Almost forty years ago Donald Bullough, in a paper read before the Society, drew attention to the importance of the Ludus de Antichristo for our understanding of twelfth-century society. He argued that the Ludus illustrates not only the role of ritual and drama in the high Middle Ages (which was the focus of his paper), but also the frequently overlooked contribution of apocalyptic thought to intellectual life of the period.Footnote 1 His point, as I take it, was that apocalyptic and prophetic literature played a key role in contemporary society and that it was modern, not medieval, sensibilities which had led to this being sidelined in discussions of such subjects as the Twelfth-Century Renaissance. Now, since Bullough's day much work has been done to redress this imbalance; nevertheless, a degree of resistance to the study of apocalypticism remains. As recently as the late 1990s, the response of a senior academic to a paper on eschatology within Carolingian court circles was outright denial: ‘I cannot believe that Charlemagne had anything at all to do with eschatological matters.’Footnote 2 Less overt, but arguably no less revealing, is Knut Görich's recent biography of Frederick Barbarossa – at or around whose court Bullough and many others, both before and since, have placed the performance of the Ludus – which says nothing whatsoever about eschatology.Footnote 3 The following paper seeks to challenge such reticence, building on recent work on medieval apocalypticism. Particular inspiration has come from studies of Charlemagne's reforming efforts of the eighth and ninth centuries, which argue that religious and political correctio were motivated in part by eschatological concerns.Footnote 4 Important from a slightly different angle is work on apocalyptic traditions in the high Middle Ages, which highlights the dynamic contribution of eschatology to movements as diverse as church reform, the crusades and the missionary efforts of the mendicant orders.Footnote 5
Indeed, eschatology was an existential matter in the Middle Ages: it was widely believed that the world was in its sixth (and final) age and that the end might come at any point. There was nothing unorthodox about this: Augustine of Hippo taught that the world had entered its sixth and final age upon the incarnation and authorities such as Gregory the Great expressed the expectation that little if any time remained before this. That not only monks and bishops but also kings and noblemen held such beliefs should not be doubted. From its inception, the office of kingship was influenced by ecclesiastical ideals and by the Carolingian period it was understood as a form of God-given ministry (or ministerium), much like episcopal office.Footnote 6 Taking inspiration from the Church Fathers (in particular Augustine and Gregory), manuals were written for laymen in order to teach them in the implications of this ministry. The central message was that with power comes responsibility, since leaders will have to answer for the souls of those entrusted to them at the Day of Judgement.Footnote 7 Rulers therefore had every reason to be concerned about the end of time and it is simply absurd to suggest that Charlemagne would not have had any interest in such matters – regardless of whether he harboured apocalyptic expectations about anno mundi 6000 (that is, ad 800/1), as has been suggested,Footnote 8 the one thing we can be fairly certain is that he would have given considerable thought to the Last Judgement and the fate of his soul.
To illustrate the benefits of taking eschatology seriously as a factor in medieval politics, I should like to examine the role of apocalyptic thought at the court of Otto III of Germany (983–1002). This subject has generally been subsumed into debates regarding the turning of the first millennium and the fears which some scholars claim were attendant upon this. As a consequence, opinion is highly polarised: whilst some ascribe great significance to the ‘apocalyptic year 1000’, seeing this as the driving force behind heightened apocalyptic expectation in Otto III's reign, others deny that such an increase in eschatological interests can be seen at all.Footnote 9 Indeed, the issue has become so fraught that Otto's most recent scholarly biographer, Gerd Althoff, avoids it altogether.Footnote 10 However, as is so often the case, it may not so much be the answers which historians are receiving as the questions we are asking which are wrong here. Sources from Otto III's reign say nothing explicit about the turning of the year 1000 and it is therefore impossible to establish with certainty what he and his contemporaries thought about this.Footnote 11 Nevertheless, there is ample evidence for heightened eschatological interest and expectation, as I hope to show.
In what follows, my focus shall be on events between 996 and Otto's death in 1002, with discussion framing the emperor's actions in the year 1000 within broader developments in his reign. These were, of course, the years of the famed renovatio imperii Romanorum (i.e. ‘renewal of the empire of the Romans’) and though it has long been noted that this project may have been apocalyptic in inspiration, the details have yet to be explored fully. Discussion will proceed chronologically, tracing the events of Otto's reign and the role of eschatological thought therein. The argument presented, it must be emphasised, is aggregate: any individual piece of evidence might quite reasonably be called into question; however, the cumulative impression is, I hope, persuasive.
We shall begin in 996 with Otto's first trip to Italy. Like all Saxon rulers since the time of his grandfather, Otto I, Otto III laid great store in obtaining the imperial title and began making plans for his coronation in Rome from the start of his independent reign (which seems to have begun gradually over 994–5).Footnote 12 Initially, he was held back by affairs on his eastern border, but by 996 Otto was able to proceed south. Upon arrival in Italy, he found that the pope, John XV, had passed away and arranged to have his chaplain Bruno appointed Pope Gregory V, a move which paved the way for his own imperial coronation on 21 May. Of particular interest from our present standpoint is the fact that the Miracula S. Alexii report that Otto wore a cloak bearing images of the Apocalypse (of John) on this occasion, which he subsequently donated to the monastery of Boniface and Alexius on the Aventine.Footnote 13 This was clearly a sumptuous item and its importance is twofold: first, it suggests that Otto began his imperial reign with eschatological considerations in mind; and secondly, it may imply an association between these and SS Boniface and Alexius. The significance of this latter point will become clearer as we proceed, but at present we should simply note that the monastery had offered refuge to Otto's friend and associate Adalbert of Prague in the later 980s and early 990s. Indeed, it was at this point that Otto first met Adalbert – an event which apparently made a deep impression on the emperor – and it may be that the Bohemian bishop introduced the newly crowned ruler to the centre.Footnote 14 However, the emperor was soon drawn back north of the Alps; Adalbert, on the other hand, who had been ordered by synodal decree to return to Prague, was only able to visit Otto briefly at Aachen before departing eastwards.
