse Clodius tamen mulier inciderat in uiros (‘Why was he overcome?…because, although Clodius, prepared, attacked those who were unprepared, nonetheless that very Clodius, a woman, attacked men’, Mil. 55).Footnote 60 Clodius, Cicero implies, shares Clytemnestra's womanly physical weakness.
The Aeschylean parallel also implies more specifically, however, that Clodius, like Clytemnestra, habitually acts outside of the normal and accepted parameters of his gender. Aeschylus' Clytemnestra is a woman who famously bends gender norms. In the opening scenes of the Agamemnon, for example, the watchman describes Clytemnestra's ἀνδρόβουλον…κέαρ (‘heart that plans like a man’, A. 11). Clytemnestra is also known for taking on the masculine and dominant role in her affair with Aegisthus; she and her paramour are described in the Choephori with the words δυοῖν γυναικοῖν (‘a pair of women’, Ch. 304) with the clear implication that Clytemnestra, as it were, wears the pants in their relationship. While Clytemnestra does exhibit the cunning and deceit characteristic of many female figures from mythology, and tragedy specifically, when faced with imminent death at Orestes' hands she does not react like a typical tragic heroine by lamenting or pleading but instead demands δοίη τις ἀνδροκμῆτα πέλεκυν ὡς τάχος (‘Quick, somebody give me a man-slaying axe’, Ch. 889).
By comparing Clodius to Clytemnestra, Cicero attributes the transgressive character of this well-known tragic protagonist to Milo's enemy. Cicero makes use of the villainous gender-bending example of this famous tragic figure to discredit Clodius and diminish the sense of outrage at his murder. Clodius was, of course, particularly vulnerable to attacks on his masculinity because of his own personal history, having narrowly escaped conviction for infiltrating the rites of the Bona Dea disguised as a woman in 62 BCE.Footnote 61 This infamous scandal is alluded to three times (Mil. 72, 86, 87) amongst other more oblique hints at Clodius' effeminacy and lack of sexual propriety.Footnote 62 The early comparison of Clodius to Clytemnestra sets Cicero up to assimilate him to this transgressive woman throughout the speech and thus suggest that Milo's crime can be deemed as pardonable as Athena deems Orestes' to be.
A final aspect of the sustained comparison between Clodius and Clytemnestra relies on the more general emphasis on the visual in Cicero's speech to liken the hypothetical threat of Clodius' return from the dead to Clytemnestra's own ghostly appearance in the opening scene of the Eumenides, in which she spurs on the Furies to pursue Orestes (Eu. 94-139). This frightening Aeschylean depiction of a vengeful Clytemnestra returned from the dead lends tragic weight to similar scenes describing Clodius in the Pro Milone. In section 79, for example, Cicero says to his audience:
fingite animis—liberae sunt enim nostrae cogitationes et quae uolunt sic intuentur ut ea cernimus quae uidemus—fingite igitur cogitatione imaginem huius condicionis meae, si possimus efficere ut Milonem absoluatis, sed ita si P. Clodius reuixerit—quid uoltu extimuistis? quonam modo ille uos uiuus adficeret quos mortuus inani cogitatione percussit?
(Mil. 79)Imagine—for our thoughts are free, and they see what they wish to just as we perceive what we see [with our eyes]—imagine, then, a picture of this scenario of mine, namely if I could see to it that you would acquit Milo, but on the condition that P. Clodius should live again. Why are your expressions alarmed? How might the living man affect you, when the dead man has struck you with a mere thought?
Cicero similarly tries to frighten his audience with the prospect of Clodius' ghostly return in section 91. The terrifying thought of the reanimated Clodius corresponds to the fearsome ghost of Clytemnestra.Footnote 63 Clodius' spectral presence in the courtroom, brought on by Cicero's evocative words, recalls the frisson of horror generated by the appearance of Clytemnestra in the final play of the Oresteia. Just as the Athenian court could not ultimately side with such a monster (in fact she is banished from the stage by Apollo never to return to the play), surely the Roman court, Cicero suggests, must rule against Clodius as well.
