Declared by then United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees Sadako Ogata to be the “decade of repatriation,” the 1990s saw the return of some twelve million refugees to their countries of origin. This volume reviews lessons learned from these varied experiences with repatriation and explores the extent to which they can be applied to benefit the more than seven million Palestinian refugees and displaced persons whose claims to repatriation remain unfulfilled. Emanating from an international workshop at Exeter University in 2004, the book acknowledges the ways in which the Palestinian refugee question is unique, such as in its longevity and large numbers. Nevertheless, in the words of editor Michael Dumper, those engaged in planning Palestinian repatriation need not reinvent the wheel. Rather, they should examine the wheels that have already been used and choose from those most suitable for their particular road conditions.
The volume's fourteen essays are organized in three parts. Part I provides an overview of trends and patterns in refugee repatriation in the Palestinian and global contexts. These essays consider the treatment of repatriation in the fields of refugee and forced migration studies, the evolution of the role of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in repatriation matters, and track-two diplomatic discussions about return in the Palestinian case. Especially helpful in this section is an essay by Rex Brynen that uses Israeli, Palestinian, and donor thinking to outline possible elements of a Palestinian repatriation strategy. This essay might have deserved a more prominent place in the volume because it critically sets forth the Palestinian reality against the applicability of comparative expertise.
Part II presents case studies from all corners of the globe. A number of points appear especially relevant for the Palestinian case. Finn Stepputat's essay on Guatemala warns against grandiose mass-return operations and calls for support for local administrations that bear the largest burdens in assisting repatriated persons. Laura Hammond's research on the Horn of Africa recommends that policymakers design reintegration packages on the basis of microeconomic assessments of the requirements of postreturn life. Michael Kagan's piece on Iraq draws the distinction between the principle of voluntariness, which refers to the legal requirement that refugee repatriation be uncoerced, and the existence of choice, which implies that refugees be guaranteed real alternatives.
Part III concludes by identifying lessons that can be drawn from past practices for the design of policy for Palestinian refugees. Sari Hanafi suggests that Palestinian repatriation be thought of as return migration, for which lessons can be categorized according to their political, sociological, or institutional dimensions. Dumper posits that, although decision makers in the Palestinian case cannot simply copy policies from any other situation, they should derive inspiration from other contexts and synthesize elements from multiple programs.
The volume deserves praise for offering a fresh and imaginative perspective on very difficult questions. It also succeeds in offsetting what it identifies as two weaknesses in the literature on refugee studies: its domination by policy-oriented reports and its tendency to emphasize the exceptional character of each refugee situation at the expense of comparative analysis and broader contextualization. It is thus recommended reading for scholars of forced migration and offers often overlooked insight for students of Palestinian affairs.
Nevertheless, the volume might have benefited from more extensive treatment of two elements. First, it would have been fruitful to include more discussion of what Palestinian refugees want from repatriation or other proposed resolutions to their plight. Given the emphasis that several authors place on the need to involve refugees as protagonists in the conduct of repatriation programs, it is striking that the volume did not involve more Palestinian refugees as protagonists in its analysis of repatriation lessons. Such might have been achieved by including essays in the voice of Palestinians who are to be affected by repatriation or by presenting research on their priorities and preferences.
Second, the volume would have been stronger had it dedicated more forthright attention to the towering question of political constraints. The major challenge to Palestinian repatriation arguably lies not in the realm of program design and implementation but in the state interests that block repatriation in the first place. Several authors recognize as much when they admit that they do not envision Palestinian refugee return in the foreseeable future. For that matter, the editor acknowledges that he cannot say if his own use of the term “Palestinian refugee repatriation” indicates return to Israel or to a Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip.
In its focus on the practice of repatriation, therefore, this book sidesteps the dilemma of the politics of repatriation. Refugee return, like other issues in the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, is likely to be determined less by international best practice than by the reigning balance of power. This volume does a valiant job of investigating the degree to which repatriation policies in other countries suggest lessons for Palestinian refugees. Yet the skeptical reader will wonder about the overall meaning of such an investigation in the absence of a frank and constructive discussion of how repatriation can be made politically feasible.
