Published online by Cambridge University Press: 10 June 2004
The first half of the twentieth century was a period of major crisis and change.1
This dissertation was completed at the University of Arizona under the supervision of Price V. Fishback.
Since emancipation, black workers have been able to secure substantial income gains relative to the fast growing incomes of white workers.2
Higgs, “Black Progress.”
Fishback, “Operations”; and Heckman, Lyons, and Todd, “Understanding Black-White Wage Differentials.”
The human capital argument is primarily associated with the work of Smith, “Race”; and Smith and Welch, “Black Economic Progress.” The argument that black economic progress has been not only a function of human capital accumulation but also has advanced episodically due to changes in civil rights legislation was advanced by Heckman and Payner, “Determining the Impact”; and Donohue and Heckman, “Continuous versus Episodic Change.”
Myrdal, American Dilemma, pp. 205–09, 423–26.
Maloney, “Wage Compression”; and Margo, “Explaining Black-White Wage Convergence,” p. 471.
Higgs, “Black Progress.”
Sundstrom, “Last Hired.”
The episodic advance of black workers between 1910 and 1950 was driven substantially by the crises and institutional changes characterizing this turbulent period and may have had little to do with government antidiscrimination policy. As thousands of southern black workers made their way north in search of economic progress, the U.S. economy experienced two world wars that appear to have aided the progress of black workers and the Great Depression that retarded it. Union movements, often anathema to the progress of black workers, experienced their own ups and downs. Among nonagricultural workers, union density rose from about 10 percent in 1915 to its highest private-sector level ever of about 35 percent in 1945.9
Freeman, “Spurts,” p. 266.
Dickerson, Out of the Crucible, chaps. 6–7; Murray, Negro Handbook, pp. 132–33; and Weaver, “Recent Events.”
Though much has been learned of black economic progress during the interwar period, due to data limitations, the experience of black workers with respect to the crises and changes of the period remains largely an untold story. Much has been learned about the Great Migration of black workers from the South into the urban North, the extraordinary gains of black workers during the 1940s, and the disproportionately high unemployment suffered by black workers during the Great Depression.11
On the Great Migration, see Collins, “African-American Economic Mobility” and “When the Tide”; and Margo, “Effect.” On the gains of black workers during the 1940s, see Collins, “Race”; Maloney, “Wage Compression”; and Margo, “Explaining Black-White Wage Convergence.” On unemployment suffered by black workers during the Great Depression see, Sundstrom, “Down or Out” and “Last Hired.”
Maloney and Whatley, “Making the Effort”; Maloney, “Degrees”; Sundstrom, “Color Line”; and Whatley, “Getting a Foot.”
The attention given to black economic progress during the interwar period by cliometricians, though significant, has been limited by the availability of data. The Integrated Public Use Microdata Series (IPUMS) furnishes the researcher with race-specific information on workers' earnings, occupation, industry, and human capital characteristics for the years 1910, 1920, 1940, and 1950.13
Ruggles, Sobek, et al., Integrated Public Use Microdata Series.
Pennsylvania serves as an ideal setting in which to explore the impacts of the crises and changes of the interwar period on the economic welfare of black workers. During the Great Migration of the First World War, when many northern employers first hired black workers, Pennsylvania experienced a relatively large influx of black workers from the South. Between 1910 and 1920 Pennsylvania's southern-born black population increased by 72 percent, and in the next decade the state experienced an additional 59 percent increase. During this period Pennsylvania had the highest black population of any of the northern states.14
U.S. Department of Commerce, Negroes, p. 25.
Robert Higgs and others have shown that unskilled black and white workers performing the same job in a given industry were generally paid the same wage.15
Higgs, “Firm-Specific Evidence” and “Black Progress.” See also Fishback, “Operations,” pp. 176–77; Margo, “Explaining Black-White Wage Convergence,” p. 472; and Wright, Old South, pp. 182–85.
Dickens and Lang, “Test” and “Where Have all the Good Jobs”; Reich, Gordon, and Edwards, “Theory”; and Wright, Old South, pp. 177–97.