In all of these ways, then, Cicero subtly but consistently maintains a close correspondence between the characteristics of Aeschylus' Clytemnestra and those he attributes to Clodius throughout the Pro Milone. This analogy exists alongside the more overt comparison between Milo and Orestes, two murderers who openly confess to their crimes, having acted as instruments of divine will against truly wicked enemies. Moreover, these analogies occur in a speech which refers to a specific piece of theatre in its opening lines and contains both formal and thematic features of drama more generally throughout. Taken together, all of these aspects of the Pro Milone urge Cicero's readers to conclude that, just as Athena acquitted Orestes of all charges, Milo's crime ought to have been pardoned as well.
The parallels between the Oresteia and Milo's murder of Clodius are, of course, not perfect. While no kin relationship exists between Milo and Clodius, the animus between Orestes and his mother is very much the culmination of generations of internecine strife. Also, while a key part of Cicero's defence strategy involves convincing the jurors that Clodius set a trap for the unsuspecting Milo, Aeschylus' trilogy displays an Orestes who plots to gain access to the unsuspecting Clytemnestra through deceit. In the Pro Milone, Cicero goes to great lengths to convince his audience that Milo had no reason to kill Clodius and yet Orestes confesses openly that his crime was committed intentionally in vengeance for the death of Agamemnon. Finally, Aeschylus' tale of family revenge lacks the strong sense of patriotism and nationalism with which Cicero infuses Milo's actions. Orestes' crime is a crime of passion directed inward on a self-destructive family unable to resolve its private problems until they are brought before an impartial jury of Athenian strangers. Milo's actions, by contrast, are shown by Cicero to have consequences far beyond the personal relationship between Clodius and Milo.
In spite of these discrepancies, it is clear that Cicero felt that the allusion as he presented it worked sufficiently well for his purposes. The analogy between the key trial scene from the Eumenides and Milo's own trial—each implicating a confessed murderer fully deserving of pardon—is transparent, even for the reader, whose existence is doubtful, not otherwise familiar with the myth of Orestes. But, of course, there is every reason to believe that Cicero expected his readers to be familiar with the myth. The question that remains to be addressed is to what extent Cicero believed his readers familiar with the fine details of the text of the Oresteia that I have just cited. While surely some in Cicero's intellectual circle were as conversant in Greek tragedy as Cicero himself, this is not the only way in which Cicero's readers might have become aware of the smaller points of plot and characterisation to which the Pro Milone alludes. The evidence for Republican adaptations of the Oresteia supports the case that Cicero's readers would have encountered aspects of Aeschylus' trilogy performed in Latin. Exposure to these plays, as much as to Aescyhlus', would have primed Cicero's readers to pick up on the literary allusions woven into the arguments of the Pro Milone.
5. Orestes and Clytemnestra in Roman Republican tragedy
Stories about the Pelopidae were hugely successful on the Roman tragic stage and it is very likely that the first readers of the Pro Milone were familiar with the myth of Orestes from the theatre even in the unlikely event that they had not encountered it elsewhere.Footnote 64 Few new tragedies were being produced by the time of Milo's trial in 52 BCE but revivals of older Republican plays were commonplace,Footnote 65 and the fragments of the Republican tragedies that survive offer a glimpse of the tradition in which Cicero was working. On the assumption that Cicero had no single play in mind when composing the Pro Milone but rather was working on the basis of a sense of his readers' cumulative familiarity with the myths of the House of Atreus as received from Aeschylus in the Republican theatre, these plays confirm, in broad strokes, that Cicero could be confident that his readers would have encountered both the story and the classic Aeschylean characterisation of Orestes and Clytemnestra.
The oldest surviving fragments that may be relevant to Cicero's project in the Pro Milone come from the Aegisthus of Livius Andronicus.Footnote 66 This play appears to describe the events of Aeschylus' Agamemnon, the first play in the Oresteia, including Agamemnon's return from Troy with Cassandra (frr. I-VI) and his murder at the hands of Aegisthus and Clytemnestra (frr. VII-VIII).Footnote 67 Such a play would presumably have addressed the characterisation of Clytemnestra so valuable to Cicero in vilifying Clodius. None of the extant fragments, however, suggests that the play dealt with Orestes or his exoneration at Athens.