The events of the following year are particularly important. When Adalbert failed once more to establish himself at Prague he took up the mission to Prussia, where he found his martyrdom in 997. News of this reached Otto in autumn, while he was staying at Aachen once more, and his reaction was swift: he founded a monastery in honour of saint and began taking measures to promote his cult, including commissioning a Vita (perhaps from the pen of Bishop Notker of Liège).Footnote 15 The significance of these events lies in the nexus visible in the following years between Aachen, the memory of Charlemagne, the cult of St Adalbert and apocalyptic expectation. Indeed, not only did Otto found a monastery dedicated to Adalbert at this juncture, but he also initiated a series of changes at Aachen, the nature of which has been a matter of controversy. Thus, while Ernst-Dieter Hehl believes that the emperor intended to establish a bishopric at the site, a plan which he was prevented from realising by his early death, Ludwig Falkenstein argues that Otto's aim was simply to introduce a more ‘Roman’ (stadrömisch) form of liturgical observance and to promote the palace and its environs as an urban centre.Footnote 16 Regardless of which interpretation one favours, there can be no doubt as to Aachen's importance to the emperor; after Rome, it is the location at which he spent the most time during his mature reign.Footnote 17 Otto's love of the palace also drew the attention of his contemporaries: the Annals of Quedlinburg report that it was his favourite centre after Rome and Adabold of Utrecht recalls the emperor's affection for the site.Footnote 18 Otto apparently began making plans for Aachen from the start of his independent reign and his first move to realise these came in early 997, when he secured papal permission to establish a college of cardinals at the Chapel of St Mary.Footnote 19 It was in autumn of this year, when Otto next enjoyed an extended stay at the palace, that further developments can be seen. It was at this juncture that the emperor heard of Adalbert's martyrdom and undertook to propagate the new saint's cult. It was also during this stay that Otto granted the estate of Dortmund to the chapel in a charter which opens with an arenga meditating on the rewards which go to those who restore churches from misfortune and neglect, perhaps reflecting the emperor's troubled state of mind. More importantly (and unusually), this grant is said to have been issued for the memory of not only Otto's parents, but also Charlemagne, which is the first time that the latter's memory is mentioned in an Ottonian diploma.Footnote 20 More extraordinary yet is a second grant in favour of the chapel issued at this point, which was likewise undertaken for the memory of Otto's parents and Charlemagne. This also opens with a lengthy arenga, but here the thoughts expressed are distinctly apocalyptic: Otto meditates on the fragility of life and quotes 1 Corinthians x.11 to the effect that ‘we are those, upon whom the ends of the ages are come’.Footnote 21 Now, we must be careful not to make too much of this; at a literal level the charter expresses little more than the belief, shared by all medieval Christians, that the end is nigh. Nevertheless, there is an unmistakable tone of urgency. Indeed, biblical quotation is rare in Ottonian diplomata (even in arengae) and the specific line cited is not found in any other contemporary charter. Such deviations from standard diplomatic practice are all the more noteworthy in the light of the emperor's known penchant for drafting his own charters – it may well be that this document preserves elements of what Hartmut Hoffmann terms Otto's ‘own dictation’ (Eigendiktat).Footnote 22 The emperor's well-evidenced interest in Aachen makes the proposition especially tempting: if he were to have taken a hand in the formulation of any of his early charters, we should expect it to be in privileges concerning Aachen. Moreover, apocalyptic expressions are often found in documents relating to Aachen, Charlemagne and Adalbert, as we shall see, reinforcing the impression that these details were not included by chance.
Why eschatological expectations might have come to the fore at this point is difficult to ascertain. On a general level, it may be that as the year 1000 drew nigh the end of time was felt to ‘loom dangerously close’ (to paraphrase Johannes Fried): the Apocalypse of John famously predicted that Satan (often interpreted as Antichrist) would be bound for 1,000 years and there are indications that some took this literally to mean 1,000 years from the birth (or death) of Christ.Footnote 23 However, it may also be that Adalbert's death led Otto to consider his own mortality and the fate of his soul: having lost a close friend, it was natural for the emperor's thoughts to stray onto death and judgement. Another factor may have been events in Italy. After Otto's departure in 996, the people of Rome led by Crescentius Nomentanus had risen up and elected John Philagathos, an associate of Otto's mother Theophanu, as (anti-)pope. To make matters worse, in 997 Arduin of Ivrea, a leading north Italian magnate, killed Bishop Peter of Vercelli. As Henry Mayr-Harting notes, such events may have possessed an apocalyptic quality for contemporary observers: it was believed that Antichrist would arise in the East and John was not only Greek, but backed by the Byzantine emperor.Footnote 24 Moreover, it was expected that Antichrist's reign would be preceded by a ‘falling away’ (discessio) from the empire, something which the Roman revolt might have been felt to fulfil. Yet these are not the only biblical prophecies which might be associated with recent events. The so-called Little Apocalypse (Mark xiii, Matt. xxiv and Luke xxi) predicts that false belief will spread and love will grow cold immediately before the end of time and these rebellions might also be seen in such terms – after all, what clearer evidence could there be for love growing cold than the betrayal of John, who may have been one of Otto's tutors?Footnote 25 To make matters more sinister, John was elected in 997, meaning that a reign of three and a half years – the length, that is, that Antichrist was expected to reign – would have taken him into the year 1000.
There are indications that contemporaries did indeed see events in such terms. Thus, the Annals of Quedlinburg term John and Crescentius ‘ministers of Satan’ at this point, a title with clear apocalyptic resonances.Footnote 26 Even more telling is the evidence of Otto's diplomata: in later privileges in favour of Vercelli, Arduin and his followers are termed heresiarchs and any who dare to oppose the bishop are said to be inspired by the devil, terms which, as Matthew Gabriele notes, associate these individuals with the false belief and diabolical machination which were expected to precede Endtime.Footnote 27 Indeed, it is uncommon for Ottonian diplomata to associate malefactors with the devil in this fashion and the source of these sentiments is probably to be sought at court.Footnote 28 This conclusion is supported by the fact that the documents in question were drafted by Leo of Vercelli, one of the emperor's chief advisers.Footnote 29 A similar, albeit more hypothetical connection with court can be postulated for the entry in the Annals of Quedlinburg. This work draws on the (now-lost) Annales Hildesheimenses majores, a contemporary set of annals kept at Hildesheim, whose bishop at the time, Bernward, enjoyed close contacts with court.Footnote 30 Gerbert of Aurillac, another leading royal adviser, may also have harboured such feelings: during earlier struggles over the archbishopric of Reims he had accused Crescentius in similarly apocalyptic terms of being a membrum diaboli.Footnote 31 Hence, though there are no more than hints to work with, it would seem that the events of 997–8 inspired a degree of apocalyptic disquiet within court circles.
