This book brings together a complex mixture of physical spaces, machines, observation regimes, theories and charts to show how nineteenth-century tidal research – like the related sciences of hydrography and meteorology – connected the world of natural philosophy to the prestige and practices of Britain's maritime empire. The book's structure flows from the littoral zone inland, moving from an investigation of tidal management of the Thames to the world of the metropolitan and academic philosophers who engaged themselves with tidal research in the 1830s and early 1840s. The narrative then widens out again to consider William Whewell's tidal crusade, analysing the networks of tidal collaborators as they spread from college to harbourfront and beyond. It ends with a chapter on Whewell's tidal projects as a self-conscious projection of scientific and technological authority, ‘creating space for the “scientist”’ (p. 236).
The Victorian ambition to reach a detailed understanding of the tides was simultaneously philosophical and practical. Tidal research was in some ways an unusual field, with the general explanation for tides in place since the time of Newton and Halley, but the particular explanation for variation in any one coastal location left in disarray. Assumptions about uniform ocean depth and a homogeneous surface of the globe made Newtonian theory of little practical use. The Bernoulli method of calculating tides based on the position of the moon, developed in the 1740s, did lead to predictions and tide tables, but was notoriously difficult to use. It started with the ‘vulgar establishment’ of a mean hour of high water, which depended on observations specific to each port, and then required fairly sophisticated mathematics to produce predictions. Such difficulties with theory, observation and calculation led to unsatisfactory results, especially for the indented coastline of Britain. Moreover, by the early nineteenth century the development of ports and waterways in the first several decades of industrialization had physically transformed the effect of the tides, often intensifying tidal variation. At the same time, heavier steamships created new navigational needs. Thus, in Britain, a heritage of impressive theoretical explanation coexisted with practical inadequacy, which in turn bred two diverging traditions of expertise – local producers of almanacs and the natural philosophers interested in connecting abstract and particular explanation. With his vivid pictures of ports, charts and men, Reidy analyses how the ‘tidology’ of the 1830s, especially the work of Whewell, attempted to bring these two worlds together.
Reidy's account is particularly valuable as a window into British empirical science. He explores its philosophical justification; its vision of the relationship of theory and observation and computation; its layers of participants; its arguments over funding, collaboration and the exact connection between art and science. Whewell's vision and procedures for studying tidal variation, Reidy shows, shaped his historical and philosophical accounts of natural philosophy and revealed the shape of his imagined ideal world of scientific activity. The story of how and why Whewell got into (and out of) tide research is eminently worth telling; it changes the picture of Whewell as a detached analyst, composing his philosophy from behind the walls of Trinity College. This result is rather ironic, since for Whewell the organization of tidal research manifested an elegantly hierarchical relationship, with men like himself at the top.
Yet somehow the blow-by-blow record of his relationships with the Admiralty and Francis Beaufort, harbour officials, fellow mathematicians, captains and computers, leaves a different impression – not tidy hierarchy but constant back-and-forth. As this point suggests, one of Reidy's major accomplishments in this book is a close study of the world of computers, illuminating their relationship to scientific elites. Equally revealing, though accumulated more incidentally throughout the text, is the account of the influence of the British Association for the Advancement of Science (BAAS) – not its leadership, or its annual pageant, but its cold, hard cash. British tidal research would have foundered several times over without injections from the research committee of that institution. Victorian success in observational networks of all sorts clearly stemmed from the example of the BAAS commitment to such projects, and is underappreciated presumably because subsequent generations worked so hard to create the rationale for public funding of science. Reidy lays claim through such stories to the theme of Victorian scientific collaboration, and his conclusions on collaboration as ideal and as practice are valuable to a wide range of other sciences and other eras.
Reidy also concludes that the story of tidal research testifies to the globalizing vision of Victorian science, citing Whewell's isographic techniques, the 1830s networks for synchronic observation, and a keen sense of natural knowledge as the framework for global commerce and empire. This is familiar historiographical terrain, though no less interesting in its details for that. And yet the overwhelming impression left by this story is of the weight and significance of local conditions and local expertise, and the limited penetration of these by the elite methods and practitioners of natural philosophy. The tidology of the 1830s may have held consequences for future initiatives in government-sponsored science, but it is not really clear that it came to dominate the other world of practical navigational expertise that Reidy lays out so well. Nor was I fully convinced that the enterprise of tidal research led to a decisive reimagining of the ocean as a controlled natural space. Whewell's maps and tables seem powerful in some settings, but papery-thin in others. An ‘end-user’ picture of the authority of the new knowledge of the nineteenth century related to the ocean – who used the new knowledge about magnetism, meteorology, tides and surveying, how and when, at home or abroad – is needed to make this clear. The strengths of this book instead lie with the rich picture of the organization and production of knowledge and the bridges between different interests in a science of the oceans.
