—Due to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the labor market, millions of Americans experienced sharp reductions in household income and faced increased housing insecurity.Footnote 1 Record levels of unemployment, destabilized communities, and a lack of affordable housing all contributed to increased risk of bankruptcy and foreclosure.Footnote 2 Estimates showed that 30 to 40 million Americans would be at risk of eviction during the COVID-19 pandemic without government intervention.Footnote 3 As federal, state, and local governments failed to renew expiring housing protections, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (“CDC”) announced its own federal eviction mortarium.Footnote 4 This unprecedented action raised serious implementation, constitutionality, and statutory concerns. Numerous courts reviewed challenges to the federal eviction moratorium between 2020 to 2021, but analyses were inconsistent.Footnote 5 In Alabama Association of Realtors (“AAR”) v. Department of Health and Human Services (“HHS”), the Supreme Court of the United States (“Supreme Court”) confirmed that the federal eviction moratorium was unlawful.Footnote 6 Consequently, the CDC’s federal eviction moratorium ended on August 26, 2021.
In AAR v. HHS, trade associations, real estate professionals, and rental management corporations (“Plaintiffs”) brought suit against the HHS, CDC, and several government officials (“Government”) challenging the federal eviction moratorium on statutory and constitutional grounds.Footnote 7 On May 5, 2021, the United States District Court for the District of Columbia (“District Court”) granted the Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment after determining that the CDC unlawfully exceeded its statutory authority; however, this judgment vacating the federal eviction moratorium was stayed pending appeal.Footnote 8 In June 2021, both the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit (“D.C. Circuit”) and Supreme Court declined to vacate the stay for the federal eviction moratorium, which was set to expire on July 31, 2020.Footnote 9
Due to concerns regarding new COVID-19 variants and changes to the public health landscape, the CDC subsequently renewed the expired federal eviction moratorium through October 3, 2021, while implementing some minor modifications.Footnote 10 Following this renewal, the Plaintiffs filed an Emergency Motion to Enforce the Supreme Court’s Ruling and to Vacate the Stay Pending Appeal.Footnote 11 While the District Court no longer believed that a stay was warranted, it was incapable of vacating the stay because of D.C. Circuit precedent.Footnote 12 The D.C. Circuit continued to support the stay.Footnote 13 Ultimately, the Supreme Court issued an order vacating the stay on August 26, 2021.Footnote 14 The Supreme Court found that it was “virtually certain … that the CDC has exceeded its authority” by issuing a federal eviction moratorium.Footnote 15
I. EVICTION MORATORIUMS ADDRESSED A CRUCIAL NEED DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC
On March 11, 2020, the World Health Organization officially declared the spread of COVID-19—a novel and highly infectious respiratory disease—to be a pandemic.Footnote 16 In response to concerns regarding economic crises, including a COVID-19-related eviction crisis, the United States federal government passed the Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security (“CARES”) Act.Footnote 17 The CARES Act implemented a temporary 120-day eviction moratorium for homeowners with federally backed multifamily mortgage loans.Footnote 18 In addition to federal eviction protections, many state and local governments also implemented tenant protections by issuing temporary moratoriums on evictions and utility shutoffs.Footnote 19 Unfortunately, many of these housing protections expired by mid-2020 without renewal, despite the ongoing nature of the COVID-19 pandemic.Footnote 20
Expiring eviction moratoriums placed millions at risk of eviction.Footnote 21 Evicted individuals were less likely to be able to effectively quarantine, social distance, and/or isolate. Therefore, the CDC sought to mitigate the spread of COVID-19 by instituting housing protections.Footnote 22 On September 4, 2020, the CDC issued an agency order titled “Temporary Halt in Residential Evictions to Prevent the Spread of COVID-19” (“Order”), which implemented a federal eviction moratorium that would be effective from September 4 to December 31, 2020.Footnote 23
The Order aimed to prohibit no-fault evictions for non-payment by tenants in residential properties who (1) had pursued all avenues for governmental rental assistance; (2) were unable to make housing payments in full due to “substantial loss of household income, loss of compensable hours of work, or wages, lay-offs, or extraordinary out-of-pocket medical exposures;” (3) were “using best efforts to make timely partial payments that [were] as close to the full payment” as possible; and (4) would likely suffer from homelessness or have to move into a shared living space if evicted.Footnote 24 To qualify for protections under the Order, tenants needed to “earn no more than $99,000 in annual income for Calendar Year 2020 (or no more than $198,000 if filing a joint tax return), … not [have been] required to report any income in 2019 to the U.S. Internal Revenue Service, or [have] received an Economic Impact Payment … pursuant to Section 2201 of the CARES Act.”Footnote 25