Such a cosmic view of these struggles may help explain the emperor's harsh response to them: upon retaking Rome in 998, Otto had John Philagathos blinded, mutilated and driven from the city; Crescentius, on the other hand, he had executed and displayed publicly. The brutality of these acts, which conform ill to the merciful approach which Ottonian rulers generally took to rebels, has long troubled historians. Gerd Althoff suggests that they are to be understood in terms of contemporary societal norms (Spielregeln, or ‘rules of the game’, as he terms them). It was, he argues, only to be expected that mercy would be offered to a rebel once and Crescentius faced harsh punishment because he had broken this rule: he had already opposed Otto during the emperor's first sojourn in Italy and thus by 998 was a ‘repeat offender’. In the case of John, on the other hand, Althoff seems to suggest that he was tainted by association.Footnote 32 Though there is much to be said for this analysis, it faces at least two problems. First, it is dangerously circular: Althoff's belief that rebels could only expect pardon once derives in no small part from the treatment of Crescentius at this point. And second, it fails to explain why contemporaries were so shocked by Otto's behaviour: if the emperor were doing little more than following the established ‘rules of the game’, then it is hard to comprehend such dissatisfaction. In the light of these problems, David Warner has offered an alternative solution: he sees Otto's response as part of his programme of renovatio, designed to represent a return to Roman traditions of criminal punishment.Footnote 33 Viewing these acts in the light of the apocalyptic rhetoric seen at court opens up a further possibility: if Otto understood these struggles in cosmic terms, as a battle against evil, against Antichrist or his forerunners, then his lack of mercy would be perfectly understandable – he was not dealing with men, but ‘heresiarchs’ and ‘ministers of Satan’.Footnote 34
In any case, it was in 997–8 as Otto marched south to retake Rome that the group of advisers which was to characterise the rest of his reign begins to appear at court and it was at this moment that his famed renovatio imperii Romanorum (‘renewal of the empire of the Romans’) seems to have been introduced. Although opinion has shifted away from Percy E. Schramm's idealised vision of this as a conscious programme to renew the Roman Empire of antiquity, there can be no doubt that there is something distinctive about the emperor's actions in the following years.Footnote 35 Thus, soon after Otto retook Rome in April 998 his charters began to be sealed with lead bulls – rather than the wax seals preferred by his predecessors – bearing the device renovatio imperii Romanorum.Footnote 36 The overall appearance of Otto's diplomata also underwent changes at this point, with these documents taking on an ever more ostentatious form.Footnote 37 Indeed, though renovatio was probably neither as coherent nor as programmatic as Schramm imagined, Otto certainly was at pains to emphasise the imperial nature of his authority in these years and a common strand can be traced through his politics, one which repeatedly runs through Rome and Aachen. A flurry of literary patronage is also visible at this point and the resulting works praise the emperor in terms which unmistakably underline the antique nature of his imperium.Footnote 38 Artwork provides further evidence of an interest in Rome and empire and thus, for example, the portrait of Otto in the Munich Gospels (Munich, Bayerische Staatsbibliothek, Clm 4453) portrays the emperor receiving homage from the four constituent parts of his realm, personified as women bearing tribute: Rome, Gaul (i.e. Lotharingia), Germany and the Slavic lands.Footnote 39 That this programme owes something to the Roman rebellion of the previous year is clear: in response to threats, Otto sought to underline his claim to the city. That it followed the example of his predecessors is equally clear: since 962 every East Frankish ruler had achieved imperial status and great store seems to have been placed in this. However, there may also have been something new and decidedly eschatological about renovatio. Not only could the rebellions of 996–8 be seen in apocalyptic terms, but empire, especially in its Roman guise, was intimately associated with eschatology. Since Late Antiquity, the Roman Empire had been identified with the fourth (and final) kingdom signified by the statue's feet of iron and clay in Nebuchadnezzar's dream and the restraining force mentioned in 2 Thessalonians ii.6. With the translatio imperii from Byzantinium to the west these implications had not been lost; such teachings were preserved in authoritative works such as Jerome's biblical commentaries and later writers elaborated on the theme. The Latin renderings of Pseudo-Methodius's Revelationes, the earliest of which began circulating in the eight century, highlight the eschatological role of empire and Adso picked up on this in the mid-tenth century, assuring Queen Gerberga that the end is not yet at hand because the empire remains intact (in the form of the West Frankish kingdom).Footnote 40 That such knowledge was available east of the Rhine is suggested by Thietmar of Merseburg's attempts to reassure his readers that recent reverses are not evidence of Pauline discessio.Footnote 41