Another Latin adaptation of the Oresteia story that Cicero and his readers probably knew in common is the Eumenides of Ennius.Footnote 68 On the basis of the surviving fragments of this play, it is at least possible that it reworked Aeschylus' Eumenides.Footnote 69 The play certainly showed Orestes' trial and acquittal on the Areopagus—the scene most relevant to Milo's defence—probably in the presence of both Athena, as judge, and Apollo, as advocate (frr. I-IV). Whether or not the play included an appearance of Clytemnestra as a ghost or characterised her in any of the ways I have identified in Aeschylus' Oresteia is uncertain. However, Zimmermann's discussion of these Ennian fragments in the context of the larger Republican reception of the story told in Aeschylus' Eumenides (including both Virgil and Cicero) offers a helpful perspective. For Zimmermann, Ennius' version of the story of Orestes' acquittal for the murder of Clytemnestra celebrates Orestes as a champion of patria potestas and pietas in his chastisement of a woman who failed to model the uirtus and pudicitia appropriate to a Roman matrona.Footnote 70 If this was indeed how Ennius' Eumenides was received in Rome, then Cicero may very well have found this play useful for characterising Milo as saving the Republic and Clodius as transgressing gender-appropriate boundaries.
A final playwright, Accius, has left fragments of three plays that concern the myths of the House of Atreus. The Agamemnonidae,Footnote 71 which picks up the story after the events of the Oresteia, is unlikely to have had much influence on Cicero's comparison of Milo to Orestes in the Pro Milone. Accius' Aegisthus,Footnote 72 on the other hand, suggests that Clytemnestra is hardened (fr. V), hinting at a broader masculine characterisation of Orestes' mother which may have proved useful to Cicero in his depiction of Clodius as soft. The fragments, however, do not suggest that Orestes' trial was included in the play.Footnote 73 Finally, Accius' Clytemnestra Footnote 74 features Agamemnon's return from Troy (frr. III-V), a disconsolate Cassandra at Mycenae (frr. VI-VIII) and Clytemnestra apparently chastising Electra for supporting Agamemnon's act of violence but condemning hers (fr. X). While this play seems to have much in common with Aeschylus' Agamemnon, there is no reference to the murder of Clytemnestra or to Orestes' subsequent trial at Athens. Moreover, scholars disagree as to whether Aeschylus was Accius' source for the story he tells in this play.Footnote 75
The likelihood that the Clytemnestra nonetheless served as a point of reference for Cicero is greatly increased by the fact that Fam. 7.1.2f. tells us not only that the Clytemnestra was performed at the dedication of the Theatre of Pompey in 55 BCE, a mere three years before Milo's trial, but also that Cicero himself was in the audience for this specific performance.Footnote 76 Cicero's report to M. Marius about the occasion is scathing: the actor's voice failed him; the staging was lavish and excessive; none of the other spectacles was worth seeing. However poor Cicero's opinion of the spectacle may have been, his letter offers a fixed point of reference, confirming that he could expect his readers to have seen a play (or at least heard about a play) recounting part of the Oresteia story only a few years before the dissemination of his speech in defence of Milo.
