What are the biggest challenges to peace in the world today, and how might understanding conflicts as generated by differences in civilizational values facilitate conflict resolution and the promotion of peace? This work comprises seven interrelated, previously unpublished essays, presenting in one volume what Bassam Tibi describes as his contribution to the amelioration of intercivilizational conflict through intercivilizational dialogue. He sees his argument as distinct from Samuel Huntington's “clash of civilizations” thesis, noting that “a conflict is not a clash” because clashes essentialize and promote polarity (p. ix). The author explains that he focuses on Islam and the West because each claims a universal status and a “world mission” (p. 169), unlike many other civilizations. Two main issues exacerbate their potential for conflict: the religionization of politics and the shrinking world brought about by globalization. With respect to the religionization of politics, he focuses on Islamism, a modern phenomenon that rests on the “invented tradition,” a la Hobsbawm, of an “Islamic state” (which, he argues, is not found in earlier Islamic history) and uses this ahistorical concept ideologically, turning political claims into divine decrees. With respect to globalization, he sees its product as not a global village but the concatenation of multiple civilizations with conflicting values. A smaller world brings more civilizational value conflict, while “religionized politics,” as he terms it, presents those conflicts as nonnegotiable because the values they support are understood as divine edicts. To address these conflicts, he suggests, civilizations must end the “war of ideas” and develop a dialogue based on mutual respect and on shared values, including democracy and human rights.
Tibi's argument about intercivilizational conflict is deeply historical; he argues that the contemporary era is characterized by a religionized politics, which has brought religion back into the public sphere, but in new forms and with new capacities for influencing public discourse and political behavior. This politics’ strongest impact has been on international relations and, consequently, on international conflicts. Tibi's argument allows him to note the crucial role played by Islam in contemporary world politics and in world conflicts—not because of any inherent “church-state” unity in Islam but because Islam, like Christianity, considers itself a universal religion that can and should spread itself through proselytization. Hence he shifts from analyzing the rituals of Muslim praxis or the theology of Islam to the societal phenomenon of Islam as a religion made political by Islamist thought and action. How is this politicized Islam employed, by whom, and to what ends? Because Tibi's answers are: for political purposes, by Islamist actors, resulting in increasing international conflicts, his focus is on how to move the world from conflict to conflict resolution. To do so, he argues, religion must be removed again from the public sphere. The religionization of politics makes political conflicts into conflicts of belief, and “beliefs are not negotiable” (p. 23). Rather than embrace the invented history of past societies submitting to divine sovereignty—“God's rule,” as espoused by Sayyid Qutb (p. 26)—Tibi suggests that Muslims look back to what he terms the actual, “Hellenized” Islam (p. 74) of the medieval era, which embraced civilizational bridging and respect for cultural and religious others.
Tibi's work is both a theoretical reflection and a manifesto. His diagnosis is presented in the first chapter, and he spends the bulk of the book elaborating on this diagnosis in hopes of ameliorating present and future conflicts. He does so by emphasizing the notion of “civilizational value conflict” (p. 1). These values are real and deeply rooted, and their role in fomenting intercivilizational (and, he adds, intracivilizational) conflict has been too little understood. The politicization of Islam leads to cultural tensions because “Western” values are rejected as foreign and un-Islamic. Tibi reads current conflicts as stemming from the structural conflict between the world of Islam and the nation-state system, which has produced nation-states across the Muslim-majority world whose legitimacy is contested and which suffer from weak internal unity. The result has been the emergence of an Islamist ideology that rejects international law—whether the laws of the nation-state system or of human rights—as secular and antithetical to Islam. This Islamist agenda develops out of the new conflicts that globalization fosters and heightens the fragmenting effect of globalization by presenting a polarized world: a Muslim “we” threatened by a non-Muslim “they,” from whom Muslims must be separated and Islam must be kept pure. That this thinking is deeply at odds with Islamic history is well known to scholars; that its power as a mobilizing ideology does not depend on historical accuracy is also worth recognizing.
For Tibi, the impact of Islamism highlights the important but dividing role that culture and religion play in human life, inhibiting the mutual respect necessary for dialogue. Hence, he advocates secularism as a universal shared value, even if its application through the post-Westphalian nation-state system has been inequitable (p. 38). Similarly, while arguing for the recognition of culture as equally important as economic and other factors in international relations, he insists that values must be above culture. Human rights, for example, should not be embraced or rejected at the cultural level—he considers them universal. While Tibi contends that individual cultures have little role in intercivilizational dialogue, he sees cultural modernity, which he defines as the values of “secular European Enlightenment” (p. viii) as the embodiment of universal shared values. What has produced confusion has been the conflation of technical and cultural modernity. Islamists embrace the technological advances of the modern age but reject cultural modernity as a Western invention. Instead, Tibi argues, cultural modernity and the humanist values it espouses are universal phenomena (p. 137) and the crucial foundation of a dialogue that could help to address the enclavization of Muslims in western Europe. Encouraging Muslim and non-Muslim Europeans to embrace the universality of cultural modernity would ameliorate the anti-Muslim prejudices that Tibi describes himself having faced in Germany, thus enabling Muslim Europeans to be welcomed as “citizens of the heart,” and not just “citizens by passport” (p. 127).
Tibi's work is grounded in the study of civilizations and in the argument that humans are steeped in the values of each civilization. He describes human history as defined by civilizations, noting that historians are comfortable with this concept but that social scientists are not (p. 6). As a historian, I count myself among the discomfited, in part because his definition of Islam as a civilization is so homogenizing. He acknowledges different cultures within the Muslim world, but insists that all Muslims share the same worldview. The idea that Muslims comprise many cultures but only one Islamic civilization needs to be argued with evidence, not proclaimed. Similarly, while framed as a global argument, the historical case studies are all Middle Eastern: the Ottoman Empire is described as the paradigmatic Islamic system of government; Middle Eastern states provide his case studies for “nominal nation states”; and the failure of the Six Day War is described as the catalyst for Islam's contemporary politicization (pp. 20–21). A global study should present global examples; if the Mughal Empire does not count because it did not govern Mecca and Medina, this also should be argued rather than assumed.
Due to the tremendous overlap between chapters, including extensive signposting and the regular reintroduction of concepts and of Tibi's personal history, this book is a difficult text to read in its entirety. Taken individually, however, the various chapters each would make strong and provocative reading for classes in international relations, the contemporary Middle East, Islam in Europe, and contemporary Islam. His argument for international relations as intercivilizational relations, his emphasis on the role of culture, and his characterization of Islamism as a totalitarian ideology should spark lively discussions. Given Tibi's unqualified embrace of secularism, this book would also make provocative reading in conversation with recent theorists of the secular, including Saba Mahmood and Salwa Ismail.
