As the introduction to this very welcome publication spells out, cities were a defining characteristic of the Roman Empire, flourishing throughout the provinces but dropping away abruptly beyond the limes. The correlation means that the Empire and its inhabitants cannot fully be understood without an appreciation of these centres, and the ways of life which they enabled. Yet students and others coming to Roman urbanism for the first time have long lacked an accessible — let alone comprehensive — English-language introduction to the subject. It is this omission which Laurence, Esmonde Cleary and Sears aim to address.
Their book traces and seeks to account for the evolution of Roman-style cities in the Western Empire, focusing especially on their monumental public aspect. Two main threads of discussion run through the work. One concerns the varied, localized character of city development. By adopting a comparative approach, the authors are able to show that the speed and nature of urban development varied dramatically across the Western Empire. They argue that although Roman urbanism was inherently dynamic, the trajectory of growth and change was locally determined, and did not simply unfold according to a standard schema defined by Rome. Though many accounts of urban evolution in individual provinces are available, here the collaboration of three authors with expertise in different regions throws their discrepant experiences into sharp relief, and confirms the importance of local people and conditions in generating them.
The second, related, thread, looks for the macro-economic conditions which supported urban evolution. As the authors show, the number and density of cities and monuments increased constantly from around 250 b.c. to a.d. 250. Urbanism, then, was a consistent surplus product of the Empire's socio-economic conditions, though the rate of production varied. The authors propose that cities were an effective mechanism for extracting resources from the flow of goods and services moving around the Empire, but that the efficiency of the extraction and its local impact were determined by a range of factors. These include the degree of connectedness with the transport network, the distances between cities, the distance from Rome itself, demographic fluctuations, and the changing priorities of the wealthy élite. Varying combinations of these factors help to explain disparities in the rate of urban development, and of shrinkage and abandonment during Late Antiquity.
The macro-scale approach is refreshing, particularly because it often lies beyond the scope of single-authored research publications. The authors set urbanism in a wider context by examining its relationship with other indexes of economic and social development — trading patterns, the development of collegia, the spread of inscriptions, and the emergence of provincial equites and senators — and find convincing correlations between them. This in turn allows them to articulate some interesting new ideas: for example, that the construction of walled circuits in second-century Britain reflects localized spending priorities, rather than being an early sign of insecurity (297–8). Their decision to omit any detailed discussion of artisanal activity, though, perhaps weakens the connections which they are able to draw between empire-wide and local economics. While the authors recognize the local impact of élite patronage, loans and spending projects, little is said about the smaller-scale economic opportunities afforded by densely-populated and well-connected urban centres. These economic attractions could have been explored further, and this might have helped the authors to explain the persistence of some urban centres in Late Antiquity, despite profound changes in élite spending priorities.
But what of the students at whom this book is chiefly aimed? After six years of teaching Roman urbanism myself, I am certain that undergraduates will find this book invaluable. Above all, future essays will surely be the richer for its up-to-date accounts of some really informative sites which have nevertheless not traditionally been prominent in the literature: Minturnae, Falerii Novi, Mérida, Timgad, Thugga, Amiens, Jublains or Silchester. Nor are these examples offered in isolation, but adeptly woven into the debates outlined above, providing clear, practical support for the authors’ theories about Roman urbanism. Key conceptual issues such as the relationships between cities and cultural change, or individual agency and collective identity, are effectively explained, with useful accounts of changing scholarly perspectives. And the technical issues which must be grasped before the big picture can be understood — such as the differences between coloniae and municipia — are generally well covered.
Yet some explanatory details are overlooked. It is striking that the word ‘civitas’ occurs several times, but (unlike coloniae and municipia) is never defined or included in the index. Given the importance of civitates in the West, and the many which are discussed, this should surely have been tackled explicitly. Indeed, more could have been done to clarify the general nature of the ancient city-state model and its conceptual and administrative importance. Again, phrases like ‘city and hinterland’ and ‘central places’ are common, while some references to the organization of newly-conquered peoples into civic units are made (e.g. 24–6). But the issue is never quite tackled head-on: and given that in my experience it is one that students find difficult to grasp, this seems regrettable. A better approach might have been to include a glossary dealing with some of this technical and conceptual vocabulary, to ensure fuller and more consistent coverage. Nonetheless, the explanatory framework on offer here is certainly a vast improvement on anything previously written for this audience. I can only hope that Cambridge University Press have already commissioned a similar volume for the Eastern Empire.
