Van Jackson, a former Pentagon insider and a Korean security expert currently teaching at Victoria University of Wellington in New Zealand, has succeeded in writing a highly accessible book that traces the roots of the often-hostile relationship between the United States and the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK) that nearly led to nuclear war in 2017. Jackson's investigation of North Korea's strategic culture is especially illuminating, as it highlights the “I die, you die” approach of the Kim family regime. As Jackson explains, the standoff between Donald Trump and Kim Jong Un was a long time in coming, and a Hillary Clinton presidency likely would have encountered similar circumstances in Northeast Asia.
As US policymakers struggle to understand North Korea's rhetoric and actions, Jackson's explanation of Pyongyang's strategic culture offers valuable insights. For example, he highlights the “theory of victory” that undergirds North Korea's behavior abroad. North Korea's resolve to show strength, rather than weakness, makes Northeast Asia a particularly volatile space for US intervention. In addition, as Jackson explains, North Korea's historical legacy of “anti-Great Power-ism” under the rubric of its juche ideology still influences how the Kim family regime interacts with larger powers on the world stage. Jackson states, “And to North Koreans, survival required risk-taking; superior resolve could compensate for inferior size. North Korea's nuclear obsession was not ‘caused’ by juche strategic culture, but the latter enabled the former” (p. 24). As a historian of international relations myself, I found Jackson's use of historical context and emphasis on North Korea's ideological traditions particularly enlightening and perceptive.
Jackson offers a play-by-play analysis of Trump's nuclear standoff with the Kim family regime. From analyzing the US president's mystifying (dare I say, idiotic) tweets to examining the impact of Otto Warmbier's tragic death, Jackson's book is one of the most readable and intellectual examinations of contemporary US-DPRK relations. One of the general themes that Jackson evokes in his writing is the sheer lack of restraint from the Trump administration. The White House's ratcheting up of sanctions, military exercises, and fiery rhetoric did little to help ease the situation on the Korean peninsula but instead fanned the flames of nuclear brinkmanship.
As Jackson makes explicit, the Trump administration's bellicose rhetoric and actions nearly started a second Korean War. Jackson gives South Korean president Moon Jae-in due credit in alleviating tensions on the Korean peninsula. Moon's rapprochement with Kim Jong Un resulted in a unified Korea women's hockey team at the Winter Olympics and a successful PyeongChang Olympic Games. Kim Jong Un's strategic decision in 2018 to move away from a policy of nuclear development to economic growth was also heralded by Jackson as an important step in deescalating the nuclear crisis with the United States.
Jackson aptly argues that the US “maximum pressure” policy toward North Korea's nuclear arsenal is too rigid and comprehensive. As a regime with a paranoid fear of a US invasion and a siege mentality, the North Korean government will never surrender its nuclear weapons. As the US government maintains an inflexible policy of compete denuclearization, Jackson argues that working-level diplomatic talks, a nuclear arms reduction rather than total dismantlement of the DPRK's nuclear program, and a gradual rollback of US sanctions would yield a more peaceful and friendly US-DPRK relationship. Primarily because of the Kim family regime's horrendous record of human rights violations, I am a bit of a hawk on North Korea–related issues. However, I, too, believe that all-out international sanctions have exceeded their lifespan in curbing North Korea's nuclear development and subversive behavior abroad. Unfortunately, Trump is far too impatient and selfish to pursue such a delicate process of diplomatic normalization with Pyongyang. He prefers the superficial photo ops of flashy summits with Kim Jong Un in luxury hotels in Southeast Asia.
One of my minor criticisms is that Jackson does not go far enough in examining North Korea's official rhetoric. English-language statements from North Korea's state-run media and quotes from DPRK Foreign Ministry officials to Western journalists are highly sanitized for foreign consumption by Pyongyang's propaganda apparatus. The Kim family regime's internal messaging to its own people would have been an interesting perspective to look at. An in-depth investigation of North Korea's internal Korean-language publications, such as the party organ Rodong Sinmun and cultural magazines such as Chollima, may have yielded additional insights into the Kim family regime's mindset during the nuclear standoff. Most, if not all, of Jackson's sources come from English-language materials. In addition, the constant sectioning in the chapters made the reading jarring at times.
However, these are minor quibbles and Jackson should be commended for his excellent book. I highly recommend this book to international relations scholars, Korea specialists, and especially those in Beltway policy circles.
