This is the first book by a young and promising scholar in the field of fragrance history and anthropology. The book is mainly based on the author's dissertation submitted to the University of Basel. In general this work was composed in order to partly fill a lacuna in our knowledge about the perfumery arts of the East; these have traditionally been presented as exotic and even secretive. Therefore, the book fulfills the tremendous need to record and conserve the knowledge of a unique historical/traditional art of the Arabic perfumery, which can unfortunately be considered as an extinct tradition due to modernisation processes.
This is a superb piece of solid academic research, well written and meticulously scientific. The author asks various important and original research questions and deals with them one by one using a wide range of historical sources and various anthropological methodologies applied during her field work in Yemen 2002–2004. Jung's book recalibrates the meaning and character of perfumery in Arabia illustrated by the local example of ‘Adan/Laḥj.
The book is written simultaneously on two levels. The first is the historical and cultural one in which it examines Arabian perfumery in Islamic culture from an historical point of view. The other level, the ethnographical one, is the story of current perfumery art in the southern districts of Yemen, especially among the ‘Adan/Laḥj women. It is no wonder that the writer dedicated the book “For the women in South Arabia”, since they act as ‘guardians’ of the tradition and the secrets of the unique fragrance and perfumes of Arab culture. Moreover, Jung's book seems to be a successful attempt to explore the full spectrum of perfumery in the Arab world.
Chapter One serves as an introductory chapter, and it deals with various basic issues related to perfumery which are important for the understanding of the field and the work. The author calls them: “the burden of Orientalism, the anthropological background, a fine art and the ethnographic venture”. This allows the author to portray her aims whilst defining the book and its scope. The introduction also prepares the reader for the task of appreciating what goes on “behind the scenes”, of the importance of writing the book, and of having a clearer understanding as to why they should read it.
In the main part of the book the author manages to portray the network of aesthetic features and criteria that are especially applicable to the contemporary perfumery arts in ‘Adan/Laḥj. The first few chapters (Chapters Two to Five) comprise historical knowledge and the retrospective recollections of older people to a greater extent. The next few chapters (Chapters Six to Nine) comprise historical knowledge increasingly represent youth as well.
The last chapter, entitled “A Fragrant Mirror of Culture” serves to draw the diverse ethnographic data together theoretically as a conclusion for her study of the perfumery arts of ‘Adan/Laḥj and the artistic features and the specialty of the perfumery arts in the region.
The local perfumery substances used and made by ‘Adan/Laḥj's reflect the long history of intercontinental connections in which Yemen was involved. The aromatics that were recorded in the book such as musk, roses, civet, agar-wood and many more - mirror the short and long distance trade connections and the industrial achievements of Yemen throughout its history.
The cultural exchange along the Indian Ocean Rim and within the colonial empires supported the spread and refinement of aromatics. The result is a new and fascinating portrayal and explanation of perfumery in general as well as of its tradition and special features in West Asia up to recent times.
The book's specialty is best described by the author's words: “. . .. The perfumery endeavors in Islamic cultures have never constituted an ‘art’ in the sense of being object of the formulated theory of aesthetics. . . .. Instead of being an issue of beauty, Muslim theoreticians reflected upon perfumes in the context of discussing the matters of purity courtesy and elegance; and perfumery production has traditionally been part of pharmacy. . . ..” (p. 206).
The writer succeeded not only in learning the fascinating past of the art of perfumery, but has also dealt with the present situation of the art and especially its future: “The increasing commercialization of the perfumery craft, in connection with the rising international perfume industry, has led to the creation of perfumes as mass articles, and over exploitation of natural resources”. Moreover, she calls for preventive action: “Scholars, traders, perfumers, consumers, and officials are nowadays asked to search for ways to contribute to the sustainable management of resources, and to protect people from the possibly harmful effects of synthetic substances” (p. 203).
The balanced combination of a serious and deep study of Arabian perfumery as it appears in Islamic and the historical sources, together with a superb ethnographical field study; give this book its unique importance, and therefore its much needed publication. It is a seminal work for scholars and students of the social and economical history of the Arabian Peninsula, especially during the medieval period, but also beyond that.
Jung has shown her many talents in this work and has based this well written work on meticulous research. Although it is primarily an academic work, the book is written in an elegant and delightful way and the various issues it deals with are interwoven into a piece of solid literary and academic research. An Ethnography of Fragrance is graced with a rich bibliography, a very useful glossary of terms, Islamic literary sources regarding perfumery, and four detailed and very helpful indexes. The appendices also include important information regarding the chronological, legal and ecological aspects of the issue, and therefore are very useful for reader and scholars in the field.
Jung's book is essential for those interested in the history and ethnography of perfumery. I look forward to reading her next work that might record, conserve and reveal the secrets of perfumery in another culture in some remote geographical area; hopefully East Asia.