Fascinatingly, if indeed Cicero was inspired by this performance to cast Milo as an Orestes a few years later, he was not the only one to draw contemporary political comparisons with Accius' play. We might well speculate that Pompey, in whose honour the festivities were held and who certainly had a say in which plays were performed, chose the two plays for the occasion—the Equus Troianus and the Clytemnestra—in order to draw himself on a level with the mighty Agamemnon. These plays evoked his own foreign conquests and spectacular triple triumph of 61 BCE, respectively, by analogy with the exploits of the Mycenaean king. The attempt certainly failed to impress Cicero, who reports in his letter to Marius his utter lack of interest in the 3000 bronze bowls dedicated in the Equus Troianus and the train of 600 mules paraded across the stage of the Clytemnestra. But later reports confirm that the association between Pompey and Agamemnon established on this occasion was a lasting one and certainly not one favourable to Pompey. The occasion was later recalled by Domitius Ahenobarbus, who scathingly called Pompey Agamemnon, βασιλέα βασιλέων (‘king of kings', Plu. Pomp. 67.3), criticising his tyrannical behaviour.Footnote 77
While this anecdotal evidence offers no specific insight into Cicero's use of Aeschylean material in the Pro Milone, it does confirm that Greek myths performed on the stage, and specifically the myths of the House of Atreus, were part of an ongoing public discourse in which Roman public figures were assimilated to Greek tragic ones. As we have already seen, Orestes was used not long after the publication of the Pro Milone as a mythical analogue for Octavian. It would be very surprising indeed if the use that both Octavian and his enemies made of this mythical material did not rely on representations of Orestes on the Republican stage. The surviving fragments of Republican tragedy, which contain ample evidence for the popularity of the Oresteia story in the Roman theatre, as well as evidence that it was not uncommon for public figures to be assimilated to theatrical characters,Footnote 78 support my claim that Cicero's rhetorical strategy in the Pro Milone relies on the assumption that his readers would easily perceive the wider implications of the Aeschylean analogy he suggests. Cicero's decision to pair Milo with Orestes and, by association, Clodius with Clytemnestra, clearly fits into a larger pattern of mythological borrowings in contemporary Roman political discourse that drew on the presentation of Greek tragic material on the Latin stage.
6. Conclusion
The Pro Milone, then, in both style and content puts its readers in mind of the theatre. Presenting the story of Milo and his trial as a fabula paenulata, so to speak, that combines elements of both myth and history, the speech has many dramatic features of language and theme. These reinforce a sustained comparison between, on the one hand, Orestes and Milo and, on the other hand, Clytemnestra and Clodius, introduced by Cicero's overt reference to Aeschylus' Oresteia at the beginning of the speech. The Ciceronian corpus makes it clear that Cicero was both competent and inclined to construct this kind of extended theatrical comparison. As for Cicero's first reading audience, they could be counted on to be familiar with Greek myth and comfortable finding references to political figures in the Greek mythological characters they knew from the Republican stage. Whether they were familiar with the Oresteia from an education similar to Cicero's or from the many Republican stagings of the stories of the Oresteia—performances as recent as that of Accius' Clytemnestra in 55 BCE—the readers of Cicero's Pro Milone when the published version circulated in the aftermath of the trial were not only capable of picking up on Cicero's extended dramatic allusion but disposed to do so. Cicero's reference to Aeschylus in the Pro Milone, then, is far from casual, but actually represents one among many elaborate rhetorical strategies simultaneously at work in the speech to convince his readers that Milo should have been pardoned in the original trial.
Quintilian, in Book 5 of the Institutio Oratoria, offers a charming anecdote about the tragedian, Accius:
aiunt Accium interrogatum, cur causas non ageret, cum apud eum in tragoediis tanta uis esset optime respondendi, hanc reddidisse rationem, quod illic ea dicerentur quae ipse uellet, in foro dicturi aduersarii essent quae minime uellet.
(Quint. Inst. 5.13.43)They say that Accius, when he was asked why he did not plead cases since his tragedies had such a strength for offering the best answers, responded with the following reasoning: that in his tragedies people said what he wanted them to say, but in the forum his adversaries would say what he least wanted them to say.
After the death of his long-time adversary, Clodius, Cicero seems to have achieved the ideal that escaped Accius, namely the ability to stage a courtroom drama in which he had total control over what was said. By his clever manipulation of tragic themes and tropes in the Pro Milone, Cicero is quite literally able to cast Clodius as a vile Clytemnestra and, likewise, to cast Milo as the heroic Orestes who slew her. In the trial, Cicero's speech proved unsuccessful and Milo was sent into exile for Clodius' murder. But through the published speech that circulated in the aftermath of the trial, Cicero continued to enjoy the poetic licence to disseminate the tragic text that suited his own purposes. Though the trial was over, the first readers of this speech became the audience for Cicero's own Republican Oresteia.