A more direct connection between such concepts and Otto's court can be established. The evidence comes from two related manuscripts, which were originally bound together as a single codex and may have belonged to Otto's personal library: Bamberg Staatsbibliothek MSS 22 and 76.Footnote 42 These were both produced at Reichenau and contain illuminated copies of the Books of Daniel, Isaiah and the Song of Songs, along with extracts from Jerome's commentaries. As such, they testify not only to the emperor's interest in the teachings of Daniel and Isaiah, two of the most apocalyptic of Old Testament prophets, but also to his acquaintance with Jerome's teachings on these, including his famous equation of the feet of the statue of Nebuchadnezzar's dream with the Roman Empire.Footnote 43 That Otto's imperial ideals were informed by such thoughts is further suggested by Leo of Vercelli's Versus de Gregorio et Ottone augusto (c. 998), which lists Babylon and Greece amongst the nations subject to Otto. This is, of course, a play on the exegesis of Nebuchadnezzar's dream, according to which the four successive kingdoms signified by the statue were to be those of the Babylonians, Persians, Greeks and Romans.Footnote 44 In fact, this passage is very close to one in Adso's De ortu et tempore Antichristi, as Knut Görich notes.Footnote 45 Yet this is not the only apocalyptic passage in Leo's writings. In the Versus de Ottone et Heinrico (c. 1002) the reference to Heaven and earth changing appearance in sorrow at Otto's death may be an allusion to Christ's prediction that sun and moon will darken before the advent of the Son of Man.Footnote 46 Thus, Leo, who as we have seen had a hand in drafting apocalyptically worded royal charters, clearly appreciated the eschatological implications of Otto's programme of Roman renewal. In fact, it may be more than a coincidence that before his election to Vercelli Leo seems to have witnessed Otto's brutal retaking of Rome in 998. Further evidence for an interest in such matters in these years comes from the Bamberg Apocalypse (Bamberg Staatsbibliothek Msc.Bibl. 140), which was also produced at Reichenau, probably at the emperor's request.Footnote 47
In any case, it is time to return to developments in Rome in 997–8. It was, as we have seen, at this point that the emperor retook the city and treated his enemies unusually harshly, a fact which seems to have occasioned unrest. According to later traditions, two of the leading ascetic figures of the day, Romuald of Ravenna and Nilus of Rossano, criticised the emperor for his actions, calling upon him to repent. Though it is difficult to sort fact from fiction in these accounts – each is designed to praise its respective saint and neither mentions the other – there is clearly a kernel of truth in the opposition they record.Footnote 48 In fact, where both accounts agree is in reporting that the emperor undertook a penitential pilgrimage to Monte Gargano in Lent of the following year (999), an event which fits within his known itinerary. Whilst this act was in part an effort to appease those (such as Romuald and Nilus) who did not approve of Otto's actions, from our perspective it is important as the first of a series of penitential undertakings on the emperor's part.Footnote 49 In this respect, Otto's repentance went beyond political expediency and we should do well to allow for the possibility that he genuinely felt regret and concern. Indeed, Jean-Marie Sansterre argues that these ascetic exercises were an essential part of Otto's renovatio and it is tempting also to associate them with the apocalyptic atmosphere at court.Footnote 50 The connection between penance and apocalypticism should be clear: the nearer the Last Judgement looms, the more urgent is the need for the remission of sin. The choice of pilgrimage site may suggest just this: Monte Gargano boasted the shrine of the Archangel Michael, who was accorded an important role in the Last Days, when he was to announce Christ's arrival and slay the dragon (sometimes identified with Antichrist), as depicted in the Bamberg Apocalypse.Footnote 51 Moreover, as noted, this was not a one-off act: shortly thereafter Otto spent further time in penitential seclusion with Franco of Worms, with whom he undertook a pilgrimage to Subiaco, where he founded a church dedicated to the Archangel and Adalbert (note once more the possible connection between Adalbert and eschatology).Footnote 52
Yet Otto's penitential acts did not end here. Almost immediately after returning from Subiaco in late summer 999, he retired north of Rome to the abbey of Farfa, where he held a meeting with his senior advisers. The importance of this event was first noted by Schramm, who saw therein the archetypal expression of the emperor's renovatio: it was on this occasion, he postulated, that the extraordinary events of the following year were planned.Footnote 53 However, though the meeting itself has attracted much interest, little attention has been given to its immediate context. Indeed, our main sources for this event, two diplomata issued in favour of Farfa, have received remarkably little discussion. This is doubtless because at first glance they seem fairly mundane: petitioned by Abbot Hugh, they grant the abbey fodrum, annul a series of earlier transactions and confirm the abbey's liberty.Footnote 54 Nevertheless, viewed within the context of the emperor's relations with Farfa, these documents take on a much greater significance. Some background is necessary here.Footnote 55 Hugh had first become abbot of Farfa in 997, achieving the post by means of simony. As soon as Otto became aware of this, he had Hugh removed and granted the monastery to a certain Bishop Hugh (probably of Ascoli-Piceno) as a benefice. At this point, he also appointed his chaplain Herpo to oversee affairs at the centre. However, shortly thereafter Otto was prevailed upon by the monks to return the monastery to Abbot Hugh, which he agreed to do under the condition that future successions to the office be decided by free election, confirmed by the emperor.Footnote 56 Otto also confirmed Farfa's holdings and liberty, oversaw a court judgement in its favour and restored some of its lands.Footnote 57 Not long after these events, both Herpo and Bishop Hugh died unexpectedly, a turn of events which triggered a further change of heart on the emperor's part.Footnote 58 He now seems to have come to the conclusion that the placement of the abbey under the oversight of Herpo and Hugh had not only been a political mistake, but also a sin, for which the two had paid the ultimate price.
