The topic of reconciliation is often discussed in the context of settlement of internal conflicts, which constitute a great majority of armed conflicts in the contemporary world. But the author of Reconciling Enemy States in Europe and Asia, Seunghoon Emilia Heo, focuses upon the relationship between states or nations. While exploring conceptual and theoretical issues of reconciliation, Heo illuminates examples of relations between traditionally antagonistic nation-states such as France and Germany in Europe and Japan and South Korea in Asia. It seems that his main interest lies in the Asian example. Given the achievement of reconciliation in Europe, Heo asks if Asian countries will follow suit.
The value of the book is to bring the perspective of reconciliation in the relations between states. When we discuss reconciliation in the context of domestic society, we tend to identify individuals who are the stakeholders of possible or desirable reconciliation. We naturally analyze the psychological aspects of individuals and groups of victims and perpetrators, and so on. The topic of reconciliation between nation-states is much more abstract and requires a different level of analysis. How do politically organized groups of human beings achieve collective reconciliation? Heo tackles this fundamental question.
While elaborating upon various conceptual and theoretical discussions on reconciliation between nation-states as well as various episodes and citations concerning ‘enemy states’ in Europe and Asia, the book tries to provide a clue to how multiple nation-states could achieve what we may understand as reconciliation. Individuals could achieve reconciliation in their own terms. But do we need political benchmarks in order to make sure reconciliation is achieved? Or do we rely upon more subjective assessments of those who constitute the nation-states concerned?
The author begins with the book in Chapter 1 by asking the question of ‘why reconciliation’ in international relations. Traditionally, reconciliation is not a term to analyze international relations. But Heo argues that it is important to discuss reconciliation in international relations, as it is important to discuss sustainable peace beyond simple coexistence. While a simple lack of war does not promise sustainable peace, reconciliation should terminate sources of further conflicts and solidify sustainable peace. Heo insists that international relations or political science thus ought to pay more attention to the topic of reconciliation.
Chapter 2 defines the framework of the book. The author indicates that the concept of ‘enemy’ does not exclusively apply to military enemies. Nation-states create images of enemy in their opposing relations in ideological, political, and cultural terms. So, the book deals with the relationship between some particular nation-states which have enemy-like relations with each other. Heo argues that two nation-states can be described as ‘hereditary enemy states’ when they had traumatic historical events in the past, have an hostile public mood at present, and might have hostile national strategies in the future.
Chapter 3 moves on to discuss reconciliation. After looking at some seemingly relevant concepts ranging from alliance, appeasement, coexistence, détente, normalization, rapprochement to special relations, the book defines reconciliation as ‘the most cooperative behaviour between hereditary enemy states that implies both people and state of each side to transform their mutual relations from a state of war toward a state of peace’. The transformation from a state of war to a state of peace cannot be achieved through a simple lack of war. Reconciliation is the key to achieve sustainability of peace.
Chapter 4 discusses an ideal type of interstate reconciliation. The author seeks to analyze interstate reconciliation at the systemic level, regional level, and domestic level. While external pressures and structural constraints at the systemic level and institutional frameworks at the regional level are important, domestic factors are the most essential issues for reconciliation. Heo distinguishes between ‘state-to-state reconciliation’ and ‘people-to-people reconciliation’. The former includes ‘politico-diplomatic’ and ‘economic’ reconciliation among state actors, while the latter includes ‘socio-cultural’ and ‘historical’ reconciliation among civil society actors. Heo also argues that a positive interplay among and between state actors and people is indispensable.
Chapter 5 attempts to provide varieties of interstate reconciliation. The author goes on to discuss ‘quantitative typology’ and ‘qualitative typology’. According to the author, the quantitative typology is intended to find the degree of reconciliation in the process of the development of a state-led reconciliation process from diplomatic normalization, economic cooperation to defense alliance and that of a people-led reconciliation process from socio-cultural interaction to historical reconciliation. The qualitative typology is intended to analyze sources of reconciliation of various cases. The author then looks at power relations between two states, such as asymmetric, symmetric, and transitional relationships. He also discusses the difference between reconciliation after war, reconciliation after colonial experience, and reconciliation after ethnic, religious, and cultural conflicts.
In conclusion, the author argues that hereditary enemy states continue to have unstable relations without reconciliation, and, thus, more research is needed on the topic of reconciliation in international relations. Finally, Heo emphasizes the contrast between Europe represented by France, Germany, and England, and Asia represented by Japan, South Korea, and China.
The book's attempt to bring reconciliation back into international relations ought to be appreciated, given the cotemporary complexity of relations among states in ideological, political, and cultural terms. In developing the path cultivated by Heo, there should be some more suggestions. First, a solid concrete case study is required. Heo often mentions various examples of what he calls hereditary enemy states. But more concrete discussions would have to substantiate his argument. Second, Heo presupposes the existence of nation-states in the world, while illustrating the discrepancy between state and people. It seems that the determination of a unit of analysis requires a careful consideration. Not all the existing nation-states have stable and permanent bases in the contemporary world. Third, the comparison between Europe and Asia is attractive, but in the end a stereotype. It is not really certain that Europe is an ideal example of reconciliation between states. In the end, it seems that the author's main interest lies in the Asian case of reconciliation between Japan and South Korea. If so, a further detailed application of his model to the case will be highly welcomed.
