Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:52:59.358Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Nonlinear waves in three-dimensional co-current gas–liquid film flow

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  09 June 2026

Wei Xie
Affiliation:
Key Laboratory for Mechanics in Fluid Solid Coupling Systems, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
Zhan Wang*
Affiliation:
Key Laboratory for Mechanics in Fluid Solid Coupling Systems, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Science, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR ChinaState Key Laboratory of High Temperature Gas Dynamics, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR China
*
Corresponding author: Zhan Wang, zwang@imech.ac.cn

Abstract

We investigate the dynamics of a three-dimensional thin laminar liquid film flowing down an inclined plane, influenced by both gravity and wind forces. The gas phase is modelled using a quasi-laminar approximation, in which viscosity is neglected. We expand Miles’ theory of wind-induced pressure, which previously focused on a one-dimensional interface, to a two-dimensional framework. From this, we derive evolution equations for the liquid film, including Benney-type and Nepomnyashchy-type models that capture the effects of wind on flow instability and wave dispersion. Our findings reveal two families of travelling-wave solutions and their bifurcation structures through numerical continuation. We analyse secondary instabilities using the centre-manifold method and Floquet theory, discovering finite-wavenumber bands in which oblique perturbations are more unstable than longitudinal ones. Based on these secondary-instability characteristics, we propose a classification framework for various flow regimes. Time-dependent numerical simulations support our predictions of secondary instabilities and reveal a range of nonlinear phenomena that occur after their onset. These phenomena include checkerboard-symmetric patterns, strip-like structures, phase-type instabilities and localised wave packets, some of which have been observed experimentally in previous studies.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Sketch of the geometry of the gas–liquid flow problem, where $\boldsymbol{g}=(g\sin \theta ,0,-g \cos \theta )$, with $g$ representing the acceleration due to gravity.

Figure 1

Figure 2.Effects of wind on the growth rate. ($a$) Supercritical flow with $r=2$ and various values of $\alpha$: $\alpha =0$ (blue solid line), $\alpha =1$ (red dash-dotted line) and $\alpha =2$ (green dashed line). ($b$) Subcritical flow with $r=0.01$ and various values of $\alpha$: $\alpha =0$ (blue solid line), $\alpha =2.03$ (red dash-dotted line) and $\alpha =2.1$ (green dashed line).

Figure 2

Figure 3.Effects of wind parameters on the $k^*-c$ bifurcation curves for $\gamma _1$ and $\gamma _2$ waves. $(a)$ The influence of the parameter $\alpha$ at a fixed value of $r=2$ and $\beta =-0.2$. The curves correspond to $\alpha =0.8$ (blue dashed line), $\alpha =2$ (red solid line) and $\alpha =2$ (green dash-dotted line). $(b)$ The influence of the parameter $\beta$ at a fixed value of $r=2$ and $\alpha =1$. The curves represent $\beta =0$ (blue dashed line), $\beta =-0.1$ (red solid line) and $\beta =-0.2$ (green dash-dotted line). $(c)$ Wave profiles of $\gamma _1$ corresponding to the circles in panel $(a)$. $(d)$ Wave profiles of $\gamma _2$ corresponding to the circles in panel $(a)$.

Figure 3

Figure 4.Effects of wind parameters on the $r{-}c$ diagrams for $\gamma _2$ waves. $(a)$ With $\beta$ fixed at 0 and $\alpha$ varying: $\alpha =0$ (blue), $\alpha =1$ (red) and $\alpha =2$ (green). $(b)$ With $\alpha$ fixed at 1 and $\beta$ varying: $\beta =0$ (green), $\beta =-0.2$ (blue) and $\beta =-0.4$ (red). $(c)$ Wave profiles corresponding to the circles in panel $(b)$.

Figure 4

Figure 5.$(a)$ The $\beta\!-\!c$ bifurcation curve for $\gamma _2$ waves at $r=3$ and $\alpha =1$. $(b)$ Representative wave profiles corresponding to the circles in panel $(a)$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Effects of wind parameters on the $r{-}c$ bifurcation curves for $\gamma _1$ waves. $(a)$ With $\beta$ fixed at 0 and $\alpha$ varying: $\alpha =0$ (blue), $\alpha =1$ (red) and $\alpha =2$ (green). $(b)$ With $\alpha$ fixed at 1 and $\beta$ varying: $\beta =0$ (green), $\beta =-0.2$ (blue) and $\beta =-0.4$ (red). $(c)$ Wave profiles corresponding to the circles in panel $(b)$.

Figure 6

Figure 7.$(a)$ The $\beta\!-\!c$ bifurcation curve for $\gamma _1$ waves at $r=3$ and $\alpha =1$. $(b)$ Representative wave profiles corresponding to the circles in panel $(a)$.