This was the situation in late September 999 when Otto held his meeting at Farfa. On this occasion, he issued a charter granting the abbey the fodrum due from its lands as well as annulling earlier grants which Bishop Hugh and others had undertaken; eleven days later in Rome, he issued a further diploma confirming Farfa's liberty. It is this latter document which is particularly interesting from our present standpoint. Farfa had received a confirmation of its freedom only shortly before this, so the legal nature of the transaction must have been very much secondary – it was intended to send a message. The text of the diploma contains a detailed narratio describing the plundering of Farfa in previous years and the roles of Bishop Hugh and Herpo therein. It then speaks of the deaths of these two figures and expresses the hope that by restoring the abbey to its former glory the emperor will be able to achieve the remedy of Herpo's soul (Bishop Hugh, however, seems to have inspired no such sympathy). This level of detail is highly unusual, but it is not the only feature which makes this privilege stand out. The document ends with a striking spiritual sanction, which threatens that any who violates its terms will have to answer alongside Otto himself (nobiscum) at the Day of Judgement, when Christ will come to judge the age with fire.Footnote 59 Spiritual sanctions such as this were not a standard part of Italian diplomatic and of all Otto's charters for Farfa this is the only to bear one.Footnote 60 Even more unusual is the reference to future perpetrators facing judgement alongside the emperor – no previous Ottonian diploma contains anything like this, though the sentiment sits well with the penitential actions which Otto had undertaken in the months preceding this. Overall, it is hard not to conclude, as Hartmut Hoffmann has, that this charter was drafted by the emperor himself: Otto felt the need to confirm Farfa's liberty because he feared for the soul of his recently deceased chaplain and was concerned about the implications of Herpo's death for his own salvation.Footnote 61 Thus, this is a performative text in the sense recently outlined by Geoffrey Koziol: its issuing was not so much a legal event, as a highly political (and religious) act.Footnote 62 Indeed, it is possible that the diploma itself was read aloud and presented to Abbot Hugh on this occasion, in which case its unusual features could not have passed unnoticed.Footnote 63
So far my argument has of necessity been largely hypothetical, but as we move into the year 1000 the evidence starts to become more solid. In this year, Otto undertook a second Lenten pilgrimage – another penitential act, it should be noted – to Gniezno in Poland. The parallels between this and the penances of the previous year, which involved pilgrimages to Monte Gargano and Subiaco, should be clear, though they have occasioned little comment.Footnote 64 It is in this context that Adalbert comes to the fore once more: the aim of this journey was to pray at the grave of the martyr, an act which Otto combined with visiting his ally Bolesław Chrobry and founding the first Polish archbishopric.Footnote 65 Otto also apparently received relics of the saint from Bolesław, though not his entire body, as may have been his hope. The timing of these events is important: the emperor visited Adalbert's grave during Lent, the liturgical season of penance, then returned to Quedlinburg for Easter, before proceeding to Aachen for Pentecost. As Knut Görich observes, this itinerary suggests careful planning: Otto evidently wanted to be at Gniezno for Lent, at Quedlinburg for Easter (as was traditional) and at Aachen for Pentecost, a decision which necessitated crossing the Alps in the heart of winter (which was no mean feat in this period).Footnote 66 That this trip was conceived of as part of a conscious programme finds further support in Otto's titulature: throughout much of the journey he bears an otherwise unparalleled imperial style, Otto tercius servus Jesu Christi et Romanorum imperator augustus secundum voluntatem Dei salvatoris nostrique liberatoris (‘Otto III servant of Jesus Christ and emperor augustus of the Romans according to the will of God, the Saviour and our Liberator’). This title, which has been the subject of much discussion, was probably modelled on papal diplomatic, emphasising the emperor's humility and apostolic aims.Footnote 67 Johannes Fried suggests that it also represents a play on the teachings of Daniel and Isaiah, copies of which the emperor may have owned, as we have seen.Footnote 68
It is, therefore, clear that this trip was planned in advance, quite possibly at the Farfa meeting of September 999. That Aachen was the intended destination from the start is suggested by the last two diplomata issued before Otto's arrival in Gniezno. These charters, produced at Regensburg on 6 February, were issued for foundations in Aachen, indicating that the emperor was already looking towards his eventual goal. The first of these is for the community of Marienkapelle and includes not only a reference to the throne which had been established there by Charlemagne, but also a lengthy spiritual sanction, which reads remarkably like the one in the Farfa diploma issued a few months earlier, right down to the tell-tale reference to future malefactors facing judgement alongside Emperor Otto himself (nobiscum). The second, issued for the new foundation of Burtscheid, also contains a spiritual sanction and, though the wording in this case is somewhat more restrained, it too threatens perpetual malediction and anathema at the Day of Judgement.Footnote 69 Thus, once again we see an association between eschatology, Aachen and Charlemagne. Indeed, another diploma referring to the end of time was issued at Aachen shortly after Pentecost, further suggesting an association between such concepts.Footnote 70 Together, these documents demonstrate that the Farfa charter of 999 was not a flash in the pan: it was part of a series of documents in which Otto expresses his anxieties about sin, judgement and the end of time. They recall the emperor's grant of Tiel to the Chapel of St Mary in 997, which, as we have seen, bears an unusually apocalyptic arenga. They also reveal a further connection with Adalbert: not only were two issued during the journey to the saint's grave (and one at Aachen only shortly thereafter), but one was in favour of Burtscheid, whose first abbot, Gregory of Cassano, had spent time with Adalbert at the monastery of Boniface and Alexius in Rome.Footnote 71
It is, however, Otto's own actions at Aachen in this year that are most famous. It was here, upon his return from Gniezno (via Quedlinburg), that the emperor undertook a visit to the resting place of Charlemagne. This is reported independently in three contemporaneous sources – Thietmar's Chronicon, Adémar of Chabannes's Chronicon and the Chronicon Novaliciense – each of which provides a slightly different version of events. Thietmar's account is the shortest, but the nearest both temporally and geographically. It reports that Otto visited Charlemagne's grave secretly at Pentecost because he had doubts as to its location; upon discovering the emperor seated upright on his throne, Otto took a gold cross from his neck as well as a piece of his clothing, but otherwise left the body undisturbed.Footnote 72 More detail is provided by the account of the Aquitanian monk Adémar, who reports that Otto, inspired by a dream in which the location of the emperor's grave was revealed to him, proceeded to have it uncovered. Here, Charlemagne was found seated on his throne, which Otto ordered to be raised up for all present to see. At this point, a canon of the church, who was known for his stature, tried on the emperor's crown, only to find it too large for him; he then compared his leg with that of the dead emperor, only to find that it too was larger than his. These actions were followed by a miracle: the presumptuous cleric's leg was broken. Clearly impressed by this, Otto had the body reburied in the right transept, where it began to be known for its many signs and miracles. The throne, however, was given to Duke Bolesław of Poland in exchange for the arm of St Adalbert.Footnote 73 While more florid, the core details of this account are much the same: there was apparently some uncertainty as to the location of Charlemagne's grave, then once discovered the Carolingian emperor was found seated and some of his accoutrements were taken (in this case his throne rather than clothing). The final report comes from the mid-eleventh-century Chronicle of Novalesa, which claims to be based on the eyewitness account of Count Palatine Otto of Lomello. According to this, Otto III entered Charlemagne's tomb with only two bishops and Count Otto. There, they found the emperor seated upright on his throne ‘as if alive’ (ceu vivus), untouched by the passing of time except for the fact that his fingernails had grown through his gloves and the tip of his nose had fallen off. They proceeded to say a prayer, cut the emperor's nails and replace the tip of his nose in gold before departing.Footnote 74 Once more, we see many of the same elements, albeit with different emphasis: the visit is secret (or small-scale), the emperor is found seated and mementos are taken.