Wright, Old South, pp. 177–97.
Among manufacturing and mining industries in Pennsylvania, there was a significant difference in how black and white workers were distributed across industry immediately after World War I (chapter 2). However, this pattern of segregation was not rigid, changing substantially over time. After World War II, the black-white industrial distribution differential was significantly less than it had been after the First World War. Further, among manufacturing and mining industries black workers were not disproportionately employed by industries with a relatively low-wage structure. Multivariate analysis on individual data suggest that if black workers had been distributed across industry as white workers were, they would not have earned more, but, if anything, would have earned less. Black workers were not disproportionately employed by industries that were disproportionately dangerous or that were relatively labor intensive.
The degree to which the distribution of black workers across industry differed from that of whites was partly a function of the business cycle activity of the interwar period (chapters 2 and 3). During periods of economic expansion, there were significant reductions in the extent of industrial segregation. The period of most significant integration took place in the late 1930s and 1940s. During World War II, black workers obtained their highest level of representation within the overall manufacturing and mining sector between 1916 and 1950. However, some measures of segregation increased during World War II, suggesting that black workers were disproportionately hired by some industries during the wartime expansion. After the small recession following the Second World War, all measures of black integration suggest that industrial segregation after the war was less than it was before.
One way that industrial segregation harmed black workers was by exposing them to a greater risk of unemployment (chapter 2). During periods of expansion, the fast-growing industries disproportionately hired black workers. Regardless of race, workers in the industries that disproportionately expanded during times of boom found their jobs relatively insecure during periods of bust. During the Great Depression, black workers suffered a disproportionate share of the declines in employment. One of the causes of this unemployment differential was the black-white industry distribution differential.
The integration of black workers into the manufacturing and mining sector during the interwar period was significantly influenced by the level and nature of unionization (chapter 3). The craft unions affiliated with the American Federation of Labor (AFL) were not open to the integration of black workers into their ranks.18
Dickerson, Out of the Crucible, chaps. 6–7; Murray, Negro Handbook, pp. 132–33; and Weaver, “Recent Events.”
Due to the AFL's policies of racial exclusion and its attempts to enforce craft union jurisdictions in industries not conducive to craft organization, a substantial segment of workers were left unorganized. In the late 1930s John L. Lewis recognized and acted on an opportunity to successfully organize this sector by expanding industrial, rather than craft, unionization. Because many of these industries conducive to industrial organization also had work forces employing a substantial number of black workers, a key to union success was the organization of black workers. The Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) was formed after Lewis and other industrial union promoters were forced out of the AFL.19
Bernstein, History, pp. 427–31.
Dickerson, Out of the Crucible, chaps. 6–7; Murray, Negro Handbook, pp. 132–33; and Weaver, “Recent Events.”
The 1940s, including the wartime expansion of the Second World War, was a period of significant black integration. There are a number of factors that could have influenced this integration, including tight labor markets, the changing level and nature of unionization, and the Fair Employment Practices Committee (FEPC). The FEPC was a government agency created to enforce an executive order that made it illegal for defense contractors to discriminate on the basis of race, religion, or national origin. Arguably, the FEPC was a weak agency created to appease the demands of protesting black activists who might interfere with war production.21
Dalfiume, Desegregation, pp. 118–21; Bernstein, “America,” p. 298; and Polenberg, War, pp. 122–23.
Collins (“Race”), using city-level data, finds that FEPC activity had a significant positive impact on black employment.
The New Deal policies that strove to obtain a “living wage for the forgotten man” may have caused more harm than good among the most forgotten—black Americans. There is evidence that these policies were successful in increasing labor's share of revenue during the Great Depression. Increases in labor's share of revenue increased blacks workers' share of economic downturns and decreased their share of the steady-state employment that did not fluctuate with the business cycle (chapter 4). Increases in unionization had a similar effect. Thus, New Deal high-wage policies that successfully increased labor's share of revenue and expanded unionization increased the degree to which black workers suffered disproportionately high rates of unemployment during the Great Depression.