Though controversial, the Order was extended several times to prevent further transmission of the COVID-19 virus. In fact, even after COVID-19 vaccines became widely available, the CDC continued to recognize a need for eviction moratoriums because of the risks posed by new COVID-19 variants and lower vaccination rates exhibited among populations vulnerable to eviction.Footnote 26 On December 31, 2020, Congress chose to extend the federal eviction moratorium through January 31, 2021 via the Consolidated Appropriations Act.Footnote 27 Subsequently, the CDC also renewed the Order on January 29, 2021 through March 31, 2021; on March 28, 2021 through June 31, 2021; and on June 24, 2021 through July 31, 2021.Footnote 28 While officials expressed that the July 31, 2021 end date would be final, the rise of the COVID-19 Delta variant led the CDC to renew the eviction moratorium on August 3, 2021 through October 3, 2021.Footnote 29 In this final iteration of the federal eviction moratorium, the CDC implemented some modifications. Most significantly, the latest version of the moratorium applied only “in U.S. count[ies] experiencing substantial or high levels of community transmission levels of SARS-CoV-2,” rather than all counties.Footnote 30
II. CDC’S FEDERAL EVICTION MORATORIUM PLAGUED WITH CRITICISM AND LEGAL CHALLENGES SINCE INITIAL IMPLEMENTATION
Due to criticism regarding the implementation of the federal eviction moratorium, the CDC released a non-binding guidance document (“Guidance Document”) shortly after issuing the Order. Footnote 31 The Guidance Document (1) clarified landlords did not need to inform their tenants about the Order’s existence and (2) allowed landlords to “challeng[e] the truthfulness of a tenant’s declaration” that a tenant qualified for protections under the Order.Footnote 32 Despite such limiting guidance, numerous legal challenges to the Order were quickly brought forward seeking declaratory and injunctive relief.Footnote 33 Lower courts were often inconsistent in their analyses and holdings.Footnote 34
In AAR v. HHS, Plaintiffs argued that the federal eviction moratorium was unlawful because it was not issued through the Administrative Procedure Act’s (“APA’s”) notice-and-comment process, did not comply with the Regulatory Flexibility Act, exceeded the CDC’s statutory authority, was arbitrary and capricious, constituted an improper delegation of legislative power, violated the Takings Clause, violated the Due Process Clause, and deprived Plaintiffs of their right of access to courts.Footnote 35 The Government asserted that the CDC had the statutory and regulatory authority to issue the Order and that the agency complied with all rulemaking requirements.Footnote 36 Furthermore, the Government denied any constitutional violations and emphasized the need to narrowly tailor any remedy found necessary.Footnote 37 When granting the Plaintiff’s Motion for Summary Judgment in AAR v. HHS, the District Court focused its analysis on the issue of the CDC’s statutory authority—or lack thereof.Footnote 38 The Supreme Court also emphasized this issue when it articulated its concerns about the Order.Footnote 39 Hence, while other courts have found some merit in constitutional,Footnote 40 as well as statutory, challenges to the Order, this Recent Case Development will limit its focus to the issue of the CDC’s statutory authority, as prioritized in AAR v. HHS.
A. District Court Found that Federal Eviction Moratorium Exceeded CDC’S Authority Under Chevron
In AAR v. HHS, the District Court limited its analysis to the narrow question of: “Does the Public Health Service Act grant the CDC the legal authority to impose a nationwide eviction moratorium?” Footnote 41 To effectuate the Order, the CDC relied on an expansive reading of § 361 of the Public Health Service Act, 42 U.S.C. § 264, as well as 42 C.F.R. § 70.2, an agency regulation implementing that statute.Footnote 42 However, the “CDC provided no analysis of this authority” justifying such an expansive interpretation.Footnote 43
In its first sentence, § 264(a) authorizes the Secretary of the HHS (“Secretary”) to “make and enforce such regulations as in his judgment are necessary to prevent the introduction, transmission, or spread of communicable diseases.” Footnote 44 The second sentence of the statute subsequently allows the Secretary, “for the purposes of carrying out and enforcing such regulations, … [to] provide for such inspection, fumigation, disinfection, sanitation, pest extermination, destruction of animals or articles … and other measures, as in his judgment may be necessary.”Footnote 45 Under 42 C.F.R. § 70.2, the Secretary may delegate these powers to the Director of the CDC (“Director”).