The meaning of these events is not immediately clear. Some have suggested that Otto's visit was modelled on antique traditions, perhaps on Augustus's visit to the sepulchre of Alexander the Great, as recorded by Suetonius.Footnote 75 Others are inclined to be cautious about these accounts, especially where their claims regarding Charlemagne's seated burial are concerned.Footnote 76 However, the most likely explanation to date is that of Knut Görich, who sees this as an abortive attempt to establish a cult of Charlemagne. As Görich points out, all of the accounts contain elements which might be associated with the fostering of a saint's cult. Thus, it was common to visit a saint's body in the hope of finding it uncorrupted and it was normal under such circumstances to take mementos as evidence of the body's uncorrupted nature (these would become relics). The need for secrecy (however nominal) is also understandable within this context: until one knew that the body was uncorrupted (and hence that the individual was indeed a saint), one ran the risk of committing sacrilege by defiling a Christian grave.Footnote 77 Thus, this was a further expression of the emperor's devotion to the memory of Charlemagne and it sits well with his other attempts to glorify Aachen. It is worth reflecting briefly upon the importance of Charlemagne for Otto's plans within this context. The emperor's interest in his Frankish predecessor should be seen in part as an element of his renovatio: Charlemagne was well on his way to achieving legendary status by this period and an interest in his memory went naturally with other efforts at imperial renewal. Otto's interest in the emperor was also consonant with his attempts to spread the cult of Adalbert (to whom a church was dedicated at Aachen) and to encourage the eastern mission: Charlemagne was remembered as the ‘apostle of the Saxons’ and Otto may have conceived of his own missionary endeavours as a continuation of Charlemagne's.Footnote 78 That Otto had the mission in mind when he visited Charlemagne's tomb is suggested by the choice of date: Pentecost was the moment at which the Holy Spirit had descended upon the apostles and prepared them to spread the Word. However, there may also have been an apocalyptic significance to this. Matthew xxiv.14 had predicted that Endtime would come once the Word had been preached to all the nations, a prophecy which endowed all missionary activity with eschatological implications.Footnote 79 Moreover, as Gabriele points out, by this time the memory of Charlemagne was beginning to coalesce with the legendary figure of the Last Emperor. The so-called Legend of the Last Emperor survives in many forms; first attested in the Middle East in the seventh century, it had found its way into the Latin West by the eighth. The Legend drew on the exegetical tradition associating Daniel's fourth kingdom and the restraining force of 2 Thessalonians ii with the Roman Empire, elaborating on this in important fashions.Footnote 80 According to it, a Last World Emperor will reign immediately before the end of time: he will defeat Antichrist's precursors (often designated as Gog and Magog), then lay down his crown in Jerusalem, paving the way for the coming of Antichrist and the Last Judgement. As noted, Charlemagne often came to be identified with the messianic figure of the Last Emperor: as the archetypal ruler (and, after 1165, saint), it was believed that he might come again before the end of time. The accounts of Otto's visit to Charlemagne's grave seem to represent an early stage in this development: they report that the Frankish emperor was found resting, rather than dead (‘almost alive’, as the Chronicon Novaliciense puts it), ready to spring into action.Footnote 81
Of course, to establish such a connection we must be able to demonstrate that Otto or at least those around him were aware of the Legend and in this respect there are a number of tantalising clues. The emperor's mother, Theophanu, came from the Byzantine court, where the Legend was well known (Liudprand of Cremona goes so far as to characterise such prophecies as particularly GreekFootnote 82) and it is conceivable that she acted as a conduit for such knowledge: Theophanu would probably have been acquainted with the Legend and it is not unreasonable to presume that she might have taught her son (and possibly also husband) about this. Indeed, Jean Flori suggests that John Tzimikes, Theophanu's uncle and the reigning emperor at the time of her marriage with Otto II, modelled aspects of his rule on the Legend, in which case the queen might have identified personally with such traditions.Footnote 83 Liudprand's own writings, which preserve a version of the Visions of Daniel (itself a version of the Legend), as well as his activity at the Ottonian and Byzantine courts, provide a further channel whereby such ideas might have reached the Reich. Yet Byzantium is not the only potential source. Another is the Tiburtine Sibyl, the earliest surviving version of which comes from northern Italy and shows signs of having been redacted c. 1000.Footnote 84 An even more likely source is Adso's De ortu et tempore Antichristi, which was written for Queen Gerberga (Otto I's sister and thus Otto III's great-aunt) and enjoyed wide circulation.Footnote 85 Indeed, Alboin dedicated his redaction of this work to Otto's chancellor Heribert of Cologne, so at least one of the emperor's chief advisers seems to have been receptive to (and acquainted with) such literature.Footnote 86 Moreover, as we have seen, Leo of Vercelli's Versus de Gregorio et Ottone augusto may allude to this work, further suggesting that it was known at court. Thus, whilst it is impossible to prove beyond doubt that Otto both knew and identified with the Legend, the evidence in favour of the proposition is strong. What his aims at Pentecost 1000 were, however, remains unclear: it may be that he hoped to take on Charlemagne's mantle, as Gabriele suggests; alternatively, he may simply have wished to honour the man (or indeed saint) who he believed would come to save mankind at the end of time.Footnote 87
It would, therefore, seem that in a number of respects these events constitute the high point of a programme which can be traced back as far as 996. The fact that this peaked precisely at the turn of the millennium inevitably raises the question of what role (if any) hopes and anxieties about the year 1000 had to play therein. Within this context, it should be emphasised from the start that sources from the Reich do not mention any concrete concerns about the passing of this year: they associate the end of time with Pauline discessio (and relate this to contemporary events), they speculate as to the eschatological role of empire and in some cases they may allude to the Legend of the Last Emperor, but at no point do they say anything about the millennium within an eschatological context. While it has been suggested that this reflects a clerical ‘consensus of silence’, inspired by Augustine of Hippo's anti-apocalyptic teaching, such arguments are not only dangerously circular, but presuppose a much wider dissemination of Augustinian eschatology than can be demonstrated.Footnote 88 Indeed, as Jean Flori reminds us, throughout the earlier Middle Ages many writers broke Augustine's strictures (doubtless often unconsciously) when it came to interpreting events in an eschatological light.Footnote 89 Thus when, to pick two of the most famous examples from this period, Wulfstan of York and Thietland of Einsiedeln express the belief that certain dates possess an apocalyptic quality, neither shows any sign of being concerned about reproach – quite the reverse, their awareness of the proximity of these dates seems to have driven them to write.Footnote 90 Hence, if the apocalyptic interests at Otto's court were focused entirely on the turning of the millennium, we should expect to hear rather more about this. Indeed, it is interesting to note that Thietland, whose monastery of Einsiedeln enjoyed close contacts with the Ottonian dynasty, anticipated the end of time coming in 1033 (that is, the millennium of the passion) rather than 1000.
