From the Iranian Green Movement in 2009 to the “Arab Spring” in 2011–2012, the role of new media in political uprisings in the Middle East/North Africa (MENA) region has been extensively debated among scholars and critics. Published case studies often focus upon the ways use of Internet and social media platforms such as Twitter and Facebook have expanded protest expression in challenging authoritarian states. While examining the platforms and the social media data they generated was a necessary first step in understanding the outbreak of these revolutionary movements, existing studies failed to provide a nuanced analysis of the events leading to political upheaval or to examine the digital resistance in context. Mohamed Zayani's Networked Publics and Digital Contention, The Politics of Everyday Life in Tunisia reveals the missing historical and contextual perspective of the Tunisian Revolution. The author offers a complex investigation of the social, political, and technological dynamics that led to the fall of the long-standing autocrat in the country and consequently inspired the insurgence in the region.
Rather than championing the emancipatory potential of new media technologies, the book's overarching theme is the relationship between everyday life, digital culture, youth activism, online resistance, and political agency. To Zayani, what people do on the Internet is as important as what they do with the Internet [emphasis in the original] (12). Rooted in extensive fieldwork in Tunisia from 2011–2013, he maps out the ways by which the online resistance that emerged in the decade prior to the uprisings fostered new political sensibilities, experiences, and actions, gradually prompted a digital culture of contention, and ultimately altered the nature of political action in Tunisia. As such, the ordinary, daily online conversations and self-expressions on discussion boards, forums, and blogs are among the major focuses of the book. Zayani argues that Tunisian youths’ digital chronicles and apolitical discussions of everyday life were essentially political. The micro contentions cultivated “the self as a project and narrative—one that rested on a unique communicative experience and provided anchorage for the virtual” (109). The author's examples demonstrate that active involvement and participation online gradually transformed and propelled alternative forms of political action different from traditional strategies and political groups (119). As the country's use of the Internet evolved from a space for social connectivity to a site of political action, collective advocacy for freedom of expression, citizenship, and democracy also grew.
In exploring the various forms of digital resistance preceding the ouster of President Zine al-Abidine Ben Ali in January 2011, Zayani reveals that the opposition silenced through the regime's mechanisms of control became empowered through online exchanges that ultimately redefined citizen participation and political activism. The control imposed by Ben Ali's regime unwittingly inspired a creative assertiveness and resistance among Internet users. To overcome the state's repressive laws against freedom of speech, online citizens negotiated their political agency through “artful contentions,” using words, images, and video in creative, symbolic, and literary forms of expression. The artful contentions offered “incisive commentary on the writers’ lived reality” (124). Borrowing from Michel de Certeau's The Practice of Everyday Life (1984), Zayani maintains that artful contentions and bloggers’ playful, subversive approaches “deflect the power of a system one lacks the means to challenge; they make it possible ‘to escape a social order without leaving it’” (125).
The study of the evolution of the Tunisian blogosphere in Chapter 5 is especially worthwhile. Reminiscent of the development of the blogosphere in other MENA countries such as Iran and Egypt, Zayani shows how the micro acts of transgression and civil disobedience on Tunisian's weblogs enabled the youth to build a collective identity independent from, and parallel to, the dominant political discourse. The author's examination of daily life bloggers reveals that among Tunisian youth “a new consciousness of what was politically possible started to take hold” (108). As the chapter lays out, the significance of the growing assertiveness of the Tunisian blogosphere in the 2000s was not in its ability to bring about political action but in that it led to a new form of political identity online. The blogosphere provided a vital infrastructure for demanding freedoms and for the initial stages of protest against the Ben Ali government, giving rise to a new space for contestation (107).
Networked Publics and Digital Contention is a comprehensive sociological, historical, and political probe of Tunisia's contemporary history in the Digital Age. It also offers a substantial contribution to the study of the region and its rapidly evolving definition of political processes, agency, and democratic culture in the age of global networks. Considering the ephemeral nature of online communication, the book not only preserves Internet history but also provides a much-needed theorization of citizenship and sociopolitical experiences in twenty-first-century MENA. After more than half a decade since the Tunisian Revolution, however, a new edition of the book including an afterthought chapter on the post-revolutionary state of the country and the political life of the ordinary citizens would further benefit the reader.