The District Court applied the two-step Chevron framework and used traditional tools of statutory interpretation to assess whether § 264(a) afforded the CDC the discretion and flexibility to implement a federal eviction moratorium.Footnote 46 When Chevron deference applies, courts adopt an underlying assumption that Congress intended to delegate and grant agencies the ability to interpret ambiguous provisions of statutory authority.Footnote 47 The first step of the Chevron framework requires the court to determine “whether Congress has directly spoken to the precise question at issue.”Footnote 48 If Congress did not express its intent, courts then proceed to “determine if the agency’s interpretation is permissible, and if so, defer to it.” Footnote 49
Under the Chevron framework, the District Court concluded that the precise language of § 264(a) did not permit the Government’s expansive reading of the CDC’s statutory authority, as “rulemaking authority in the first sentence of § 264(a) is tethered to—and narrowed by—the second sentence.”Footnote 50 Even though § 264(a) permitted non-enumerated “other measures” to be taken, such measures were still to be “controlled and defined by reference to the enumerated categories before it.”Footnote 51 The Order was not like the other enumerated measures in § 264(a), which were “directed toward specific targets found to be sources of infection.” Footnote 52 Various tools of judicial interpretation, such as the canons of construction, confirmed the District Court’s interpretation of § 264(a)’s plain text.Footnote 53
The District Court determined that the Government’s expansive reading of § 264(a) was inappropriate as “‘Congress could not have intended to delegate’ such extraordinary power ‘to an agency in so cryptic a fashion.’”Footnote 54 Furthermore, the District Court stated that “the CDC has never used § 264(a) in this manner” and “rarely … utilized [the statute] … for disease-control purposes.”Footnote 55 The District Court also failed to find merit in the Government’s argument that Congress’ extension of the federal eviction moratorium through the Consolidated Appropriations Act served to ratify the CDC’s Order, as Congress failed to acknowledge the CDC’s interpretation of its statutory authority under 42 U.S.C. § 264(a) when Congress temporarily extended the federal eviction moratorium for a limited 30-day duration.Footnote 56 The District Court ultimately held that federal eviction moratorium did not qualify as a permissible measure under the CDC’s statutory authority.
On May 5, 2020, the District Court granted the Plaintiffs’ Motion for Expedited Summary Judgment on the basis that the implementation of a federal eviction moratorium unlawfully exceeded the CDC’s statutory authority.Footnote 57 As part of this judgment, the District Court believed that vacating the Order was an appropriate remedy.Footnote 58 However, the federal eviction moratorium remained in effect until August 26, 2021, because the District Court stayed its order vacating the federal eviction moratorium.Footnote 59
B. Extraordinary Circumstances Sometimes Justify Extraordinary Remedies
A stay is an “intrusion into the ordinary processes of administration and judicial review” that qualifies as an “extraordinary remedy.”Footnote 60 To assess whether such an extraordinary remedy is warranted, courts apply a four-factor test to determine: “(1) whether the stay applicant has made a strong showing that he is likely to succeed on the merits; (2) whether the applicant will be irreparably injured absent a stay; (3) whether issuance of the stay will substantially injure the other parties interested in the proceeding; and (4) where the public interest lies.” Footnote 61
The District Court did not find that the Government showed a substantial likelihood of success on the merits.Footnote 62 However, the Government’s inability to satisfy the first of the four prerequisites for granting a stay did not preclude the District Court’s holding that a stay was warranted. In considering a stay pending appeal, the District Court relied on a sliding-scale analysis, in which “a movant may make up for a lower likelihood of success on the merits ‘with a strong showing as to the other three factors, provided that the issue on appeal presents a ‘serious legal question’ on the merits.’”Footnote 63 Here, the District Court recognized that the Government did “raise[] a ‘serious legal question on the merits,’” given that other courts reached different conclusions when reviewing challenges to the federal eviction moratorium at the preliminary injunction stage.Footnote 64 The District Court also found that the Government satisfied the other three factors warranting a stay.Footnote 65 Upon considering