Figure 7

Figure 8.Dependence of the second-order growth rate $g_m^{(2)}$ on the normalised wavenumber $k^*=k/k^+$. $(a)$ In the subcritical regime with $r=0.5$, $\beta =-0.2$ and varying $\alpha$: $\alpha =2$ (solid line), $\alpha =2.5$ (dash-dotted line) and $\alpha =3$ (dashed line). $(b)$ In the supercritical regime with $r=2$, $\beta =-0.2$ and varying $\alpha$: $\alpha =0.5$ (solid line), $\alpha =1$ (dash–dotted line) and $\alpha =2$ (dashed line).

Figure 8

Figure 9.Dominant secondary growth rates and the corresponding streamwise wavenumbers $\hat {k}_x$. A comparison between theoretical predictions and numerical Floquet stability results: longitudinal disturbances (solid lines), oblique disturbances (dash-dotted lines) and theoretical predictions (dashed lines). (a,c) subcritical flow with $r=0.5$, $\alpha =2$ and $\beta =- 0.2$; (b,d) supercritical flow with $r=2$, $\alpha =2$ and $\beta =-0.2$.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Dependence of $g_{k/2,2}$ and $g_{k/2,4}$ on the normalised wavenumber $k^*=k/k^+$. In the left panels, we depict the subcritical flow for $r=0.5$ and $\beta =-0.2$, with varying values of $\alpha$: $\alpha =2$ (solid lines), $\alpha =2.5$ (dash–dotted lines) and $\alpha =3$ (dashed lines). In the right panels, we present the supercritical flow for $r=2$ and $\beta =-0.2$, with varying values of $\alpha$: $\alpha =0.5$ (solid linear), $\alpha =1$ (dash–dotted lines) and $\alpha =2$ (dashed lines).

Figure 10

Figure 11.Secondary growth rate $\textrm{Re} (g_r)$ as a function of $k^*$ and $\hat {k}_y$: $(a)$ subcritical flow with parameters set to $r=0.5$, $\alpha =2$ and $\beta =-0.2$, and $(b)$ supercritical flow with parameters set to $r=2$, $\alpha =2$ and $\beta =-0.2$. The solid lines indicate the fastest-growing spanwise wavenumber $\hat {k}_{y,m}$ obtained through numerical computations, while the dash-dotted lines represent the corresponding predictions from (5.19).

Figure 11

Figure 12.Secondary growth rate $\textrm{Re} (g_r)$ for different values of $\alpha$. $(a)$ Subcritical flow with $r=0.5$, $\beta =-0.2$ and varying $\alpha$: $\alpha =2$ (blue), $\alpha =2.5$ (red) and $\alpha =3$ (green). $(b)$ Supercritical flow with $r=2$, $\beta =-0.2$ and varying $\alpha$: $\alpha =1$ (blue), $\alpha =1.5$ (red) and $\alpha =2$ (green). The solid lines indicate the growth rate of longitudinal secondary disturbances, while the dash-dotted lines correspond to oblique secondary disturbances.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Secondary growth rate $\textrm{Re} (g_r)$ for different values of $\beta$. $(a)$ Subcritical flow with $r=0.5$, $\alpha =2.5$ and varying $\beta$: $\beta =-0.2$ (blue) and $\beta =-0.8$ (red). $(b)$ Supercritical flow with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$ and varying $\beta$: $\beta =-0.2$ (blue) and $\beta =-0.8$ (red). The solid lines indicate the growth rate of longitudinal secondary disturbances, while the dash-dotted lines correspond to oblique secondary disturbances.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Behaviour of secondary instability of $\gamma _1$ waves for $\lambda ^r_{k^+/2}\lt 0$, with parameters set to $r=0.01$, $\alpha =2.1$ and $\beta =-0.2$: oblique disturbances (red dash–dotted lines), longitudinal disturbances (blue solid lines) and the fastest-growing transverse wavenumber $\hat {k}_{y,m}$ (brown solid line). $(a)$ Streamwise wavenumber $\hat {k}_x$ of the most unstable secondary mode. $(b)$ Growth rate $\textrm{Re} (g_r)$ of the most unstable secondary mode. $(c)$ Secondary growth rate $\textrm{Re} (g_r)$ as a function of $k^*$ and $\hat {k}_y$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Behaviour of secondary instability of $\gamma _2$ waves with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$ and $\beta =-0.2$: oblique disturbances (red dash–dotted line), longitudinal disturbances (blue solid line) and the fastest-growing transverse wavenumber $\hat {k}_{y,m}$ (brown solid line). $(a)$ Streamwise wavenumber $\hat {k}_x$ of the most unstable secondary mode. $(b)$ Secondary growth rate $\textrm{Re} (g_r)$ as a function of $k^*$ and $\hat {k}_y$.