On the other hand, it is clear that Otto's imperial programme reached a highpoint in the year 1000 and even those, such as Görich, who are sceptical about the degree of apocalyptic expectation at court admit that there was something special about this year. However, as Görich is at pains to emphasise, this need not be seen in apocalyptic terms; Otto's actions might have simply constituted a celebration of the thousandth anniversary of Christ's life.Footnote 91 Here is where the limitations of our sources become acute. Though we can be fairly confident that the turning of the millennium was important to the emperor, we cannot be certain what significance he ascribed to it. From our present standpoint, however, what is important to note is that the main competing interpretations need not, in fact, be mutually exclusive: it is entirely conceivable that Otto entertained the possibility that the end of time was at hand (and might come in or around the year 1000), yet also hoped that this was not the case. Indeed, there is no contradiction in seeing his actions both in eschatological terms, as preparation for a potentially imminent end, and in soteriological terms, as a celebration of Christ's salvational message. Such a mixture of hope and concern, apocalyptic expectation and concrete plans for the future is by no means unparalleled.Footnote 92 Medieval prophecy was a response to uncertainty about the future and as such less often led to the unshakable belief in a single future scenario than to efforts to weigh various interpretations.Footnote 93 Theologians and prophetic writers alike tended to hedge their bets when it came to predicting the end and it is more common to find claims to the effect that the events leading up to the Last Times have begun – that love is growing cold and heresy spreading, sometimes even that Antichrist is born or starting to make his influence felt – than that the Apocalypse itself has begun. Indeed, whilst it was widely accepted that Antichrist's reign would last three and a half years, the precise length of the period preceding this was unclear and it was possible to live an entire lifetime (or more) in the belief that this had begun.Footnote 94 Otto III may have possessed a similar perspective to that of the apocalyptic writers of the early twelfth century, many of whom believed that the events leading up to the end of time had begun, yet hoped that pious works might delay or even turn back this process.Footnote 95
Appreciating that eschatological expectation coexisted with other less apocalyptic views of the future helps explain why Otto's own actions send such mixed messages. On the one hand there are, as we have seen, indications that he reckoned with an imminent end: his visit to Charlemagne's tomb, ascetic exercises and the unusual sanctions and arengae in his diplomata all point in this direction. Nevertheless, many of Otto's undertakings suggest the reverse: his efforts to obtain a Byzantine bride are not easy to reconcile with a conviction that the Last Times are at hand; meanwhile, the same charter sanctions which mention judgement and the end of time also include warnings for Otto's successors.Footnote 96 It would be too simplistic to suggest that the emperor's plans for the future negated his eschatological interests (or vice versa); rather, the two sat side-by-side and Otto himself may have seen little contradiction in this. As a ruler, it was less important that his actions conform to a theologically consistent plan than that he reckon with a variety of eventualities, some more apocalyptic than others. In this respect, Otto looks little different from his Byzantine counterpart, Basil II (976–1025), whose regime was influenced by apocalyptic thought, yet who was certainly not prevented from dealing with the normal demands of rule as a consequence. As Paul Magdalino neatly puts it, ‘Basil II, like Otto III, did not spend all of his time rapt in expectation of the Second Coming; he spent a lot of time conducting business as usual, doing things he would have done anyway if the millennium had not been there.’Footnote 97
The year 1000, therefore, may have provided a focus for the eschatological hopes and concerns so evident at Otto's court, but it would be too simplistic to see it as the sole cause of these. Indeed, what is perhaps most striking is the fact that the emperor's imperial plans and apocalyptic interests did not come to an abrupt halt in his final year on the throne (1001). Thus, although the unique style used during the pilgrimage to Gniezno was dropped in late 1000 and the renovatio bull disappeared in 1001, there are numerous indications that Otto's overall programme of renewal was maintained. In particular, a new bull was introduced to replace the old one, bearing the equally programmatic device aurea Roma (‘Golden Rome’), while a new ‘apostolic’ imperial style came into use, developing ideas expressed earlier in the experimental title used during the Gniezno pilgrimage.Footnote 98 More concretely, Otto's final year was dedicated to maintaining his increasingly precarious position in Rome – renovatio was threatened and the emperor's response was action. Continuities can also be seen in other regards. In Hungary, Stephan was consecrated with a crown granted to him by Sylvester II and Otto, probably in 1001, and in the same year Esztergom was elevated to metropolitan status and received relics of Adalbert, developments which clearly relate to Otto's missionary efforts.Footnote 99 The emperor's concerns about sin and repentance, which as we have seen often found expression in his charters, are also visible at this point. Thus, a diploma issued for Hildesheim, which the emperor himself may have drafted, ends with a sanction threatening future malefactors with torment alongside Judas, while a grant in favour of the nunnery S. Salvatore in Pavia is said to have been issued so that the emperor might be freed from the nets of sin and merit eternal life.Footnote 100 This latter document draws specific attention to the presence of a relic of the True Cross at S. Salvatore, perhaps suggesting an association between Otto's patronage of the centre and his actions in the previous year. The True Cross, of course, was often associated with Charlemagne (in part because of his perceived role as Last Emperor). Moreover, interest in the cross (and in particular the True Cross) often went hand in hand with apocalyptic expectation, since the cross was not only the sign of Christ's sacrifice for mankind, but also the symbol of his eventual victory over Antichrist at the end of time. Indeed, the ‘sign of the Son of Man’, mentioned as appearing in Heaven at the Last Times (Matt. xxiv.30), had been associated with the cross since Late Antiquity.Footnote 101