both the economic and public health interests implicated by the Order, the District Court believed that public interest favored a stay.Footnote 66 Though the District Court acknowledged that Plaintiffs’ financial losses could be substantial, the District Court also recognized that some of the losses would be recoverable and financial relief was available to Plaintiffs.Footnote 67 Meanwhile, the federal eviction moratorium’s ability to help curtail the spread of COVID-19 implicated strong public health interests that could lead to irreparable societal harms.Footnote 68 By weighing all four factors using a sliding-scale analysis, the District Court granted the Government’s Motion for Stay Pending Appeal.Footnote 69
When reviewing the emergency motion to vacate the stay pending appeal, the D.C. Circuit dismissed concerns regarding the District Court’s use of sliding-scale analysis to find that the District Court “did not abuse its discretion in granting a stay … [under] the deferential abuse-of-discretion standard of review.”Footnote 70 To reach its conclusion, the D.C. Circuit applied the traditional four-factor test for a stay to find that the Government satisfied all parts of the test.Footnote 71 When analyzing the Government’s likelihood of success on the merits, the D.C. Circuit argued: the “CDC’s [carefully targeted] eviction moratorium falls within the plain text of 42 U.S.C.§ 264(a);” “Congress has expressly recognized that the agency had the authority to issue its narrowly crafted moratorium under Section 264;” “the text and structure of Section 264’s additional provisions … reinforce HHS’s authority to temporarily suspend evictions;” and the Government is “likely to succeed” despite other statutory-construction and federalism challenges.Footnote 72 The D.C. Circuit also emphasized the weight of the public harm that could stem from lifting the federal eviction moratorium.Footnote 73 The emergence of new COVID-19 variants posed significant risks of permanent public health repercussions, while economic implications were potentially recoverable.Footnote 74
By denying the motion to vacate the stay, the D.C. Circuit adopted a much more favorable assessment of the Government’s arguments. This was not surprising. Circuits were split on the issue of the CDC’s statutory authority,Footnote 75 and it was quite possible that the Supreme Court would not favor the District Court’s analysis. The District Court applied the Chevron framework to conclude that the CDC lacked the statutory authority to issue a federal eviction moratorium.Footnote 76 While Chevron deference is the strongest level of deference to agency interpretations that can be applied during judicial review, Chevron deference is often inconsistently applied.Footnote 77 For example, prior to AAR v. HHS, some district courts found that the CDC’s statutory authority under 42 U.S.C. § 264 was not ambiguous, so Chevron deference would not apply.Footnote 78 Furthermore, several Supreme Court justices have previously expressed an interest in abandoning the Chevron doctrine altogether.Footnote 79 This reluctance to rely on Chevron can be observed from the Supreme Court’s failure to explicitly mention the Chevron framework in AAR v. HHS. Footnote 80
In a 5-4 decision issued on June 29, 2021, the Supreme Court denied an application to vacate the stay.Footnote 81 In his concurrence, Justice Kavanaugh expressed his belief that the federal eviction moratorium unlawfully exceeded the CDC’s statutory authority.Footnote 82 Justice Kavanaugh favored not vacating the stay because the Order was set to expire in a few weeks; however, he emphasized that “clear and specific congressional authorization (via new legislation) would be necessary for the CDC to extend the moratorium past July 31.”Footnote 83
After the CDC renewed the federal eviction moratorium on August 3, 2021, Plaintiffs filed an Emergency Motion to Enforce the Supreme Court’s Ruling and to Vacate the Stay Pending Appeal.Footnote 84 Influenced by Justice Kavanaugh’s concurrence, the District Court thought that the Government was unlikely to succeed on the merits and recognized a shift in the balance of equities favoring the Plaintiffs.Footnote 85 While the District Court no longer believed that a stay was justified, the District Court held that it could not vacate the stay because law-of-case doctrine prevented reopening a question decided by the D.C. Circuit in earlier phases.Footnote 86 The D.C. Circuit continued to recognize the stay as valid.Footnote 87 In a 6-3 per curiam decision, the Supreme Court determined that vacating the stay was appropriate, thus rendering the District Court’s initial judgment enforceable.Footnote 88 The federal eviction moratorium ended on August 26, 2021.
