In the forty-five years since Roland Barthes declared the death of the Author, the disciples of literature and performance have struggled against long-standing traditions of centralized meaning, seeking to wrest control and claim subjective interpretive power from the godlike grasp of an omnipotent, omniscient artist-creator. Yet, in the arena of theatrical performance, the advent of the modern director's role at the end of the nineteenth century and its continued organic development over the past century or so have given rise to a new category of potential arbiter of signification onstage: the auteur. Avra Sidiropoulou's deceptively slim Authoring Performance explores the analytical and cultural tensions that fractured the role of the Western director in the late twentieth century, leading to what she refers to as the contemporary function of the “‘director-author’” (4). She asserts that this tension is often localized within the increasingly fluid nature of postmodern dramatic texts, whose rejection of realism, classical codes of representation, and linear structure facilitate—indeed, necessitate—a secondary voice that can bring physical shape to these works in performance.
The book is divided into an introduction, six theoretical-historical chapters (comprising the bulk of the book) that focus on the rise of the auteur in the twentieth century, and an excellent appendix of six contemporary case studies. In its first chapter, “The Rise of the Modern Auteur,” Sidiropoulou's painstaking research into the development of the director's theatrical function deserves praise for its concise packaging and intelligent presentation. Of particular note is her discussion of early design innovators such as Gordon Craig and Adolphe Appia. Yet, significant gaps appear in this chronology, such as the short shrift (almost to the point of exclusion) she grants to influential vanguard artists such as Konstantin Stanislavsky and Jerzy Grotowski. While Grotowski's “poor theatre” arguably deserves comparable attention to her later examinations of absurdism and the “theatre of cruelty” (in Chapters 2 and 3), one could reasonably make the case that Stanislavsky's attention to realism disqualifies his inclusion in a discussion of avant-garde theatrics, despite the fact that he devoted the last stage of his career to more experimental modes of performance. Although Sidiropoulou's work on the early auteurs she does engage is very strong, as I read the first chapters I could not help but wonder, again and again, about who and what else had been left out, and why.
I also found myself struggling to understand the book's title in light of its actually quite historical focus. Though this entry in Palgrave Macmillan's What Is Theatre? series purports to consider the function of the “contemporary” director, Sidiropoulou does not specify what temporal parameters comprise the “contemporary” in her volume, nor does she clarify the nomenclature of the “director” proper: a full third of her volume is devoted to the work of dramatist-theorists Antonin Artaud and Samuel Beckett, both of whom often staged their own texts but whose primary identities reside more within the world of dramaturgy than of directing. Thus, without a clear indication of what both “contemporary” and “director” mean for her purposes, their appearance here is at times puzzling. Further, not until Chapters 4 and 5 does Sidiropoulou actively engage in a detailed aesthetic examination of the processes of directors working over the past three to four decades. While her goal is to establish Artaud and Beckett as stylistic predecessors to auteurs such as Peter Brook, Robert Wilson, Richard Foreman, and Anne Bogart, and while this goal is indeed a valuable one, such focused emphasis on early- to mid-twentieth-century drama in the bulk of the volume feels disingenuous given the book's title. Once more, the result is that readers may feel keenly what is missing: for example, a brief description of JoAnne Akalaitis's infamous ART production of Beckett's Endgame (which I would think supports the book's thesis about the nature of contemporary auteurism as clearly as any example in recent memory) reads more like a footnote than a key intersection of the (post)modern and contemporary.
At the heart of Sidiropoulou's argument is the tension between text and performance/playwright and director that marks twentieth-century avant-garde performance, and that ultimately leads the auteur director to abandon fidelity to authorial intent, and the avant-garde playwright to abandon Aristotelian cohesion of action, character, and language. Sidiropoulou struggles with this tension on every page, sometimes vigorously but sometimes in a way that seems to privilege the playwright—the figure who, according to the lore of the auteur, is supposed to be increasingly irrelevant in modern theatrical practice—as director, generating a paradox that threatens to undermine her central thesis. This is not to say that Sidiropoulou's theoretical approaches are misdirected or flawed, but merely to signal an imbalance of attention in her analysis: because she has preferred to focus on experimental dramatic texts, often at the expense of other forms of postdramatic performance equally important to a discussion of contemporary auteurism, she offers a view of the “contemporary director” that skews strangely at times toward the playwright.
I have taken issue with the specific historical focus of Sidiropoulou's analysis, given her title and her apparent intentions for the book, but nevertheless there is much extremely good work here. In particular, Sidiropoulou appends to the primary text of Authoring Performance a series of six excellent case studies of contemporary auteur directors, including behind-the-scenes glimpses into works by British company Complicite; by the NYC mainstay of the theatrical avant-garde, The Wooster Group; and by director Ivo van Hove. The writing in the appendix is clear and passionate, devoid of the overanalytical jargon of critical theory and directly honing in on the director's practical role in the creation of performance, be it textually derived or collaboratively devised as an original work. I wish these case studies had formed the basis of the main body of the book, but without doubt even in their shortened appendix form they will prove valuable for readers and especially for students.
Despite some shortcomings in maintaining its intended focus, Authoring Performance: The Director in Contemporary Theatre is a welcome, extensively researched addition to the bookshelves of scholars of performance studies and theatrical semiotics. Unfortunately, while directors and students of directing may find value in Sidiropoulou's historical surveys and case studies, her dense concentration on dramaturgy and critical theory may vex them and leave them wondering whether they are the volume's fundamental audience.