Figure 15

Figure 16.Secondary growth rates of $\gamma _2$ waves for varying $\alpha$ and $\beta$: longitudinal secondary disturbances (solid lines) and oblique disturbances (dash–dotted lines). $(a)$ Parameters are set to $r=2$, $\beta =-0.2$ and varying $\alpha$: $\alpha =1$ (blue), $\alpha =1.5$ (red) and $\alpha =2$ (green). $(b)$ Parameters are set to $r=2$, $\alpha =1$ and varying $\beta$: $\beta =-0.1$ (blue), $\beta =-0.15$ (red) and $\beta =-0.2$ (green).

Figure 16

Figure 17.Evolution of a family of $\gamma _1$ waves triggered by a Gaussian wave packet, with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$ and $\beta =-0.8$. The solid lines represent results from time-dependent numerical simulations, while the dashed line corresponds to an exact steady-state solution obtained via the Newton–Raphson iteration.

Figure 17

Figure 18.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _1$ wave with parameters $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.9$, perturbed by a modulation with $A_s=10^{-3}$, $k_x=0.5k$ and $k_y=0.28k$: $t=1$ ($a$), $t=43$ ($b$) and $t=45$ ($c$). The blue and red colours indicate surface depressions and elevations, respectively. $(d)$ Energy as a function of time. $(e)$ The corresponding phase diagram. A checkerboard-symmetric pattern develops following the secondary instability.

Figure 18

Figure 19.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _1$ wave with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.83$, under a longitudinal perturbation with $A_s=10^{-3}$, $k_x=0.5k$ and $k_y=0$. $(a)$ Contour plot at $t = 300$. $(b)$ The $y=0$ cross-section at $t=300$: time-dependent simulation (solid line) and exact steady solution (dashed line). $(c)$ Energy as a function of time.

Figure 19

Figure 20.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _1$ wave with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.83$, under an oblique perturbation with $A_s=10^{-3}$, $k_x=0.5k$ and $k_y=0.42k$: $t=1$ ($a$), $t=28$ ($b$) and $t=33$ ($c$).

Figure 20

Figure 21.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _1$ wave with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.8$, under an oblique perturbation with $A_s=0.2$, $k_x=k$ and $k_y=0.4k$. $(a)$ Contour plot at $t=1$. $(b)$ Contour plot at $t=50$. $(c)$ The $y=0$ cross-section at $t=300$: time-dependent simulation (solid line) and exact steady solution (dashed line).

Figure 21

Figure 22.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _1$ wave with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$, and $k^*=0.47$, under an oblique perturbation with $A_s=10^{-3}$, $k_x=0.5k$ and $k_y=0.6k$: $t=100$ ($a$), $t=250$ ($b$) and $t=300$ ($c$). $(d)$ Energy evolution.

Figure 22

Figure 23.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _1$ wave with $r=0.01$, $\alpha =2.1$, $\beta =-0.2$, and $k^*=0.95$, under an oblique perturbation with $A_s=10^{-3}$, $k_x=0.25k$, and $k_y=0.05k$: $t=53$ ($a$), $t=600$ ($b$), and $t=800$ ($c$). $(d)$ Energy evolution.

Figure 23

Figure 24.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _1$ wave with $r=0.01$, $\alpha =2.1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.621$, under an oblique perturbation with $A_s=10^{-3}$, $k_x=k/3$ and $k_y=0.05k$: $t=50$ ($a$), $t=150$ ($b$), $t=200$ ($c$), $t=250$ ($d$), $t=500$ ($e$) and $t=1000$ ($f$). $(g)$ Energy evolution.

Figure 24

Figure 25.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _2$ wave with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.5$, under a transverse perturbation with $A_s=10^{-1}$, $k_x=0$ and $k_y=0.1k$: $t=1$ ($a$), $t=100$ ($b$) and $t=1000$ ($c$). $(d)$ The $y=0$ cross-section at $t=1000$: time-dependent simulation (solid line) and exact steady solution (dashed line). $(e)$ Energy evolution.

Figure 25

Figure 26.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _2$ wave with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.5$, under an oblique perturbation with $A_s=10^{-3}$, $k_x=0.5k$ and $k_y=0.1k$: $t=10$ ($a$), $t=20$ ($b$) and $t=500$ ($c$).

Figure 26

Figure 27.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _2$ wave with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.5$, under an oblique perturbation with $A_s=10^{-3}$, $k_x=0.25k$ and $k_y=0.5k$: $t=1$ ($a$), $t=150$ ($b$) and $t=300$ ($c$).

Figure 27

Figure 28.Surface evolution of a $\gamma _2$ wave with $r=2$, $\alpha =1$, $\beta =-0.2$ and $k^*=0.05$, under a transverse perturbation with $A_s=10^{-2}$, $k_x=0$ and $k_y=0.1k$: $t=1$ ($a$), $t=7$ ($b$), $t=14$ ($c$), $t=30$ ($d$), $t=50$ ($e$) and $t=70$ ($f$).