C. Supreme Court Demonstrated Reluctance to Adopt Broad Interpretations of CDC’s Statutory Authority
Given that the federal eviction moratorium’s July 31st expiration date significantly impacted at least one Justice’s initial review of the Order,Footnote 89 it was not surprising that the Order’s renewal caused the Supreme Court to vacate the stay. To limit expansive interpretations of the CDC’s statutory authority, the Supreme Court emphasized that it was “virtually certain… that the CDC ha[d] exceeded its authority … [by] impos[ing] a nationwide moratorium on evictions in reliance on a decades-old statute that authorizes it to implement measures like fumigation and pest extermination.”Footnote 90
The Supreme Court ultimately found that “[t]he District Court produced a comprehensive opinion that the statute on which the CDC relie[d] does not grant it the authority it claim[ed].”Footnote 91 Even without referencing the District Court’s reliance on the Chevron framework, the Supreme Court rejected an expansive reading of § 264(a).Footnote 92 The Supreme Court argued that “it strains credulity to believe that this statute grants the CDC the sweeping authority that it asserts … [when] the downstream connection between eviction and the interstate spread of disease is markedly different from the direct targeting of disease that characterizes the measures identified in the statute.”Footnote 93 Even if § 264(a) was ambiguous, the major questions doctrine counsels against deferring to the Government’s interpretation of the statute, as “Congress [must] speak clearly when authorizing an agency to exercise powers of vast economic and political significance.”Footnote 94
The Supreme Court was especially concerned that the Government’s interpretation of § 264(a) imposed no limits on the CDC’s authority other than requiring the agency to “deem a measure necessary.”Footnote 95 Such a limitation was insufficient considering the sweeping power an expansive interpretation of § 264(a) offered.Footnote 96 While describing § 264(a) as a “wafer-thin reed,” the Supreme Court emphasized the wide-reaching implications of a federal eviction moratorium.Footnote 97 Specifically, the Supreme Court was concerned that the CDC’s intrusion into the landlord-tenant relationship, which is usually governed by state law, would “alter the balance between federal and state power and the power of the Government over private property.”Footnote 98 Hence, the Supreme Court argued that a statutory challenge to the federal eviction moratorium “not only [has] a substantial likelihood of success on the merits—it is difficult to imagine [it] losing.”Footnote 99 Therefore, a stay was no longer warranted as the four-factor test failed even under a sliding-scale analysis.
To further justify its findings, the Supreme Court argued that the balance of equities also favored vacating the stay.Footnote 100 While the Supreme Court recognized the Government’s “strong interest in combating the spread of the COVID-19 Delta variant,” it also recognized the significant economic costs and harms that businesses and trade associations faced because of eviction moratoriums.Footnote 101 Specifically, the federal eviction moratorium placed millions of landlords – many of whom lacked significant resources – at risk of being irreparably deprived of rent payments without guarantee of recovery.Footnote 102
The significance of the Supreme Court’s holding is emphasized by the unprecedented nature of the CDC’s federal eviction moratorium, the complexity of the legal issues involved, and limitations in the District Court’s analysis related to the heavy reliance on the Chevron Footnote 103 framework. The dissent by Justices Breyer, Sotomayor, and Kagan (“Dissent”) raised serious concerns that “[g]iven the split among the Circuits, it is at least hard to say that the Government’s reading of the statute is ‘demonstrably wrong.’”Footnote 104 The Dissent emphasized that “it is far from ‘demonstrably’ clear that the CDC lacks the power to issue its modified moratorium order.”Footnote 105 When originally denying the Emergency Motion to Vacate the Stay Pending Appeal, even the D.C. Circuit recognized that the Government made a “strong showing that it is likely to succeed on the merits.”Footnote 106 Rather, the Dissent argued that § 264(a)’s “plain meaning includes eviction moratoria necessary to stop the spread of diseases like COVID–19,” especially as the statute’s “second sentence is naturally read to expand [rather than cabin] the agency’s powers by providing congressional authorization to act on personal property when necessary.”Footnote 107 The Dissent also argued that the balance of equities and public interest also favored a stay.Footnote 108
While recognizing the public interest in implementing a federal eviction moratorium to limit the transmission of new COVID-19 variants, the Supreme Court ultimately emphasized the need for Congress to specifically authorize such measures.Footnote 109 The CDC acted inappropriately by claiming an “unprecedented” expansion of statutory authority.Footnote 110 The balance of equities and overall public interest ultimately favored curtailing unlawful expansions of agency authority.Footnote 111 In finding that the CDC lacked the statutory authority to issue a federal eviction moratorium, the Supreme Court prioritized efforts to protect the separation of powers by ensuring that agencies “did not act unlawfully [without congressional authorization] even in pursuit of desirable ends” during a global pandemic.Footnote 112