Further evidence for Otto's continuing interest in sin and repentance comes from his actions in Lent 1001, which he spent in penitential seclusion with Romuald at Pereum. On this occasion, Otto is reported not only to have encouraged some of Romuald's monks to take up the mission, but also to have promised to spend the next three years rectifying his errors before retiring to Jerusalem to live as a monk. Although Bruno of Querfurt, who records this promise, clearly has his own agenda (and is at times very critical of Otto), he was present on this occasion so his testimony commands respect.Footnote 102 Indeed, this promise is a poignant expression of the emperor's ascetic ideals and the eschatological perspective which informed them: Jerusalem was to be the location of the Last Judgement and this promise may allude to the Legend of the Last Emperor, who was expected to lay down his crown at Golgotha.Footnote 103 Ultimately, we will never know whether Otto intended to keep this promise, but it certainly gives us an impression of his state of mind as he braced himself to travel south and face the Roman rebellion once more. In any case, he was not much longer for this world: after a brief stay in Tivoli and Rome, which ended with his retreat, Otto fell ill and died in early January 1002. His body was taken north and buried in Aachen at Easter, in an act which probably accorded with his own desires.Footnote 104
To conclude, I should like to return to some of the broader themes touched upon at the start of this paper. There, I suggested that historians have at times been rather reticent when it comes to discussing the eschatological beliefs of their subjects and that a case-study in the reign of Otto III might illustrate the benefits of doing so. As I hope to have demonstrated, Otto's court was deeply influenced by apocalyptic thought and many of the emperor's more unusual actions cannot be understood fully without reference to this: his Lenten pilgrimages and penitential acts; the extraordinary sanctions and arengae in his charters; his love of Aachen and interest in empire; and, of course, his devotion to the memory (and possibly cult) of Charlemagne. Although not all of the evidence surveyed suggests acute apocalyptic angst, it certainly is indicative of a heightened interest in (and probably also expectation of) the end. Examining eschatological beliefs thus provides not only a deeper understanding Otto's reign, but also serves as an antidote to more recent studies, which have been keen to emphasise the emperor's ‘normality’.Footnote 105 Otto had an interest in the end of time that clearly went beyond the typical: it was not every ruler who possessed copies of the Books of Daniel and Isaiah and commissioned illuminated apocalypses, nor was it every ruler who undertook extended penances and identified with the figure of the Last Emperor. Indeed, there is doubtless some truth in Johannes Fried's assertion that no emperor save perhaps Frederick II displayed such a keen interest in the Last Things.Footnote 106
Nevertheless, viewed within a broader perspective Otto III's apocalyptic outlook also owes much to existing traditions. His interest in empire is not so different from that seen under Charlemagne, whose imperial ideals were probably also eschatologically informed.Footnote 107 Indeed, the exegetic tradition associating empire with the end of time was known throughout the earlier Middle Ages and Otto's predecessors, Otto I and Otto II, may also have been aware of this. Moreover, such interests did not disappear upon Otto's death: his successor, Henry II, possessed a cloak embroidered with cosmic images and it has been suggested that he too saw himself as ‘ruler at the end of time’.Footnote 108 Later emperors were more circumspect in this regard, but the eschatological significance of empire remained a potent force. Thus when figures such as Henry IV, Frederick Barbarossa and Frederick II found themselves at odds with the papacy, this was often interpreted in apocalyptic terms.Footnote 109 Otto's more immediate contemporaries also displayed eschatological interests. In England, Wulfstan of York, a leading adviser of King Æthelred ‘the Unready’, famously preached that the end was nigh, while in France the response of Robert the Pious to a bout of blood rain in Aquitaine may reveal a degree of eschatological concern.Footnote 110 More generally, the Peace of God movement is suggestive of a lively interest in sin and judgement amongst the laity of France, Catalonia and the Low Countries in these years (though whether this constitutes evidence of concrete apocalyptic expectation is unclear).Footnote 111 What stands out about Otto III, therefore, is not so much the emperor's interest eschatology per se, as the connections this led him to draw between Rome, the Carolingian past and the end of time. Indeed, even Frederick II, who like Otto seems to have modelled aspects of his rule on the Legend, was less interested in Rome, Aachen and Charlemagne than in crusade, Jerusalem and the Holy Land.Footnote 112
Of course, in isolating apocalypticism for study there is a danger of exaggerating its importance. All of Otto's actions cannot be reduced to cosmic concerns regarding time and eternity and doubtless matters of a more quotidian nature were often foremost on his mind. Nevertheless, to assert that Otto's actions possess an apocalyptic quality need not (and should not) involve excluding other influences – it is simply to point out that we have not understood them fully unless we acknowledge the apocalyptic resonances which would have been so clear to Otto and his contemporaries. Here, in particular, is where the present study seeks to part ways with previous work: it sees apocalypticism as an important part of the emperor's thought-world, but not the only one – eschatology was but one ingredient in the complex mix that made up late Ottonian politics. It is for this reason that we should be cautious about attributing too much causal power to the year 1000: while Otto III's political programme came to a head at this point, other more contingent factors, such as the death of Adalbert and the Roman rebellion, also contributed decisively to his eschatological outlook. In this respect, Paul Magdalino's conclusions regarding the role of eschatological expectation in Byzantine history also hold for Western Europe in these years:
It would certainly be a distortion to register every episode in that past as a tick or a chime in an eschatological clock. But it is equally distorting to close our ears deliberately to the eschatological echoes of worlds and actions produced in a climate of a genuine uncertainty about the future.Footnote 113
Thus, the end of time was certainly not Otto III's only preoccupation, but we do not do him justice unless we acknowledge its importance to him. Whereas some fifty years ago Josef Déer coined the famous dictum that ‘Otto III is not to be understood without Byzantium’,Footnote 114 we might now assert that he is not to be understood without reference to eschatology. Donald Bullough was right: the contribution of apocalyptic thought to society and politics in the Middle Ages is easy to underestimate, but we do so at our peril.
